Skip to main content
    • Aa
    • Aa
  • Get access
    Check if you have access via personal or institutional login
  • Cited by 95
  • Cited by
    This article has been cited by the following publications. This list is generated based on data provided by CrossRef.

    Eidinow, Esther 2016. Telling stories: Exploring the relationship between myths and ecological wisdom. Landscape and Urban Planning,

    Karlsson, Marianne and Bryceson, Ian 2016. Continuity and change: understanding livelihood shifts and adaptation in coastal Belize 1830–2012. Local Environment, Vol. 21, Issue. 2, p. 137.

    Anderson, Jon Mehta, Shreya Epelu, Edna and Cohen, Brian 2015. Managing leftovers: Does community forestry increase secure and equitable access to valuable resources for the rural poor?. Forest Policy and Economics, Vol. 58, p. 47.

    Hernández-Barrios, Juan C. Anten, Niels P. R. Martínez-Ramos, Miguel and Clough, Yann 2015. Sustainable harvesting of non-timber forest products based on ecological and economic criteria. Journal of Applied Ecology, Vol. 52, Issue. 2, p. 389.

    Louis, Elizabeth “Cedar” 2015. Food Sovereignty's New Frontiers. International Studies Review, Vol. 17, Issue. 3, p. 463.

    Myers, Rodd 2015. What the Indonesian rattan export ban means for domestic and international markets, forests, and the livelihoods of rattan collectors. Forest Policy and Economics, Vol. 50, p. 210.

    Swanson, Heather Anne 2015. Shadow ecologies of conservation: Co-production of salmon landscapes in Hokkaido, Japan, and southern Chile. Geoforum, Vol. 61, p. 101.

    Abram, Nicola K. Meijaard, Erik Ancrenaz, Marc Runting, Rebecca K. Wells, Jessie A. Gaveau, David Pellier, Anne-Sophie and Mengersen, Kerrie 2014. Spatially explicit perceptions of ecosystem services and land cover change in forested regions of Borneo. Ecosystem Services, Vol. 7, p. 116.

    Frake, Charles 2014. How to be a Tribe in the Southern Philippines during the Advent of NGOs and the Invention of The Indigenous. Human Organization, Vol. 73, Issue. 3, p. 197.

    Chomba, Chansa Nyirenda, Vincent and Silengo, Mitulo 2013. Selective use patterns of woody plant species by local communities in Mumbwa Game Management Area: A prerequisite for effective management of woodland resources and benefit sharing. Open Journal of Ecology, Vol. 03, Issue. 08, p. 532.

    Ingram, Verina and Tieguhong, Julius Chupezi 2013. Bars to Jars: Bamboo Value Chains in Cameroon. AMBIO, Vol. 42, Issue. 3, p. 320.

    Rico García-Amado, Luis Ruiz Pérez, Manuel Dahringer, Guillaume Reyes Escutia, Felipe Barrasa García, Sara and Contreras Mejía, Elsa 2013. From wild harvesting to agroforest cultivation: A Chamaedorea palm case study from Chiapas, Mexico. Forest Policy and Economics, Vol. 28, p. 44.

    Rudel, Thomas K. 2013. Food Versus Fuel: Extractive Industries, Insecure Land Tenure, and Gaps in World Food Production. World Development, Vol. 51, p. 62.

    Belcher, Brian 2012. Biodiversity Conservation and Poverty Alleviation: Exploring the Evidence for a Link.

    Leisher, Craig Sanjayan, M. Blockhus, Jill Larsen, Neil and Kontoleon, Andreas 2012. Biodiversity Conservation and Poverty Alleviation: Exploring the Evidence for a Link.

    Pokorny, Benno Johnson, James Medina, Gabriel and Hoch, Lisa 2012. Market-based conservation of the Amazonian forests: Revisiting win–win expectations. Geoforum, Vol. 43, Issue. 3, p. 387.

    Rist, Lucy Shanley, Patricia Sunderland, Terry Sheil, Douglas Ndoye, Ousseynou Liswanti, Nining and Tieguhong, Julius 2012. The impacts of selective logging on non-timber forest products of livelihood importance. Forest Ecology and Management, Vol. 268, p. 57.

    Knudsen, Are 2011. Logging the ‘Frontier’: Narratives of Deforestation in the Northern Borderlands of British India, c. 1850–1940. Forum for Development Studies, Vol. 38, Issue. 3, p. 299.

    Lybbert, T. J. Aboudrare, A. Chaloud, D. Magnan, N. and Nash, M. 2011. Booming markets for Moroccan argan oil appear to benefit some rural households while threatening the endemic argan forest. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, Vol. 108, Issue. 34, p. 13963.

    Pollini, Jacques 2011. The Difficult Reconciliation of Conservation and Development Objectives: The Case of the Malagasy Environmental Action Plan. Human Organization, Vol. 70, Issue. 1, p. 74.


A Revisionist View of Tropical Deforestation and Development

  • Michael R. Dove (a1)
  • DOI:
  • Published online: 01 August 2009

This study critiques one of the prevailing theories of tropical deforestation, namely that the forest is being cleared because its riches have been overlooked (the purported solution to which is the marketing of ‘rainforest crunch’). Edelman's work on the language of ‘helping’ is drawn on to suggest that a focus on the microeconomics of forest dwellers diverts attention from macro-economic and political issues whose impact on the forest is far more serious.

The study begins with a parable from Kalimantan, relating how the discovery of a big diamond can bring misfortune to a poor miner. It is suggested that this parable applies more generally to resource development in tropical forests, and that the major challenge is not to give more development opportunities to forest peoples but to take fewer away.

This principal is illustrated with respect to gold mining, rattan gathering, and truck-farming, in Indonesia. In each case, when a forest resource acquires greater value in the broader society, it is appropriated by external entrepreneurs at the expense of local communities. A detailed case-study is presented of the development of Para Rubber cultivation. Smallholders currently dominate this cultivation, despite steadfast opposition by both contemporary and colonial governments, whose self-interests are better served by the cultivation of the Rubber on large estates.

Each of these cases illustrates the predisposition of political and economic forces in the broader society to take over successful resource development in the tropical forest. Contemporary efforts to develop ‘non-timber forest products’ are reinterpreted, in this light, as attempts to allocate to the forest dwellers the resources of least interest to the broader society. The absence of research in this area is attributed not to academic oversight but to conflicting political-economic interests.

This thesis of resource exploitation is at variance with the ‘rain-forest crunch’ premise: namely that forest reserves are being overexploited by forest dwellers, that this is due to the absence of other sources of income, and that the solution is to help forest dwellers to find such sources. It is suggested that there has been no lack of such sources in the past, and that the problem has been in maintaining the forest peoples' control of them. The lesson of this analysis is not to ignore minor forest products, but to place them — and their potential development value for indigenous forest peoples — clearly within their proper political-economic context.

Any resolution of the problems of tropical forest development and conservation must begin, not by searching for resources that forest dwellers do not already have, but by first searching for the institutional forces which restrict the forest dwellers' ownership and productive use of existing resources. One of these institutional forces is discourse. It is widely understood that state elites seek to control valuable forest resources; it is less widely understood that an important means to this end is the control of resource-related discourse. De-mystification of the current debate over tropical deforestation and development is thus sorely needed.

Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Environmental Conservation
  • ISSN: 0376-8929
  • EISSN: 1469-4387
  • URL: /core/journals/environmental-conservation
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *