Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home

Non-pharmacological interventions for reducing aggression and violence in serious mental illness: A systematic review and narrative synthesis

  • J Rampling (a1), V Furtado (a1) (a2), C Winsper (a2), S Marwaha (a2), G Lucca (a3), M Livanou (a2) and SP Singh (a2)...

Abstract

Background

For people with mental illness that are violent, a range of interventions have been adopted with the aim of reducing violence outcomes. Many of these interventions have been borrowed from other (offender) populations and their evidence base in a Serious Mental Illness (SMI) population is uncertain.

Aims

To aggregate the evidence base for non-pharmacological interventions in reducing violence amongst adults with SMI and PD (Personality Disorder), and to assess the efficacy of these interventions. We chose to focus on distinct interventions rather than on holistic service models where any element responsible for therapeutic change would be difficult to isolate.

Methods

We performed a systematic review and narrative synthesis of non-pharmacological interventions intended to reduce violence in a SMI population and in patients with a primary diagnosis of PD. Five online databases were searched alongside a manual search of seven relevant journals, and expert opinion was sourced. Eligibility of all returned articles was independently assessed by two authors, and quality of studies was appraised via the Cochrane Collaboration Tool for Assessing Risk of Bias.

Results

We included 23 studies of diverse psychological and practical interventions, with a range of experimental and quasi-experimental study designs that included 7 Randomised Controlled Trials (RCTs). The majority were studies of Mentally Disordered Offenders. The stronger evidence existed for patients with a SMI diagnosis receiving Cognitive Behavioural Therapy or modified Reasoning & Rehabilitation (R&R). For patients with a primary diagnosis of PD, a modified version of R&R appeared tolerable and Enhanced Thinking Skills showed some promise in improving attitudes over the short-term, but studies of Dialectical Behaviour Therapy in this population were compromised by high risk of experimental bias. Little evidence could be found for non-pharmacological, non-psychological interventions.

Conclusions

The evidence for non-pharmacological interventions for reducing violence in this population is not conclusive. Long-term outcomes are lacking and good quality RCTs are required to develop a stronger evidence base.

Copyright

Corresponding author

*Corresponding author. at: c/o Reaside Clinic, Birmingham Great Park, Birmingham B45 9EB, UK. E-mail address:jeremy.rampling@nhs.net (J. Rampling).

References

Hide All
[1]Walsh, EBuchanan, AFahy, TViolence and schizophrenia: examining the evidence. Br J Psychiatry 2002;180: 490495.
[2]Large, MNielssen, OViolence in first-episode psychosis: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Schizophr Res 2011;125(2–3):209220.
[3]Yee, NLarge, MKemp, RNielssen, OSevere non-lethal violence during psychotic illness. Aust N Z J Psychiatry 2011;45(6):466472.
[4]Fazel, SDinesh, JSerious mental disorder in 23,000 prisoners: a systematic review of 62 surveys. Lancet 2002;359: 545550.
[5]Cuellar, ASnowden, LEwing, TCriminal records of persons served in the public Mental Health system. Psychiatr Serv 2007;58(1):114120.
[6]Hodgins, SCalem, MShimel, RWilliams, AHarleston, DMorgan, Cet al.Criminal offending and distinguishing features of offenders among persons experiencing a first episode of psychosis. Early Intervent Psychiatry 2011;5(1):1523.
[7]Fazel, SSeewald, KSevere mental illness in 33,588 prisoners worldwide: systematic review and meta-regression analysis. Br J Psychiatry 2012;200: 364373.
[8]Yu, RGeddes, JRFazel, SPersonality disorders, violence, and antisocial behaviour: a systematic review and meta-regression analysis. J Personal Disord 2012;26(5):775792.
[9]Volavka, JCzobor, PCitrome, LMcQuade, RCarson, WKostic, Det al.Efficacy of Aripiprazole against hostility in schizophrenia and schizoaffective disorder: data from 5 double-blind studies. J Clin Psychiatry 2005;66(11):13621366.
[10]Frogley, CTaylor, DDickens, GPicchioni, MA systematic review of the evidence of clozapine’s anti-aggressive effects. Int J Neuropsychopharmacol 2012;15: 13511371.
[11]Volavka, JAggression in psychoses. Adv Psychiatr 2014;2014:120. http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2014/196281 [Article ID: 196281]
[12]Winsper, CSingh, SMarwaha, SAmos, TLester, HEverard, Let al.Pathways to violent behaviour during first episode psychosis: a report from the UK National EDEN study. JAMA Psychiatry 2013;70(12):12871293.
[13]Morgan, RFisher, WDuan, NMandracchia, JMurray, DPrevalence of criminal thinking among state prison inmates with serious mental illness. Law Hum Behav 2010;34: 324336.
[14]Maden, AScott, FBurnett, RLewis, GSkapinakis, POffending in psychiatric patients after discharge from medium secure units: prospective national cohort study. BMJ 328 2004 1534
[15]Nilsson, TWallinius, MGustavson, CAnckarsäter, HKerekes, NViolent recidivism: a long-term follow-up study of mentally disordered offenders. PLoS ONE 2011;6(10):e2576810.1371/journal.pone.0025768
[16]Blackburn, R“What works” with mentally disordered offenders. Psychol Crime Law 2004;10(3):297308.
[17]Ross, JQuayle, ENewman, ETansey, LThe impact of psychological therapies on violent behaviour in clinical and forensic settings: a systematic review. Aggress Violent Behav 2013;18: 761773.
[18]Moher, DLiberati, ATetzlaff, JAltman, DGPRISMA Group Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. Ann Intern Med 2009;151(4):264269.
[19]Hockenhull, JWhittington, RLeitner, MBarr, WMcGuire, JCherry, Met al.A systematic review of prevention and intervention strategies for populations at high risk of engaging in violent behaviour: update 2002–2008. Health Technol Assess 2012;16(3):1152.
[20]Morgan, RFlora, DKroner, DMills, JVarghese, FSteffan, JTreating offenders with mental illness: a research synthesis. Law Hum Behav 2010;36(1):3750.
[21]Martin, MDorken, SWamboldt, AWootten, SStopping the revolving door: a meta-analysis on the effectiveness of interventions for criminally involved individuals with major mental disorders. Law Hum Behav 2012;36(1):112.
[22]Blackburn, RLogan, CDonnelly, JRenwick, SPersonality disorders, psychopathy and other disorders: co-morbidity among patients at English and Scottish high-security hospitals. J Forensic Psychiatry Psychol 2003;14(1):111137.
[23]Fazel, SZetterqvist, JLarsson, HLångström, NLichtenstein, PAntipsychotics, mood stabilisers, and the risk of violent crime. Lancet 2014;384: 12061214.
[24]Novaco, RAnger as a risk factor for violence among the mentally disorderedMonahan, J.Steadman, H.Violence and mental disorder 1994 University of Chicago Press Chicago269295.
[25]Cochrane Collaboration’s Tool for assessing risk of bias. http://www.ohg.cochrane.org/sites/ohg.cochrane.org/files/uploads/Risk%20of%20bias%20assessment%20tool.pdf [Last accessed 6/2/2015].
[26]Haddock, GBarrowclough, CShaw, JDunn, GNovaco, RTarrier, NCognitive-behavioural therapy v. social activity therapy for people with psychosis and a history of violence: randomised controlled trial. Br J Psychiatry 2009;194: 152157.
[27]Hornsveld, RNijman, HEvaluation of a cognitive-behavioral program for chronically psychotic forensic inpatients. Int J Law Psychiatry 2005;28: 246254.
[28]Davidson, KTyrer, PTata, PCooke, DGumley, AFord, Iet al.Cognitive behaviour therapy for violent men with antisocial personality disorder in the community: an exploratory randomized controlled trial. Psychol Med 2009;39: 569577.
[29]Yates, KKunz, MKhan, AVolavka, JRabinowitz, SPsychiatric patients with histories of aggression and crime five years after discharge from a cognitive-behavioral program. J Forensic Psychiatry Psychol 2010;21(2):167188.
[30]Ross, RFabiano, ETime to think: a cognitive model of delinquency prevention and offender rehabilitation Johnson City, TN: Institute of Social Sciences and Arts; 1985.
[31]Cullen, AClarke, AKuipers, EHodgins, SDean, KFahy, TA multisite randomised trial of a cognitive skills programme for male mentally disordered offenders: social-cognitive outcomes. Psychol Med 2012;42: 557569.
[32]Cullen, AClarke, AKuipers, EHodgins, SDean, KFahy, TA multisite randomised trial of a cognitive skills programme for male mentally disordered offenders: violence and antisocial behaviour outcomes. J Consult Clin Psychol 2012;80(6):11141120.
[33]Clarke, ACullen, AWalwyn, RFahy, TA quasi-experimental pilot study of the Reasoning and Rehabilitation programme with mentally disordered offenders. J Forensic Psychiatry Psychol 2010;21(4):490500.
[34]Young, SChick, KGudjonsson, GA preliminary evaluation of reasoning and rehabilitation 2 in mentally disordered offenders (R&R2M) across two secure forensic settings in the United Kingdom. J Forensic Psychiatry Psychol 2010;21(3):336349.
[35]Rees-Jones, AGudjonsson, GYoung, SA multi-site controlled trial of a cognitive skills program for mentally disordered offenders. BMC Psychiatry 12 2012 44
[36]Yip, VGudjonsson, GPerkins, DDoidge, AHopkin, GYoung, SA non-randomised controlled trial of the R&R2MHP cognitive skills program in high risk male offenders with severe mental illness. BMC Psychiatry 13 2013 267
[37]Jotangia, ARees-Jones, AGudjonsson, GHYoung, SA multi-site controled trial of the R&R2MHP cognitive skills program for mentally disordered female offenders. Int J Offender Ther Comp Criminol 2015;59(5):539559.
[38]Young, SHopkin, GPerkins, DFarr, CDoidge, AGudjonsson, GA controlled trial of a cognitive skills program for personality-disordered offenders. J Atten Disord 2013;17(7):598607.
[39]Evershed, STennant, ABoomer, DRees, ABarkham, MWatson, APractice-based outcomes of dialectical behaviour therapy (DBT) targeting anger and violence, with male forensic patients: a pragmatic and non-contemporaneous comparison. Crim Behav Ment Health 2003;13: 198213.
[40]Long, CFulton, BDolley, OHollin, CDealing with feelings: the effectiveness of cognitive behavioural group treatment for women in secure settings. Behav Cogn Psychother 2010;39: 243247.
[41]Tapp, JFellowes, EWallis, NBlud, LMoore, EAn evaluation of the Enhanced Thinking Skills (ETS) programme with mentally disordered offenders in a high security hospital. Legal Criminol Psychol 2009;14: 201212.
[42]Doyle, MKhanna, TLennox, CShaw, JHayes, ATaylor, Jet al.The effectiveness of an enhanced thinking skills programme in offenders with antisocial personality traits. J Forensic Psychiatry Psychol 2013;24(1):115.
[43]Hornsveld, RNijman, HKraaimaat, FAggression Control Therapy for violent forensic psychiatric patients: first results. Psychol Crime Law 2008;14(1):118.
[44]Wilson, CGandolfi, SDudley, AThomas, BTapp, JMoore, EEvaluation of anger management groups in a high-security hospital. Crim Behav Ment Health 2013;23: 356371.
[45]Tarrier, NDolan, MDoyle, MDunn, GShaw, JBlackburn, RExploratory randomized clinical trial of schema modal therapy in the personality disorder service at Ashworth Hospital UK: Ministry of Justice; 2010 [Research Series 5/10]
[46]Bernstein, DNijman, HKaros, KKeulen-de Vos, Mde Vogel, VLucker, TSchema therapy for forensic patients with personality disorders: design and preliminary findings of a multicentre randomised clinical trial in the Netherlands. Int J Forensic Ment Health 2012;11: 312324.
[47]Nurenberg, JRSchleifer, SJShaffer, TMYellin, MDesai, PJAmin, Ret al.Animal-Assisted therapy with chronic psychiatric inpatients: equine-assisted psychotherapy and aggressive behavior. Psychiatr Serv 2015;66(1):8086.
[48]Bruce, MCrowley, SJeffcote, NCoulston, BCommunity DSPD pilot services in South London: rates of reconviction and impact of supported housing on reducing recidivism. Crim Behav Ment Health 2014;24: 129140.
[49]Troquette, Nvan den Brink, RBeintema, HMulder, Tvan Os, TSchoevers, Ret al.Risk assessment and shared care planning in out-patient forensic psychiatry: cluster randomised controlled trial. Br J Psychiatry 2013;202: 365371.
[50]McMurran, MHuband, NOverton, ENon-completion of personality disorder treatments: a systematic review of correlates, consequences and interventions. Clin Psychol Rev 2010;30: 277287.
[51]Anderson, AWest, SGViolence against Mental Health professionals: when the treater becomes the victim. Innov Clin Neurosci 2011;8(3):3439.
[52]Fazel, SLangstrom, NHjern, AGrann, MLichtenstein, PSchizophrenia, substance abuse, and violent crime. JAMA 2009;301(19):20162023.
[53]Scott, DAMcGilloway, SDempster, MBrowne, FDonnelly, MEffectiveness of criminal justice liaison and diversion services for offenders with mental disorders: a review. Psychiatr Serv 2013;64(9):843849.
[54]Wilson, DTien, GEaves, DIncreasing the community tenure of mentally disordered offenders: an assertive case management program. Int J Law Psychiatry 1995;18: 6169.
[55]Walsh, EGilvarry, CSamele, CHarvey, KManley, CTyrer, Pet al.Reducing violence in severe mental illness: randomised controlled trial of intensive case management compared with standard care. BMJ 2001;323: 15.
[56]Stevens, HAgerbo, EDean, KMortensen, PBNordentoft, MReduction of crime in first-onset psychosis: a secondary analysis of the OPUS randomized trial. J Clin Psychiatry 2013;74(5):e439e444.

Keywords

Type Description Title
WORD
Supplementary materials

Rampling et al. supplementary material
Supplementary materials

 Word (65 KB)
65 KB

Non-pharmacological interventions for reducing aggression and violence in serious mental illness: A systematic review and narrative synthesis

  • J Rampling (a1), V Furtado (a1) (a2), C Winsper (a2), S Marwaha (a2), G Lucca (a3), M Livanou (a2) and SP Singh (a2)...

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed.

Non-pharmacological interventions for reducing aggression and violence in serious mental illness: A systematic review and narrative synthesis

  • J Rampling (a1), V Furtado (a1) (a2), C Winsper (a2), S Marwaha (a2), G Lucca (a3), M Livanou (a2) and SP Singh (a2)...
Submit a response

Comments

No Comments have been published for this article.

×

Reply to: Submit a response


Your details


Conflicting interests

Do you have any conflicting interests? *