Skip to main content



A large body of evidence demonstrates the agronomic superiority of maize hybrids over open-pollinated varieties (OPVs) in intensive monoculture. However, comparisons of the performance of hybrids and OPVs in agroforestry systems are scarce. In this study, the performance of four maize hybrids and four OPVs is compared in sole crop and under mature trees. Experiments were conducted on-farm during four seasons in Bugesera, Rwanda and two seasons in Meki, Ethiopia. Two tree species were selected in Bugesera (Grevillea robusta and Senna spectabilis) and one in Meki (Acacia tortilis), and three farms were selected for each tree species, each including two plots with almost identical trees in their centre and two plots without tree. In Bugusera, grain yield was higher for hybrids (2 Mg ha−1) than for OPVs (1.5 Mg ha−1), and the presence of trees reduced the harvest index more in OPVs than in hybrids. In this region, the estimated reduction in grain yield due to the presence of trees was 0.9 and 1.1 Mg ha−1 in hybrids and OPVs, respectively, while estimated reduction in biomass was 1.5 and 1.7 Mg ha−1, respectively. In Meki, the grain yield of OPVs (2.08 Mg ha−1) and hybrids (2.04 Mg ha−1) did not differ and the presence of trees reduced their grain yields in the same manner. Our results showed that hybrids yielded more than OPVs under G. robusta and S. spectabilis in Bugesera but performed equally well under A. tortilis in Meki. We conclude that agroforestry farmers could benefit from growing hybrids in the equatorial savannahs of Rwanda, but that the choice between hybrid and OPV in equatorial savannahs of Ethiopia can simply be based on other factors such as seed costs and availability.

Corresponding author
§Corresponding author. Email: or
Hide All
Abate, T., Shiferaw, B., Menkir, A., Wegary, D., Kebede, Y., Tesfaye, K., Kassie, M., Bogale, G., Tadesse, B. and Keno, T. (2015). Factors that transformed maize productivity in Ethiopia. Food Security 7:965981.
Alemu, D., Mwangi, W., Nigussie, M. and Spielman, D. J. (2008). The maize seed system in Ethiopia: Challenges and opportunities in drought prone areas. African Journal of Agricultural Research 3:305314.
Anley, W., Zeleke, H. and Dessalegn, Y. (2013). Genotype x environment interaction of maize (Zea mays L.) across north western Ethiopia. Journal of Plant Breeding and Crop Science 5:171181.
Beshir, B. (2011). Open Pollinated Maize Seed Systems Linkages through Farmer Research Group in Central Rift Valley of Ethiopia. Addis Ababa, Ethiopia: EIAR.
CIMMYT (1997). Book of Abstracts. The Genetics and Exploitation of Heterosis in Crops; An International Symposium. Mexico, D.F., Mexico: CIMMYT.
Desclaux, D., Huang, H.-Y., Bernazeau, B. and Lavene, P. (2016). Agroforestry: New challenge for field crop breeding. In 3rd European Agroforestry Conference INRA – Montpellier, France, 23–25 May 2016, 103.
Efa, N., Gorman, M. and Phelan, J. (2005). Implications of an extension package approach for farmers’ indigenous knowledge: The maize extension package in south-western Ethiopia. Journal of International Agricultural and Extension Education 12:6578.
Getachew, H. and Tesfaye, K. (2015). Analysis of risks in crop production due to climate change in the central rift valley of Ethiopia. African Journal of Agricultural Research 10:19131922.
Kamara, A., Menkir, A., Badu-Apraku, B. and Ibikunle, O. (2003). Reproductive and stay-green trait responses of maize hybrids, improved open-pollinated varieties and farmers's local varieties to terminal drought stress. Maydica 48:2938.
Kidane, H., Yirga, H., Teklay, Y., Teklay, Z. and Juhar, J. (2016). Pre-extension popularization of improved maize varieties: In Raya-Azebo Woreda South of Tigray, Ethiopia. Journal of Economics and Sustainable Development 7:111.
Kottek, M., Grieser, J., Beck, C., Rudolf, B. and Rubel, F. (2006). World map of the Köppen-Geiger climate classification updated. Meteorologische Zeitschrift 15:259263.
Macharia, C., Njeru, C., Ombakho, G. and Shiluli, M. (2010). Comparative performance of advanced generations of maize hybrids with a local maize variety: Agronomic and financial implications for smallholder farmers. Journal of Animal and Plant Sciences 7:801809.
Maddonni, G. and Otegui, M. (1996). Leaf area, light interception, and crop development in maize. Field Crops Research 48:8187.
NISR (2014). Statistical Yearbook. Kigali, Rwanda: National Institute of Statistics of Rwanda (NISR).
Ong, C. K. and Leakey, R. R. B. (1999). Why tree-crop interactions in agroforestry appear at odds with tree-grass interactions in tropical savannahs. Agroforestry Systems 45:109129.
R Development Core Team (2014). R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing. Vienna, Austria: R Foundation for Statistical Computing.
Regional State of Oromia (2003). Lume Woreda Based Development Programme Oromia Economic Study Project Office. Mojo, Ethiopia.
Russel, W. (1984). Agronomic performance of maize cultivars representing different eras of breeding. Maydica 29:75390.
Smale, M. and Jayne, T. (2003). Maize in Eastern and Southern Africa: "Seeds" of Success in Retrospect. Washington, DC: Environment and Production Technology Division, International Food Policy Research Institute.
Smale, M. and Mason, N. (2014). Hybrid seed and the economic well-being of smallholder maize farmers in Zambia. Journal of Development Studies 50:680695.
Tiwari, T. P., Brook, R. M. and Sinclair, F. L. (2004). Implications of hill farmers' agronomic practices in Nepal for crop improvement in maize. Experimental Agriculture 40:397417.
Tiwari, T. P., Brook, R. M., Wagstaff, P. and Sinclair, F. L. (2012). Effects of light environment on maize in hillside agroforestry systems of Nepal. Food Security 4:103114.
Tiwari, T., Virk, D. and Sinclair, F. L. (2009). Rapid gains in yield and adoption of new maize varieties for complex hillside environments through farmer participation: I. Improving options through participatory varietal selection (PVS). Field Crops Research 111:137143.
van Heerwaarden, J., Hellin, J., Visser, R. and Van Eeuwijk, F. (2009). Estimating maize genetic erosion in modernized smallholder agriculture. Theoretical and Applied Genetics 119:875888.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Experimental Agriculture
  • ISSN: 0014-4797
  • EISSN: 1469-4441
  • URL: /core/journals/experimental-agriculture
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
Type Description Title
Supplementary materials

Ndoli et al. supplementary material
Figure S1

 Word (36 KB)
36 KB


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed