Skip to main content
    • Aa
    • Aa
  • Get access
    Check if you have access via personal or institutional login
  • Cited by 23
  • Cited by
    This article has been cited by the following publications. This list is generated based on data provided by CrossRef.

    Donia, Atef El-Sayed and Tolba, Omar Atef 2016. Use of early pulse oximetry in the detection of cardiac lesions among asymptomatic term newborns. Egyptian Pediatric Association Gazette, Vol. 64, Issue. 1, p. 1.

    Narayen, Ilona C Blom, Nico A Ewer, Andrew K Vento, Maximo Manzoni, Paolo and te Pas, Arjan B 2016. Aspects of pulse oximetry screening for critical congenital heart defects: when, how and why?. Archives of Disease in Childhood - Fetal and Neonatal Edition, Vol. 101, Issue. 2, p. F162.

    Tobe, Ruoyan Gai Martin, Gerard R. Li, Fuhai and Mori, Rintaro 2016. Should postnatal oximetry screening be implemented nationwide in China? A cost-effectiveness analysis in three regions with different socioeconomic status. International Journal of Cardiology, Vol. 204, p. 45.

    Franke, J. and Haas, N.A. 2015. Leitlinien Kinder- und Jugendmedizin.

    Guthrie, Susan Bienkowska-Gibbs, Teresa Manville, Catriona Pollitt, Alexandra Kirtley, Anne and Wooding, Steven 2015. The impact of the National Institute for Health Research Health Technology Assessment programme, 2003–13: a multimethod evaluation. Health Technology Assessment, Vol. 19, Issue. 67, p. 1.

    Haas, N.A. and Schirmer, K.R. 2015. Leitlinien Kinder- und Jugendmedizin.

    Oakley, Juliette L. Soni, Naharmal B. Wilson, Dirk and Sen, Siddhartha 2015. Effectiveness of pulse-oximetry in addition to routine neonatal examination in detection of congenital heart disease in asymptomatic newborns. The Journal of Maternal-Fetal & Neonatal Medicine, Vol. 28, Issue. 14, p. 1736.

    Zuppa, Antonio Alberto Riccardi, Riccardo Catenazzi, Piero D'Andrea, Vito Cavani, Maria D'Antuono, Annamaria Iafisco, Alma and Romagnoli, Costantino 2015. Clinical examination and pulse oximetry as screening for congenital heart disease in low-risk newborn. The Journal of Maternal-Fetal & Neonatal Medicine, Vol. 28, Issue. 1, p. 7.

    Bhola, Kavita Kluckow, Martin and Evans, Nick 2014. Post-implementation review of pulse oximetry screening of well newborns in an Australian tertiary maternity hospital. Journal of Paediatrics and Child Health, Vol. 50, Issue. 11, p. 920.

    Frank, Lowell H. Bradshaw, Elizabeth Beekman, Robert Mahle, William T. and Martin, Gerard R. 2013. Critical Congenital Heart Disease Screening Using Pulse Oximetry. The Journal of Pediatrics, Vol. 162, Issue. 3, p. 445.

    Hiremath, Gurumurthy and Kamat, Deepak 2013. When to Call the Cardiologist: Treatment Approaches to Neonatal Heart Murmur. Pediatric Annals, Vol. 42, Issue. 8, p. 329.

    Munoz, Flor M. 2013. Maternal Immunization: An Update for Pediatricians. Pediatric Annals, Vol. 42, Issue. 8, p. e163.

    Steuten, Lotte van de Wetering, Gijs Groothuis-Oudshoorn, Karin and Retèl, Valesca 2013. A Systematic and Critical Review of the Evolving Methods and Applications of Value of Information in Academia and Practice. PharmacoEconomics, Vol. 31, Issue. 1, p. 25.

    Turiy, Yuliya 2013. Evaluation of a Newborn With a Murmur. Journal of Pediatric Health Care, Vol. 27, Issue. 3, p. 226.

    Govindaswami, B. Jegatheesan, P. and Song, D. 2012. Oxygen Saturation Screening for Critical Congenital Heart Disease. NeoReviews, Vol. 13, Issue. 12, p. e724.

    Hines, Amanda J. 2012. A Nurse-Driven Algorithm to Screen for Congenital Heart Defects in Asymptomatic Newborns. Advances in Neonatal Care, Vol. 12, Issue. 3, p. 151.

    Östman-Smith, Ingegerd and Granelli, Anne de-Wahl 2012. Screening for congenital heart disease with newborn pulse oximetry. The Lancet, Vol. 379, Issue. 9813, p. 309.

    Sharland, Gurleen 2012. Fetal cardiac screening and variation in prenatal detection rates of congenital heart disease: why bother with screening at all?. Future Cardiology, Vol. 8, Issue. 2, p. 189.

    Ageliki, Karatza A. Sotirios, Fouzas Sotirios, Tzifas Alexandra, Mermiga Gabriel, Dimitriou and Stefanos, Mantagos 2011. Accuracy of Cardiac Auscultation in Asymptomatic Neonates with Heart Murmurs: Comparison Between Pediatric Trainees and Neonatologists. Pediatric Cardiology, Vol. 32, Issue. 4, p. 473.

    Bedford, Christopher D. 2011. Examination of the Newborn.

  • International Journal of Technology Assessment in Health Care, Volume 23, Issue 2
  • April 2007, pp. 192-204

Comparing the clinical and economic effects of clinical examination, pulse oximetry, and echocardiography in newborn screening for congenital heart defects: A probabilistic cost-effectiveness model and value of information analysis

  • Ingolf Griebsch (a1), Rachel L. Knowles (a2), Jacqueline Brown (a1), Catherine Bull (a3), Christopher Wren (a4) and Carol A. Dezateux (a2)
  • DOI:
  • Published online: 01 April 2007

Objectives: Congenital heart defects (CHD) are an important cause of death and morbidity in early childhood, but the effectiveness of alternative newborn screening strategies in preventing the collapse or death—before diagnosis—of infants with treatable but life-threatening defects is uncertain. We assessed their effectiveness and efficiency to inform policy and research priorities.

Methods: We compared the effectiveness of clinical examination alone and clinical examination with either pulse oximetry or screening echocardiography in making a timely diagnosis of life-threatening CHD or in diagnosing clinically significant CHD. We contrasted their cost-effectiveness, using a decision-analytic model based on 100,000 live births, and assessed future research priorities using value of information analysis.

Results: Clinical examination alone, pulse oximetry, and screening echocardiography achieved 34.0, 70.6, and 71.3 timely diagnoses per 100,000 live births, respectively. This finding represents an additional cost per additional timely diagnosis of £4,894 and £4,496,666 for pulse oximetry and for screening echocardiography. The equivalent costs for clinically significant CHD are £1,489 and £36,013, respectively. Key determinants of cost-effectiveness are detection rates and screening test costs. The false-positive rate is very high with screening echocardiography (5.4 percent), but lower with pulse oximetry (1.3 percent) or clinical examination alone (.5 percent).

Conclusions: Adding pulse oximetry to clinical examination is likely to be a cost-effective newborn screening strategy for CHD, but further research is required before this policy can be recommended. Screening echocardiography is unlikely to be cost-effective, unless the detection of all clinically significant CHD is considered beneficial and a 5 percent false-positive rate acceptable.

Linked references
Hide All

This list contains references from the content that can be linked to their source. For a full set of references and notes please see the PDF or HTML where available.

1.G Acharya , V Sitras , JM Maltau , Major congenital heart disease in Northern Norway: Shortcomings of pre- and postnatal diagnosis. Acta Obstet Gynecol Scand. 2004; 83: 11241129.

2.S Ainsworth , JP Wyllie , C Wren . Prevalence and clinical significance of cardiac murmurs in neonates. Arch Dis Child Fetal Neonatal Ed. 1999; 80: F43F45.

3.E Alberman . The National Down Syndrome Cytogenetic Register (NDSCR). J Med Screen. 2002; 9: 9798.

4.R Arlettaz , N Archer , AR Wilkinson . Natural history of innocent heart murmurs in newborn babies: Controlled echocardiographic study. Arch Dis Child Fetal Neonatal Ed. 1998; 78: F166F170.

5.AF Bakr , HS Habib . Combining pulse oximetry and clinical examination in screening for congenital heart disease. Pediatr Cardiol. 2005; 26: 832835.

6.RS Boneva , LD Botto , CA Moore , Mortality associated with congenital heart defects in the United States: Trends and racial disparities, 1979-1997. Circulation. 2001; 103: 23762381.

7.EL Bove , C Bull , J Stark , Congenital heart disease in the neonate: Results of surgical treatment. Arch Dis Child. 1983; 58: 137141.

10.KL Brown , DA Ridout , AP Goldman , A Hoskote , DJ Penny . Risk factors for long intensive care unit stay after cardiopulmonary bypass in children. Crit Care Med. 2003; 31: 2833.

11.C Bull . Current and potential impact of fetal diagnosis on prevalence and spectrum of serious congenital heart disease at term in the UK. British Paediatric Cardiac Association. Lancet. 1999; 354: 12421247.

13.RR Clancy , SA McGaurn , G Wernovsky , Preoperative risk-of-death prediction model in heart surgery with deep hypothermic circulatory arrest in the neonate. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2000; 119: 347357.

14.K Claxton . The irrelevance of inference: A decision-making approach to the stochastic evaluation of health care technologies. J Health Econ. 1999; 18: 341364.

15.K Claxton , PJ Neumann , S Araki , MC Weinstein . Bayesian value-of-information analysis. An application to a policy model of Alzheimer's disease. Int J Technol Assess Health Care. 2001; 17: 3855.

16.K Claxton , JT Cohen , PJ Neumann . When is evidence sufficient? Health Aff (Millwood). 2005; 24: 93101.

17.RT Clemen , RL Winkler . Combining probability distributions from experts in risk analysis. Risk Anal. 1999; 19: 187203.

18.GA de Wahl , M Mellander , J Sunnegardh , K Sandberg , I Ostman-Smith . Screening for duct-dependant congenital heart disease with pulse oximetry: A critical evaluation of strategies to maximize sensitivity. Acta Paediatr. 2005; 94: 15901596.

20.E Fenwick , K Claxton , M Sculpher . Representing uncertainty: The role of cost-effectiveness acceptability curves. Health Econ. 2001; 10: 779787.

21.CM Glazener , CR Ramsay , MK Campbell , Neonatal examination and screening trial (NEST): A randomised, controlled, switchback trial of alternative policies for low risk infants. BMJ. 1999; 318: 627631.

22.I Griebsch , J Coast , J Brown . Quality-adjusted life-years lack quality in pediatric care: A critical review of published cost-utility studies in child health. Pediatrics. 2005; 115: e600e614.

23.DM Hall . The role of the routine neonatal examination. BMJ. 1999; 318: 619620.

24.JI Hoffman , S Kaplan . The incidence of congenital heart disease. [Review] [124 refs]. J Am Coll Cardiol. 2002; 39: 18901900.

25.TR Hoke , PK Donohue , PK Bawa , Oxygen saturation as a screening test for critical congenital heart disease: A preliminary study. Pediatr Cardiol. 2002; 23: 403409.

27.R Knowles , I Griebsch , C Dezateux , Newborn screening for congenital heart defects: A systematic review and cost-effectiveness analysis. Health Technol Assess. 2005; 9: 1168.

28.RI Koppel , CM Druschel , T Carter , Effectiveness of pulse oximetry screening for congenital heart disease in asymptomatic newborns. Pediatrics. 2003; 111: 451455.

29.C Kwon . FPM. The magnitude and challenge of false-positive newborn screening test results. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 2000; 154: 714718.

32.S Petrou . Methodological issues raised by preference-based approaches to measuring the health status of children. Health Econ. 2003; 12: 697702.

33.JD Reich , S Miller , B Brogdon , The use of pulse oximetry to detect congenital heart disease. J Pediatr. 2003; 142: 268272.

34.S Richmond , G Reay , HM Abu . Routine pulse oximetry in the asymptomatic newborn. Arch Dis Child Fetal Neonatal Ed. 2002; 87: F83F88.

35.TE Roberts . Economic evaluation and randomised controlled trial of extracorporeal membrane oxygenation: UK collaborative trial. The Extracorporeal Membrane Oxygenation Economics Working Group. BMJ. 1998; 317: 911915.

36.A Rosano , LD Botto , B Botting , P Mastroiacovo . Infant mortality and congenital anomalies from 1950 to 1994: An international perspective. J Epidemiol Community Health. 2000; 54: 660666.

37.A Sands , B Craig , C Mulholland , Echocardiographic screening for congenital heart disease: A randomized study. J Perinat Med. 2002; 30: 307312.

38.DJ Spiegelhalter , NL Harris , K Bull , RCG Franklin . Empirical evaluation of prior beliefs about frequencies: Methodology and a case study in congenital heart disease. J Am Stat Assoc. 1994; 89: 435443.

39.AA Stinnett , J Mullahy . Net health benefits: A new framework for the analysis of uncertainty in cost-effectiveness analysis. Med Decis Making. 1998; 18: S68S80.

40.JM Tilford . Cost-effectiveness analysis and emergency medical services for children: Issues and applications. Ambul Pediatr. 2002; 2 (Suppl): 330336.

41.RM Tulloh , SP Tansey , K Parashar , Echocardiographic screening in neonates undergoing surgery for selected gastrointestinal malformations. Arch Dis Child Fetal Neonatal Ed. 1994; 70: F206F208.

42.C Wren , JJ O'Sullivan . Survival with congenital heart disease and need for follow up in adult life. Heart. 2001; 85: 438443.

Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

International Journal of Technology Assessment in Health Care
  • ISSN: 0266-4623
  • EISSN: 1471-6348
  • URL: /core/journals/international-journal-of-technology-assessment-in-health-care
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *