Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home

Political Authority in International Relations: Revisiting the Medieval Debate

  • Julia Costa Lopez

Abstract

In international relations, accounts of medieval political authority are divided between those who see a heteronomous patchwork of overlapping authorities and those who claim that the era of the state started in the twelfth century. How can we overcome this divide? I argue that IR's current difficulties in grasping the nature of medieval political authority stem from shortcomings in how the notion of political authority itself has been conceptualized. Thus, rather than starting from a substantive definition of political authority, I focus on contestation over the categorization and authorization of rule, that is, on how authority is produced in historically specific ways as a result of contemporary contestation over what political authority is, who is authorized, and how rulers stand in relation to one another. This reorientation allows us to appreciate how medieval political authority emerged from the competition between four sets of ordering categories: iurisdictio, potestas, lord/vassal, and magistrate. Each one of these four categories understood authority, rulers, and the relation between rulers in different ways. The problem with existing accounts of medieval authority is that they attempt to find the single ordering principle of medieval international relations. In doing so, they not only fail to capture the features of the time but also reinforce a particular approach to political authority that is unhelpful for understanding medieval and modern politics alike.

Copyright

References

Hide All
Accursius. 1560. Digestum Vetus. Pandectarum Iuris Civilis Tomus Primus.
Adler-Nissen, Rebecca. 2013. Sovereignty. In Bourdieu in International Relations: Rethinking Key Concepts in International Relations, edited by Adler-Nissen, Rebecca, 179–92. Routledge.
Adler-Nissen, Rebecca, and Gammeltoft-Hansen, Thomas, eds. 2008. Sovereignty Games: Instrumentalizing State Sovereignty in Europe and Beyond. Palgrave Macmillan.
Albericus de Rosate., 1974. Commentarii in Primam Digesti Veteris Partem. A. Forni.
Avant, Deborah D., Finnemore, Martha, and Sell, Susan K.. 2010. Who Governs the Globe? Cambridge University Press.
Azo., 1966. Azonis Summa Super Codicem. Ex officina Erasmiana.
Baldus de Ubaldis., 1577. Baldi Ubaldi Perusini in Primam Digesti Veteris Partem Commentaria.
Bartelson, Jens. 1995. A Genealogy of Sovereignty. Cambridge University Press.
Bartolus de Sassoferrato., 1589. Bartoli a Saxoferrato in Primam Digesti Veteris Partem Commentaria Cum Additionibus.
Black, Antony. 1992. Political Thought in Europe 1250–1450. Cambridge University Press.
Black, Jane. 2009. Absolutism in Renaissance Milan: Plenitude of Power under the Visconti and the Sforza 1329–1535. Oxford University Press.
Blaydes, Lisa, and Chaney, Eric. 2013. The Feudal Revolution and Europe's Rise: Political Divergence of the Christian West and the Muslim World Before 1500 CE. American Political Science Review 107 (1):1634.
Blaydes, Lisa, and Paik, Christopher. 2016. The Impact of Holy Land Crusades on State Formation: War Mobilization, Trade Integration, and Political Development in Medieval Europe. International Organization 70 (3):551–86.
Bourdieu, Pierre. 1985. The Social Space and the Genesis of Groups. Theory and Society 14 (6):723–43.
Boutoulle, Frédéric. 2009. La “Gascogne Allodiale”: Reconsidérations Sur Un Thème Historiographique [“Allodial Gascony”: Reconsiderations over a historiographical topic] In Provinciales. Hommages à Anne-Marie Cocula, edited by Mondot, Jean and Loupès, Philippe, 553–62. Presses universitaires de Bordeaux.
Brown, Chris, Nardin, Terry, and Rengger, Nicholas J.. 2002. International Relations in Political Thought. Cambridge University Press.
Brundage, James A. 2008. The Medieval Origins of the Legal Profession: Canonists, Civilians, and Courts. Chicago University Press.
Bull, Hedley. 2002. The Anarchical Society: A Study of Order in World Politics. Palgrave.
Buzan, Barry, and Albert, Mathias. 2010. Differentiation: A Sociological Approach to International Relations Theory. European Journal of International Relations 16 (3):315–37.
Buzan, Barry, and Little, Richard. 2000. International Systems in World History. Oxford University Press.
Canning, Joseph. 1980. The Corporation in the Political Thought of the Italian Jurists of the Thirteenth and Fourteenth Centuries. History of Political Thought 1 (1):932.
Canning, Joseph. 1983. Ideas of the State in Thirteenth and Fourteenth-Century Commentators on the Roman Law. Transactions of the Royal Historical Society 33:127.
Canning, Joseph. 1987. The Political Thought of Baldus De Ubaldis. Cambridge University Press.
Canning, Joseph. 1988. Law, Sovereignty and Corporation Theory, 1300–1450. In The Cambridge History of Medieval Political Thought C. 350–1450, edited by Burns, J.H., 454–76. Cambridge University Press.
Canning, Joseph. 2011. Ideas of Power in the Late Middle Ages, 1296–1417. Cambridge University Press.
Cerny, Philip G. 1998. Neomedievalism, Civil War and the New Security Dilemma: Globalisation as Durable Disorder. Civil Wars 1 (1):3664.
Chaplais, Pierre. 1948. English Arguments Concerning the Feudal Status of Aquitaine in the Fourteenth Century. Historical Research 21 (64):203–13.
Chaplais, Pierre. 1957. Le Duché-Pairie de Guyenne: L'hommage et les Services Féodaux de 1259 à 1303. [The Duchy-Pairie of Guyenne. Homage and Feudal Services from 1259 to 1303]Annales du Midi: revue archéologique, historique et philologique de la France méridionale 69 (37):538.
Collier, David, and Levitsky, Steven. 1997. Democracy with Adjectives: Conceptual Innovation in Comparative Research. World Politics 49 (3):430–51.
Costa Lopez, Julia. 2016. Beyond Eurocentrism and Orientalism: Revisiting the Othering of Jews and Muslims through Medieval Canon Law. Review of International Studies 42 (3):450–70.
Costa Lopez, Julia. 2018. Merum Imperium and Sovereignty in the Later Middle Ages. In Forum: In the Beginning There Was No Word (For It): Terms, Concepts, and Early Sovereignty. International Studies Review 20 (3):489519.
Costa Lopez, Julia. Forthcoming. International Relations in the Middle Ages. In The Routledge Handbook of Historical International Relations, edited by Carvalho, Benjamin de, Lopez, Julia Costa and Leira, Halvard. Routledge.
Davenport, Christian. 1917. European Treaties Bearing on the History of the United States and Its Dependencies to 1648. 4 Volume 1. Carnegie.
Durantis, Guilelmus. 1612. Speculum Juris.
Fischer, Markus. 1992. Feudal Europe, 800–1300: Communal Discourse and Conflictual Practices. International Organization 46 (2):427–66.
Friedrichs, Jörg. 2001. The Meaning of New Medievalism. European Journal of International Relations 7 (4):475501.
Friedrichs, Jörg. 2004. The Neomedieval Renaissance: Global Governance and International Law in the New Middle Ages. In Global Governance and International Legal Theory, edited by Dekker, Ige F. and Werner, Wouter G., 336. Springer.
Guenée, Bernard. 1981. L'occident aux XIVe et XVe Siècles: Les États. [The West in the XIV and XV centuries: States] 2nd ed. Presses universitaires de France.
Guillaume, Xavier. 2014. International Relations and Identity: A Dialogical Approach. Routledge.
Hall, Rodney Bruce, and Biersteker, Thomas J., eds. 2004. The Emergence of Private Authority in Global Governance. Cambridge University Press.
Hall, Rodney Bruce, and Kratochwil, Friedrich V.. 1993. Medieval Tales: Neorealist “Science” and the Abuse of History. International Organization 47 (3):479–91.
Holland, Ben. 2010. Sovereignty as Dominium? Reconstructing the Constructivist Roman Law Thesis. International Studies Quarterly 54 (2):449–80.
Holsinger, Bruce. 2016. Neomedievalism and International Relations. In The Cambridge Companion to Medievalism, edited by Darcens, Louise, 165–79. Cambridge University Press.
Hurd, Ian. 1999. Legitimacy and Authority in International Politics. International Organization 53 (2):379408.
Kant, Immanuel. 2018. Groundwork for the Metaphysics of Morals. Edited by Wood, Allen W.. Yale University Press.
Kantorowicz, Ernst. 1997. The King's Two Bodies: A Study in Mediaeval Political Theology. Princeton University Press.
Keene, Edward. 2013. The Naming of Powers. Cooperation and Conflict 48 (2):268–82.
Keene, Edward. 2014. The Standard of “Civilisation,” the Expansion Thesis and the Nineteenth-Century International Social Space. Millennium—Journal of International Studies 42 (3):651–73.
Kessler, Oliver, and Herborth, Benjamin. 2013. Recognition and the Constitution of Social Order. International Theory 5 (1):155–60.
Kicklighter, Joseph. 1979. French Jurisdictional Supremacy in Gascony: One Aspect of the Ducal Government's Response. Journal of Medieval History 5 (2):127–34.
Kobrin, Stephen J. 1999. Back to the Future: Neomedievalism and the Postmodern Digital World Economy. In Globalization and Governance, edited by Prakash, Aseem and Hart, Jeffrey A., 165–87. Routledge.
Kratochwil, Friedrich. 1986. Of Systems, Boundaries, and Territoriality: An Inquiry into the Formation of the State System. World Politics 39 (1):2752.
Kratochwil, Friedrich. 1995. Sovereignty as Dominium: Is There a Right of Humanitarian Intervention? In Beyond Westphalia? State Sovereignty and International Intervention, edited by Lyons, Gene M. and Mastanduno, Michael, 2142. Johns Hopkins University Press.
Krisch, Nico. 2017. Liquid Authority in Global Governance. International Theory 9 (2):237–60.
Lake, David. 2009. Relational Authority and Legitimacy in International Relations. American Behavioural Scientist 53 (3):331–53.
Lake, David. 2010. Rightful Rules: Authority, Order, and the Foundations of Global Governance. International Studies Quarterly 54 (3):587613.
Larkins, Jeremy. 2010. From Hierarchy to Anarchy. Territory and Politics Before Westphalia. Palgrave Macmillan.
Latham, Andrew. 2012. Theorizing Medieval Geopolitics: War and World Order in the Age of the Crusades. Routledge.
Le Patourel, John. 1965. The Plantagenet Dominions. History 50 (170):289308.
Lehmann, Karl. 1896. Das Langobardische Lehnrecht. Handschriften, Textentwicklung, Ältester Text Und Vulgattext Nebst Der Capitual Extraordinaria. [The Lombard Feudal Law. Manuscripts, Text Development, Oldest Text and Vulgate Text next to the Capitual Extraordinaria] Dieterich
Mochi Onory, Sergio. 1951. Fonti Canonistiche Dell'idea Moderna Dello Stato. Vita e Pensiero.
Moraw, Peter. 1992. Careers of Graduates. In A History of the University in Europe. Volume 1. The Middle Ages, edited by Ridder-Symoens, Hilde De, 244–79. Cambridge University Press.
Musgrave, Paul, and Nexon, Daniel. 2018. Defending Hierarchy from the Moon to the Indian Ocean: Symbolic Capital and Political Dominance in Early Modern China and the Cold War. International Organization 72 (3):591626.
Nederman, Cary. 2009. Lineages of European Political Thought. Catholic University of America Press.
Nexon, Daniel H. 2009. The Struggle for Power in Early Modern Europe: Religious Conflict, Dynastic Empires and International Change. Princeton University Press.
Odofredus de Denariis., 1480. Lectura Super Codice.
Odofredus de Denariis., 1967. Lectura Super Digesto Veteri. Volume 1. Forni.
Onuf, Nicholas Greenwood. 2013. World of Our Making: Rules and Rule in Social Theory and International Relations. Routledge.
Osiander, Andreas. 2001. Before Sovereignty: Society and Politics in Ancien Régime Europe. Review of International Studies 27 (5):119–45.
Osiander, Andreas. 2007. Before the State. Systemic Political Change in the West from the Greeks to the French Revolution. Oxford University Press.
Pennington, Kenneth. 1984. Pope and Bishops: The Papal Monarchy in the Twelfth and Thirteenth Centuries. University of Pennsylvania Press.
Pennington, Kenneth. 1993. The Prince and the Law, 1200–1600: Sovereignty and Rights in the Western Legal Tradition. University of California Press.
Phillips, Andrew. 2010. War, Religion and Empire: The Transformation of International Orders. Cambridge University Press.
Philpott, Daniel. 2001. Revolutions in Sovereignty: How Ideas Shaped Modern International Relations. Princeton University Press.
Pouliot, Vincent. 2017. Against Authority. In Hierarchies in World Politics, edited by Zarakol, Ayşe, 113–33. Cambridge University Press.
Prestwich, Michael. 1997. Edward I. Yale University Press.
Reus-Smit, Christian. 1999. The Moral Purpose of the State. Princeton University Press.
Reus-Smit, Christian. 2013. Individual Rights and the Making of the International System. Cambridge University Press.
Reynolds, Susan. 1994. Fiefs and Vassals. The Medieval Evidence Reinterpreted. Oxford University Press.
Riesenberg, Peter 1956. Inalienability of Sovereignty in Medieval Political Thought. Columbia University Press.
Rothwell, H. 1927. Edward I's Case Against Philip the Fair over Gascony. The English Historical Review 42 (168):572–82.
Rufinus., 1963. Summa Decretorum. Edited by Singer, Heinrich. Scientia Verlag.
Ruggie, John Gerard. 1993. Territoriality and Beyond: Problematizing Modernity in International Relations. International Organization 47 (1):139–74.
Ruggie, John Gerard. 1998. Constructing the World Polity: Essays on International Institutionalization. Routledge.
Ryan, Magnus. 1998. The Oath of Fealty and the Lawyers. In Political Thought and the Realities of Power in the Middle Ages, edited by Canning, Joseph and Oexle, Otto Gerhard, 211–28. Vandenhoeck and Ruprecht.
Ryan, Magnus. 2000. Bartolus of Sassoferrato and Free Cities. The Alexander Prize Lecture. Transactions of the Royal Historical Society 10:6589.
Ryan, Magnus. 2002. Feudal Obligation and Rights of Resistance. In Die Gegenwart Des Feudalismus, edited by Fryde, Natalie, Monnet, Pierre, and Oexle, Otto Gerhard, 5178. Vandenhoeck and Ruprecht.
Ryan, Magnus. 2009. Zur Tradition Des Langobardischen Lehnrechts. [On the tradition of Lombard Feudal Law] In Die Anfänge Des Öffentlichen Rechts, edited by Dilcher, G. and Quaglioni, Diego, 225–45. Dunker and Humblot.
Sending, Ole Jacob. 2015. The Politics of Expertise: Competing for Authority in Global Governance. University of Michigan Press.
Sending, Ole Jacob. 2017. Recognition and Liquid Authority. International Theory 9 (2):311–28.
Teschke, Benno. 2003. The Myth of 1648: Class, Geopolitics, and the Making of Modern International Relations. Verso.
Tilly, Charles. 1994. Coercion, Capitals and European States 990–1992. Blackwell.
Ullmann, Walter. 1971. The Medieval Papal Court as an International Tribunal. Virginia Journal for International Law 11:356–71.
Vale, M.G.A. 1996. The Origins of the Hundred Years War: The Angevin Legacy, 1250–1340. Clarendon.
Vallejo, Jesus. 1992a. Power Hierarchies in Medieval Juridical Thought. An Essay in Reinterpretation. Ius Commune 19:129.
Vallejo, Jesus. 1992b. Ruda Equidad, Ley Consumada. Concepción De La Potestad Normativa (1250–1350). Centro de Estudios Constitucionales.
Watt, J.A. 1964. The Theory of Papal Monarchy in the Thirteenth Century: The Contribution of the Canonists. Traditio 20:79317.
Watt, J.A. 1965. The Use of the Term “Plenitudo Potestatis” by Hostiensis. In Proceedings of the Second International Congress of Medieval Canon Law, edited by Kuttner, Stephan and Ryan, James, 161–87. S. Congregatio de seminariis et studiorum universitatibus.
Weimar, P. 1990. Die Handschriften Des Liber Feudorum Und Seine Glossen. [The Manuscripts of the Liber Feudorum and its Glosses] Rivista internazionale del diritto comune 1:3198.
Wendt, Alexander. 1998. On Constitution and Causation in International Relations. Review of International Studies 24 (5):101–18.
Wiener, Antje. 2008. The Invisible Constitution of World Politics. Cambridge University Press.
Wiener, Antje. 2014. A Theory of Contestation. Springer.
Wittgenstein, Ludwig. 1997. Philosophical Investigations. Blackwell.
Woolf, Cecil Sidney. 1913. Bartolus of Sassoferrato: His Position in the History of Medieval Political Thought. Cambridge University Press.
Zielonka, Jan 2006. Europe as Empire: The Nature of the Enlarged European Union. Oxford University Press.
Zielonka, Jan. 2013. The International System in Europe: Westphalian Anarchy or Medieval Chaos? Journal of European Integration 35 (1):118.

Keywords

Political Authority in International Relations: Revisiting the Medieval Debate

  • Julia Costa Lopez

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed