Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home

Recapturing Regime Type in International Relations: Leaders, Institutions, and Agency Space

  • Susan D. Hyde and Elizabeth N. Saunders

Abstract

A wave of recent research challenges the role of regime type in international relations. One striking takeaway is that democratic and autocratic leaders can often achieve similar levels of domestic constraint, which in many issue areas results in similar international outcomes—leading many to question traditional views of democracies as distinctive in their international relations. In this review essay, we use recent contributions in the field to build what we call a “malleable constraints” framework, in which all governments have an institutionally defined default level of domestic audience constraint that is generally higher in democracies, but leaders maintain some agency within these institutions and can strategically increase their exposure to or insulation from this constraint. Using this framework, we argue that regime type is still a crucial differentiator in international affairs even if, as recent studies suggest, democratic and autocratic leaders can sometimes be similarly constrained by domestic audiences and thus achieve similar international outcomes. This framework helps reconcile many competing claims in recent scholarship, including the puzzle of why autocracies do not strategically increase domestic audience constraint more often. Just because autocracies can engage audience constraints and democracies can escape them does not mean that they can do so with equal ease, frequency, or risk.

Copyright

References

Hide All
Arias, Eric, Hollyer, James R., and Rosendorff, B. Peter. 2018. Cooperative Autocracies: Leader Survival, Creditworthiness, and Bilateral Investment Treaties. American Journal of Political Science 62 (4):905–21.
Auerswald, David P., and Saideman, Stephen M.. 2014. NATO in Afghanistan: Fighting Together, Fighting Alone. Princeton University Press.
Ballard-Rosa, Cameron. 2016. Hungry for Change: Urban Bias and Autocratic Sovereign Default. International Organization 70 (2):313–46.
Ballard-Rosa, Cameron, Mosley, Layna, and Wellhausen, Rachel L.. 2019. Contingent Advantage? Sovereign Borrowing, Democratic Institutions, and Global Capital Cycles. British Journal of Political Science, 121. doi:10.1017/S0007123418000455.
Bastiaens, Ida, and Rudra, Nita. 2018. Democracies in Peril: Taxation and Redistribution in Globalizing Economies. Cambridge University Press.
Baum, Matthew A., and Lake, David A.. 2003. The Political Economy of Growth: Democracy and Human Capital. American Journal of Political Science 47 (2):333–47.
Baum, Matthew A., and Potter, Philip B.K.. 2015. War and Democratic Constraint: How the Public Influences Foreign Policy. Princeton University Press.
Beaulieu, Emily, Cox, Gary W., and Saiegh, Sebastian. 2012. Sovereign Debt and Regime Type: Reconsidering the Democratic Advantage. International Organization 66 (4):709–38.
Berinsky, Adam J. 2009. In Time of War: Understanding American Public Opinion from World War II to Iraq. University of Chicago Press.
Binder, Sarah. 2018. Dodging the Rules in Trump's Republican Congress. The Journal of Politics 80 (4):1454–63.
Boix, Carles, and Svolik, Milan W.. 2013. The Foundations of Limited Authoritarian Government: Institutions, Commitment, and Power-Sharing in Dictatorships. The Journal of Politics 75 (2):300–16.
Brown, Jonathan N., and Marcum, Anthony S.. 2011. Avoiding Audience Costs: Domestic Political Accountability and Concessions in Crisis Diplomacy. Security Studies 20 (2):141–70.
Broz, J. Lawrence. 2002. Political System Transparency and Monetary Commitment Regimes. International Organization 56 (4):861–87.
Brutger, Ryan, and Kertzer, Joshua D.. 2018. A Dispositional Theory of Reputation Costs. International Organization 72 (3):693724.
Bueno de Mesquita, Bruce, and Siverson, Randolph M.. 1995. War and the Survival of Political Leaders: A Comparative Study of Regime Types and Political Accountability. American Political Science Review 89 (4):841–55.
Bueno de Mesquita, Bruce, Smith, Alastair, Siverson, Randolph M., and Morrow, James D.. 2003. The Logic of Political Survival. MIT Press.
Bush, Sarah Sunn. 2011. International Politics and the Spread of Quotas for Women in Legislatures. International Organization 65 (1):103–37.
Busse, Matthias, and Hefeker, Carsten. 2007. Political Risk, Institutions and Foreign Direct Investment. European Journal of Political Economy 23 (2):397415.
Byman, Daniel, and Pollack, Kenneth. 2001. Let Us Now Praise Great Men: Bringing the Statesman Back In. International Security 25 (4): 107–46.
Carnegie, Allison. 2015. Power Plays: How International Institutions Reshape Coercive Diplomacy. Cambridge University Press.
Carson, Austin. 2018. Secret Wars: Covert Conflict in International Politics. Princeton University Press.
Caverley, Jonathan D. 2014. Democratic Militarism: Voting, Wealth, and War. Cambridge University Press.
Chaudhry, Suparna. 2016. The Assault on Democracy Assistance: Explaining State Repression of NGOs. PhD Dissertation, Yale University.
Chaudoin, Stephen, Milner, Helen V., and Pang, Xun. 2015. International Systems and Domestic Politics: Linking Complex Interactions with Empirical Models in International Relations. International Organization 69 (2):275309.
Cheibub, José Antonio, Gandhi, Jennifer, and Vreeland, James Raymond. 2009. Democracy and Dictatorship Revisited. Public Choice 143 (1–2):67101.
Chiozza, Giacomo, and Goemans, H.E.. 2011. Leaders and International Conflict. Cambridge University Press.
Colgan, Jeff D. 2013. Domestic Revolutionary Leaders and International Conflict. World Politics 65 (4):656–90.
Conrad, Courtenay R., and Ritter, Emily Hencken. 2019. Contentious Compliance: Dissent and Repression Under International Human Rights Law. Oxford University Press.
Croco, Sarah E., and Weeks, Jessica L.P.. 2016. War Outcomes and Leader Tenure. World Politics 68 (4):577607.
Davenport, Christian. 2007. State Repression and the Domestic Democratic Peace. Cambridge University Press.
Debs, Alexandre, and Goemans, H.E.. 2010. Regime Type, the Fate of Leaders, and War. American Political Science Review 104 (3):430–45.
Donno, Daniela. 2013. Defending Democratic Norms: International Actors and the Politics of Electoral Misconduct. Oxford University Press.
Downes, Alexander B. 2009. How Smart and Tough Are Democracies? Reassessing Theories of Democratic Victory in War. International Security 33 (4):951.
Downes, Alexander B., and Sechser, Todd S.. 2012. The Illusion of Democratic Credibility. International Organization 66 (3):457–89.
Drezner, Daniel W., and McNamara, Kathleen R.. 2013. International Political Economy, Global Financial Orders and the 2008 Financial Crisis. Perspectives on Politics 11 (1):155–66.
Escriba-Folch, Abel, and Wright, Joseph. 2015. Foreign Pressure and the Politics of Autocratic Survival. Oxford Studies in Democratization. Oxford University Press.
Farrell, Henry, and Newman, Abraham L.. 2014. Domestic Institutions Beyond the Nation-State: Charting the New Interdependence Approach. World Politics 66 (2):331–63.
Fearon, James D. 1994. Domestic Political Audiences and the Escalation of International Disputes. American Political Science Review 88 (3):577–92.
Fravel, M. Taylor. 2008. Strong Borders, Secure Nation: Cooperation and Conflict in China's Territorial Disputes. Princeton University Press.
Freeman, John R., and Quinn, Dennis P.. 2012. The Economic Origins of Democracy Reconsidered. American Political Science Review 106 (1):5880.
Gandhi, Jennifer. 2010. Political Institutions Under Dictatorship. Cambridge University Press.
Geddes, Barbara. 1999. What Do We Know About Democratization After Twenty Years? Annual Review of Political Science 2 (1):115–44.
Goemans, Henk E., Gleditsch, Kristian Skrede, and Chiozza, Giacomo. 2009. Introducing Archigos: A Dataset of Political Leaders. Journal of Peace Research 46 (2):269–83.
Golder, Ben, and Williams, George. 2006. Balancing National Security and Human Rights: Assessing the Legal Response of Common Law Nations to the Threat of Terrorism. Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis: Research and Practice 8 (1):4362.
Goldstein, Judith. 1993. Ideas, Interests, and American Trade Policy. Cornell University Press.
Gourevitch, Peter. 1978. The Second Image Reversed: The International Sources of Domestic Politics. International Organization 32 (4):881912.
Gourevitch, Peter. 2002. Domestic Politics and International Relations. In Handbook of International Relations, edited by Carlsnaes, Walter, Risse, Thomas, and Simmons, Beth A., 309–28. Sage.
Gowa, Joanne. 2000. Ballots and Bullets: The Elusive Democratic Peace. Princeton University Press.
Gray, Julia. 2013. The Company States Keep: International Economic Organizations and Investor Perceptions. Cambridge University Press.
Greitens, Sheena Chestnut. 2016. Dictators and Their Secret Police: Coercive Institutions and State Violence. Cambridge University Press.
Grossman, Gene M., and Helpman, Elhanan. 1994. Protection for Sale. The American Economic Review 84 (4):833–50.
Guisinger, Alexandra. 2009. Determining Trade Policy: Do Voters Hold Politicians Accountable? International Organization 63 (3):533–57.
Guisinger, Alexandra. 2017. American Opinion on Trade: Preferences Without Politics. Oxford University Press.
Gunitsky, Seva. 2015. Corrupting the Cyber-Commons: Social Media As a Tool of Autocratic Stability. Perspectives on Politics 13 (1):4254.
Gunitsky, Seva. 2017. Aftershocks: Great Powers and Domestic Reforms in the Twentieth Century. Princeton University Press.
Hafner-Burton, Emilie M. 2013. Forced To Be Good: Why Trade Agreements Boost Human Rights. Cornell University Press.
Hafner-Burton, Emilie M., Haggard, Stephan, Lake, David A., and Victor, David G.. 2017. The Behavioral Revolution and International Relations. International Organization 71 (S1):S1S31.
Hankla, Charles R., and Kuthy, Daniel. 2013. Economic Liberalism in Illiberal Regimes: Authoritarian Variation and the Political Economy of Trade. International Studies Quarterly 57 (3):492504.
Hollyer, James R., Rosendorff, B. Peter, and Vreeland, James Raymond. 2018. Information, Democracy, and Autocracy: Economic Transparency and Political (In)Stability. Cambridge University Press.
Horowitz, Michael C., Stam, Allan C., and Ellis, Cali M.. 2015. Why Leaders Fight. Cambridge University Press.
Hyde, Susan D. 2011. The Pseudo-Democrat's Dilemma: Why Election Observation Became an International Norm. Cornell University Press.
Hyde, Susan D., and Marinov, Nikolay. 2014. Information and Self-Enforcing Democracy: The Role of International Election Observation. International Organization 68 (2):329–59.
Jensen, Nathan. 2008. Political Risk, Democratic Institutions, and Foreign Direct Investment. The Journal of Politics 70 (4):1040–52.
Kant, Immanuel. 1795. Toward Perpetual Peace. In Toward Perpetual Peace and Other Writings on Politics, Peace, and History, translated by Colclasure, David L., 7478. Yale University Press.
Kaplan, Stephen B. 2016. Banking Unconditionally: The Political Economy of Chinese Finance in Latin America. Review of International Political Economy 23 (4):643–76.
Keck, Margaret E., and Sikkink, Kathryn. 1998. Activists Beyond Borders: Advocacy Networks in International Politics. Cornell University Press.
Keohane, Robert O. 1984. After Hegemony: Cooperation and Discord in the World Political Economy. Princeton University Press.
Keohane, Robert O., Macedo, Stephen, and Moravcsik, Andrew. 2009. Democracy-Enhancing Multilateralism. International Organization 63 (1):131.
Kertzer, Joshua D. 2016. Resolve in International Politics. Princeton University Press.
Krcmaric, Daniel. 2018. Should I Stay or Should I Go? Leaders, Exile, and the Dilemmas of International Justice. American Journal of Political Science 62 (2):486–98.
Kreps, Sarah. 2018. Taxing Wars: The American Way of War Finance and the Decline of Democracy. Oxford University Press.
Kreps, Sarah E., Saunders, Elizabeth N., and Schultz, Kenneth A.. 2018. The Ratification Premium: Hawks, Doves, and Arms Control. World Politics 70 (4):479514.
Lake, David A. 1992. Powerful Pacifists: Democratic States and War. American Political Science Review 86 (1):2437.
Lake, David A. 2009. Open Economy Politics: A Critical Review. The Review of International Organizations 4 (3):219–44.
Lake, David A., and Baum, Matthew A.. 2001. The Invisible Hand of Democracy: Political Control and the Provision of Public Services. Comparative Political Studies 34 (6):587621.
Lall, Ranjit. 2016. How Multiple Imputation Makes a Difference. Political Analysis 24 (4):414–33.
Leblang, David, and Chan, Steve. 2003. Explaining Wars Fought by Established Democracies: Do Institutional Constraints Matter? Political Research Quarterly 56 (4):385400.
Leeds, Brett Ashley, Mattes, Michaela, and Vogel, Jeremy S.. 2009. Interests, Institutions, and the Reliability of International Commitments. American Journal of Political Science 53 (2):461–76.
Levitsky, Steven, and Way, Lucan A.. 2010. Competitive Authoritarianism: Hybrid Regimes After the Cold War. Cambridge University Press.
Li, Quan, and Resnick, Adam. 2003. Reversal of Fortunes: Democratic Institutions and Foreign Direct Investment Inflows to Developing Countries. International Organization 57 (1):175211.
Lindberg, Staffan I., Coppedge, Michael, Gerring, John, and Teorell, Jan. 2014. V-Dem: A New Way to Measure Democracy. Journal of Democracy 25 (3):159–69.
Lipscy, Phillip Y. 2018. Democracy and Financial Crisis. International Organization 72 (4):937–68.
Lipson, Charles. 2003. Reliable Partners: How Democracies Have Made a Separate Peace. Princeton University Press.
Lohmann, Susanne, and O'Halloran, Sharyn. 1994. Divided Government and US Trade Policy: Theory and Evidence. International Organization 48 (4):595632.
Lupu, Yonatan. 2015. Legislative Veto Players and the Effects of International Human Rights Agreements. American Journal of Political Science 59 (3):578–94.
Lyall, Jason. 2010. Do Democracies Make Inferior Counterinsurgents? Reassessing Democracy's Impact on War Outcomes and Duration. International Organization 64 (1):167–92.
Mack, Andrew. 1975. Why Big Nations Lose Small Wars: The Politics of Asymmetric Conflict. World Politics 27 (2):175200.
Mansfield, Edward D., Milner, Helen V., and Rosendorff, B. Peter. 2000. Free to Trade: Democracies, Autocracies, and International Trade. American Political Science Review 94 (2):305–21.
Mansfield, Edward D., Milner, Helen V., and Rosendorff, B. Peter. 2002. Why Democracies Cooperate More: Electoral Control and International Trade Agreements. International Organization 56 (3):477513.
Mansfield, Edward D., Mutz, Diana C., and Silver, Laura R.. 2015. Men, Women, Trade, and Free Markets. International Studies Quarterly 59 (2):303–15.
Maoz, Zeev, and Russett, Bruce. 1993. Normative and Structural Causes of Democratic Peace, 1946–1986. American Political Science Review 87 (3):624–38.
Marinov, Nikolay, and Goemans, Hein. 2014. Coups and Democracy. British Journal of Political Science 44 (4):799825.
Martin, Lisa L. 2000. Democratic Commitments: Legislatures and International Cooperation. Princeton University Press.
Mattes, Michaela, Leeds, Brett Ashley, and Matsumura, Naoko. 2016. Measuring Change in Source of Leader Support: The CHISOLS Dataset. Journal of Peace Research 53 (2):259–67.
Mattes, Michaela, and Rodríguez, Mariana. 2014. Autocracies and International Cooperation. International Studies Quarterly 58 (3):527–38.
Miller, Michael K., and Peters, Margaret E.. 2018. Restraining the Huddled Masses: Migration Policy and Autocratic Survival. British Journal of Political Science, 131. doi:10.1017/S0007123417000680.
Milner, Helen V. 1997. Interests, Institutions, and Information: Domestic Politics and International Relations. Princeton University Press.
Milner, Helen V., and Kubota, Keiko. 2005. Why the Move to Free Trade? Democracy and Trade Policy in the Developing Countries. International Organization 59 (1):107–43.
Milner, Helen V., and Mukherjee, Bumba. 2009. Democratization and Economic Globalization. Annual Review of Political Science 12:163–81.
Milner, Helen V., and Tingley, Dustin. 2015. Sailing the Water's Edge: The Domestic Politics of American Foreign Policy. Princeton University Press.
Moravcsik, Andrew. 1997. Taking Preferences Seriously: A Liberal Theory of International Politics. International Organization 51 (4):513–53.
Musgrave, Paul. 2019. International Hegemony Meets Domestic Politics: Why Liberals Can Be Pessimists. Security Studies 28 (3):451–78.
Naoi, Megumi. 2015. Building Legislative Coalitions for Globalization in Asia: Globalization As Legislation. Cambridge University Press.
Narang, Vipin, and Staniland, Paul. 2018. Democratic Accountability and Foreign Security Policy: Theory and Evidence from India. Security Studies 27 (3):410–47.
Narang, Vipin, and Talmadge, Caitlin. 2018. Civil-Military Pathologies and Defeat in War: Tests Using New Data. Journal of Conflict Resolution 67 (7):1379–405.
Nooruddin, Irfan, and Simmons, Joel W.. 2006. The Politics of Hard Choices: IMF Programs and Government Spending. International Organization 60 (4):1001–33.
Oatley, Thomas. 2011. The Reductionist Gamble: Open Economy Politics in the Global Economy. International Organization 65 (2):311–41.
Owen, John M. 2002. The Foreign Imposition of Domestic Institutions. International Organization 56 (2):375409.
Peceny, Mark, and Butler, Christopher K.. 2004. The Conflict Behavior of Authoritarian Regimes. International Politics 41 (4):565–81.
Peinhardt, Clint, and Wellhausen, Rachel L.. 2016. Withdrawing from Investment Treaties but Protecting Investment. Global Policy 7 (4):571–76.
Putnam, Robert D. 1988. Diplomacy and Domestic Politics: The Logic of Two-Level Games. International Organization 42 (3):427–60.
Rathbun, Brian C., Kertzer, Joshua D., Reifler, Jason, Goren, Paul, and Scotto, Thomas J.. 2016. Taking Foreign Policy Personally: Personal Values and Foreign Policy Attitudes. International Studies Quarterly 60 (1):124–37.
Regilme, Salvador Santino Fulo. 2018. Does US Foreign Aid Undermine Human Rights? The “Thaksinification” of the War on Terror Discourses and the Human Rights Crisis in Thailand, 2001 to 2006. Human Rights Review 19 (1):7395.
Reiter, Dan, and Stam, Allan C.. 2002. Democracies at War. Princeton University Press.
Rho, Sungmin, and Tomz, Michael. 2017. Why Don't Trade Preferences Reflect Economic Self-Interest? International Organization 71 (S1):S85–S108.
Rød, Espen Geelmuyden, and Weidmann, Nils B.. 2015. Empowering Activists or Autocrats? The Internet in Authoritarian Regimes. Journal of Peace Research 52 (3):338–51.
Roeder, Philip G. 1993. Red Sunset: The Failure of Soviet Politics. Princeton University Press.
Rogowski, Ronald. 1989. Commerce and Coalitions: How Trade Affects Domestic Political Alignments. Reprint edition. Princeton University Press.
Russett, Bruce M. 1993. Grasping the Democratic Peace: Principles for a Post-Cold War World. Princeton University Press.
Russett, Bruce M., and Oneal, John R.. 2001. Triangulating Peace: Democracy, Interdependence, and International Organizations. Norton.
Saunders, Elizabeth N. 2011. Leaders at War: How Presidents Shape Military Interventions. Cornell University Press.
Saunders, Elizabeth N. 2015. War and the Inner Circle: Democratic Elites and the Politics of Using Force. Security Studies 24 (3):466501.
Schattschneider, E.E. 1975. The Semisovereign People: A Realist's View of Democracy in America. Wadsworth.
Schuessler, John M. 2015. Deceit on the Road to War: Presidents, Politics, and American Democracy. Cornell University Press.
Schultz, Kenneth A. 2001a. Democracy and Coercive Diplomacy. Cambridge University Press.
Schultz, Kenneth A. 2001b. Looking for Audience Costs. Journal of Conflict Resolution 45 (1):3260.
Schultz, Kenneth A., and Weingast, Barry R.. 2003. The Democratic Advantage: Institutional Foundations of Financial Power in International Competition. International Organization 57 (1):342.
Shepsle, Kenneth A. 2017. Rule Breaking and Political Imagination. University of Chicago Press.
Shirk, Susan L. 1993. The Political Logic of Economic Reform in China. University of California Press.
Simmons, Beth A. 2009. Mobilizing for Human Rights: International Law in Domestic Politics. Cambridge University Press.
Simmons, Beth A. 2014. Bargaining Over Bits, Arbitrating Awards: The Regime for Protection and Promotion of International Investment. World Politics 66 (1):1246.
Slantchev, Branislav L. 2006. Politicians, the Media, and Domestic Audience Costs. International Studies Quarterly 50 (2):445–77.
Slater, Dan. 2013. Democratic Careening. World Politics 65 (4):729–63.
Slaughter, Anne-Marie. 1995. International Law in a World of Liberal States. European Journal of International Law 6 (3):503–38.
Snyder, Jack, and Borghard, Erica D.. 2011. The Cost of Empty Threats: A Penny, Not a Pound. American Political Science Review 105 (3):437–56.
Stein, Rachel M. 2015. War and Revenge: Explaining Conflict Initiation by Democracies. American Political Science Review 109 (3):556–73.
Steinberg, David. 2015. Demanding Devaluation: Exchange Rate Politics in the Developing World. Cornell University Press.
Steinberg, David A., and Malhotra, Krishan. 2014. The Effect of Authoritarian Regime Type on Exchange Rate Policy. World Politics 66 (3):491529.
Svolik, Milan W. 2012. The Politics of Authoritarian Rule. Cambridge University Press.
Talmadge, Caitlin. 2015. The Dictator's Army: Battlefield Effectiveness in Authoritarian Regimes. Cornell University Press.
Tobin, Jennifer L., and Busch, Marc L.. 2010. A BIT Is Better Than a Lot: Bilateral Investment Treaties and Preferential Trade Agreements. World Politics 62 (1):142.
Tomz, Michael R., and Weeks, Jessica L.P.. 2013. Public Opinion and the Democratic Peace. American Political Science Review 107 (4):849–65.
Tufekci, Zeynep. 2017. Twitter and Tear Gas: The Power and Fragility of Networked Protest. Yale University Press.
Voeten, Erik. 2019. Populism and Backlashes Against International Courts. Perspectives on Politics, 116, doi:10.1017/S1537592719000975.
Von Stein, Jana. 2015. Making Promises, Keeping Promises: Democracy, Ratification, and Compliance in International Human Rights Law. British Journal of Political Science 46:655–79.
Vreeland, James Raymond. 2008. Political Institutions and Human Rights: Why Dictatorships Enter into the United Nations Convention Against Torture. International Organization 62 (1):65101.
Wallace, Jeremy. 2016. Juking the Stats? Authoritarian Information Problems in China. British Journal of Political Science 46 (1):1129.
Waltz, Kenneth N. 1979. Theory of International Politics. Addison-Wesley.
Weeks, Jessica L. 2008. Autocratic Audience Costs: Regime Type and Signaling Resolve. International Organization 62 (1):3564.
Weeks, Jessica L. 2014. Dictators at War and Peace. Cornell University Press.
Weiss, Jessica Chen. 2014. Powerful Patriots: Nationalist Protest in China's Foreign Relations. Oxford University Press.
Weiss, Jessica Chen. 2019. A World Safe for Autocracy? Foreign Affairs July/August.
Wendt, Alexander E. 1987. The Agent-Structure Problem in International Relations Theory. International Organization 41 (3):335–70.
Whitaker, Beth Elise. 2007. Exporting the Patriot Act? Democracy and the “War on Terror” in the Third World. Third World Quarterly 28 (5):1017–32.
Wolford, Scott. 2007. The Turnover Trap: New Leaders, Reputation, and International Conflict. American Journal of Political Science 51 (4):772–88.

Keywords

Recapturing Regime Type in International Relations: Leaders, Institutions, and Agency Space

  • Susan D. Hyde and Elizabeth N. Saunders

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed