Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-4hhp2 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-05-11T00:05:43.792Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

‘I ran away’? The I.R.A. and 1969: the evolution of a myth

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  04 February 2015

Brian Hanley
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Between 13 and 15 August 1969 communal violence in Belfast saw seven people killed and over 400 treated for injuries. Nearly 2,000 families were forced from their homes. British troops were deployed on the streets to prevent further violence, events usually seen as the starting point of the modern Irish Troubles. In 1972 the Sunday Times Insight Team's Ulster set the tone for commentary on the role of the I.R.A. during this period. It claimed that the organisation had been ‘largely an irrelevance’ in Belfast during August 1969 and as a result ‘I.R.A. – I Ran Away was scrawled derisively over the walls of the Catholic Ghettos’. Conor Cruise O'Brien soon asserted in States of Ireland that when violence erupted ‘the I.R.A. had very few weapons and very few people trained and ready to use them. Their prestige in the Ghettos went sharply down. People wrote on walls I.R.A. I Ran Away.’ Echoing these statements twentythree years later Tim Pat Coogan in his book The Troubles stated that ‘the I.R.A. posed very little threat to anyone during those days. So little that the disgusted inhabitants of the area, used to regarding the I.R.A. in the traditional role of “the defenders” wrote up the letters I.R.A. on gable walls as Irish Ran Away.' Similar assertions are found in a wide variety of the literature, both popular and academic, dealing with the outbreak of the Troubles.

Type
Research Article
Information
Irish Historical Studies , Volume 38 , Issue 152 , November 2013 , pp. 671 - 687
Copyright
Copyright © Irish Historical Studies Publications Ltd 2013 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Irish Times, 16 Aug. 1969.

2 Government of Northern Ireland, Violence and civil disturbances in Northern Ireland in 1969: report of tribunal of inquiry [hereafter ‘Scarman report’] (Belfast, 1972), part XII, ‘Social cost’.Google Scholar

3 Sunday Times Insight Team, Ulster (London, 1972), pp 114, 177.

4 O’Brien, Conor Cruise, States of Ireland (London, 1974 edn.), p. 193.Google Scholar

5 Coogan, Tim Pat, The Troubles: Ireland’s ordeal 1966–1995 and the search for peace (London, 1995), p. 89.Google Scholar

6 See for example Mulholland, Marc, The longest war: Northern Ireland’s troubled history (Oxford, 2002), p. 78;Google Scholar O’Leary, Brendan, ‘Mission accomplished? Looking back at the I.R.A.?’ in Field Day Review, 1 (2005), pp 217–16 at p. 226;Google Scholar Hennessey, Thomas, A history of Northern Ireland (London, 1997), p. 171;Google Scholar Kelley, Kevin, The longest war (London, 1982), p 122;Google Scholar Wichert, Sabine, Northern Ireland since 1945 (London, 1999), p. 121;Google Scholar Holland, Jack, Too long a sacrifice (New York, 1981), p. 43;Google Scholar Bartlett, Thomas, Ireland: a history (Cambridge, 2010), p. 511.Google Scholar

7 McGarry, John and O’Leary, Brendan, Explaining Northern Ireland: broken images (London, 1995), p. 259 and pp 66–7.Google Scholar

8 Bardon, Jonathan, A history of Ulster (Belfast, 1992), p. 675.Google Scholar

9 Moloney, Ed, The secret history of the I.R.A. (London, 2002), pp 52–73.Google Scholar

10 Foster, Roy, Modern Ireland, 1600–1972 (London, 1988), p. 589.Google Scholar

11 Treacy, Matt, The I.R.A. 1956–69: rethinking the Republic (Manchester, 2011), pp 63–87.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

12 Patterson, Henry, Ireland since 1939: the persistence of conflict (Oxford, 2006), p. 199.Google Scholar

13 Harris, Eoghan, ‘My secret life’ in Britain and Ireland: lives entwined (Dublin, 2005),p 66–81.Google Scholar

14 Harris, Eoghan, ‘Portrait of a party hack’ in In Dublin, 7 Jan. 1988.Google Scholar

15 Johnston, Roy, Century of endeavour: a biographical and autobiographical view of the 20th century in Ireland (Dublin, 2006); Saoirse-Irish Freedom, May 2006.Google Scholar

16 An tOglach, Dec. 1967, quoted in Brian Hanley, “‘Agitate, educate, organise”: the I.R.A.’s An tÓglach, 1965–68’ in Saothar, xxxii (2007), pp 51–62.

17 United Irishman, June 1967; Irish News, 15 Jan. 1968.

18 McMillen, Liam, ‘The role of the I.R.A., 1962–1967’, lecture, June 1972, in hAgáin, Deasún, Liam McMillen, separatist, socialist, republican (Dublin, 1975), p. 8.Google Scholar

19 Scarman report, ‘West Belfast’, 18.6; interview, Seán Curry, Belfast, 9 Sept. 2004.

20 Minutes of national I.R.A. officers meeting, 29 and 30 Aug. 1967 (private source, copy deposited in U. C. D. archives).

21 Hanley, Brian, The I.RA.: a documentary history 1916–2005(Dublin, 2010), pp 150–1.Google Scholar

22 United Irishman, Dec. 1970.

23 ‘Discussion on the strategy of Peoples Democracy’ in New Left Review, i, 55, May-June 1969.

24 Royal Ulster Constabulary (R.U.C.) report, 7 July 1969, (P.R.O.N.I., HA/32/2/28).

25 Irish News, 5 Aug. 1968.

26 R.U.C. report, 29 Aug. 1968, (P.R.O.N.I., CAB/9B/1205/7).

27 McMillen, , ‘The role of the I.R.A.’, p. 9; Gerry Adams, ‘A republican in the civil rights campaign’ in Farrell, Michael (ed.), Twenty years on (Dingle, 1988), pp 39–53; interview, Bobby McKnight, Belfast, 1 Sept. 2004.Google Scholar

28 Heatley, Fred, ‘The early marches’ in Fortnight, 5 Apr. 1974.Google Scholar

29 United Irishman, Feb. 1969.

30 Government of Northern Ireland, Disturbances in Northern Ireland: report of the commission appointed by the governor of Northern Ireland (Cameron report) (Belfast, 1969)p. 86.Google Scholar

31 Irish Times, 7 Feb. 1969.

32 Sunday Tribune, 2 Sept. 1984.

33 Magill, June 1980.

34 Irish Times, 30 May, 2 Aug., 8 Oct., 9 Oct. 1968; Irish Press, 17 Mar., 12 June 1969.

35 Memorandums for government in relation to I.R.A., 18 Mar., 14 July, 1969 (N.A.I., DJ 2000/36/3).

36 A play on the title of a republican song and the name of the supposed Marxist theorist within the I.R.A., Roy Johnston.

37 Irish Press, 12 June 1969.

38 Irish Press, 4 Aug, 6 Aug. 1969.

39 Savage, Robert J. A loss of innocence: television and Irish society, 1960–72 (Manchester, 2010) pp 367–8.Google Scholar

40 Joint Intelligence Committee memorandum, 16 June 1969, (T.N.A., CAB, 186/3).

41 Irish News, 7 Apr. 1969; Derry Journal, 8 Apr. 1969; United Irishman, May 1969.

42 Interview Seán O’Hare, Belfast 30 Aug. 2004; Curry interview.

43 Irish News, 21 Apr. 1969.

44 R.U.C., report, 10 Aug. 1969 (P.R.O.N.I, HA/32/2/28).

45 McMillen, , ‘The role of the I.R.A.’, p.10; Irish News, 22, 23 Apr. 1969.Google Scholar

46 Hennessey, Thomas, Northern Ireland: the origins of the troubles (Dublin, 2005), p. 209; Belfast Telegraph, 24 Apr. 1969.Google Scholar

47 Belfast Newsletter, 21, 22 Apr. 1969.

48 Irish Times, 22 Apr.1969.

49 McMillen, , ‘The role of the I.R.A.’, p. 10.Google Scholar

50 Interview, Mick Ryan, Dundalk, 2 Apr. 2005.

51 Resolutions of 1968 General Army Convention (private source, copy deposited in U.C.D. archives).

52 Irish Times, 15–16 May and 22–24 May 1969.

53 Memorandum for government in relation to I.R.A., 14 July 1969 (N.A.I., DJ 2000/36/3).

54 Ibid.

55 Taylor, Peter, Provos (London, 1997), pp 45–6.Google Scholar

56 Sinn Féin coiste seasta minutes, July 1969, Dublin (courtesy of Workers Party of Ireland).

57 White, Robert, Ruairí O Brádaigh: portrait of an Irish revolutionary (Bloomington, IN, 2006) pp 143–4.Google Scholar

58 Saoirse-Irish Freedom, May 2006.

59 This Week, 7 Aug. 1970.

60 Sunday Press, 24 Aug. 1969.

61 Patterson, Henry, The politics of illusion: a political history of the I.R.A. (London, 1997), p. 124.Google Scholar

62 Irish News, 15 Apr. 1970; Scarman report, 9.21.

63 Bradley, Gerry with Feeney, Brian, Insider: Gerry Bradley’s life in the I.R.A. (Dublin, 2009), p. 37.Google Scholar

64 McMillen, , ‘The role of the I.R.A.’, p. 11.Google Scholar

65 United Irishman, Dec. 1970.

66 Dochartaigh, Niall Ó, From civil rights to armalites: Derry and the birth of the Northern Ireland Troubles (London, 2005), pp 99–104.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

67 Derry Journal, 14 Aug. 2009.

68 Curry interview; O’Hare interview.

69 Curry interview.

70 McMillen, , ‘The role of the I.R.A.’ p.11;Google Scholar Irish News, 30 May 1970; Scarman report, 18. 25–6.

71 Interviews Belfast I.R.A. 16 Mar. 2006; Alonso, Rogelio, The IRA. and armed struggle (London, 2006), pp 46–7.Google Scholar

72 Sunday Press, 24 Aug. 1969; Scarman report, 17.8–10.

73 Adams, Gerry, Before the dawn (London, 1996), p. 104.Google Scholar

74 Scarman report, 21.30-4; Curry interview; O’Hare interview.

75 Irish News, 3 Nov. 1970.

76 Irish News, 14–16 Aug. 1969; Belfast Telegraph, 14–16 Aug. 1969.

77 Republican News (Cork) Sept. 1969.

78 Ibid; Curry interview; O’Hare interview.

79 O’Hare interview.

80 Irish News, 5 Sept. 1969.

81 Adams, , Before the dawn, p. 105.Google Scholar

82 Magill, May 1980; McKnight interview.

83 Belfast Telegraph, 14 Aug. 1969; Newry Reporter, 21 Aug. 1969; The Plough, June 1974.

84 Irish Times, 23 Aug. 1969.

85 Ryan interview.

86 Swan, Sean, Official Irish Republicanism, 1962–1972 (Lulu, 2007) pp 296–7.Google Scholar

87 Irish Times, 16 Aug. 1969.

88 Tyrone Democrat, 21 Aug. 1969; Irish Times, 23 Aug. 1969; interview, Jer O’Leary, Dublin, 29 Aug. 2004.

89 Irish Times, 18 Aug. 1969.

90 Irish Times, 19 Aug. 1969; United Irishman, Sept. 1969.

91 Belfast Newsletter, 18 Aug. 1969; Irish Times, 19 Aug. 1969.

92 Irish Press, 19 Aug. 1969.

93 Irish Press, 23 Aug. 1969.

94 English, Armed struggle, p. 104.

95 R.U.C. report, 18 Aug. 1969 in Scarman report, Appendix, pp 53–4.

96 War Office and Ministry of Defence: Army Unit Historical Records and Reports, Headquarters, Northern Ireland Command, 1 Sept. 1969 (T.N.A., WO 305/3758).

97 Peter Berry to Jack Lynch, 8 June 1970, (N.A.I., DJ 2001/6/10); Kelly, John, ‘How urgent the need?’, The Blanket, 17 Aug. 2005;Google Scholar Hennessey, , Northern Ireland, pp 337–55.Google Scholar

98 Belfast Newsletter, 25 Aug. 1969.

99 Hibernia, 29 Aug. 1969.

100 Belfast Telegraph, 26 Aug. 1969.

101 Republican News, Cork, 1969.

102 The monthly republican newspaper, published in Dublin.

103 United Irishman, Sept. 1969.

104 Callaghan, James, A house divided: the dilemma of Northern Ireland (London, 1973), pp 102–03;Google Scholar The Times, 8 Sept. 1969; Belfast Newsletter, 17 Sept. 1969.

105 War Office and Ministry of Defence: Army Unit Historical Records and Reports, Headquarters, Northern Ireland Command, 2 and 12 Sept. 1969, (T.N.A., WO 305/3758).

106 Belfast Telegraph, 8 Sept. 1969.

107 Belfast Newsletter, 8 Sept. 1969.

108 Belfast Telegraph, 21, 23 Aug. 1969; Irish News, 11 Sept. 1969; Irish Independent, 10 Sept. 1969; Belfast Newsletter, 17 Sept. 1969.

109 Irish Independent, 26 Aug. 1969.

110 O’Hare interview.

111 Curry interview.

112 Letter from Horgan, Tim in History Ireland, 18, no.2, (Mar./Apr. 2010), p. 13.Google Scholar

113 Hibernia, 29 Aug. 1969.

114 Nusight, Sept. 1969.

115 United Irishman, Oct. and Nov.1969.

116 Comhar, Meán Fómhair/Sept. 1969.

117 Hibernia, 5–15 Dec. 1969.

118 Hastings, Max, Ulster 1969: the fight for civil rights in Northern Ireland (London, 1970) pp 141, 167.Google Scholar

119 Irish Times, 29 Apr. 1970.

120 Sunday Press, 24 Aug. 1969.

121 An Phoblacht/Republican News, 19 Aug. 1999.

122 An Phoblacht, May 1970; Republican News, Oct. 1970.

123 Meaning the pre-split I.R.A. The term ‘Official’ did not come into use until after January 1970.

124 Hughes, Brendan, ‘I.R.A. volunteer Charlie Hughes and the courage of the brave’in The Blanket, 10 Sept. 2002.Google Scholar

125 Sinn Féin education department, republican lecture no.1, The Split (Dublin, 1984).

126 Adams, , Before the dawn, p. 126 Google Scholar

127 Time, 5 Apr. 1971. However eight years later the magazine would claim it was British soldiers who first used the slogan in 1969: Time, 19 Nov. 1979.

128 Sunday Times Insight Team, Ulster; O’Brien, States of Ireland.

129 The Guardian, 24 Oct. 2001. A more nuanced recent account is Simon Prince and Warner, Geoffrey, Belfast and Derry in revolt (Dublin, 2012).Google Scholar

130 Irish Press, 13–15 Aug. 1969.

131 Irish Times, 14 Aug. 1969.

132 Irish Press, 10 Aug. 1971.

133 Lynch, Robert, ‘The people’s protectors? The Irish Republican Army and the “Belfast pogrom”, 1920–1922’ in Journal of British Studies, 47, no. 2 (Apr. 2008), pp 375–91;CrossRefGoogle Scholar Hanley, Brian, The I.R.A., 1926–1936 (Dublin, 2002), pp 145–60;Google Scholar Glennon, Kieran, From pogrom to civil war: Tom Glennon and the Belfast IRA, (Cork, 2013).Google Scholar

134 There is little evidence of any effort to interview veterans of the pre-1969 Belfast I.R.A.

135 Irish News, 30 Mar. 1970.

136 United Irishman, Dec. 1970.

137 Hanley, Brian and Millar, Scott, The lost revolution: the story of the Official I.R.A. and the Workers Party (Dublin, 2009), pp 336–587.Google Scholar

138 Foster, , Modern Ireland, p. 584.Google Scholar

139 Rossa, Proinsias de, Irish Times, 4 May 1991.Google Scholar

140 Irish Times, 18 Apr. 1988.

141 See Bew, Paul, Ireland: the politics of enmity 1789–2006 (Oxford, 2007), p. 503.Google Scholar

142 During 2010 the Workers Party published a pamphlet commemorating the role of the Official I.R.A. during the 1970 Falls curfew. This was the party’s first public acknowledgement of the Offical I.R.A.’s military actions since the mid-1970s: Workers Party, The story of the Falls curfew (Dublin, 2010).

143 This Week, 7 Aug. 1970.

144 Sunday Tribune, 2 Sept. 1984.

145 Goulding in ‘The sparks that lit the bonfire’, Timewatch, B.B.C.2, 27 Jan. 1992.