Skip to main content Accessibility help

Effects of management practices on the welfare of dairy donkeys and risk factors associated with signs of hoof neglect

  • Francesca Dai (a1), Giulia Segati (a1), Marta Brscic (a2), Matteo Chincarini (a3), Emanuela Dalla Costa (a1), Lorenzo Ferrari (a1), Faith Burden (a4), Andrew Judge (a4) and Michela Minero (a1)...


This Research Paper aimed to investigate donkey welfare in dairy husbandry systems and to identify the potential factors affecting it at animal level. In 2015, twelve dairy donkey farms (19–170 donkeys per farm, mean = 55 ± 48), distributed throughout Italy, were visited. On each farm, the Animal Welfare Indicators (AWIN) welfare assessment protocol for donkeys was used by two trained assessors to evaluate the welfare of animals for a total of 257 donkeys assessed. The protocol includes animal-based indicators that were entered in a digitalised system. Prevalence of different scores at individual, farm and category level were calculated. Farmers were asked to fill out a questionnaire including information regarding the management of donkeys and their final destination. Answers to the questionnaire were then considered as effects in the risk factor analysis whereas the scores of the animal-based indicators were considered as response variables. Most of the donkeys (80·2%) enjoyed a good nutritional status (BCS = 3). 18·7% of donkeys showed signs of hoof neglect such as overgrowth and/or incorrect trimming (Min = 0% Max = 54·5%). Belonging to a given farm or production group influenced many of the welfare indicators. The absence of pasture affected the likelihood of having skin lesions, alopecia, low BCS scores and a less positive emotional state. Lack of routine veterinary visits (P < 0·001) and having neglected hooves (P < 0·001) affected the likelihood of being thin (BCS < 3). Belonging to specific production groups, lack of access to pasture and showing an avoidance reaction to an approaching human (AD) resulted in risk factors associated with a higher prevalence of signs of hoof neglect. Our results support the idea that lack of knowledge of proper donkey care among owners was behind many welfare issues found.


Corresponding author

*For correspondence; e-mail:


Hide All
Aida, H & Dehghani, SN 2012 Hoof morphometry before and after trimming in donkeys. Research Opinions in Animal & Veterinary Sciences 2 381383
AWIN 2015 AWIN welfare assessment protocol for donkeys. doi:10.13130/AWIN_DONKEYS_2015
Boersema, JSC, Noordhuizen, JPTM & Lievaart, JJ 2013 Hazard perception of Dutch farmers and veterinarians related to dairy young stock rearing. Journal of Dairy Science 96 50275034
Brscic, M, Leruste, H, Heutinck, LFM, Bokkers, EAM, Wolthuis-Fillerup, M, Stockhofe, N, Gottardo, F, Lensink, BJ, Cozzi, G & Van Reenen, CG 2012 Prevalence of respiratory disorders in veal calves and potential risk factors. Journal of Dairy Science 95 27532764
Burden, F 2011 Practical feeding and condition scoring for donkeys and mules. Equine Veterinary Education 24 589596
Carroccio, A, Cavataio, F, Montalto, G, D'Amico, D, Alabrese, L & Iacono, G 2000 Intolerance to hydrolysed cow's milk proteins in infants: clinical characteristics and dietary treatment. Clinical and Experimental Allergy 30 15971603
Corbett, CJ, Love, S, Moore, A, Burden, F, Matthews, JB & Denwood, MJ 2014 The effectiveness of faecal removal methods of pasture management to control the cyathostomin burden of donkeys. Parasites & Vectors 7 48
Cox, R, Proudman, CJ, Trawford, AF, Burden, F & Pinchbeck, GL 2007 Epidemiology of impaction colic in donkeys in the UK. BMC Veterinary Research 3 1
Crane, M 2008 The donkey's foot. In The Professional Handbook of the Donkey, pp. 188201 (Eds. Svendsen, ED, Duncan, J & Hadrill, D). Yatesbury, Wiltshire, UK: Whitted Books
Dai, F, Dalla Costa, E, Battini, M, Barbieri, S, Minero, M, Mattiello, S & Canali, E 2014 An innovative tool for on-farm data collection and information sharing. In Proceedings of the 6th International Conference on the Assessment of Animal Welfare at Farm and Group Level, p. 153 (Eds. Mounier, L & Veissier, I), Wageningen, The Netherlands: Wageningen Academic Publishers
Dai, F, Dalla Costa, E, Murray, LMA, Canali, E & Minero, M 2016 Welfare conditions of donkeys in Europe: initial outcomes from On-farm assessment. Animals 6 5
Dai, F, Segati, G, Dalla Costa, E, Burden, F, Judge, A & Minero, M 2017 Management practices and milk production in dairy donkey farms distributed over the Italian territory. Macedonian Veterinary Review 40 i-vi
Dalla Costa, E, Murray, LAM, Dai, F, Canali, E & Minero, M 2014 Equine on-farm welfare assessment: a review of animal-based indicators. Animal Welfare 23 323341
Dalla Costa, E, Dai, F, Murray, LAM, Guazzetti, S, Canali, E & Minero, M 2015 A study on validity and reliability of on-farm tests to measure human–animal relationship in horses and donkeys. Applied Animal Behaviour Science 163 110121
Duffield, H 2008 Colic. In The Professional Handbook of the Donkey, pp. 3751 (Eds. Svendsen, ED, Duncan, J & Hadrill, D). Yatesbury, Wiltshire, UK: Whitted Books
Dwyer, CM 2009 Welfare of sheep: providing for welfare in an extensive environment. Small Ruminant Research 86 1421
Faostat 2015
Faramarzi, B, Thomason, JJ & Sears, WC 2009 Changes in growth of the hoof wall and hoof morphology in response to regular periods of trotting exercise in standardbreds. American Journal of Veterinary Research 70 13541364
Goddard, P, Waterhouse, T, Dwyer, C & Stott, A 2006 The perception of the welfare of sheep in extensive systems. Small Ruminant Research 62 215225
Goddard, PJ 2013 Small ruminant welfare: levelling the playing field or raising the bar-A European perspective. Small Ruminant Research 110 108111
Górecka-Bruzda, A, Jaworski, Z, Suwała, M, Sobczyńska, M, Jastrzębska, E, Ogłuszka, M, Sankeyc, , Marlena Boroń, C & Jezierski, T 2017 Aversiveness of husbandry procedures for pre-weaned foals: acomparison using behavioural and physiological indices. Applied Animal Behaviour Science 191 3138
Grosso, L, Battini, M, Wemelsfelder, F, Barbieri, S, Minero, M, Dalla Costa, E & Mattiello, S 2016 On-farm qualitative behaviour assessment of dairy goats in different housing conditions. Applied Animal Behaviour Science 180 5157
Iacono, G, Carrocio, A, Cavataio, F, Montalto, G, Soresi, M & Balsamo, V 1992 Use of Ass milk in multiple food allergy. Journal of Pediatric Gastroenterology and Nutrition 14 177181
Ivemeyera, S, Pisani, M & Knierim, U 2015 Short-term ante-calving handling of dairy heifers in relation to heifers’ behaviour and udder health after parturition. Applied Animal Behaviour Science 171 3338
Klingel, H 1998 Observations on social organization and behaviour of African and Asiatic wild asses (equus africanus and equus hemionus). Applied Animal Behaviour Science 60 103113
Mekuria, S & Abebe, R 2010 Observation on major welfare problems of equine in Meskan district, Southern Ethiopia. Livestock Research for Rural Development 22 48
Minero, M, Dalla Costa, E, Dai, F, Murray, LAM, Canali, E & Wemelsfelder, F 2016 Use of qualitative behaviour assessment as an indicator of welfare in donkeys. Applied Animal Behaviour Science 174 147153
Moehlman, P 1998 Feral asses (equus africanus): intraspecific variation in social organization in arid and mesic habitats. Applied Animal Behaviour Science 60 171195
Pritchard, JC, Lindberg, AC, Main, DCJ & Whay, HR 2005 Assessment of the welfare of working horses, mules and donkeys, using health and behaviour parameters. Preventive Veterinary Medicine 69 265283
Proops, L, Burden, F & Osthaus, B 2012 Social relations in a mixed group of mules, ponies and donkeys reflect differences in equid type. Behavioural Processes 90 337342
Sevi, A, Casamassima, D, Pulina, G & Pazzona, A 2010 Factors of welfare reduction in dairy sheep and goats. Italian Journal of Animal Science 8 81101
Seyoum, Z, Tesfaye, M & Derso, S 2015 Prevalence, intensity and risk factors of infestation with major gastrointestinal nematodes in equines in and around Shashemane, Southern Ethiopia. Tropical Animal Health and Production 47 15151521
Smith, D & Wood, S 2008 Donkey nutrition. In The Professional Handbook of the Donkey, pp. 1027 (Eds. Svendsen, ED, Duncan, J & Hadrill, D). Yatesbury, Wiltshire, UK: Whittet Books
Sutherland, MA & Dowling, SK 2014 The relationship between responsiveness of first-lactation heifers to humans and the behavioral response to milking and milk production measures. Journal of Veterinary Behavior 9 3033
Thomason, JJ 1998 Variation in surface strain on the equine hoof wall at the mid step with shoeing, gait, substrate, direction of travel, and hoof shape. Equine Veterinary Journal Supplement 26 8695
Trawford, AF & Mulugeta, G 2008 Parasites. In The Professional Handbook of the Donkey, pp. 82110 (Eds. Svendsen, ED, Duncan, J & Hadrill, D). Yaresbury, Wilshire, UK: Whitted Books
van de Mortel, T 2008 Faking it: social desirability response bias in self-report research. Australian Journal of Advanced Nursing 25 4048
Vincenzetti, S, Polidori, P, Mariani, P, Cammertoni, N, Fantuz, F & Vita, A 2008 Donkey's milk protein fractions characterization. Food Chemistry 106 640649
Welfare Quality® 2009 Welfare Quality® Assessment Protocol for Cattle. Lelystad, the Netherlands: Welfare Quality® Consortium
Wemelsfelder, F 2007 How animals communicate quality of life: the qualitative assessment of behaviour. Animal Welfare 16 2531.
World Horse Welfare, Eurogroup for Animals 2015 Removing the Blinkers: The Health and Welfare of European Equidae in 2015
Wubie, A & Getaneh, G 2015 Study on prevalence and intensity of strongyle nematode infections in working donkeys in and around adet town, yilmana denssa woreda, Ethiopia. World Journal of Pharmaceutical Research 4 480494


Related content

Powered by UNSILO
Type Description Title
Supplementary materials

Dai et al supplementary material 1
Dai et al supplementary material

 PDF (463 KB)
463 KB

Effects of management practices on the welfare of dairy donkeys and risk factors associated with signs of hoof neglect

  • Francesca Dai (a1), Giulia Segati (a1), Marta Brscic (a2), Matteo Chincarini (a3), Emanuela Dalla Costa (a1), Lorenzo Ferrari (a1), Faith Burden (a4), Andrew Judge (a4) and Michela Minero (a1)...


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed.