Skip to main content


  • Juan Carlos Cordoba (a1) and Xiying Liu (a2)

Stochastic dominance (SD) is commonly used to rank income distributions and assess social policies. The literature argues that SD is a robust criterion for policy evaluation because it requires minimal knowledge of the social welfare function. We argue that, on the contrary, SD is not a robust criterion. We do this by carefully introducing microfoundations into a model by Chu and Koo (1990) who use SD to provide support to family-planning programs aiming at reducing the fertility of the poor. We show that fertility restrictions are generally detrimental for both individual and social welfare in spite of the fact that SD holds. Our findings are an application of the Lucas’ Critique.

Hide All
Alvarez, Fernando (1999) Social mobility: The Barro-Becker children meet the Laitner-Loury dynasties. Review of Economic Dynamics 2, 65103.
Atkinson, Anthony B. (1970) On the measurement of inequality. Journal of Economic Theory 2 (3), 244263.
Atkinson, Anthony B. and Brandolini, Andrea (2010) On analyzing the world distribution of income. World Bank Economic Review 24 (1), 137.
Barro, Robert J. and Becker, Gary S. (1989) Fertility choice in a model of economic growth. Econometrica 57 (2), 481501.
Becker, Gary S. (1960) An economic analysis of fertility. In Coale, A. J. (ed.), Demographic and Economic Change in Developed Countries, pp. 209240. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Becker, Gary S. and Barro, Robert J. (1988) A reformulation of the economic theory of fertility. The Quarterly Journal of Economics 103 (1), 125.
Chu, C. Y. Cyrus and Koo, Hui-Wen (1990) Intergenerational income-group mobility and differential fertility. American Economic Review 80 (5), 11251138.
Cordoba, Juan Carlos and Liu, Xiying (2014) Altruism, fertility and risk. Working paper 14010, Department of Economics, Iowa State University.
Cordoba, Juan Carlos, Liu, Xiying, and Ripoll, Marla (forthcoming) Fertility, social mobility and long run inequality. Journal of Monetary Economics.
Cordoba, Juan Carlos and Ripoll, Marla (2014) The elasticity of intergenerational substitution, parental altruism, and fertility choice. Working paper 14015, Department of Economics, Iowa State University.
Cordoba, Juan Carlos and Ripoll, Marla (in press) Intergenerational transfers and the fertility-income relationship. The Economic Journal.
Dasgupta, Partha, Sen, Amartya, and Starrett, David (1973) Notes on the measurement of inequality. Journal of Economic Theory 6 (2), 180187.
Davidson, Russell and Duclos, Jean-Yves (2000) Statistical inference for stochastic dominance and for the measurement of poverty and inequality. Econometrica 68 (6), 14351464.
Doepke, Matthias (2004) Accounting for fertility decline during the transition to growth. Journal of Economic Growth 9 (3), 347383.
Eckstein, Zvi. and Wolpin, Kenneth I. (1985) Endogenous fertility and optimal population size. Journal of Public Economics 27 (1), 93106.
Foster, James E. and Shorrocks, Anthony F. (1988a) Poverty orderings. Econometrica 56 (1), 173177.
Foster, James E. and Shorrocks, Anthony F. (1988b) Poverty orderings and welfare dominance. Social Choice and Welfare 5 (2), 179198.
Golosov, Mikhail, Jones, Larry E., and Tertilt, Michele (2007) Efficiency with endogenous population growth. Econometrica 75 (4), 10391071.
Guvenen, Fatih (2006) Reconciling conflicting evidence on the elasticity of intertemporal substitution: A macroeconomic perspective. Journal of Monetary Economics 53 (7), 14511472.
Hansen, Gary D. and Prescott, Edward C. (2002) Malthus to solow. American Economic Review 92 (4), 12051217.
Jones, Larry E., Schoonbroodt, Alice, and Tertilt, Michele (2008) Fertility theories: Can they explain the negative fertility-income relationship? Working Paper 14266, NBER.
Jones, Larry E. and Tertilt, Michele (2006) An economic history of fertility in the US: 1826–1960. Working paper 12796, NBER.
Kolm, Serge-Christophe (1969) The optimal production of social justice. Chapter 7. In Margolis, J. and Guitton, H. (eds.), Public Economics: An Analysis of Public Production and Consumption and their Relations to the Private Sectors, pp. 145200. London: Macmillan.
Kremer, Michael (1993) Population growth and technological change: One million B.C. to 1990. Quarterly Journal of Economics 108 (3), 681716.
Lam, David (1986) The dynamics of population growth, differential fertility, and inequality. American Economic Review 76 (5), 11031116.
Lam, David (1997) Demographic variables and income inequality. In Rosenzweig, M. K. and Stark, O. (ed.), Handbook of Population and Family Economics, pp. 10151059. New York: Elsevier Science.
Liao, Pei-Ju (2013) The one-child policy: A macroeconomic analysis. Journal of Development Economics 101, 4962.
Lucas, Robert E. JR (1976) Econometric policy evaluation: A critique. Carnegie-Rochester Conference Series on Public Policy 1 (1), 1946.
Manuelli, Rodolfo E. and Seshadri, Ananth (2009) Explaining international fertility differences. The Quarterly Journal of Economics 124 (2), 771807.
Pazner, Elisha A. and Razin, Assaf (1980) Competitive efficiency in an overlapping-generation model with endogenous population. Journal of Public Economics 13 (2), 249258.
Raut, Lakshmi K. (1990) Capital accumulation, income distribution and endogenous fertility in an overlapping generations general equilibrium model. Journal of Development Economics 34 (1–2), 123150.
Rothschild, Michael and Stiglitz, Joseph E. (1973) Some further results on the measurement of inequality. Journal of Economic Theory 6 (2), 188204.
Saposnik, Rubin (1981) Rank-dominance in income distributions. Public Choice 36 (1), 147151.
Schoonbroodt, Alice and Tertilt, Michele (2014) Property rights and efficiency in OLG models with endogenous fertility. Journal of Economic Theory 150 (C), 551582.
Shorrocks, Anthony F. (1983) Ranking income distributions. Economica 50 (197), 317.
Willis, Robert J. (1987) Externalities and population. In Johnson, D. Gale and Lee, R. D. (eds.), Population Growth and Economic Development: Issues and Evidence, Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin Press.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Journal of Demographic Economics
  • ISSN: 2054-0892
  • EISSN: 2054-0906
  • URL: /core/journals/journal-of-demographic-economics
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *



Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 6
Total number of PDF views: 43 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 2081 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 18th March 2018. This data will be updated every 24 hours.