Hostname: page-component-5d59c44645-jqctd Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-02-23T15:37:06.867Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

The plantation paradigm: colonial agronomy, African farmers, and the global cocoa boom, 1870s–1940s*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  12 February 2014

Corey Ross*
Affiliation:
Department of History, University of Birmingham, Edgbaston, Birmingham B15 2TT, UK E-mail: c.d.ross@bham.ac.uk

Abstract

This article investigates the powerful normative role of plantation-oriented agricultural practices in what was arguably the premier indigenous crop revolution of the colonial era: the West African cocoa boom. It traces the links between the extraordinary growth of cocoa production in the region – above all in the Gold Coast – and the longer experience of cocoa estates in other parts of the world, in particular the Caribbean, which served as a key reference point for the expanding global cocoa frontier in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. In spite of the manifest competitive success of African farmers’ extensive agricultural practices during this period, most outside observers retained a strong partiality towards intensive production techniques under centralized European management. This article emphasizes the role played by the transcontinental exchange of ideas in sustaining the cultural authority of such cultivation techniques long after their commercial viability came into question.

Type
Articles
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2014 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

*

I would like to thank the British Academy for generously supporting the research upon which this article is based, as well as Francesca Carnevali, Matthew Hilton, and Tom McCaskie for their helpful comments on an earlier draft. In addition, the two anonymous reviewers as well as the journal editors deserve a special word of thanks for the exceptionally constructive comments they provided.

References

1 The essential study is Ruf, François, Booms et crises du cacao: les vertiges de l'or brun, Paris: Karthala, 1995Google Scholar.

2 See, generally, Curtin, Philip D., The rise and fall of the plantation complex: essays in Atlantic history, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1990Google Scholar. On cocoa specifically, see Clarence-Smith, William Gervase, Cocoa and chocolate, 1765–1914, London: Routledge, 2000CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Clarence-Smith, William Gervase, ed., Cocoa pioneer fronts since 1800: the role of smallholders, planters and merchants, Basingstoke: Macmillan, 1996CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

3 Chatelin, Yvon and Bonneuil, Christophe, eds., Nature et environnement, Paris: Orstom Éditions, 1995Google Scholar; Bonneuil, Christophe, Des savants pour l'empire: la structuration des recherches scientifiques coloniales au temps de ‘la mise en valeur des colonies françaises’ 1917–1945, Paris: ORSTOM, 1991Google Scholar; Osborne, Michael A., Nature, the exotic, and the science of French colonialism, Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press, 1994Google Scholar; Maat, Harro, Science cultivating practice: a history of agricultural science in the Netherlands and its colonies 1863–1986, Dordrecht: Kluwer, 2001CrossRefGoogle Scholar; McCook, Stuart, States of nature: science, agriculture, and environment in the Spanish Caribbean, 1760–1940, Austin, TX: University of Texas Press, 2002Google Scholar; Bald, Detlef and Bald, Gerhild, Das Forschungsinstitut Amani: Wirtschaft und Wissenschaft in der deutschen Kolonialpolitik Ostafrika 1900–1918, Munich: IFO, 1972Google Scholar; Worboys, Michael, ‘Science and British colonial imperialism, 1895–1940’, PhD thesis, University of Sussex, 1979Google Scholar; Masefield, G. B., A history of the colonial agricultural service, Oxford: Clarendon, 1972Google Scholar.

4 Headrick, Daniel, The tools of empire: technology and European imperialism in the nineteenth century, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1981Google Scholar; idem, The tentacles of progress: technology transfer in the age of imperialism, 1850–1940, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1988, pp. 209–58; Drabble, J. H., Rubber in Malaya, 1876–1922: the genesis of the industry, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1973Google Scholar; Barlow, Colin, The natural rubber industry: its development, technology, and economy in Malaysia, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1978Google Scholar; Van der Schoor, Wim, ‘Pure science and colonial agriculture: the case of the private Java sugar experimental stations, 1885–1940)’, in Chatelin and Bonneuil, Nature et environnement, pp. 1320Google Scholar; Galloway, J. H., ‘Botany in the service of empire: the Barbados cane-breeding program and the revival of the Caribbean sugar industry, 1880s–1930s’, Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 86, 4, 1996, pp. 682706CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

5 Willis, John C., A report upon agriculture in the Federated Malay States, Kuala Lumpur: FMS Government Printing Press, 1904, p. 90Google Scholar.

6 See the remarks in Klopstock, Fritz, Kakao: Wandlungen in der Erzeugung und der Verwendung des Kakaos nach dem Weltkrieg, Leipzig: Bibliographisches Institut, 1937, p. viiGoogle Scholar; also Chevalier, Auguste, La situation agricole de l'ouest africain: enquête, Domfront: Senen, 1906, p. 21Google Scholar.

7 First highlighted for Ghana by Green, R. H. and Hymer, S. H., ‘Cocoa in the Gold Coast: a study in the relations between African farmers and agricultural experts’, Journal of Economic History, 26, 3, 1966, pp. 299319CrossRefGoogle Scholar; further elaborated by Austin, Gareth, ‘Mode of production or mode of cultivation: explaining the failure of European cocoa planters in competition with African farmers in colonial Ghana’, in Clarence-Smith, Cocoa pioneer fronts, pp. 154175Google Scholar.

8 Scott, James C., Seeing like a state: how certain schemes to improve the human condition have failed, New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1998Google Scholar.

9 Adas, Michael, Machines as the measure of men: science, technology, and ideologies of Western dominance, Ithaca, NY: Cornell, 1989Google Scholar.

10 For inroads, see Clarence-Smith, Cocoa and chocolate; Acquaah, Benjamin, Cocoa development in West Africa: the early period with particular reference to Ghana, Oxford: Ghana University Press, 1999Google Scholar.

11 Masefield, Colonial agricultural service, pp. 31–2.

12 Young, Allen, The chocolate tree: a natural history of cacao, Washington, DC: Smithsonian, 1994, pp. 23Google Scholar.

13 Ruf, Booms et crises, pp. 91–159.

14 Coe, Sophie D. and Coe, Michael D., The true history of chocolate, London: Thames & Hudson, 1996, pp. 203235Google Scholar, 241–51.

15 Wickizer, Vernon D., Coffee, tea and cocoa: an economic and political analysis, London: Stanford University Press, 1951, pp. 264Google Scholar, 484–5; Grunwald, Joseph and Musgrove, Philip, Natural resources in Latin American development, Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins Press, 1970, pp. 332Google Scholar, 336; Clarence-Smith, Cocoa and chocolate, pp. 238239Google Scholar.

16 Clarence-Smith, Cocoa and chocolate, pp. 176–80.

17 And frequently by coerced labour as well, as the slavery scandals of the 1900s attest: see Satre, Lowell J., Chocolate on trial: slavery, politics, and the ethics of business, Athens, OH: Ohio University Press, 2005Google Scholar; Higgs, Catherine, Chocolate islands: cocoa, slavery, and colonial Africa, Athens, OH: Ohio University Press, 2012CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

18 Preuss, Paul, Expedition nach Central- und Südamerika, Berlin: Kolonial-Wirtschaftliches Komitee, 1901, pp. 239240Google Scholar.

19 Moll, E. R., Cacao in Trinidad and Tobago, n.p., 1960, p. 2Google Scholar;

Lewis, Kathleen Phillips, ‘The Trinidad cocoa industry and the struggle for crown land during the nineteenth century’, in Clarence-Smith, Cocoa pioneer fronts, pp. 45–64Google Scholar.

20 E.g. Chevalier, Auguste, Le cacaoyer dans l'ouest Africain, Paris: Challamel, 1908, pp. 116117Google Scholar;

Jumelle, Henri, Le cacaoyer: sa culture et son exploitation dans tous les pays de production, Paris: Challamel, 1900, pp. 7780Google Scholar;

Colonies, Ministère des, Manuel pratique de la culture du caféier et du cacaoyer au Congo belge, Brussels: Van Campenhout, 1908, pp. 7678Google Scholar;

Knapp, Arthur W., Cocoa and chocolate: their history from plantation to consumer, London: Chapman and Hall, 1920, pp. 3640Google Scholar.

21 Knapp, Cocoa and chocolate, p. 40Google Scholar.

22 Jumelle, Le cacaoyer, pp. 79–80Google Scholar.

23 Knapp, Cocoa and chocolate, pp. 34–37Google Scholar, quote p. 37;

Preuss, Expedition, pp. 181–184Google Scholar.

24 Preuss, Expedition, p. 187Google Scholar;

Shephard, C. Y., Report on the economics of peasant agriculture in the Gold Coast, Accra: Government Printer, 1936, pp. 24Google Scholar.

25 Milstead, Harley P., ‘Cacao industry of Grenada’, Economic Geography, 16, 2, April 1940, p. 199Google Scholar.

26 Wickizer, Coffee, tea and cocoa, pp. 297–298Google Scholar.

27 Milstead, ‘Cacao industry’, pp. 202–203Google Scholar.

28 Knapp, Cocoa and chocolate, p. 30Google Scholar.

29 Milstead, ‘Cacao industry’, p. 199Google Scholar.

30 Preuss, Expedition, pp. 168–169Google Scholar, 239–40;

Clarence-Smith, Cocoa and chocolate, pp. 154–155Google Scholar.

31 Bartelink, E. J., Handleiding voor kakao-planters, Amsterdam: de Bussy, 1885, pp. 1819Google Scholar, 20–3.

32 Young, Chocolate tree, pp. 167–171Google Scholar.

33 Wickizer, Coffee, tea and cocoa, p. 297Google Scholar;

Clarence-Smith, Cocoa and chocolate, pp. 155Google Scholar, 183–4;

Bartelink, Handleiding, 32–33Google Scholar.

34 See McCook, Stuart, ‘Global rust belt: Hemileia vastatrix and the ecological integration of world coffee production since 1850’, Journal of Global History, 1, 2, 2006, pp. 177195CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

35 Masefield, G. B., A short history of agriculture in the British colonies, Oxford: Clarendon, 1950, p. 117Google Scholar.

36 Schwarz, Leonard J., Cocoa in the Cameroons under French mandate and in Fernando Po, Washington, DC: Government Printing Office, 1933, pp. 10Google Scholar, 47;

Clarence-Smith, Cocoa and chocolate, pp. 185–186Google Scholar;

Ruf, Booms et crises, p. 120Google Scholar.

37 Preuss, Paul, ‘Über Pflanzenschädlinge in Kamerun’, Der Tropenpflanzer, 7, 8, August 1903, p. 361Google Scholar;

Zacher, Friedrich, Die wichtigsten Krankheiten und Schädlinge der tropischen Kulturpflanzen und ihre Bekämpfung, Hamburg: Thaden, 1914, p. 80Google Scholar.

38 Friederichs, K., ‘Bericht über den staatlichen Pflanzenschutzdienst in Deutsch-Samoa 1912–1914’, Der Tropenpflanzer: Beiheft, 18, 1918, pp. 257266Google Scholar, 283–4;

Ettling, C. E., ‘Die Aussichten der Kakaokultur auf Samoa’, Der Tropenpflanzer, 7, 2, February 1903, pp. 79–82Google Scholar;

Reinicke, F., ‘Gefährdung der Kakaokultur auf Samoa’, Der Tropenpflanzer, 6, 12, December 1902, pp. 632–635Google Scholar.

39 Greaves, I. C., Modern production among backward peoples, London: Allen & Unwin, 1935, p. 215Google Scholar.

40 Austin, ‘Mode of production’, p. 154Google Scholar.

41 Revue générale de botanique, 36, 1924, p. 190, cited in Ruf, Booms et crises, p. 177.

42 The classic study is Hill, Polly, The migrant cocoa-farmers of southern Ghana: a study in rural capitalism, 2nd edn, Oxford: James Currey, 1997Google Scholar.

43 Ibid., pp. 15–17.

44 On land rights in Asante, see Austin, Gareth, Labour, land and capital in Ghana: from slavery to free labour in Asante, 1807–1956, Rochester, NY: University of Rochester Press, 2005, pp. 258276Google Scholar.

45 Schwarz, Leonard J., Cocoa in West Africa, Washington, DC: Government Printing Office, 1928, p. 17Google Scholar.

46 McLeod, N. C., Address on forestry in connection with the cocoa industry of the Gold Coast, Accra: Government Press, 1920, p. 5Google Scholar;

Schwarz, Cocoa in West Africa, p. 1Google Scholar.

47 Shephard, Report on the economics, p. 9Google Scholar. The Gold Coast production figures here include output from British Togo, though this was marginal: Wickizer, Coffee, tea and cocoa, p. 483.

48 See, generally, Hill, Migrant cocoa-farmers.

49 This paragraph is based on Shephard, Report on the economics, pp. 2–3; Faulkner, O. T. and Mackie, J. R., West African agriculture, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1933, pp. 106108Google Scholar;

Austin, Labour, pp. 60–79Google Scholar.

50 Faulkner and Mackie, West African agriculture, pp. 110–111Google Scholar.

51 See esp. Austin, Labour, pp. 253–258Google Scholar;

Berry, Sara S., Cocoa, custom, and socio-economic change in rural western Nigeria, Oxford: Clarendon, 1975Google Scholar;

Frechou, Hubert, ‘Les plantations européennes en Côte d'Ivoire’, Cahiers d'Outre-Mer, 8, 29, January 1955, pp. 56–83Google Scholar;

Chauveau, Jean-Pierre and Léonard, Eric, ‘Côte d'Ivoire's pioneer fronts: historical and political determinants of the spread of cocoa cultivation’, in Clarence-Smith, Cocoa pioneer fronts, pp. 176–194Google Scholar;

Coquery-Vidrovitch, Catherine, Le Congo au temps des grandes compagnies concessionaires 1898–1930, Paris: Mouton & Co., 1972, pp. 470473CrossRefGoogle Scholar;

Clarence-Smith, William Gervase, ‘Plantation versus smallholder production of cocoa: the legacy of the German period in Cameroon’, in Peter Geschiere and Piet Konings, eds., Itinéraires d'accumulation au Cameroun, Paris: Karthala, 1993, pp. 187216Google Scholar.

52 Southall, Roger J., ‘Cadbury on the Gold Coast, 1907–1938: the dilemma of the “model firm” in a colonial economy’, PhD thesis, University of Birmingham, 1975, pp. 76–87Google Scholar;

Green and Hymer, ‘Cocoa in the Gold Coast’, p. 310Google Scholar;

Austin, ‘Mode of production’, pp. 157–159Google Scholar.

53 See, generally, Austin, ‘Mode of production’.

54 Klopstock, Kakao, pp. 9–10Google Scholar;

Faulkner and Mackie, West African agriculture, pp. 110–111Google Scholar;

Austin, ‘Mode of production’, p. 168Google Scholar.

55 Austin, ‘Mode of production’, pp. 164–168Google Scholar.

56 Wickizer, Coffee, tea and cocoa, p. 291Google Scholar.

57 Faulkner and Mackie, West African agriculture, pp. 107–108Google Scholar;

Green and Hymer, ‘Cocoa in the Gold Coast’, pp. 308–309Google Scholar.

58 Masefield, Short history, pp. 120–121Google Scholar.

59 Quoted in Robertson, Emma, Chocolate, women and empire: a social and cultural history, Manchester: Manchester University Press, 2009, p. 84Google Scholar.

60 For heterodox views, see Chevalier, La situation agricole, p. 5Google Scholar; Faulkner and Mackie, West African agriculture;

Stamp, L. D., ‘Land utilization and soil erosion in Nigeria’, Geographical Review, 28, 1938, pp. 3245CrossRefGoogle Scholar. More generally, see

Tilley, Helen, Africa as a living laboratory: empire, development, and the problem of scientific knowledge, 1870–1950, Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press, 2011, pp. 128159CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

61 Richards, Paul, Indigenous agricultural revolution: ecology and food production in West Africa, Boulder, CO: Westview, 1985Google Scholar.

62 Sir Arthur W. Hill, Cacao research, December 1935, quoted in Klopstock, Kakao, p. 5.

63 Knapp, Cocoa and chocolate, pp. 94–96Google Scholar.

64 E.g. Renodier, L., ‘Le cacaoyer en Côte d'Ivoire’, L'Agronomie Coloniale, 18, 142, October 1929, pp. 304–310Google Scholar.

65 Chevalier, La situation agricole, p. 21Google Scholar.

66 Quoted in Greaves, Modern production, pp. 209–210Google Scholar.

67 Schwarz, Cocoa in West Africa, pp. 3–4Google Scholar.

68 Shephard, Report on the economics, p. 7Google Scholar; see also

Sampson, H. C. and Crowther, E. M., The West African commission 1938–1939: technical reports, London: Waterlow, 1943, pp. 3940Google Scholar.

69 Viton, Albert, Cacao: tendances actuelles de la production, des prix et de la consommation, Rome: FAO, 1957, p. 12Google Scholar.

70 See, more generally, Tilley, Africa, pp. 115–168Google Scholar.

71 McLeod, Address on forestry, p. 4Google Scholar.

72 Unwin, A. Harold, West African forests and forestry, London: T. Fisher Unwin Ltd., 1920, p. 492Google Scholar;

Knapp, Cocoa and chocolate, p. 78Google Scholar.

73 Klopstock, Kakao, p. 57Google Scholar.

74 Schwarz, Cocoa in West Africa, p. 2Google Scholar.

75 McLeod, Address on forestry, p. 5Google Scholar.

76 See the dire warnings in Stockdale, F. A., Report by Mr. F. A. Stockdale on his visit to Nigeria, Gold Coast and Sierra Leone, October 1935–February 1936, London: Colonial Office, 1936, pp. 99100Google Scholar; also

Shephard, Report on the economics, pp. 2Google Scholar, 16–20;

Troup, R. S., Colonial forest administration, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1940, p. 59Google Scholar.

77 McLeod, Address on forestry, pp. 5Google Scholar, 8.

78 Moor, H. W., ‘Forestry and its application to the Gold Coast’, Journal of the Gold Coast Agricultural and Commercial Society, 3, 2, 1924, p. 82Google Scholar, quoted in

Fairhead, James and Leach, Melissa, Reframing deforestation: global analyses and local realities, London: Routledge, 1998, p. 68Google Scholar.

79 Shephard, Report on the economics, p. 6Google Scholar;

Fairhead and Leach, Reframing deforestation, pp. 68–69Google Scholar and passim.

80 Though the ban was widely evaded: see Austin, Labour, pp. 50Google Scholar, 350, 437, 445;

Stockdale, Report by Mr. F. A. Stockdale, p. 7Google Scholar.

81 Klopstock, Kakao, p. 41Google Scholar.

82 Stockdale, Report by Mr. F. A. Stockdale, p. 96Google Scholar.

83 Moll, Cacao, p. 3Google Scholar.

84 Shephard, C. Y., The cacao industry of Trinidad: some economic aspects: series III–IV, Port-of-Spain: Government Printer, 1937, pp. 31Google Scholar, 70–2.

85 As do Green and Hymer, ‘Cocoa in the Gold Coast’, pp. 308–9.

86 Shephard, Report on the economics, p. 5Google Scholar.

87 Moll, Cacao, pp. 4–5Google Scholar.

88 Shephard, Cacao industry, p. 72Google Scholar.

89 Beckett, W. H., Koransang: a Gold Coast cocoa farm, Accra: Government Printer, 1945Google Scholar, reprinted as Part 1 of idem, Koransang 1904–1970, Legon: University of Ghana Institute of Statistical, Social and Economic Research, 1972.

90 Moll, Cacao, pp. 4–6Google Scholar.

91 Ruf, Booms et crises, pp. 94–95Google Scholar.

92 See, more generally, Clarence-Smith, William Gervase and Ruf, François, ‘Cocoa pioneer fronts: the historical determinants’, in Clarence-Smith, Cocoa pioneer fronts, pp. 1–2Google Scholar, 14–15.

93 Ruf, François, ‘The myth of complex agroforests: the case of Ghana’, Human Ecology, 39, 2011, pp. 373388CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

94 As clearly recognized by some contemporaries: see e.g. Faulkner and Mackie, West African agriculture, p. 7Google Scholar.

95 Hill, Migrant cocoa-farmers, pp. 23–24Google Scholar;

Coast, Gold, Report on the department of agriculture 1944–5, Accra: Government Printer, 1945, pp. 45Google Scholar; Report on the department of agriculture 1945–6, Accra: Government Printer, 1946, pp. 4–5; Report on the department of agriculture 1951–2, Accra: Government Printer, 1952, p. 5.

96 Coast, Gold, Sessional paper, 2, 1916Google Scholar–1917, Accra, 1916, quoted in

Green and Hymer, ‘Cocoa in the Gold Coast’, p. 312Google Scholar.