Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
×
Home

Meta-regulation meets Deliberation: Situating the Governor within NHS Foundation Trust Hospitals

  • ROSS MILLAR (a1), TIM FREEMAN (a2), RUSSELL MANNION (a3) and HUW T. O. DAVIES (a4)
Abstract

NHS Foundation Trust (FT) hospitals in England have complex internal governance arrangements. They may be considered to exhibit meta-regulatory characteristics to the extent that governors are able to promote deliberative values and steer internal governance processes towards wider regulatory goals. Yet, while recent studies of NHS FT hospital governance have explored FT governors and examined FT hospital boards to consider executive oversight, there is currently no detailed investigation of interactions between these two groups. Drawing on observational and interview data from four case-study sites, we trace interactions between the actors involved; explore their understandings of events; and consider the extent to which the proposed benefits of meta-regulation were realised in practice. Findings show that while governors provided both a conscience and contribution to internal and external governance arrangements, the meta-regulatory role was largely symbolic and limited to compliance and legitimation of executive actions. Thus while the meta-regulatory ‘architecture’ for governor involvement may be considered effective, the soft intelligence gleaned and operationalised may be obscured by ‘hard’ performance metrics which dominate resource-allocation processes and priority-setting. Governors were involved in practices that symbolised deliberative involvement but resulted in further opportunities for legitimising executive decisions.

Copyright
References
Hide All
Abelson, J., Forest, P., Eyles, J., Smith, P., Martin, E. and Gauvin, F. (2003), ‘Deliberations about deliberative methods: issues in the design and evaluation of public participation processes’, Social Science & Medicine, 57 (2), 239251.
Abelson, J., Blacksher, E. A., Li, K. K., Boesveld, S. E. and Goold, S.D. (2013), ‘Public deliberation in health policy and Bioethics: mapping an emerging, interdisciplinary field’, Journal of Public Deliberation, 9 (1), 5.
Allen, P., Wright, J., Keen, J., Dempster, P., Hutchings, A., Townsend, J., Street, A. and Verzulli, R. (2010), Investigating The Governance Of NHS Foundation Trusts: Final report, NIHR Service Delivery and Organisation programme.
Allen, P., Townsend, J., Dempster, P., Wright, J., Hutchings, A. and Keen, J. (2012), ‘Organizational form as a mechanism to involve staff, public and users in public services: a study of the governance of NHS Foundation Trusts’, Social Policy & Administration, 46 (3), 239257.
Baxter, J. (2017), ‘School governor regulation in England's changing education landscape’, Educational Management Administration & Leadership, 45 (1), 2039.
Braithwaite, J. (2015), ‘Deliberative Republican hybridity through restorative justice’, Raisons Politiques, 59 (3), 3349.
Braithwaite, J. (2016), ‘Restorative justice and responsive regulation: the question of evidence’, RegNet Research Papers No. 51, http://regnet.anu.edu.au/sites/default/files/uploads/2016-10/SSRN_2016_updated_Braithwaite%20J.pdf (accessed 16/10/18)
Chambers, N. (2012), ‘Healthcare board governance’, Journal of Health Organization and Management, 26 (1), 614.
Day, P. and Klein, R. (2005), Governance of Foundation Trusts: Dilemmas Of Diversity, London: The Nuffield Trust.
Degeling, C., Carter, S. M. and Rychetnik, L. (2015), ‘Which public and why deliberate? A scoping review of public deliberation in public health and health policy research’, Social Science & Medicine, 131, 114121.
Dixon, A., Storey, J. and Alvarez-Rosete, A. (2010), ‘Accountability of foundation trusts in the English NHS: views of directors and governors’, Journal of Health Services Research and Policy, 15 (2), 8289.
Dryzek, J.S. (1982), ‘Policy analysis as hermeneutic activity’, Policy Sciences, 14 (4): 309329.
Dryzek, J. S. (2000), Deliberative Democracy and Beyond, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Dryzek, J.S. (2001), ‘Legitimacy and economy in deliberative democracy’, Political Theory, 29 (5), 651669.
Duran, A. and Saltman, R. B. (2015), ‘Governing Public Hospitals’, in Kuhlmann, E., Blank, R. H., Bourgeault, I. L. and Wendt, C. The Palgrave International Handbook of Healthcare Policy and Governance, UK: Palgrave Macmillan, 443461.
Ercan, S. A., Hendriks, C. M. and Boswell, J. (2017), ‘Studying public deliberation after the systemic turn: the crucial role for interpretive research’, Policy & Politics, 45 (2), 195212.
Ferlie, E. (2017), ‘Exploring 30 years of UK public services management reform – the case of health care’, International Journal of Public Sector Management, 30 (6–7), 615625.
Francis, R. (2013), The Mid Staffordshire NHS Foundation Trust Public Inquiry. London: Stationery Office.
Freeman, T., Millar, R., Mannion, R. and Davies, H.T.O. (2016), ‘Enacting corporate governance of safety and quality: a dramaturgy of English hospital Boards’, Sociology of Health & Illness, 38 (2), 233251.
Furnival, J., Walshe, K. and Boaden, R. (2017), Emerging hybridity: comparing UK healthcare regulatory arrangements, Journal of Health Organization and Management, 31 (4), 517528.
Goddard, M., Mannion, R. and Smith, P. (1999), ‘Assessing the performance of NHS Trusts: the use of hard and soft information’, Health Policy, 48 (2), 119132.
Hajer, M. (2005), ‘Setting the stage: a dramaturgy of policy deliberation’, Administration and Society, 36 (6), 624–47.
Ham, C. and Hunt, P. (2008), Membership Governance In NHS Foundation Trusts: A Review For The Department Of Health. Birmingham: University of Birmingham and Mutuo.
Healy, J. and Braithwaite, J. (2006), ‘Designing safer health care through responsive regulation’, Medical Journal of Australia, 184 (10), 5659.
Hendriks, C. M. (2005), ‘Participatory storylines and their influence on deliberative forums’, Policy Sciences, 38 (1), 120.
Hendriks, C. M. (2009), ‘Deliberative governance in the context of power’, Policy and Society, 28 (3), 173184.
Hendriks, C. M. (2011), The Politics Of Public Deliberation: Citizen Engagement And Interest Advocacy, London: Palgrave Macmillan.
Jones, L., Pomeroy, L., Robert, G., Burnett, S., Anderson, J. and Fulop, N. J. (2017), ‘How do hospital boards govern for quality improvement? A mixed methods study of 15 organisations in England’, BMJ Quality & Safety, 26, 978986.
MacDonald, D., Barnes, M., Crawford, M., Omeni, E., Wilson, A. and Diana, R. (2014), ‘Service user Governors in mental health foundation trusts: accountability or business as usual?Health Expectations, 18 (6), 28922902.
Mannion, R., Freeman, T., Millar, R. and Davies, H. T. O. (2016), ‘Effective board governance of safe care: a (theoretically underpinned) cross-sectioned examination of the breadth and depth of relationships through local case studies and national surveys’, Health Services and Delivery Research, 4 (4).
Mannion, R., Davies, H. T. O., Jacobs, R., Kasteridis, P., Millar, R. and Freeman, T. (2017), ‘Do Hospital Boards matter for better, safer, patient care?’, Social Science & Medicine, 177, 278287.
Martin, G. P., McKee, L. and Dixon-Woods, M. (2015), ‘Beyond metrics? Utilizing ‘soft intelligence’ for healthcare quality and safety’, Social Science & Medicine, 142, 1926.
Maybin, J., Addicott, R., Dixon, A. and Storey, J. (2011), Accountability in the NHS, London: The King's Fund.
McDermott, A. M. Hamel, L. M. Steel, D. Flood, P. C. and McKee, L. (2015), ‘Hybrid healthcare governance for improvement? Combining top-down and bottom-up approaches to public sector regulation’, Public Administration, 93 (2), 324344.
Michels, A. (2011), ‘Innovations in democratic governance: how does citizen participation contribute to a better democracy?International Review of Administrative Sciences, 77 (2), 275293.
Millar, R., Mannion, R., Freeman, T. and Davies, H.T.O. (2013), ‘Hospital Board oversight of patient safety: a narrative review and synthesis of recent empirical studies’, The Milbank Quarterly, 91 (4), 738770.
Millar, R., Freeman, T. and Mannion, R. (2015), ‘Effective hospital Board oversight of quality and safety: a stakeholder analysis exploring the role of trust and intelligence’, BMC Health Services Research, 15 (196), DOI 10.1186/s12913-015-0771-x.
Mitton, C., Smith, N., Peacock, S., Evoy, B. and Abelson, J. (2009), ‘Public participation in health care priority setting: a scoping review’, Health Policy, 91 (3), 219228.
Providers, NHS (2015), Membership and Council of Governors Briefing, Available at: http://nhsproviders.org/resource-library/surveys/membership-and-council-of-governors-survey (accessed 16/10/18)
Ocloo, J., O'Shea, A. and Fulop, N. (2014), ‘Empowerment or rhetoric? Investigating the role of NHS Foundation Trust Governors in the governance of patient safety’, Health Policy, 111 (3), 301310.
Parker, C., Scott, S., Lacey, L. and Braithwaite, J. (2004), Regulating Law. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Parker, C. (2007), ‘Meta-regulation: legal accountability for corporate social responsibility?’ In McBarnet, D., Voiculescu, A. and Campbell, T. (eds), The New Corporate Accountability: Corporate Social Responsibility and the Law. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 207237.
Parkinson, J. (2006), Deliberating In The Real World: Problems Of Legitimacy In Deliberative Democracy, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Selznick, P. (2002), The Communitarian Persuasion, Washington D.C: Woodrow Wilson Center Press.
Stake, R. E. (2006), Multiple Case Study Analysis, New York: Guilford Press.
Street, J., Duszynski, K., Krawczyk, S. and Braunack-Mayer, A. (2014), ‘The use of citizens' juries in health policy decision-making: a systematic review’, Social Science & Medicine, 109, 19.
Wilkins, A. (2015), Professionalizing school governance: the disciplinary effects of school autonomy and inspection on the changing role of school governors, ‘Journal of Education Policy’, 30 (2), 182200.
Wright, J. S. F. (2009), ‘The regulatory state and the UK Labour government's re-regulation of provision in the English National Health Service’, Regulation and Governance, 3 (4), 334–59.
Wright, J. S. F., Dempster, P. G., Keen, J., Allen, P. and Hutchings, A. (2012), ‘The new governance arrangements for NHS Foundation Trust Hospitals: reframing Governors as meta regulators’, Public Administration, 90 (2), 351369.
Wright, J. S. F., Dempster, P.G., Keen, J., Allen, P. and Hutchings, A. (2014), ‘How should we evaluate the impacts of policy? The case of payment by results and the 18 week patient pathway in English hospitals’, Policy Studies, 35 (1), 5978.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Journal of Social Policy
  • ISSN: 0047-2794
  • EISSN: 1469-7823
  • URL: /core/journals/journal-of-social-policy
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed