Skip to main content

Debunking Critics' Wine Words: Can Amateurs Distinguish the Smell of Asphalt from the Taste of Cherries?*

  • Roman L. Weil (a1)

I report my tests of the hypothesis that wine consumers cannot match critics' descriptions of wines with the wines themselves. My results suggest that testers' ability to match the descriptions with the wines is no better than random. I report on more than two hundred observations of wine drinkers who engaged in the following experiment. The drinker faces 3 glasses of wine, two of which contain identical wines and the third contains a different wine. I record whether the drinker can distinguish wines—whether he can tell the singleton from the doubleton and, if the drinker can distinguish, which wine he prefers. I present the testers with descriptions of the two wines written by the same wine critic/reviewer. I find that 51 percent of the testers who can distinguish the wines correctly match the description of the wine with the wine itself. The percentage matching does not significantly differ from the expected-if-random half. I have recorded the sex of the testers and I can find that men can distinguish the wines better than random, but women cannot. The differences are so small, even though significant, however, that the Exact F test detects no significant difference between the ability of men and women in these experiments. The results span tests of wines from Bordeaux, Burgundy, the Rhône, Spain, Germany, and Australia; the tests use only still wines, all less than ten years old. (JEL Classification: C93, D12)

I dedicate this paper to Adrienne Lehrer, whose 1983 book, Wine and Conversation, with a different experimental design, anticipated these results.

Hide All
Cholet, S. and Valentin, D. (2001). Impact of training on beer flavor perception and description. Are trained and untrained subjects really different? Journal of Sensory Studies, 16 (6), 601618.
Lawless, H. (1984). Flavor description of white wine by “expert” and nonexpert wine consumers. Journal of Food Science, 49 (1), 120123.
Lehrer, A. (1975). Talking about wine. Language, 51 (4), 901923.
Lehrer, A. (1983). Wine and Conversation. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
Lehrer, A. (2007). Can wines be brawny? Reflections on wine vocabulary. In: Smith, B. (ed.), Questions of taste: the philosophy of wine. New York: Oxford University Press. 127140.
Murray, J.M. and Delahunty, C.M. (2000). Selections of standards of reference terms in a cheddar-type cheese flavor language. Journal of Sensory Studies, 15 (2), 179199.
Noble, A.C., Arnold, R.A., Masuda, B.M., Pecore, S.D., Schmidt, J.O., and Stern, P.M. (1984). Progress towards a standardized system of wine aroma terminology. American Journal of Enology and Viticulture, 35 (2), 107109.
Parker, R. (2007). Accessed Nov 13, 2007.
Quandt, R. (2007). On wine bullshit: some new software? Journal of Wine Economics, 2 (2), 129135.
Sauvageot, F., Urdapilleta, I. and Peyron, D. (2006). Within and between variations of texts elicited from nine wine experts. Food Quality and Preference, 17, 429444.
Solomon, G.E. (1990). Psychology of novice and expert wine talk. American Journal of Psychology, 103 (4), 495517.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Journal of Wine Economics
  • ISSN: 1931-4361
  • EISSN: 1931-437X
  • URL: /core/journals/journal-of-wine-economics
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 23 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 621 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 24th March 2018. This data will be updated every 24 hours.