Skip to main content
×
Home
    • Aa
    • Aa

Preferences, perceptions, and veto players: explaining devolution negotiation outcomes in the Canadian territorial north

  • Christopher Alcantara (a1)
Abstract
ABSTRACT

Since the early part of the 20th century, the federal government has engaged in a long and slow process of devolution in the Canadian Arctic. Although the range of powers devolved to the territorial governments has been substantial over the years, the federal government still maintains control over the single most important jurisdiction in the region, territorial lands and resources, which it controls in two of the three territories, the Northwest Territories and Nunavut. This fact is significant for territorial governments because gaining jurisdiction over their lands and resources is seen as necessary for dramatically improving the lives of residents and governments in the Canadian north. Relying on archival materials, secondary sources, and 33 elite interviews, this paper uses a rational choice framework to explain why the Yukon territorial government was able to complete a final devolution agreement relating to lands and resources in 2001 and why the governments of the Northwest Territories and Nunavut have not. It finds that the nature and distance of federal-territorial preferences, combined with government perceptions of aboriginal consent and federal perceptions of territorial capacity and maturity, explain the divergent outcomes experienced by the three territorial governments in the Canadian arctic.

The following acronyms are employed: AIP: Agreement-in-Principle; DTA: Devolution Transfer Agreement; GEB: gross expenditure base; GN: Government of Nunavut; GNWT: Government of Northwest Territories; NCLA: Nunavut Land Claims Agreement; NTI: Nunavut Tunngavik Incorporated; NWT; Northwest Territories; ON: Ontario; TFF: Territorial Formula Financing; UFA: Umbrella Final Agreement; YDTA: Yukon Devolution Transfer Agreement; YTG: Yukon Territorial Government; YK: Yukon;

Copyright
References
Hide All
Abele F., Courchene T., Seidle F.L., and St-Hilaire F.. (editors). 2009. Northern exposure: peoples, powers and prospects in Canada's north. Montreal: IRPP.
Abele F., and Prince M.J.. 2008. A little imagination required: how Canada funds territorial and northern aboriginal governments. In: Maslove A. (editor). How Ottawa spends 2008–09. Montreal-Kingston: McGill-Queen's University Press.
Alcantara C. 2007. Explaining aboriginal treaty negotiation outcomes in Canada: the cases of the Inuit and the Innu in Labrador. Canadian Journal of Political Science 40 (1): 185207.
Alcantara C. 2008. To treaty or not to treaty? Aboriginal peoples and comprehensive land claims negotiations in Canada. Publius: Journal of Federalism 38 (2): 343369.
Beauliu T. 2011. Member's statements. Northwest Territories Legislative Assembly. Hansard. 16th Assembly, 5th Session, 4 February 2011.
Bone R. M. 2002. The three territories: an introduction. In: The Canadian north: embracing change. Ottawa: Centre for Research and Information on Canada.
Cameron K., and Campbell A.. 2009. The devolution of natural resources and Nunavut's constitutional status. Journal of Canadian Studies 43 (2): 198219.
Cameron K., and White G.. 1995. Northern governments in transition. Montreal: Institute for Research on Public Policy.
Cameron K., and Gomme G.. 1991. The Yukon's constitutional foundations. Vol. II. A compendium of documents relating to the constitutional development of the Yukon territory. Whitehorse: Northern Directories.
Canada. 1898. An act to provide for the government of the Yukon District. Ottawa: Department of Public Works and Government Services. URL: http://www.solon.org/Constitutions/Canada/English/yta_1898.html (Accessed 2 October 2009).
Canada. 1997. Evidence presented to the Standing Committee on Aboriginal Affairs and Northern Development. 4 November 1997. Ottawa: Department of Public Works and Government Services.
CBC (Canadian Broadcasting Corporation). 2007. Akaitcho chiefs demand N.W.T. premier's resignation. Canadian Broadcasting Corporation News North 16 May 2007.
CBC (Canadian Broadcasting Corporation). 2011. N.W.T. signs on for province-like powers. Canadian Broadcasting Corporation News North 26 January 2011.
Clancy P. 1990. Politics by remote control: historical perspectives on devolution in Canada's north. In: Dacks G. (editor). Devolution and constitutional development in the Canadian north. Ottawa: Carleton University Press: 1342.
Chretien J. 1969. Speech by the Honourable Jean Chretien, P.C., M.P., Minister of Indian Affairs and Northern Development before the Yukon Territorial Council. 12 November 1969. Ottawa: Department of Indian Affairs (MG 32 B22 29–7).
Coates K.S., Lackenbauer P.W., Morrison W. R., and Poelzer G.. 2009. Arctic front: defending Canada in the far north. Toronto: Thomas Allen Publishers.
Coates K.S., and Morrison W.R.. 2005. Land of the midnight sun: a history of the Yukon. Montreal: McGill-Queen's University Press.
Dacks G. 1990. Devolution and constitutional development in the Canadian north. Ottawa: Carleton University Press.
Dacks G., and Coates K.S.. 1988. Northern communities: the prospects for empowerment. Edmonton: Boreal Institute for Northern Studies.
Dickerson M.O. 1992. Whose north? Political change, political development and self-government in the Northwest Territories. Vancouver: UBC Press/Arctic Institute of North America.
Expert Panel on Equalization and TFF. 2005. Discussion paper: Key Issues for the review of equalization and territorial formula financing. 31 March 2005. Ottawa: Department of Public Works and Government Services.
Feehan J. 2009. Natural resource devolution in the territories: current status and unresolved issues. In: Abele F., Courchene T., Seidle F.L., and St-Hilaire F.. Northern exposure: peoples, powers and prospects in Canada's north. Montreal: IRPP.
Gargan S., and Nerysoo R.. 2011. Letter to Prime Minister Harper: NWT lands and resource devolution agreement-in-principle. 26 January 2011. Inuvik.
Government of Canada, Government of Nunavut, and Nunavut Tunngavik Incorporated. 2008. Lands and resources devolution negotiation protocol. Ottawa: Department of Public Works and Government Services.
Government of Canada and Government of the Northwest Territories. 2010. Northwest Territories lands and resources devolution agreement-in-principle. Ottawa: Department of Public Works and Government Services.
Government of Canada, Government of the Northwest Territories, and the Aboriginal Summit. 2004. Northwest Territories lands and resources devolution framework agreement. Ottawa: Department of Public Works and Government Services.
Government of Canada and Government of the Yukon. 2001. Yukon Northern Affairs Program devolution transfer agreement. Ottawa: Department of Public Works and Government Services.
GNWT (Government of Northwest Territories). 1989. Principles underlying the GNWT position on the relationship between claims implementation and devolution. 30 November 1989.Yellowknife: NWT Archives G-2006-003, 13–5.
GNWT (Government of Northwest Territories). 1990. Background: devolution/implementation working group. Yellowknife: NWT Archives G-2007-006, 4–10.
GNWT (Government of Northwest Territories). 1993. Notes of meeting with Hiram Beaubier and Bernie Funston. Ottawa. 7 April 1993. Yellowknife: NWT Archives G-2007-006, 22.
GNWT (Government of Northwest Territories). 1995. Devolution speaking points for consideration. Yellowknife: NWT Archives G-2007-006, 2–12.
GNWT (Government of Northwest Territories). 1996. Decision paper: devolution of natural resources. 16 May 1996. Yellowknife: NWT Archives G-2007-006, 1–3.
GNWT (Government of Northwest Territories). 1998. NWT Resource revenue sharing: a discussion paper. 1 July 1998. Yellowknife: NWT Archives G-2004-024, 2–1.
GNWT (Government of Northwest Territories). 2000. Devolution: aboriginal issues in devolution negotiations. Yellowknife: NWT Archives G-2004-024, 2–2.
GNWT (Government of Northwest Territories). 2007. Resource revenue sharing agreement-in-principle. 9 May 2007. Yellowknife.
Government of Nunavut. 2010. Nunavut Hansard. 11 March 2010.
Grady P. 2001. Approaches for resource revenue sharing among Northwest Territories governments. Yellowknife: NWT Archives G-2004-024, 2–1.
Health Canada. 2005. Ten years of health transfer first nations and Inuit control. Ottawa: Department of Public Works and Government Services. URL: http://www.hc-sc.gc.ca/fniah-spnia/pubs/finance/_agree-accord/10_years_ans_trans/index-eng.php (accessed 3 November 2009).
Henderson A. 2007. Nunavut: rethinking political culture. Vancouver: UBC Press.
Hurley M.C. 2002. Bill C-39, The Yukon Act. Ottawa: Government of Canada: Law and Government Division. URL: http://www2.parl.gc.ca/Sites/LOP/LegislativeSummaries/Bills_ls.asp?lang=E&ls=C39&source=library_%20prb&Parl=37&Ses=1 (accessed 2 November 2009).
Intergovernmental Affairs and Aboriginal Affairs. 1995. Briefing note: progress on devolution of land and water. 7 March 1995. Yellowknife: NWT Archives G-2007-006, 2–12.
Intergovernmental Affairs and Aboriginal Affairs. 1994. Briefing note: federal devolution of natural resource management. 17 August 1994. Yellowknife: NWT Archives G-2007-006, 212.
Intergovernmental Core Group. 1993. Northwest Territories development: division, the western constitution, devolution. 14 October 1993. Yellowknife: NWT Archives: G-2007-006, 3–4.
Irlbacher-Fox S., and Mills S.J.. 2007. Devolution and resource revenue sharing in the Canadian north: achieving fairness across generations. Toronto (Conference paper for the Walter and Duncan Gordon Foundation).
King G., Keohane R.O., and Verba S.. 1994. Designing social inquiry: scientific inference in qualitative research. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Legislative Assembly of the Northwest Territories. 2010. History of the Legislative Assembly. Yellowknife: The Legislative Assembly of the NWT. URL: http://www.assembly.gov.nt.ca/_live/pages/wpPages/factshistoryofthelegislativeassembly. aspx (accessed 15 July 2010).
Makohoniuk R. 2010. Tlicho government does not support the draft devolution AIP. Tlicho Government Press Release 29 October 2010.
May K. 2010. Aboriginal leaders sound off on devolution. Northern News Services 1 November 2010.
Mayer P. 2007. The Mayer Report on Nunavut devolution. Ottawa: Department of Indian and Northern Affairs.
McArthur D. 2007. The changing architecture of government in northern Canada west of Nunavut. Ottawa (Paper delivered at The Art of the State IV: Northern exposure), Institute for Research on Public Policy.
McDonald P. 1996. Oral questions. Whitehorse: Yukon Legislative Assembly. Hansard. 28th Legislature, 2nd Session. 25 March 1996.
Memorandum of Intent on Devolution and Resource Revenue Sharing. 22 May 2001. (Copy with author).
Michael J.M. 1987. From Sissons to Meyer: the administrative development of the Yukon Government 1948–1979. Whitehorse: Yukon Archives.
Morrison D.R. 1968. The politics of the Yukon Territory, 1898–1909. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Natcher D.C., and Davis S.. 2007. Rethinking devolution: challenges for aboriginal resource management in the Yukon Territory. Society and Natural Resources 20 (3): 271279.
O'Brien A. 2006. Strengthening Canada's territories and putting equalization back on track. Kingston: Institute of Intergovernmental Relations (The Report of the Expert Panel on Equalization and Territorial Formula Financing).
Okalik P. 2006. Devolution and nation building in Canada's north. Iqaluit: Government of Nunavut (Speech to the Public Policy Forum Seminar on Economic Transformation North of 60. 13 December 2006).
Raven A. 2005. Feds have no right: DFN. Northern News Services. 18 March 2005.
Rayner J. 2001. Fiscal Relations Between the Federal and Territorial Governments in Canada. Consortium for Economic Policy Research and Advice.
Roland F. 2008. Oral questions. Northwest Territories Legislative Assembly. Hansard. 16th Assembly, 5th Session, 18 October 2008.
Simeon R. 2006. Federal-provincial diplomacy: the making of recent policy in Canada. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Smyth S. 1991. The Yukon's constitutional foundations, Vol. I. The Yukon chronology. Whitehorse: Northern Directories.
Stokell S. 2011. New Tlicho grand chief to focus on ‘unity’. Northern News Service 28 March 2011.
Thompson R. 2008. Dehcho first nations examine its options. Northern News Service 3 February 2008.
Tsebelis G. 2002. Veto players: how political institutions work. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Unrau J. 2007. Handley brushes off Akaitcho demand that he leave town. Northern News Service. 21 May 2007.
White G. 2009. Nunavut and the Inuvialuit settlement region: differing models of northern governance. In: Abele F., Courchene J.T., Seidle F.L., and St-Hilaire F. (editors). Northern exposure: peoples, powers and prospects in Canada's north. Ottawa: The Institute for Research on Public Policy.
White G. 2002. Politics and government in the territorial north: familiar and exotic. Ottawa: Centre for Research and Information on Canada (The CRIC Papers – The Canadian north: embracing change. June 2002).
Wright R. 1995. Report to the Honourable Ronald Irwin re The devolution by DIAND of provincial-like powers to the Yukon and Northwest Territories. Ottawa: INAC.
Yakeleya N. 2011. Members’ statements. Yellowknife: Northwest Territories Legislative Assembly. Hansard. 16th Assembly, 5th Session, 16 February 2011.
Yukon Government. 2011. Yukon welcomes PM's commitment to improve resource revenue sharing agreement. Press Release #11–132. Whitehorse: Yukon Government.
Zaslow M. 1988. The northward expansion of Canada, 1914–1967. Toronto: McClelland and Stewart.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Polar Record
  • ISSN: 0032-2474
  • EISSN: 1475-3057
  • URL: /core/journals/polar-record
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 3
Total number of PDF views: 24 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 170 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 23rd October 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.