Skip to main content
×
Home

Cognitive behavioural therapy for major psychiatric disorder: does it really work? A meta-analytical review of well-controlled trials

  • D. Lynch (a1), K. R. Laws (a2) and P. J. McKenna (a3) (a4)
Abstract
Background

Although cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) is claimed to be effective in schizophrenia, major depression and bipolar disorder, there have been negative findings in well-conducted studies and meta-analyses have not fully considered the potential influence of blindness or the use of control interventions.

Method

We pooled data from published trials of CBT in schizophrenia, major depression and bipolar disorder that used controls for non-specific effects of intervention. Trials of effectiveness against relapse were also pooled, including those that compared CBT to treatment as usual (TAU). Blinding was examined as a moderating factor.

Results

CBT was not effective in reducing symptoms in schizophrenia or in preventing relapse. CBT was effective in reducing symptoms in major depression, although the effect size was small, and in reducing relapse. CBT was ineffective in reducing relapse in bipolar disorder.

Conclusions

CBT is no better than non-specific control interventions in the treatment of schizophrenia and does not reduce relapse rates. It is effective in major depression but the size of the effect is small in treatment studies. On present evidence CBT is not an effective treatment strategy for prevention of relapse in bipolar disorder.

  • View HTML
    • Send article to Kindle

      To send this article to your Kindle, first ensure no-reply@cambridge.org is added to your Approved Personal Document E-mail List under your Personal Document Settings on the Manage Your Content and Devices page of your Amazon account. Then enter the ‘name’ part of your Kindle email address below. Find out more about sending to your Kindle.

      Note you can select to send to either the @free.kindle.com or @kindle.com variations. ‘@free.kindle.com’ emails are free but can only be sent to your device when it is connected to wi-fi. ‘@kindle.com’ emails can be delivered even when you are not connected to wi-fi, but note that service fees apply.

      Find out more about the Kindle Personal Document Service.

      Cognitive behavioural therapy for major psychiatric disorder: does it really work? A meta-analytical review of well-controlled trials
      Available formats
      ×
      Send article to Dropbox

      To send this article to your Dropbox account, please select one or more formats and confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your Dropbox account. Find out more about sending content to Dropbox.

      Cognitive behavioural therapy for major psychiatric disorder: does it really work? A meta-analytical review of well-controlled trials
      Available formats
      ×
      Send article to Google Drive

      To send this article to your Google Drive account, please select one or more formats and confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your Google Drive account. Find out more about sending content to Google Drive.

      Cognitive behavioural therapy for major psychiatric disorder: does it really work? A meta-analytical review of well-controlled trials
      Available formats
      ×
Copyright
Corresponding author
*Address for correspondence: Dr P. J. McKenna, Benito Menni Complex Assistencial en Salut Mental, Germanes Hospitalàries del Sagrat Cor de Jesús, C/Doctor Antoni Pujades 38-C, 08830 Sant Boi de Llobregat, Barcelona, Spain. (Email: mckennapeter1@googlemail.com)
References
Hide All
Ball JR, Mitchell PB, Corry JC, Skillecorn A, Smith M, Malhi GS (2006). A randomized controlled trial of cognitive therapy for bipolar disorder: focus on long-term change. Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 67, 277286.
Basco MR, Rush AJ (2007). Cognitive Therapy for Bipolar Disorder, 2nd edn. Guilford Press: New York.
Barrowclough C, Haddock G, Lobban F, Jones S, Siddle R, Roberts C, Gregg L (2006). Group cognitive-behavioural therapy for schizophrenia. Randomised controlled trial. British Journal of Psychiatry 189, 527532.
Bechdolf A, Knost B, Kuntermann C, Schiller S, Klosterkotter J, Hambrecht M, Pukrop R (2004). A randomized comparison of group cognitive-behavioural therapy and group psychoeducation in patients with schizophrenia. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 110, 2128.
Beutler LE, Engle D, Mohr D, Daldrup RJ, Bergan J, Meredith K, Merry W (1991). Predictors of differential response to cognitive, experiential, and self-directed psychotherapeutic procedures. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 59, 333340.
Bockting CL, Schene AH, Spinhoven P, Koeter MW, Wouters LF, Huyser J, Kamphuis JH (2005). Preventing relapse/recurrence in recurrent depression with cognitive therapy: a randomized controlled trial. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 73, 647657.
Bowers WA (1990). Treatment of depressed in-patients. Cognitive therapy plus medication, relaxation plus medication, and medication alone. British Journal of Psychiatry 156, 7378.
Churchill R, Hunot V, Corney R, Knapp M, McGuire H, Tylee A, Wessely S (2001). A systematic review of controlled trials of the effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of brief psychological treatments for depression. Health Technology Assessment 5, 1173.
Cuijpers P, van Straten A, Andersson G, van Oppen P (2008). Psychotherapy for depression in adults: a meta-analysis of comparative outcome studies. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 76, 909922.
DeRubeis RJ, Hollon SD, Amsterdam JD, Shelton RC, Young PR, Salomon RM, O'Reardon JP, Lovett ML, Gladis MM, Brown LL, Gallop R (2005). Cognitive therapy vs. medications in the treatment of moderate to severe depression. Archives of General Psychiatry 62, 409416.
Dimidjian S, Hollon SD, Dobson KS, Schmaling KB, Kohlenberg RJ, Addis ME, Gallop R, McGlinchey JB, Markley DK, Gollan JK, Atkins DC, Dunner DL, Jacobson NS (2006). Randomized trial of behavioral activation, cognitive therapy, and antidepressant medication in the acute treatment of adults with major depression. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 74, 658670.
Dobson KS, Hollon SD, Dimidjian S, Schmaling KB, Kohlenberg RJ, Gallop RJ, Rizvi SL, Gollan JK, Dunner DL, Jacobson NS (2008). Randomized trial of behavioral activation, cognitive therapy, and antidepressant medication in the prevention of relapse and recurrence in major depression. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 76, 468477.
Drury V, Birchwood M, Cochrane R (2000). Cognitive therapy and recovery from acute psychosis: a controlled trial. 3. Five-year follow-up. British Journal of Psychiatry 177, 8–14.
Drury V, Birchwood M, Cochrane R, Macmillan F (1996). Cognitive therapy and recovery from acute psychosis: a controlled trial. I. Impact on psychotic symptoms. British Journal of Psychiatry 169, 593601.
Durham RC, Guthrie M, Morton RV, Reid DA, Treliving LR, Fowler D, Macdonald RR (2003). Tayside-Fife clinical trial of cognitive-behavioural therapy for medication-resistant psychotic symptoms. Results to 3-month follow-up. British Journal of Psychiatry 182, 303311.
Elkin I, Shea MT, Watkins JT, Imber SD, Sotsky SM, Collins JF, Glass DR, Pilkonis PA, Leber WR, Docherty JP, Fiester SJ, Parloff MB (1989). National Institute of Mental Health treatment of depression collaborative research program. General effectiveness of treatments. Archives of General Psychiatry 46, 971982.
Evans MD, Hollon SD, DeRubeis RJ, Piasecki JM, Grove WM, Garvey MJ, Tuason VB (1992). Differential relapse following cognitive therapy and pharmacotherapy for depression. Archives of General Psychiatry 49, 802808.
Fava GA, Grandi S, Zielezny M, Canestrari R, Morphy MA (1994). Cognitive behavioral treatment of residual symptoms in primary major depressive disorder. American Journal of Psychiatry 151, 12951299.
Fava GA, Rafanelli C, Grandi S, Conti S, Belluardo P (1998). Prevention of recurrent depression with cognitive behavioral therapy: preliminary findings. Archives of General Psychiatry 55, 816820.
Garety PA, Fowler DG, Freeman D, Bebbington P, Dunn G, Kuipers E (2008 a). Cognitive-behavioural therapy and family intervention for relapse prevention and symptom reduction in psychosis: randomised controlled trial. British Journal of Psychiatry 192, 412423.
Garety PA, Fowler DG, Freeman D, Bebbington P, Dunn G, Kuipers E (2008 b). Risk of harm after psychological intervention: authors' reply. British Journal of Psychiatry 193, 345346.
Gillespie R (1991). Manufacturing Knowledge: A History of the Hawthorne Experiments. Cambridge University Press: Cambridge.
Gloaguen V, Cottraux J, Cucherat M, Blackburn IM (1998). A meta-analysis of the effects of cognitive therapy in depressed patients. Journal of Affective Disorders 49, 5972.
Gould RA, Mueser KT, Bolton E, Mays V, Goff D (2001). Cognitive therapy for psychosis in schizophrenia: an effect size analysis. Schizophrenia Research 48, 335342.
Gumley A, O'Grady M, McNay L, Reilly J, Power K, Norrie J (2003). Early intervention for relapse in schizophrenia: results of a 12-month randomized controlled trial of cognitive behavioural therapy. Psychological Medicine 33, 419431.
Haddock G, Barrowclough C, Shaw JJ, Dunn G, Novaco RW, Tarrier N (2009). Cognitive–behavioural therapy v. social activity therapy for people with psychosis and a history of violence: randomised controlled trial. British Journal of Psychiatry 194, 152157.
Hogarty GE, Kornblith SJ, Greenwald D, DiBarry AL, Cooley S, Ulrich RF, Carter M, Flesher S (1997). Three-year trials of personal therapy among schizophrenic patients living with or independent of family. I: Description of study and effects on relapse rates. American Journal of Psychiatry 154, 15041513.
Hollon SD, DeRubeis RJ, Shelton RC, Amsterdam JD, Salomon RM, O'Reardon JP, Lovett ML, Young PR, Haman KL, Freeman BB, Gallop R (2005). Prevention of relapse following cognitive therapy vs medications in moderate to severe depression. Archives of General Psychiatry 62, 417422.
Jackson HJ, McGorry PD, Killackey E, Bendall S, Allott K, Dudgeon P, Gleeson J, Johnson T, Harrigan S (2008). Acute-phase and 1-year follow-up results of a randomized controlled trial of CBT versus befriending for first-episode psychosis: the ACE project. Psychological Medicine 38, 725735.
Jarrett RB, Kraft D, Doyle J, Foster BM, Eaves GG, Silver PC (2001). Preventing recurrent depression using cognitive therapy with and without a continuation phase: a randomized clinical trial. Archives of General Psychiatry 58, 381388.
Jarrett RB, Schaffer M, McIntire D, Witt-Browder A, Kraft D, Risser RC (1999). Treatment of atypical depression with cognitive therapy or phenelzine: a double-blind, placebo-controlled trial. Archives of General Psychiatry 56, 431437.
Jones C, Cormac I, Silveira da Mota Neto JI, Campbell C (2004). Cognitive behaviour therapy for schizophrenia. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 4, CD000524.
Jüni P, Douglas GAltman DG, Egger M (2001). Systematic reviews in health care: assessing the quality of controlled clinical trials. British Medical Journal 323, 4246.
Kingdon D (2006). Psychological and social interventions for schizophrenia. British Medical Journal 333, 212213.
Lam D, Bright J, Jones S, Hayward P, Schuck N, Chisholm D, Sham P (2000). Cognitive therapy for bipolar illness: a pilot study of relapse prevention. Cognitive Therapy Research 24, 503520.
Lam DH, Watkins ER, Hayward P, Bright J, Wright K, Kerr N, Parr-Davis G, Sham P (2003). A randomized controlled study of cognitive therapy for relapse prevention for bipolar affective disorder: outcome of the first year. Archives of General Psychiatry 60, 145152.
Layard R (2006). The case for psychological treatment centres. British Medical Journal 332, 10301032.
Lecomte T, Leclerc C, Corbière M, Wykes T, Wallace CJ, Spidel A (2008). Group cognitive behavior therapy or social skills training for individuals with a recent onset of psychosis? Resutls of a randomized controlled trial. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease 196, 866875.
Lewis S, Tarrier N, Haddock G, Bentall R, Kinderman P, Kingdon D, Siddle R, Drake R, Everitt J, Leadley K, Benn A, Grazebrook K, Haley C, Akhtar S, Davies L, Palmer S, Faragher B, Dunn G (2002). Randomised controlled trial of cognitive-behavioural therapy in early schizophrenia: acute-phase outcomes. British Journal of Psychiatry. Supplement 43, s91s97.
Ma SH, Teasdale JD (2004). Mindfulness-based cognitive therapy for depression: replication and exploration of differential relapse prevention effects. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 72, 3140.
McLean PD, Hakstian AR (1979). Clinical depression: comparative efficacy of outpatient treatments. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 47, 818836.
Miller IW, Norman WH, Keitner GI, Dow MG (1989). Cognitive-behavioral treatment of depressed inpatients. Behavior Therapy 20, 2547.
Murphy GE, Carney RM, Knesevich MA, Wetzel RD, Whitworth P (1995). Cognitive behavior therapy, relaxation training, and tricyclic antidepressant medication in the treatment of depression. Psychological Reports 77, 403420.
NICE (2003). Schizophrenia: Full National Clinical Guideline on Core Interventions in Primary and Secondary Care. Gaskell and the British Psychological Society: London.
NICE (2004). Depression: Management of Depression in Primary and Secondary Care. National Institute for Clinical Excellence (NICE) Clinical Guideline, CG23. Gaskell and the British Psychological Society: London.
NICE (2009). Schizophrenia: Core Interventions in the Treatment and Management of Schizophrenia in Primary and Secondary Care (update). National Institute for Clinical Excellence: London.
Parker G, Roy K, Eyers K (2003). Cognitive behavior therapy for depression? Choose horses for courses. American Journal of Psychiatry 160, 825834.
Paykel ES, Scott J, Teasdale JD, Johnson AL, Garland A, Moore R, Jenaway A, Cornwall PL, Hayhurst H, Abbott R, Pope M (1999). Prevention of relapse in residual depression by cognitive therapy: a controlled trial. Archives of General Psychiatry 56, 829835.
Perlis RH, Nierenberg AA, Alpert JE, Pava J, Matthews JD, Buchin J, Sickinger AH, Fava M (2002). Effects of adding cognitive therapy to fluoxetine dose increase on risk of relapse and residual depressive symptoms in continuation treatment of major depressive disorder. Journal of Clinical Psychopharmacology 22, 474480.
Picchioni MM, Murray RM (2007). Schizophrenia. British Medical Journal 335, 9195.
Pilling S, Bebbington P, Kuipers E, Garety P, Geddes J, Orbach G, Morgan C (2002). Psychological treatments in schizophrenia: I. Meta-analysis of family intervention and cognitive behaviour therapy. Psychological Medicine 32, 763782.
Pinto J, La Pia S, Mennella R, Giorgio D, DeSimone L (1999). Cognitive-behavioral therapy and clozapine for clients with treatment-refractory schizophrenia. Psychiatric Services 50, 901904.
Rector NA, Beck AT (2001). Cognitive behavioral therapy for schizophrenia: an empirical review. Journal of Nervous and Mental Diseases 189, 278287.
Scott AI, Freeman CP (1992). Edinburgh primary care depression study: treatment outcome, patient satisfaction, and cost after 16 weeks. British Medical Journal 304, 883887.
Scott J, Colom F, Vieta E (2007). A meta-analysis of relapse rates with adjunctive psychological therapies compared to usual psychiatric treatment for bipolar disorders. International Journal of Neuropsychopharmacology 10, 123129.
Scott J, Colom F (2005). Psychosocial treatments for bipolar disorders. Psychiatric Clinics of North America 28, 371384.
Scott J, Garland A, Moorhead S (2001). A pilot study of cognitive therapy in bipolar disorders. Psychological Medicine 31, 459467.
Scott J, Paykel E, Morriss R, Bentall R, Kinderman P, Johnson T, Abbott R, Hayhurst H (2006). Cognitive-behavioural therapy for severe and recurrent bipolar disorders: randomised controlled trial. British Journal of Psychiatry 188, 313320.
Segal ZV, Kennedy S, Gemar M, Hood K, Pedersen R, Buis T (2006). Cognitive reactivity to sad mood provocation and the prediction of depressive relapse. Archives of General Psychiatry 63, 749755.
Sensky T, Turkington D, Kingdon D, Scott JL, Scott J, Siddle R, O'Carroll M, Barnes T (2000). A randomized controlled trial of cognitive-behavioral therapy for persistent symptoms in schizophrenia resistant to medication. Archives of General Psychiatry 57, 165172.
Shea MT, Elkin I, Imber SD, Sotsky SM, Watkins JT, Collins JF, Pilkonis PA, Beckham E, Glass DR, Dolan RT, Parloff MB (1992). Course of depressive symptoms over follow-up. Findings from the National Institute of Mental Health Treatment of Depression Collaborative Research Program. Archives of General Psychiatry 49, 782787.
Tarrier N, Lewis S, Haddock G, Bentall R, Drake R, Kinderman P, Kingdon D, Siddle R, Everitt J, Leadley K, Benn A, Grazebrook K, Haley C, Akhtar S, Davies L, Palmer S, Dunn G (2004). Cognitive-behavioural therapy in first-episode and early schizophrenia: 18-month follow-up of a randomised controlled trial. British Journal of Psychiatry 184, 231239.
Tarrier N, Wittkowski A, Kinney C, McCarthy E, Morris J, Humphreys L (1999). Durability of the effects of cognitive-behavioural therapy in the treatment of chronic schizophrenia: 12-month follow-up. British Journal of Psychiatry 174, 500504.
Tarrier N, Wykes T (2004). Is there evidence that cognitive behaviour therapy is an effective treatment for schizophrenia? A cautious or cautionary tale? Behaviour Research and Therapy 42, 13771401.
Teasdale JD, Segal ZV, Williams JM, Ridgeway VA, Soulsby JM, Lau MA (2000). Prevention of relapse/recurrence in major depression by mindfulness-based cognitive therapy. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 68, 615623.
Turkington D, Kingdon D, Rathod S, Hammond K, Pelton J, Mehta R (2006). Outcomes of an effectiveness trial of cognitive-behavioural intervention by mental health nurses in schizophrenia. British Journal of Psychiatry 189, 3640.
Turkington D, Sensky T, Scott J, Barnes TR, Nur U, Siddle R, Hammond K, Samarasekara N, Kingdon D (2008). A randomized controlled trial of cognitive-behavior therapy for persistent symptoms in schizophrenia: a five-year follow-up. Schizophrenia Research 98, 17.
Valmaggia LR, van der Gaag M, Tarrier N, Pijnenborg M, Slooff CJ (2005). Cognitive-behavioural therapy for refractory psychotic symptoms of schizophrenia resistant to atypical antipsychotic medication. Randomised controlled trial. British Journal of Psychiatry 186, 324330.
Vittengl JR, Clark LA, Dunn TW, Jarrett RB (2007). Reducing relapse and recurrence in unipolar depression: a comparative meta-analysis of cognitive-behavioral therapy's effects. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 75, 475488.
Wykes T, Steel C, Everitt B, Tarrier N (2008). Cognitive behavior therapy for schizophrenia: effect sizes, clinical models, and methodological rigor. Schizophrenia Bulletin 34, 523537.
Zaretsky A, Lancee W, Miller C, Harris A, Parikh SV (2008). Is cognitive-behavioural therapy more effective than psychoeducation in bipolar disorder? Canadian Journal of Psychiatry 53, 441448.
Zimmermann G, Favrod J, Trieu VH, Pomini V (2005). The effect of cognitive behavioral treatment on the positive symptoms of schizophrenia spectrum disorders: a meta-analysis. Schizophrenia Research 77, 19.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Psychological Medicine
  • ISSN: 0033-2917
  • EISSN: 1469-8978
  • URL: /core/journals/psychological-medicine
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Keywords:

Type Description Title
PDF
Supplementary Materials

Lynch supplementary material
Appendix.doc

 PDF (36 KB)
36 KB

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 263
Total number of PDF views: 1713 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 3492 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 19th November 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.