Skip to main content
×
Home
    • Aa
    • Aa
  • Get access
    Check if you have access via personal or institutional login
  • Cited by 59
  • Cited by
    This article has been cited by the following publications. This list is generated based on data provided by CrossRef.

    Friedrich, Orsolya and Schleidgen, Sebastian 2017. Krankheit und Recht.


    Boettger, Susanne Bergman, Meredith Jenewein, Josef and Boettger, Soenke 2016. Advanced age and decisional capacity: The effect of age on the ability to make health care decisions. Archives of Gerontology and Geriatrics, Vol. 66, p. 211.


    Morán-Sánchez, Inés Luna, Aurelio and Pérez-Cárceles, Maria D. 2016. Assessment of Capacity to Consent to Research Among Psychiatric Outpatients: Prevalence and Associated Factors. Psychiatric Quarterly, Vol. 87, Issue. 1, p. 89.


    Ostermeyer, Britta Flores, Araceli Dukes, Charles and Shah, Asim A. 2016. Medical Decision-Making Capacity in Depression. Psychiatric Annals, Vol. 46, Issue. 4, p. 247.


    Ruissen, A. M. Abma, T. A. Van Balkom, A. J. L. M. Meynen, G. and Widdershoven, G. A. M. 2016. Moving Perspectives on Patient Competence: A Naturalistic Case Study in Psychiatry. Health Care Analysis, Vol. 24, Issue. 1, p. 71.


    Schütz, Holger Heinrichs, Bert Fuchs, Michael and Bauer, Andreas 2016. Informierte Einwilligung in der Demenzforschung. Eine qualitative Studie zum Informationsverständnis von Probanden. Ethik in der Medizin, Vol. 28, Issue. 2, p. 91.


    Zlodre, J. Yiend, J. Burns, T. and Fazel, S. 2016. Coercion, competence, and consent in offenders with personality disorder. Psychology, Crime & Law, Vol. 22, Issue. 4, p. 315.


    Gather, Jakov and Vollmann, Jochen 2015. How to Decide?. GeroPsych, Vol. 28, Issue. 1, p. 17.


    Hein, Irma M Daams, Joost Troost, Pieter Lindeboom, Robert Lindauer, Ramón JL and Hein, Irma M 2015. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews.


    Kepple, Alyson L. Azzam, Pierre N. Gopalan, Priya and Arnold, Robert M. 2015. Decision-making capacity at the end of life. Progress in Palliative Care, Vol. 23, Issue. 3, p. 133.


    Mueller, Tanja Haberstroh, Julia Knebel, Maren Oswald, Frank Weygandt, Martin Schröder, Johannes Markwort, Susanne and Pantel, Johannes 2015. Comparison of Three Different Assessments of Capacity to Consent in Dementia Patients. GeroPsych, Vol. 28, Issue. 1, p. 21.


    Aydin Er, Rahime and Sehiralti, Mine 2014. Comparing assessments of the decision-making competencies of psychiatric inpatients as provided by physicians, nurses, relatives and an assessment tool. Journal of Medical Ethics, Vol. 40, Issue. 7, p. 453.


    Braitman, A. Dauriac-Le Masson, V. Beghelli, F. Gallois, E. Guillibert, E. Hoang, C. Kahvedjian, A. Lana, P. and Guedj, M.-J. 2014. La décision d’hospitalisation sans consentement aux urgences : approche dimensionnelle ou catégorielle ?. L'Encéphale, Vol. 40, Issue. 3, p. 247.


    Braitman, A. Dauriac-Le Masson, V. Beghelli, F. Gallois, E. Guillibert, E. Hoang, C. Kahvedjian, A. Lana, P. and Guedj, M.-J. 2014. La décision d’hospitalisation sans consentement aux urgences : approche dimensionnelle ou catégorielle ?. Journal Européen des Urgences et de Réanimation, Vol. 26, Issue. 3-4, p. 213.


    Elzakkers, Isis F.F.M. Danner, Unna N. Hoek, Hans W. Schmidt, Ulrike and van Elburg, Annemarie A. 2014. Compulsory treatment in anorexia nervosa: A review. International Journal of Eating Disorders, Vol. 47, Issue. 8, p. 845.


    Hein, Irma M Daams, Joost Troost, Pieter Lindeboom, Robert Lindauer, Ramón JL and Hein, Irma M 2014. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews.


    Hubbeling, Dieneke 2014. Decision-making capacity should not be decisive in emergencies. Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy, Vol. 17, Issue. 2, p. 229.


    Kolva, Elissa Rosenfeld, Barry Brescia, Robert and Comfort, Christopher 2014. Assessing decision-making capacity at end of life. General Hospital Psychiatry, Vol. 36, Issue. 4, p. 392.


    Vollmann, J. 2014. Zwangsbehandlungen in der Psychiatrie. Der Nervenarzt, Vol. 85, Issue. 5, p. 614.


    Gather, Jakov and Vollmann, Jochen 2013. Physician-assisted suicide of patients with dementia. A medical ethical analysis with a special focus on patient autonomy. International Journal of Law and Psychiatry, Vol. 36, Issue. 5-6, p. 444.


    ×

Competence of mentally ill patients: a comparative empirical study

  • J. VOLLMANN (a1), A. BAUER (a1), H. DANKER-HOPFE (a1) and H. HELMCHEN (a1)
  • DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S0033291703008389
  • Published online: 01 November 2003
Abstract

Background. This study investigates the competence of patients with dementia, depression and schizophrenia to make treatment decisions. The outcome of an objective test instrument is presented and compared with clinical assessment of competence by the attending physician.

Method. The MacArthur Competence Assessment Tool-Treatment (MacCAT-T), a test instrument to assess abilities in different standards of competence, was administered to patients with diagnoses of dementia (N=31), depression (N=35) and schizophrenia (N=43). Statistical significance of group differences in the MacCAT-T results were tested with the chi-square test. The concordance of the test and clinical assessment of competence by the attending physician were evaluated by Cohen's kappa coefficient.

Results. Patients with dementia, as a group, showed significantly more often impaired performance than those with schizophrenia who were still more impaired than depressed patients. Patients were classified as impaired or not depending on the standards used. By combination of all standards substantially more patients were classified as impaired than by clinical assessment (67·7 v. 48·4% of patients with dementia, 20·0 v. 2·9% of patients with depression, 53·5 v. 18·4% of patients with schizophrenia).

Conclusions. Using different standards of competence the study showed substantial differences among patients with dementia, depression and schizophrenia. The high proportion of patients identified as incompetent raises several ethical questions, in particular, those referring to the selection of standards or the definition of cut-offs for incompetence. The discrepancy between clinical and formal evaluations points out the influence of the used procedure on competence judgements.

Copyright
Corresponding author
Professor Jochen Vollmann, Institut für Geschichte und Ethik der Medizin, Friedrich-Alexander-Universität Erlangen-Nürnberg, Glückstrasse 10, D-91054 Erlangen, Germany.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Psychological Medicine
  • ISSN: 0033-2917
  • EISSN: 1469-8978
  • URL: /core/journals/psychological-medicine
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×