Skip to main content Accesibility Help
×
×
Home

Steep discounting of delayed monetary and food rewards in obesity: a meta-analysis

  • M. Amlung (a1), T. Petker (a1), J. Jackson (a1), I. Balodis (a1) and J. MacKillop (a1) (a2)...
Abstract
Background

An increasing number of studies have investigated delay discounting (DD) in relation to obesity, but with mixed findings. This meta-analysis synthesized the literature on the relationship between monetary and food DD and obesity, with three objectives: (1) to characterize the relationship between DD and obesity in both case–control comparisons and continuous designs; (2) to examine potential moderators, including case–control v. continuous design, money v. food rewards, sample sex distribution, and sample age (<18 v. >18 years); and (3) to evaluate publication bias.

Method

From 134 candidate articles, 39 independent investigations yielded 29 case–control and 30 continuous comparisons (total n = 10 278). Random-effects meta-analysis was conducted using Cohen's d as the effect size. Publication bias was evaluated using fail-safe N, Begg–Mazumdar and Egger tests, meta-regression of publication year and effect size, and imputation of missing studies.

Results

The primary analysis revealed a medium effect size across studies that was highly statistically significant (d = 0.43, p < 10−14). None of the moderators examined yielded statistically significant differences, although notably larger effect sizes were found for studies with case–control designs, food rewards and child/adolescent samples. Limited evidence of publication bias was present, although the Begg–Mazumdar test and meta-regression suggested a slightly diminishing effect size over time.

Conclusions

Steep DD of food and money appears to be a robust feature of obesity that is relatively consistent across the DD assessment methodologies and study designs examined. These findings are discussed in the context of research on DD in drug addiction, the neural bases of DD in obesity, and potential clinical applications.

Copyright
Corresponding author
*Address for correspondence: M. Amlung, Ph.D., Peter Boris Centre for Addictions Research, McMaster University/St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton, 100 West 5th Street, Hamilton, Ontario L8N 3K7, Canada. (Email: amlungm@mcmaster.ca)
References
Hide All
Ainslie, G (1975). Specious reward: a behavioral theory of impulsiveness and impulse control. Psychological Bulletin 82, 463496.
Amlung, M, Sweet, LH, Acker, J, Brown, CL, MacKillop, J (2014). Dissociable brain signatures of choice conflict and immediate reward preferences in alcohol use disorders. Addiction Biology 19, 743753.
Appelhans, BM, Waring, ME, Schneider, KL, Pagoto, SL, DeBiasse, MA, Whited, MC, Lynch, EB (2012). Delay discounting and intake of ready-to-eat and away-from-home foods in overweight and obese women. Appetite 59, 576584.
Appelhans, BM, Woolf, K, Pagoto, SL, Schneider, KL, Whited, MC, Liebman, R (2011). Inhibiting food reward: delay discounting, food reward sensitivity, and palatable food intake in overweight and obese women. Obesity 19, 21752182.
Begg, CB, Mazumdar, M (1994). Operating characteristics of a rank correlation test for publication bias. Biometrics 50, 10881101.
Best, JR, Theim, KR, Gredysa, DM, Stein, RI, Welch, RR, Saelens, BE, Perri, MG, Schechtman, KB, Epstein, LH, Wilfley, DE (2012). Behavioral economic predictors of overweight children's weight loss. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 80, 10861096.
Bickel, WK, Jarmolowicz, DP, Mueller, ET, Koffarnus, MN, Gatchalian, KM (2012). Excessive discounting of delayed reinforcers as a trans-disease process contributing to addiction and other disease-related vulnerabilities: emerging evidence. Pharmacology and Therapeutics 134, 287297.
Bickel, WK, Johnson, MW, Koffarnus, MN, MacKillop, J, Murphy, JG (2014). The behavioral economics of substance use disorders: reinforcement pathologies and their repair. Annual Review of Clinical Psychology 10, 641677.
Bickel, WK, Odum, AL, Madden, GJ (1999). Impulsivity and cigarette smoking: delay discounting in current, never, and ex-smokers. Psychopharmacology 146, 447454.
Bickel, WK, Vuchinich, RE (2000). Reframing Health Behavior Change with Behavioral Economics. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates: Mahwah, NJ.
Boettiger, CA, Mitchell, JM, Tavares, VC, Robertson, M, Joslyn, G, D'Esposito, M, Fields, HL (2007). Immediate reward bias in humans: fronto-parietal networks and a role for the catechol-O-methyltransferase 158Val/Val genotype. Journal of Neuroscience 27, 1438314391.
Bongers, P, Van Giessen, E, Roefs, A, Nederkoorn, C, Booij, J, Van Brink, W, Jansen, A (2015). Being impulsive and obese increases susceptibility to speeded detection of high-calorie foods. Health Psychology 34, 677685.
Borghans, L, Golsteyn, BH (2006). Time discounting and the body mass index. Evidence from the Netherlands. Economics and Human Biology 4, 3961.
Brace, A, Yeomans, MR (2016). The reinforcing value of palatable snack foods and its relationship to subtypes of behavioural and self-report impulsivity. Eating Behaviors 21, 1823.
Buono, FD, Whiting, SW, Sprong, ME (2015). Comparison of temporal discounting among obese college students and obese adults. Behavior Analysis: Research and Practice 15, 139147.
Chabris, CF, Laibson, D, Morris, CL, Schuldt, JP, Taubinsky, D (2008). Individual laboratory-measured discount rates predict field behavior. Journal of Risk and Uncertainty 37, 237269.
Claus, ED, Kiehl, KA, Hutchison, KE (2011). Neural and behavioral mechanisms of impulsive choice in alcohol use disorder. Alcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research 35, 12091219.
Coffey, SF, Gudleski, GD, Saladin, ME, Brady, KT (2003). Impulsivity and rapid discounting of delayed hypothetical rewards in cocaine-dependent individuals. Experimental and Clinical Psychopharmacology 11, 1825.
Cohen, J (1988). Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates: Hillsdale, NJ.
Daniel, TO, Stanton, CM, Epstein, LH (2013). The future is now: reducing impulsivity and energy intake using episodic future thinking. Psychological Science 24, 23392342.
Dassen, FCM, Houben, K, Jansen, A (2015). Time orientation and eating behavior: unhealthy eaters consider immediate consequences, while healthy eaters focus on future health. Appetite 91, 1319.
Dassen, FCM, Jansen, A, Nederkoorn, C, Houben, K (2016). Focus on the future: episodic future thinking reduces discount rate and snacking. Appetite 96, 327332.
Davis, C, Curtis, C, Levitan, RD, Carter, JC, Kaplan, AS, Kennedy, JL (2011). Evidence that “food addiction” is a valid phenotype of obesity. Appetite 57, 711717.
Duckworth, AL, Tsukayama, E, Geier, AB (2010). Self-controlled children stay leaner in the transition to adolescence. Appetite 54, 304308.
Duval, S, Tweedie, R (2000). Trim and fill: a simple funnel-plot-based method of testing and adjusting for publication bias in meta-analysis. Biometrics 56, 455463.
Egger, M, Smith, GD, Schneider, M, Minder, C (1997). Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test. BMJ 315, 629634.
Eisenstein, SA, Gredysa, DM, Antenor-Dorsey, JA, Green, L, Arbeláez, AM, Koller, JM, Black, KJ, Perlmutter, JS, Moerlein, SM, Hershey, T (2015). Insulin, central dopamine D2 receptors, and monetary reward discounting in obesity. PLOS ONE 10, e0133621.
Epstein, LH, Jankowiak, N, Fletcher, KD, Carr, KA, Nederkoorn, C, Raynor, HA, Finkelstein, E (2014). Women who are motivated to eat and discount the future are more obese. Obesity 22, 13941399.
Epstein, LH, Richards, JB, Saad, FG, Paluch, RA, Roemmich, JN, Lerman, C (2003). Comparison between two measures of delay discounting in smokers. Experimental and Clinical Psychopharmacology 11, 131138.
Epstein, LH, Saelens, BE (2000). Behavioral economics of obesity: food intake and energy expenditure. In Reframing Health Behavior Change with Behavioral Economics (ed. Bickel, W. K. and Vuchinich, R. E.), pp. 293311. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates: Mahwah, NJ.
Feda, DM, Roemmich, JN, Roberts, A, Epstein, LH (2015). Food reinforcement and delay discounting in zBMI-discordant siblings. Appetite 85, 185189.
Fields, SA, Sabet, M, Peal, A, Reynolds, B (2011). Relationship between weight status and delay discounting in a sample of adolescent cigarette smokers. Behavioural Pharmacology 22, 266268.
Fields, SA, Sabet, M, Reynolds, B (2013). Dimensions of impulsive behavior in obese, overweight, and healthy-weight adolescents. Appetite 70, 6066.
Garza, KB, Ding, M, Owensby, JK, Zizza, CA (2016). Impulsivity and fast-food consumption: a cross-sectional study among working adults. Journal of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics 116, 6168.
Garza, KB, Harris, CV, Bolding, MS (2013). Examination of value of the future and health beliefs to explain dietary and physical activity behaviors. Research in Social and Administrative Pharmacy 9, 851862.
Hendrickson, KL, Rasmussen, EB (2013). Effects of mindful eating training on delay and probability discounting for food and money in obese and healthy-weight individuals. Behaviour Research and Therapy 51, 399409.
Hendrickson, KL, Rasmussen, EB, Lawyer, SR (2015). Measurement and validation of measures for impulsive food choice across obese and healthy-weight individuals. Appetite 90, 254263.
Hoffman, WF, Schwartz, DL, Huckans, MS, McFarland, BH, Meiri, G, Stevens, AA, Mitchell, SH (2008). Cortical activation during delay discounting in abstinent methamphetamine dependent individuals. Psychopharmacology 201, 183193.
Hsu, AS, Vlaev, I (2014). Monetary cost for time spent in everyday physical activities. Social Science and Medicine 108, 7480.
Ikeda, S, Kang, MI, Ohtake, F (2010). Hyperbolic discounting, the sign effect, and the body mass index. Journal of Health Economics 29, 268284.
Jackson, J, MacKillop, J (2016). Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder and monetary delay discounting: a meta-analysis of case–control studies. Biological Psychiatry: Cognitive Neuroscience and Neuroimaging. Published online 11 February 2016. doi:10.1016/j.bpsc.2016.01.007.
Jarmolowicz, DP, Cherry, JB, Reed, DD, Bruce, JM, Crespi, JM, Lusk, JL, Bruce, AS (2014). Robust relation between temporal discounting rates and body mass. Appetite 78, 6367.
Johnson, MW, Bickel, WK (2002). Within-subject comparison of real and hypothetical money rewards in delay discounting. Journal for the Experimental Analysis of Behavior 77, 129146.
Kenny, PJ (2011). Common cellular and molecular mechanisms in obesity and drug addiction. Nature Reviews. Neuroscience 12, 638651.
Kirby, KN, Petry, NM, Bickel, WK (1999). Heroin addicts have higher discount rates for delayed rewards than non-drug-using controls. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 128, 7887.
Kishinevsky, FI, Cox, JE, Murdaugh, DL, Stoeckel, LE, Cook, EW, Weller, RE (2012). fMRI reactivity on a delay discounting task predicts weight gain in obese women. Appetite 58, 582592.
Krishnan-Sarin, S, Reynolds, B, Duhig, AM, Smith, A, Liss, T, McFetridge, A, Cavallo, DA, Carroll, KM, Potenza, MN (2007). Behavioral impulsivity predicts treatment outcome in a smoking cessation program for adolescent smokers. Drug and Alcohol Dependence 88, 7982.
Kulendran, M, Vlaev, I, Sugden, C, King, D, Ashrafian, H, Gately, P, Darzi, A (2014). Neuropsychological assessment as a predictor of weight loss in obese adolescents. International Journal of Obesity (2005) 38, 507512.
Lawyer, SR, Boomhower, SR, Rasmussen, EB (2015). Differential associations between obesity and behavioral measures of impulsivity. Appetite 95, 375382.
Lim, SL, Bruce, AS (2015). Can't wait to lose weight? Characterizing temporal discounting parameters for weight-loss. Appetite 85, 813.
Lu, Q, Tao, F, Hou, F, Zhang, Z, Sun, Y, Xu, Y, Xu, S, Zhao, Y (2014). Cortisol reactivity, delay discounting and percent body fat in Chinese urban young adolescents. Appetite 72, 1320.
MacKillop, J, Amlung, MT, Few, LR, Ray, LA, Sweet, LH, Munafo, MR (2011). Delayed reward discounting and addictive behavior: a meta-analysis. Psychopharmacology 216, 305321.
MacKillop, J, Kahler, CW (2009). Delayed reward discounting predicts treatment response for heavy drinkers receiving smoking cessation treatment. Drug and Alcohol Dependence 104, 197203.
Madden, GJ, Begotka, AM, Raiff, BR, Kastern, LL (2003). Delay discounting of real and hypothetical rewards. Experimental and Clinical Psychopharmacology 11, 139145.
Madden, GJ, Bickel, WK (2009). Impulsivity: The Behavioral and Neurological Science of Discounting. American Psychological Association: Washington, DC.
Madden, GJ, Petry, NM, Badger, GJ, Bickel, WK (1997). Impulsive and self-control choices in opioid-dependent patients and non-drug-using control participants: drug and monetary rewards. Experimental and Clinical Psychopharmacology 5, 256262.
Manwaring, JL, Green, L, Myerson, J, Strube, MJ, Wilfley, DE (2011). Discounting of various types of rewards by women with and without binge eating disorder: evidence for general rather than specific differences. Psychological Record 61, 561582.
Martin, LE, Pollack, L, McCune, A, Schulte, E, Savage, CR, Lundgren, JD (2015). Comparison of obese adults with poor versus good sleep quality during a functional neuroimaging delay discounting task: a pilot study. Psychiatry Research 234, 9095.
Mazur, JE (1987). An adjusting procedure for studying delayed reinforcement. In Quantitative Analysis of Behavior: Vol 5. The Effects of Delay and Intervening Events on Reinforcement Value (ed. Mazur, J. E., Nevin, J. A. and Rachlin, H.), pp. 5573. Erlbaum: Hillsdale, NJ.
Mole, TB, Irvine, MA, Worbe, Y, Collins, P, Mitchell, SP, Bolton, S, Harrison, NA, Robbins, TW, Voon, V (2015). Impulsivity in disorders of food and drug misuse. Psychological Medicine 45, 771782.
Monterosso, J, Ainslie, G, Xu, J, Cordova, X, Domier, CP, London, ED (2007). Frontoparietal cortical activity of methamphetamine-dependent and comparison subjects performing a delay discounting task. Human Brain Mapping 28, 383393.
Myerson, J, Green, L, Warusawitharana, M (2001). Area under the curve as a measure of discounting. Journal of Experimental Analysis of Behavior 76, 235243.
Peters, J, Buchel, C (2010). Episodic future thinking reduces reward delay discounting through an enhancement of prefrontal–mediotemporal interactions. Neuron 66, 138148.
Petry, NM (2001). Delay discounting of money and alcohol in actively using alcoholics, currently abstinent alcoholics, and controls. Psychopharmacology 154, 243250.
Rasmussen, EB, Lawyer, SR, Reilly, W (2010). Percent body fat is related to delay and probability discounting for food in humans. Behavioural Processes 83, 2330.
Scheres, A, Lee, A, Sumiya, M (2008). Temporal reward discounting and ADHD: task and symptom specific effects. Journal of Neural Transmission 115, 221226.
Schiff, S, Amodio, P, Testa, G, Nardi, M, Montagnese, S, Caregaro, L, Sellitto, M (2015). Impulsivity toward food reward is related to BMI: evidence from intertemporal choice in obese and normal-weight individuals. Brain and Cognition. Published online 30 October 2015. doi:10.1016/j.bandc.2015.10.001.
Simmank, J, Murawski, C, Bode, S, Horstmann, A (2015). Incidental rewarding cues influence economic decisions in people with obesity. Frontiers in Behavioral Neuroscience 9, 278.
Stewart, LA, Clarke, M, Rovers, M, Riley, RD, Simmonds, M, Stewart, G, Tierney, JF (2015). Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Review and Meta-Analyses of individual participant data: the PRISMA-IPD Statement. Journal of the American Medical Association 313, 16571665.
Stoeckel, LE, Murdaugh, DL, Cox, JE, Cook, EW, Weller, RE (2013). Greater impulsivity is associated with decreased brain activation in obese women during a delay discounting task. Brain Imaging and Behavior 7, 116128.
Stojek, MM, Fischer, S, Murphy, CM, MacKillop, J (2014). The role of impulsivity traits and delayed reward discounting in dysregulated eating and drinking among heavy drinkers. Appetite 80, 8188.
Vainik, U, Dagher, A, Dubé, L, Fellows, LK (2013). Neurobehavioural correlates of body mass index and eating behaviours in adults: a systematic review. Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews 37, 279299.
Verdejo-García, A, Pérez-Expósito, M, Schmidt-Río-Valle, J, Fernández-Serrano, MJ, Cruz, F, Pérez-García, M, López-Belmonte, G, Martín-Matillas, M, Martín-Lagos, JA, Marcos, A, Campoy, C (2010). Selective alterations within executive functions in adolescents with excess weight. Obesity 18, 15721578.
Volkow, ND, Baler, RD (2015). NOW vs LATER brain circuits: implications for obesity and addiction. Trends in Neurosciences 38, 345352.
Volkow, ND, Wise, RA (2005). How can drug addiction help us understand obesity? Nature Neuroscience 8, 555560.
Wang, Y, Beydoun, MA (2007). The obesity epidemic in the United States – gender, age, socioeconomic, racial/ethnic, and geographic characteristics: a systematic review and meta-regression analysis. Epidemiologic Reviews 29, 628.
Weller, RE, Cook, EW, Avsar, KB, Cox, JE (2008). Obese women show greater delay discounting than healthy-weight women. Appetite 51, 563569.
Weygandt, M, Mai, K, Dommes, E, Ritter, K, Leupelt, V, Spranger, J, Haynes, J-D (2015). Impulse control in the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex counteracts post-diet weight regain in obesity. NeuroImage 109, 318327.
World Health Organization (2000). Obesity: Preventing and Managing the Global Epidemic. Report of a WHO Consultation. WHO Technical Report Series, 894. WHO: Geneva.
World Health Organization (2011). Waist Circumference and Waist-Hip Ratio: Report of a WHO Expert Consultation. WHO: Geneva.
Yeomans, MR, Leitch, M, Mobini, S (2008). Impulsivity is associated with the disinhibition but not restraint factor from the Three Factor Eating Questionnaire. Appetite 50, 469476.
Yoon, JH, Higgins, ST, Heil, SH, Sugarbaker, RJ, Thomas, CS, Badger, GJ (2007). Delay discounting predicts postpartum relapse to cigarette smoking among pregnant women. Experimental and Clinical Psychopharmacology 15, 176186.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Psychological Medicine
  • ISSN: 0033-2917
  • EISSN: 1469-8978
  • URL: /core/journals/psychological-medicine
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Keywords

Type Description Title
WORD
Supplementary materials

Amlung supplementary material
Table S1 and Figure S1

 Word (144 KB)
144 KB

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed