Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home

The uses of trauma in experiment: Traumatic stress and the history of experimental neurosis, c. 1925–1975

  • Ulrich Koch (a1)

Argument

The article retraces the shifting conceptualizations of psychological trauma in experimental psychopathological research in the middle decades of the twentieth century in the United States. Among researchers studying so-called experimental neuroses in animal laboratories, trauma was an often-invoked category used to denote the clash of conflicting forces believed to lead to neurotic suffering. Experimental psychologists, however, soon grew skeptical of the traumatogenic model and ultimately came to reject neurosis as a disease entity. Both theoretical differences and practical circumstances, such as the technical challenge of stabilizing neurotic symptoms in rats, led to this demise. Yet, despite their reservations, experimental psychologists continued to employ traumatic stimuli to produce psychopathological syndromes. In the 1960s, a new understanding of trauma evolved, which emphasized the loss of control experienced by traumatized animal subjects. These shifting ideas about trauma, I argue, reflect both varying experimental cultures, epistemic norms as well as changing societal concerns.

Copyright

Corresponding author

References

Hide All
Abramson, Lyn Y., and Seligman, Martin E.P.. 1977. “Modeling Psychopathology in the Laboratory: History and Rationale.” In Psychopathology: Experimental Models, edited by Maser, Jack D. and Seligman, Martin E.P., 126: San Francisco: W.H. Freeman.
American Psychiatric Association. 1980. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, third edition. Washington DC: American Psychiatric Association.
Amsel, Abraham, and Rashotte, Michael E.. 1977. “Entwicklungsrichtungen der S-R-Lerntheorien in Amerika. Mit spezieller Beruecksichtigung Clark L. Hulls, seiner Vorgänger und Nachfolger.” In Die Psychologie des 20. Jahrhunderts, Vol. 4, edited by Zeier, Hans, 5782, Zürich: Kindler.
Beach, Frank A. 1950. “The Snark was a Boojum.” American Psychologist 5(4):115124.
Block, James D. 1963. “In Memoriam: Howard S. Liddell, Ph. D. 1895-1962.” Psychosomatic Medicine 25(1):12.
Brady, Joseph V. 1951. “The Effect of Electroconvulsive Shock on a Conditioned Emotional Response: The Permanence of the Effect.” Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology 44(5):507511.
Broadhurst, Paul L. 1960. “Abnormal Animal Behaviour.” In Handbook of Abnormal Psychology, edited by Eysenck, Hans Jürgen, 726763. London: Pitman.
Broadhurst, Paul L. 1973. “Abnormal Animal Behaviour’.” In Handbook of Abnormal Psychology, 2nd ed., edited by Eysenck, Hans Jürgen, 721754, London: Pitman.
Brunner, José. 2002. “Identifications, Suspicions, and the History of Traumatic Disorders.” Harvard Review of Psychiatry 10(3):179184.
Calhoun, John B. 1962. “Population Density and Social Pathology.” Scientific American 206(2):139149.
Cassidy, Angela, Dentinger, Rachel Mason, Schoefert, Kathryn, and Woods, Abigail. 2017. “Animal Roles and Traces in the History of Medicine, c. 1880-1980.” BJHS Themes 2:1133.
Clark, Stephen R.L. 1977. The Moral Status of Animals. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Cook, Stuart W. 1939a. “A Survey of Methods Used to Produce ‘Experimental Neurosis’.” American Journal of Psychiatry 95(6):12591276.
Cook, Stuart W. 1939b. “The Production of ‘Experimental Neurosis’ in the White Rat.Psychosomatic Medicine 1(2):293308.
Darwin, Charles. 1870. The Descent of Man. London: Murray.
Darwin, Charles. [1871] 1998. The Expression of the Emotions in Man and Animals. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Decker, Hannah S. 2013. The Making of DSM-III: A Diagnostic Manual’s Conquest of American Psychiatry. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Not mentioned in text.
Dewsbury, Donald A. 1984. Comparative Psychology in the Twentieth Century. Stroudsburg: Hutchinson Ross.
Dewsbury, Donald A. 1993. “On Publishing Controversy: Norman R.F. Maier and the Genesis of Seizures.” American Psychologist 48(8):869877.
Dror, Otniel E. 1999. “The Affect of Experiment: The Turn to Emotions in Anglo-American Physiology, 1900-1940.” Isis 90:205237.
Estes, William K., and Skinner, Burrhus F.. 1941. “Some Quantitative Properties of Anxiety.” Journal of Experimental Psychology 29(5):390400.
Eysenck, Hans J. 1979. “The Conditioning Model of Neurosis.” The Behavioral and Brain Sciences 2:155199.
Fassin, Didier, and Rechtman, Richard. 2009. The Empire of Trauma: An Inquiry into the Condition of Victimhood. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Finger, Frank W. 1944. “Experimental Behavior Disorders in the Rat.” In Personality and the Behavior Disorders. A Handbook Based on Experimental and Clinical Research, edited by Hunt, Joseph McV., 413430. New York: Ronald Press.
Flannery, Raymond B. 1987. “From Victim to Survivor: A Stress Management Approach in the Treatment of Learned Helplessness.” In Psychological Trauma, edited by van der Kolk, Bessel A., 217232. Washington: American Psychiatric Association.
Foa, Edna B., Steketee, Gail, and Rothbaum, Barbara Olasov. 1989. “Behavioral/Cognitive Conceptualizations of Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder.” Behavior Therapy 20(2):155176.
Franco, Nuno. 2013. “Animal Experiments in Biomedical Research: A Historical Perspective.” Animals 3(1):238273.
Gantt, W. Horsley. 1944. “The Experimental Basis for Neurotic Behavior: Origin and Development of Artificially Produced Disturbances of Behavior in Dogs.” Psychosomatic Medicine Monographs. Washington DC: National Research Council.
Gantt, W. Horsley, Newton, Joseph E.O., Royer, Fred L., and Stephens, Joseph H.. 1966. “Effect of Person.” Conditional Reflex: A Pavlovian Journal of Research & Therapy 1(1):1835.
Greenwood, John D. 2015. A Conceptual History of Psychology: Exploring the Tangled Web. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Guerrini, Anita. 2003. Experimenting with Humans and Animals. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Hacking, Ian. 1992. “‘Style’ for Historians and Philosophers.” Studies in History and Philosophy of Science 23(1): 120.
Hacking, Ian. 1998. Rewriting the Soul: Multiple Personality and the Sciences of Memory. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Hacking, Ian. 2012. “‘Language, Truth and Reason’ 30 Years Later.” Studies in History and Philosophy of Science 43(4):599609.
Hebb, Donald O. 1947. “Spontaneous Neurosis in Chimpanzees: Theoretical Relations with Clinical and Experimental Phenomena.” Psychosomatic Medicine 9:319.
Hodos, William, and Campbell, Colin Boyd G.. 1969. “Scala Naturae: Why there is no Theory in Comparative Psychology.” Psychological Review 76(4):337350.
Horowitz, Mardi J. 1976. Stress Response Syndromes. Oxford: Jason Aronson.
Hull, Clark L. 1929. “A Functional Interpretation of the Conditioned Reflex.” Psychological Review 36(6):498511.
Hull, Clark L. 1943. Principles of Behavior: An Introduction to Behavior Theory. Oxford: Appleton Century.
Hunt, Howard F. 1964. “Problems in the Interpretation of ‘Experimental Neurosis’.” Psychological Reports 15(1):2735.
Hunt, Howard F., and Brady, Joseph V.. 1951. “Some Effects of Electro-Convulsive Shock on a Conditioned Emotional Response (‘Anxiety’).” Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology 44(1):8898.
Hunt, John McV., and Schlosberg, Harold S.. 1950. “Behavior of Rats in Continuous Conflict.” Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology 43(5):351357.
Jones, Edgar, and Wessely, Simon. 2007. “A Paradigm Shift in the Conceptualization of Psychological Trauma in the 20th Century.” Journal of Anxiety Disorders 21(2):164175.
Keehn, Jack D. 1979. Origins of Madness: Psychopathology in Animal Life. New York: Pergamon Press.
Kirk, Robert G., and Ramsden, Edmund. 2018. “Working across Species Down on the Farm: Howard S. Liddell and the Development of Comparative Psychopathology, c. 1923–1962.” History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences 40(1):24.
Koch, Ulrich. 2014. Schockeffekte: Eine historische Epistemologie des Traumas. Berlin: Diaphanes.
Koch, Ulrich. 2019. “Preparing for the Unthinkable? The Prevention of Posttraumatic Stress Disorder and the Limits of Positive Psychology.” In Developments in Neuroethics and Bioethics, vol. 2, edited by Cratsley, Kelso and Radden, Jennifer, 211233. London: Academic Press.
Kolb, Lawrence C. June 3, 1977. Letter to Robert Spitzer (with typewritten response by R.S.). Box DSM-III, Archives of the American Psychiatric Association.
Lamb, Susan D. 2014. Pathologist of the Mind: Adolf Meyer and the Origins of American Psychiatry. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Leese, Peter. 2002. Shell Shock. Traumatic Neurosis and the British Soldiers of the First World War. Houndmills: Palgrave Macmillan.
Lederer, Susan E. 1992. “Political Animals. The Shaping of Biomedical Literature in Twentieth-Century America.” Isis 83(1):6179.
Lemov, Rebecca M. 2005. World as Laboratory: Experiments with Mice, Mazes, and Men. New York: Hill and Wang.
Lerner, Paul F. 2003. Hysterical Men: War, Psychiatry, and the Politics of Trauma in Germany, 1890-1930. New York: Cornell University Press.
Levens, Joshua P. 2005. “Sex, Neurosis and Animal Behavior: The Emergence of American Psychobiology and the Research of W. Horsley Gantt and Frank A. Beach.” Ph.D. diss. Johns Hopkins University.
Leys, Ruth. 2000. Trauma: A Genealogy. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Liddell, Howard S. 1944. “Conditioned Reflex Methodology and Experimental Neurosis.” In: Personality and the Behavior Disorders, edited by Hunt, Joseph McV., 389412, New York: Ronald Press.
Liddell, Howard S. 1957. Emotional Hazards in Animals and Man. Springfield: Charles C. Thomas.
Liddell, Howard S., and Bayne, Thomas Levingston. 1927. “The Development of ‘Experimental Neurasthenia’ in the Sheep during the Formation of Difficult Conditioned Reflexes.American Journal of. Physiology 81:494.
Liddell, Howard S., James, William Thomas, and Anderson, Oscar Daniel. 1934. The Comparative Physiology of the Conditioned Motor Reflex, Based on Experiments with the Pig, Dog, Sheep, Goat, and Rabbit. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Lockard, Robert B. 1971. “Reflections on the Fall of Comparative Psychology: Is there a Message for Us All?American Psychologist 26(2):168179.
Logan, Cheryl A. 2001. “[A] re Norway Rats… Things?”: Diversity Versus Generality in the Use of Albino Rats in Experiments on Development and Sexuality.” Journal of the History of Biology 34(2):287314.
Logan, Cheryl A. 2002. “Before There Were Standards: The Role of Test Animals in the Production of Empirical Generality in Physiology.” Journal of the History of Biology 35(2): 329363.
Logan, Cheryl A. 2005. “The Legacy of Adolf Meyer’s Comparative Approach: Worcester Rats and the Strange Birth of the Animal Model.” Integrative Physiological & Behavioral Science 40(4): 169181.
Logan, Cheryl A. 2017. “Psychoneurosis beyond Oedipus: Neurophysiology, Drive Conflict, and the Resolution of Emotional Trauma.Palgrave Communications (1)3. DOI: 10.1057/s41599-017-0025-0.
Maier, Norman R.F. 1939. Studies of Abnormal Behavior in the Rat: The Neurotic Pattern and an Analysis of the Situation which Produces it. New York: Harper.
Maier, Norman R.F., and Glaser, Nathan M.. 1938. “Experimentally Produced Neurotic Behavior in the Rat.” Film. National Library of Medicine (USA). Bethesda, MD.
Masserman, Jules H. 1943. Behavior and Neurosis. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Masserman, Jules H., and Pechtel, Curtis. 1953. “Neuroses in Monkeys: A Preliminary Report of Experimental Observations.” Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 56 (1): 253265.
Masserman, Jules H., and Pechtel, Curtis. 1956. “Normal and Neurotic Olfactory Behavior in Monkeys: A Motion Picture.” The Journal of nervous and mental disease 124 (5): 518519.
Micale, Mark S. 2008. Hysterical men. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Micale, Mark S., and Lerner, Paul. eds. 2001. Traumatic Pasts: History, Psychiatry, and Trauma in the Modern Age, 1870-1930. Cambridge University Press.
Midgley, Mary. 1973. “The Concept of Beastliness: Philosophy, Ethics and Animal Behaviour.Philosophy 48 (184): 111135.
Miller, Neal E. 1948. “Studies of Fear as an Acquirable Drive: I. Fear as Motivation and Fear-Reduction as Reinforcement in the Learning of new Responses.Journal of experimental psychology 38(1): 89101.
Miller, Neal E. 1951. “Learnable Drives and Rewards.” In Handbook of Experimental Psychology, edited by Stevens, S.S., 435472. Oxford: Wiley.
Miller, William R., Rosellini, Robert, and Seligman, Martin E.P.. 1977. “Learned Helplessness and Depression.” In Psychopathology: Experimental Models, edited by Masser, Jack D., Seligman, Martin E.P., 104130. San Francisco: W.H. Freeman.
Mineka, Susan and Kihlstrom, John F.. 1978. “Unpredictable and Uncontrollable Events: A new Perspective on Experimental Neurosis.” Journal of Abnormal Psychology 87(2):256271.
Morgan, Clifford, and Waldman, Hyman. 1941. “‘Conflict’ and Audiogenic Seizures.” Journal of Comparative Psychology 31(1):111.
Mowrer, Orval H. 1939. “A Stimulus-response Analysis of Anxiety and its Role as a Reinforcing Agent.” Psychological Review 46:553565.
Mowrer, Orvan H. 1940. “Anxiety-Reduction and Learning.” Journal of Experimental Psychology 27(5):497516.
National Research Council. 1937. Proceedings of the Conferences on Experimental Neuroses and Allied Problems under the Auspices of the Inter-divisional Committee on Borderland Problems of the Life Sciences. April 17 and 18. Washington DC.
National Research Council. 1938. Problems of Neurotic Behavior: The Experimental Production and Treatment of Behavior Derangement. Appraisal of Field and Statement of Research Proposals. Washington DC.
O’Donnell, John M. 1985. The Origins of Behaviorism: American Psychology, 1870-1920. New York: New York University Press.
Overmier, J. Bruce, and Seligman, Martin E. P.. 1967. “Effects of Inescapable Shock upon Subsequent Escape and Avoidance Responding.” Journal of comparative and physiological psychology 63(1): 2833.
Pauly, Philip J. 1987. Controlling Life: Jacques Loeb and the Engineering Ideal in Biology. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Pavlov, Ivan P. 1928. Conditioned Reflexes: An Investigation of the Physiological Activity of the Cerebral Cortex. Translated by Anrep, Gleb V.. London: Oxford University Press.
Pavlov, Ivan P. 1934. “An Attempt at a Physiological Interpretation of Obsessional Neurosis and Paranoia.” Journal of Mental Science 80 (329): 187197.
Peterson, Christopher, Maier, Steven F., and Seligman, Martin E.. 1993. Learned Helplessness: A Theory for the Age of Personal Control. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Peterman, Jack N. 1940. “Experimental Neurosis in the White Rat.” University of Massachusetts Amherst. Ph.D. diss.
Poppen, Roger. 2001. “Joseph Wolpe: Challenger and Champion for Behavior Therapy.” In A History of the Behavioral Therapies: Founders’ Personal Histories, edited by O’ Donahue, William et al., 3957. Oakland: New Harbinger.
Pressman, John D. 1998. Last Resort: Psychosurgery and the Limits of Medicine. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Ramsden, Edmund. 2011. “From Rodent Utopia to Urban Hell: Population, Pathology, and the Crowded Rats of NIMH.” Isis 102(4):659688.
Ramsden, Edmund. 2018. “A Neurotic Dog’s Life: Experimental Psychiatry and the Conditional Reflex Method in the Work of W. Horsley Gantt.” Isis 109(2): 276301.
Regan, Tom. 1983. “Animal Rights, Human Wrongs.” In Ethics and Animals. Contemporary Issues in Biomedicine, Ethics, and Society, edited by Miller, Harlan B. and Williams, William H., 1943. New York: Humana Press.
Rescorla, Robert A. 1995. “Richard L. Solomon (1918-1995).” Biographical Memoirs. Washington, D. C.: National Academies Press. Retrieved from https://www.nap.edu/read/5737/chapter/16 (last accessed October 22, 2019).
Rose, Nikolas and Abi-Rached, Joelle M.. 2013. Neuro: The New Brain Sciences and the Management of the Mind. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Rudacille, Deborah. 2000. The Scalpel and the Butterfly: The War between Animal Research and Animal Protection. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Ruiz, Gabriel and Sánchez, Natividad. 2012. “Of Animals and Men: Contrasting Approaches to the Study of Animal Behavior Disorders in America (1930-1950).” Revista de Historia de la Psicologia 33(2):722.
Ruiz, Gabriel and Sánchez, Natividad. 2016. “N. W. Horsley Gantt, Nick, and the Pavlovian Science at Phipps Clinic.The Spanish Journal of Psychology 19:117.
Ruiz, Gabriel, Sánchez, Natividad and De la Casa, Luis Gonzalo. 2003. “Pavlov in America: A Heterodox Approach to the Study of his Influence.The Spanish Journal of Psychology 6(2): 99111.
Schenger-Krestovnikova, N.R. 1921. “K voprosu differentsirovanii zritel’nykh razdrazhenii I o predelakh differentsirovanii v glaznom analizatore sobaki.” [On the differentiation of the visual stimuli and on the limits of differentiation in the visual analyzer of the dog]. Izvestiia Petrogradskogo Nauchnogo Instituta im P.F. Lesgafta 3:141.
Schoenfeld, William N. 1950. “An Experimental Approach to Anxiety, Escape and Avoidance Behavior.” In Anxiety, edited by Hoch, Paul Henry and Zubin, Joseph, 7099. New York: Grune & Stratton.
Sidman, Murray. 1960. “Normal Sources of Pathological Behavior.Science 132 (3419): 6168.
Seligman, Martin E.P. 1975. Helplessness: On Depression, Development, and Death. New York, NY: WH Freeman.
Seligman, Martin E.P. 2006. Learned Optimism: How to Change your Mind and your Life. New York: Vintage, 2006.
Seligman, Martin E.P. 2018. The Hope Circuit. A Psychologist’s Journey from Helplessness to Optimism. New York: Public Affairs.
Seligman, Martin E.P, and Maier, Steven F.. 1967. “Failure to Escape Traumatic Shock.” Journal of experimental psychology 74(1): 19.
Showalter, Elaine. 1985. Female Malady: Women, Madness and English Culture. London: Virago Press.
Simpson, Sutherland, 1924. “The Effect of Thyroidectomy on Growth in Sheep and Goat as Indicated by Body-Weight.” Experimental Physiology 14(2):161183.
Singer, Peter. 1975. Animal Liberation: A New Ethic for our Treatment of Animals. New York: Avon.
Smith, Roger. 1992. Inhibition: History and Meaning in the Sciences of Mind and Brain. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Solomon, Richard L., and Wynne, Lyman C.. 1954. “Traumatic Avoidance Learning: The Principles of Anxiety Conservation and Impartial Irreversibility.” Psychological Review 61(6): 353385.
Solomon, Richard L., and Turner, Lucille H.. 1962. “Discriminative Classical Conditioning in Dogs Paralyzed by Curare can later Control Discriminative Avoidance Responses in the Normal State.” Psychological Review 69(3): 202218.
Star, Susan Leigh. 2010. “This is Not a Boundary Object: Reflections on the Origins of a Concept.” Science, Technology & Human Values 35(5): 601617.
Todes, Daniel P. 2001. Pavlov’s Physiology Factory. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Todes, Daniel P. 2014. Ivan Pavlov: A Russian Life in Science. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Walker, Leonore E. 1979. The Battered Woman. New York: Harper & Row.
Watson, John B., and Rayner, Rosalie. 1924. “Conditioned Emotional Reactions.” Journal of Experimental Psychology 3:114.
Wayman, Stan. 1966. “Concentration Camps for Dogs.” Life 60(5):2229.
Wilson, David A.H. 2004. “The Public Relations of Experimental Animal Psychology in Britain in the 1970s.” Contemporary British History, 18(2): 2746.
Windholz, G. 1990. “Pavlov, Psychoanalysis, and Neuroses.” Pavlovian Journal of Biological Science 25: 4853.
Winter, A. 2016. “Cats on the Couch: The Experimental Production of Animal Neurosis.” Science in Context 29(1):77105.
Wolpe, Joseph. 1958. Psychotherapy by Reciprocal Inhibition. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
Wolpe, Joseph. 1952. “Experimental Neuroses as Learned Behavior.” British Journal of Psychology 43:243.
Yerkes, Robert M. 1913. “Comparative Psychology: A Question of Definitions.” The Journal of Philosophy, Psychology and Scientific Methods 10 (21): 580582.
Young, Allan. 1995. The Harmony of Illusions: Inventing Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

Keywords

The uses of trauma in experiment: Traumatic stress and the history of experimental neurosis, c. 1925–1975

  • Ulrich Koch (a1)

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed