Skip to main content

Evidence-based mental health policy: Acritical appraisal

  • Brian Cooper (a1)

Arguments for and against evidence-based psychiatry have mostly centred on its value for clinical practice and teaching. Now, however, use of the same paradigm in evaluating health care has generated new problems.


To outline the development of evidence-based health care; to summarise the main critiques of this approach; to review the evidence now beingemployed to evaluate mental health care; and to consider how the evidence base might be improved.


The following sources were monitored: pub ications on evidence-based psychiatry and health care since 1990; reports of randomised trials and meta-analytic reviews to the end of 2002; and official British publications on mental health policy.


Although evidence-based health care is now being promulgated as a rational basis for mental health planning in Britain, its contributions to service evaluation have been distinctly modest. Only 10% of clinical trials and meta-analyses have been focused on effectiveness of services, and many reviews proved inconclusive.


The current evidence-based approach is overly reliant on meta-analytic reviews, and is more applicable to specific treatments than to the care agencies that control theirdelivery. A much broader evidence base is called for, extending to studies in primary health care and the evaluation of preventive techniques.

  • View HTML
    • Send article to Kindle

      To send this article to your Kindle, first ensure is added to your Approved Personal Document E-mail List under your Personal Document Settings on the Manage Your Content and Devices page of your Amazon account. Then enter the ‘name’ part of your Kindle email address below. Find out more about sending to your Kindle. Find out more about sending to your Kindle.

      Note you can select to send to either the or variations. ‘’ emails are free but can only be sent to your device when it is connected to wi-fi. ‘’ emails can be delivered even when you are not connected to wi-fi, but note that service fees apply.

      Find out more about the Kindle Personal Document Service.

      Evidence-based mental health policy: Acritical appraisal
      Available formats
      Send article to Dropbox

      To send this article to your Dropbox account, please select one or more formats and confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your <service> account. Find out more about sending content to Dropbox.

      Evidence-based mental health policy: Acritical appraisal
      Available formats
      Send article to Google Drive

      To send this article to your Google Drive account, please select one or more formats and confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your <service> account. Find out more about sending content to Google Drive.

      Evidence-based mental health policy: Acritical appraisal
      Available formats
Hide All
Adams, C. & Gelder, M. (1994) The case for establishing a register of randomised controlled trials of mental health care. A widely accessible register will minimise bias for those reviewing care. British Journal of Psychiatry, 164, 433436.
American Psychiatric Association (1994) Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (4th edn) (DSM-IV). Washington, DC: APA.
Angell, M. (2000) Is academic medicine for sale? (editorial). New England Journal of Medicine, 34, 15161518.
Bartley, M. & Plewis, J. (2002) Accumulated labour market disadvantage and limiting long-term illness: data from the 1971–1991 Office for National Statistics' Longitudinal Study. International Journal of Epidemiology, 31, 336341.
Berk, M. & Janet, M. L. (1999) Evidence-based psychiatric practice: doctrine or trap? Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice, 5, 97101.
Bisson, J. I., Jenkins, P. L., Alexander, J., et al (1997) Randomised controlled trial of psychological debriefing for victims of acute burn trauma. British Journal of Psychiatry, 171, 7881.
Bodenheimer, T. (2000) Uneasy alliance: clinical investigators and the pharmaceutical industry. New England Journal of Medicine, 342, 15391544.
Brown, T. & Wilkinson, G. (eds) (2000) Clinical Reviews in Psychiatry (2nd edn). London: Gaskell.
Brugha, T. S., Wheatley, S., Taub, N. A., et al (2000) Pragmatic randomised trial of antenatal intervention to prevent post-natal depression by reducing psychosocial risk factors. Psychological Medicine, 30, 12731281.
Burns, T. (2000) Models of community treatments in schizophrenia: do they travel? Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, 407 (suppl. 102), 1114.
Burns, T. & Catty, J. (2002) Mental health policy and evidence. Potential and pitfalls. Psychiatric Bulletin, 26, 324327.
Campbell, S. M., Roland, M.O., Bentley, E., et al (1999) Research capacity in UK primary care. British Journal of General Practice, 49, 967970.
Chalmers, I. (1993) The Cochrane Collaboration: preparing, maintaining and disseminating systematic reviews of the effects of health care. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 703, 156163.
Cochrane, A. L. (1972) Effectiveness and Efficiency. Random Reflections on Health Services. London: Oxford University Press for the Nuffield Provincial Hospitals Trust.
Crudace, T., Evans, J., Harrison, G., et al (2003) Impact of the ICD-10 Primary Health Care (PHC) diagnostic and managementguidelines for mental disorders on detection and outcomein primary care Cluster randomised controlled trial British Journal of Psychiatry, 182, 2030.
Department of Health (1999) National Service Framework for Mental Health: Modern Standards and Service Models. London: Department of Health.
Department of Health (2000) Reforming the Mental Health Act (Cm 5016-1, 5016-II). London: Stationery Office.
Department of Health (2001) The National Institute for Mental Health in England: Role and Function. London: Department of Health.
Egger, M., Schneider, M. & Davey-Smith, G. (1998) Spurious precision? Meta-analysis of observational studies. BMJ, 316, 140144.
Elliott, S. A., Leverton, T.J., Sanjack, M., et al (2000) Promoting mental health after childbirth: acontrolled trial of primary prevention of postnatal depression. British Journal of Clinical Psychology, 39, 223241.
Feinstein, A. R. (1995) Meta-analysis: statistical alchemy for the 21st century. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, 48, 7179.
Geddes, J. R. & Harrison, P.J. (1997) Closing the gap between research and practice. British Journal of Psychiatry, 171, 220225.
Goldberg, D. & Huxley, P. (1992) Common Mental Disorders: A Biosocial Model. London: Routledge.
Grosse, S. D., Matte, T. D., Schwartz, J., et al (2002) Economic gains resulting from the reduction in children's exposure to lead in the United States. Environmental Health Perspectives, 110, 563569.
Higgit, A. & Fonagy, P. (2002) Reading about clinical effectiveness. British Journal of Psychiatry, 181, 170174.
Hotopf, M., Churchill, R. & Lewis, G. (1999) Pragmatic randomised controlled trials in psychiatry. British Journal of Psychiatry, 175, 217223.
Johansson, S. E. & Sundqvist, J. (1997) Unemployment as an important risk factor for suicide in contemporary Sweden: an 11-year follow up study of a cross-sectional sample of 37 789 people. Public Health, 111, 4145.
Kendell, R. E. (1999) Influencing the Department of Health. Psychiatric Bulletin, 23, 321323.
Kpsowa, A. J. (2001) Unemployment and suicide: a cohort study of social factors predicting suicide in the US National Longitudinal Mortality Study. Psychological Medicine, 3, 127138.
Lamphear, B. P., Dietrich, K., Aninger, P., et al (2000) Cognitive deficits associated with blood lead concentrations <10μg/dL in US children and adolescents. Public Health Reports, 115, 521529.
Lelliott, P. (2002) The National Institute for Mental Health in England. Psychiatric Bulletin, 26, 321324.
Lewis, G. & Sloggett, A. (1998) Suicide, deprivation and unemployment: record linkage study. BMJ, 317, 12831286.
Lewis, S., Tarrier, N., Haddock, G., et al (2002) Randomised controlled trial of cognitive-behavioural therapy in early schizophrenia: acute-phase outcomes. British Journal of Psychiatry, 181 (suppl. 43), s9Is97.
Macarthur, C., Winter, H. R., Bick, D. E., et al (2002) Effects of redesigned postnatal care on women's health 4 months after birth: a cluster randomised controlled trial. Lancet, 359, 378385.
Mayou, R. A., Ehlers, A. & Hobbs, M. (2000) Psychological debriefing for road traffic accident victims. Three year follow-up of a randomised controlled trial. British Journal of Psychiatry, 176, 589593.
McKee, M. & Clarke, A. (1995) Guidelines, enthusiasm, uncertainty, and the limits to purchasing. BMJ, 310, 101104.
Naylor, C. D. (1995) Grey zones of clinical practice: some limits to evidence-based medicine. Lancet, 345, 840842.
NHS Centre for Reviews and Dissemination (1997) Mental health promotion in highrisk groups. Effective Health Care Bulletin, 3, 111.
Preti, A. & Miotto, P. (1999) Suicide and unemployment in Italy, 1982–1994. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 53, 694701.
Pritchard, C. (1992) Is there a link between suicide in young men and unemployment? A comparison of the UKwith other European Community countries. British Journal of Psychiatry, 160, 750756.
Proudfoot, J., Guest, D., Carson, J., et al (1997) Effect of cognitive-behavioural training on job-finding among long-term unemployed people. Lancet, 350, 96100.
Rangachari, P. K. (1997) Evidence-based medicine: old French wine with a new Canadian label. Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine, 90, 280284.
Rawlins, M. (1999) In pursuit of quality: the National Institute for Clinical Excellence. Lancet, 353, 10791082.
Rose, G. (1985) Sick individuals and sick populations. International Journal of Epidemiology, 14, 3238.
Rose, S., Brewin, C. R., Andrews, B., et al (1999) A randomised controlled trial of individual psychological debriefing for victims of violent crime. Psychological Medicine, 29, 793799.
Rosenberg, W. & Donald, A. (1995) Evidence-based medicine: an approach to clinical problem-solving. BMJ, 310, 11221126.
Royal College of Psychiatrists (2002) Reform of the Mental Health Act 1983. Response to the Draft mental Health Bill ( London: RCP.
Royal Commission on Environmental Pollution (1983) Lead in the Environment: Ninth Report. London: HMSO.
Sackett, D. L. (1995) Applying overviews and meta-analyses at the bedside. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, 48, 6166.
Sackett, D. L., Haynes, R. B. & Tugwell, P. (1985) Clinical Epidemiology: A Basic Science for Clinical Medicine. Boston: Little, Brown.
Sackett, D. L., Rosenberg, W., Gray, J., et al (1996) Evidence-based medicine: what it is and what it isn't. BMJ, 312, 7172.
Slade, M., Beck, A., Bindman, J., et al (1999) Routine clinical outcome measures for patients with severe mental illness: CANSAS and HoNOS. British Journal of Psychiatry, 174, 432434.
Swales, J. (2000) The troublesome search for evidence: three cultures in need of integration. Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine, 93, 402407.
Tansella, M. (2002) The scientific evaluation of mental health treatments: an historical perspective. Evidence-based Mental Health, 5, 45.
Thornley, B. & Adams, C. (1999) Content and quality of 2000 controlled trials in schizophrenia over 50 years. BMJ, 317, 11811184.
Tudor Hart, J. (1997) What evidence dowe need for evidence-based medicine? Cochrane Lecture, 1997. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 51, 623629.
Wadsworth, M. E., Montgomery, S. M. & Bartley, M. J. (1999) The persisting effect of unemployment on health and social well-being in men earlyin workinglife. Social Science and Medicine, 48, 14911499.
Williams, D. D. R. & Garner, J. (2002) The case against the ‘evidence’: a different perspective on evidence-based medicine. British Journal of Psychiatry, 180, 812.
Wing, J.K. (1972) Principles of evaluation. In Evaluatinga Community Psychiatric Service (eds Wing, J. K. & Hailey, A.), pp. 1139. London: Oxford University Press for Nuffield Provincial Hospitals Trust.
Wing, J.K., Beevor, A.S., Curtis, R.H., et al (1998) Health of the Nation Outcome Scales (HoNOS): research and development. British Journal of Psychiatry, 172, 1118.
Wolff, N. (2001) Randomised trials of socially complex intervention: promise or peril? Journal of Health Services and Research Policy, 6, 123126.
Wykes, T., Leese, M., Taylor, R., et al (1998) Effects of community services on disability and symptoms. British Journal of Psychiatry, 173, 385390.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

The British Journal of Psychiatry
  • ISSN: 0007-1250
  • EISSN: 1472-1465
  • URL: /core/journals/the-british-journal-of-psychiatry
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 22 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 138 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between 2nd January 2018 - 26th May 2018. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Evidence-based mental health policy: Acritical appraisal

  • Brian Cooper (a1)
Submit a response


No eLetters have been published for this article.


Reply to: Submit a response

Your details

Conflicting interests

Do you have any conflicting interests? *