Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-wg55d Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-05-19T06:21:20.285Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Farewell to Tax Neutrality: The Implications for an Aging Population

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 January 2023

Susan St. John
Susan St. John*
Affiliation:
University of Auckland
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

In the light of the financial consequences of longevity, the potential for widening living standards as the population ages, and the perception of an increased burden by the working age population, recent policy changes in New Zealand appear far from ideal. For nearly twenty years, the retirement system has comprised just a universal state pension, called New Zealand Superannuation, and voluntary unsubsidised private saving. The decision in the late 1980s to promote tax neutrality for saving was critical to attaining a cost-effective, adequate, equitable and sustainable retirement income for all in an uncertain future. Nevertheless, a level playing field was only partially achieved and by the early 2000s, large imbalances in the economy were apparent. Strident calls to promote saving gradually undermined the accord around tax neutrality for retirement saving leading in 2007 to the re-introduction of tax incentives for certain types of saving, and other types of state intervention in private provision. This paper examines how the twenty year experiment with tax neutrality is coming to an end and the implications this has for the support of an aging population experiencing increased longevity.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Economic and Labour Relations Review , Volume 18 , Issue 1 , November 2007 , pp. 27 - 52
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s) 2007

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Bollard, A. (2004) ‘What’s happening in the property sector?’, Reserve Bank of New Zealand: Bulletin, 67(3), pp. 37–46.Google Scholar
Consultative Committee on Superannuation, Life Insurance and Related Areas. (1988) Tax treatment of superannuation, Office of the Consultative Committee on Superannuation, Life Insurance and Related Areas, New Zealand Government, Wellington.Google Scholar
Cullen, M. , Minister of Finance, Minister of Revenue (2001) Superannuation tax regime, Speech to Grey Power, 18th May. Office of the Minister of Finance, New Zealand Government, Wellington.Google Scholar
Cullen, M. (2003) NZ super fund close to point of no-return. Paper presented at the Savings Summit, Wellington.Google Scholar
Cullen, M. (2005) Taxation of investment income: The treatment of collective investment vehicles and offshore portfolio investments in shares. A Government Discussion Document, Policy Advice Division of the Inland Revenue Department, Wellington.Google Scholar
Dalsgaard, T. (2001) The tax system in New Zealand: An appraisal and options for change, OECD Economics Department, Working Papers, No. 281, OECD Publishing, doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1787/382808014300 .Google Scholar
Douglas, R. (1987) Changes to the personal tax scale. Minister of Finance: Press release, 17 December.Google Scholar
Douglas, R. (1988) Consultative document on superannuation and life insurance Volume 1, New Zealand Government, Wellington.Google Scholar
Easton, B. (1997a) The Commercialisation of New Zealand, Auckland University Press, Auckland.Google Scholar
Easton, B. (1997b) In Stormy Seas: The Post-War New Zealand Economy, University of Otago Press, Dunedin.Google Scholar
Hagemann, R., Jones, B., Montador, R. (1987) Tax reform in OECD countries: Economic rationale and consequences, OECD Economics Department, Working Papers, No. 40, OECD Publishing, Paris.Google Scholar
Hughes, G. (2005) ‘Pension tax reliefs and equity’, in Stewart, J. (ed), For Richer, for Poorer: An Investigation of the Irish Pension System, Betaprint Limited, Dublin.Google Scholar
Inland Revenue Department, New Zealand (2006) Tax policy report: Fiscal implications of the SSCWT exemption for KiwiSaver (pp. Released under the Official Information Act 17 July).Google Scholar
Johnson, P. (1999) Older Getting Wiser, Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales, London.Google Scholar
Judd, (1999) ‘Optimal taxation and spending in general competitive growth models’, Journal of Public Economics, 71, pp. 1–26.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Le, T., Scobie, G., Gibson, J. (2007) Are Kiwis saving enough for retirement? Preliminary evidence from SOFIE, Paper prepared for the 8th Annual Super Funds Summit, 15–16 March, New Zealand Treasury, Wellington.Google Scholar
McCaw, Committee (1982) Task Force on Tax Reform, New Zealand Government, Wellington.Google Scholar
McLeod, R. (2001a) The issues: Tax review 2001, New Zealand Government, Wellington.Google Scholar
McLeod, R. (2001b) Tax Review 2001. Final Report, New Zealand Government, Wellington.Google Scholar
Minister of Finance, New Zealand (2002) December economic and fiscal update, available http://www.treasury.govt.nz/ [accessed 16 November 2007].Google Scholar
Ministry of Social Development, New Zealand (2006) New Zealand living standards 2004, Ministry of Social Development, Wellington.Google Scholar
Mourougane, A. (2007) Toward a more efficient taxation system in New Zealand, OECD Economics Department, Working Papers, No. 557, OECD Publishing, doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1787/176055857625.Google Scholar
Munnell, A. (1992) ‘Current taxation of qualified pension plans: Has the time come?’, New England Economic Review, March/April, pp. 49–63.Google Scholar
OECD (Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development) (2007a) Economic Survey of New Zealand, Policy Brief, OECD, Paris.Google Scholar
OECD (2007b) OECD in Figures, OECD, Paris.Google Scholar
Periodic Report Group New Zealand (1997) 1997 retirement income report: A review of the current framework: Interim report. New Zealand Government Printer, Wellington.Google Scholar
Periodic Report Group New Zealand (2003) Retirement income report 2003, New Zealand Government Printer, Wellington.Google Scholar
Retirement Commission New Zealand (2007) NZ super, available: http://www.retirement.org.nz/nz_super.html [accessed 17 November 2007].Google Scholar
Retirement Policy and Research Centre (2007) The tax implications of pay, salary sacrifice, KiwiSaver and PIEs, Briefing Paper No. 06/07, Retirement Policy and Research Centre, The University of Auckland.Google Scholar
Savings Product Working Group, New Zealand (2004) A Future for Work-Based Savings in New Zealand. Final Report of the Savings Product Working Group, Wellington.Google Scholar
Scobie, G., Gibson, J., Le, T. (2004) Saving for retirement: new evidence for New Zealand, New Zealand Treasury Working Paper No. 04/12, The New Zealand Treasury, Wellington.Google Scholar
Sinfield, A. (2000) ‘Tax benefits in non-state pensions’, European Journal of Social Security, 2(2), pp. 137–167.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Skilling, D. (2005) Home is where the money is: the economic importance of savings, Discussion Paper No. 2005/1, New Zealand Institute.Google Scholar
St John, S. (2006a) ‘Child poverty: Lessons from New Zealand’, European Journal of Social Security, 8(3), pp. 299–316.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
St John, S. (2006b) The policy implications of decumulation in retirement in New Zealand. A background paper setting out the issues prepared for the Retirement Commission. Retirement Commission, Wellington.Google Scholar
St John, S. (2007) ‘New Zealand’s experiment in tax neutrality for retirement saving’, The Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance, 32(4), pp. 532–552.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
St John, S., Ashton, T. (1993) Private Pensions in New Zealand: Can They Avert the Crisis?, Institute of Policy Studies, Victoria University Press, Wellington.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
St John, S., Gran, B. (2001) ‘The world’s social laboratory: Women-friendly aspects of New Zealand pensions’, in Ginn, J., Street, D., Arber, S. (eds), Women, Work and Pensions, Open University Press, Buckingham, pp. 199–215.Google Scholar
St John, S., Littlewood, M. (2006) Does KiwiSaver improve the unique New Zealand mix of retirement policies? Paper presented at the 14th Australian Colloquium of Superannuation Researchers: Choice in Retirement Funding, 20–21 July, UNSW, Sydney.Google Scholar
Statistics New Zealand (2002) The net worth of New Zealanders. Data from the 2001 Household Savings Survey. Standard tables and technical notes, Household Economic Statistics Division, Statistics New Zealand, Wellington.Google Scholar
Statistics New Zealand (2007) Balance of payments and international investment position March 2007 Quarter, available: http://www.stats.govt.nz/store/2007/06/balance-payments-international-investment-position-mar07qtr-hotp.htm [accessed 18 November 2007].Google Scholar
Stobo, C. (2004) Towards Consensus on the Taxation of Investment Income. Report to the Minister of Finance and Revenue, available: http://www.beehive.govt.nz/Documents/Files/Stobo%20Report%20on%20Investment%20Income.pdf [accessed 17 November 2007].Google Scholar
Taskforce on Private Provision for Retirement, New Zealand (1992) Private Provision for Retirement: The Options. Report of the Taskforce on Private Provision for Retirement, Wellington.Google Scholar
The New Zealand Treasury (2001) Treasury Report: Saving Incentive Options — Consultation and Analysis, The New Zealand Treasury, Wellington.Google Scholar
The New Zealand Treasury / Minister of Finance (2007) Budget economic and fiscal update, available: http://www.treasury.govt.nz/budget/forecasts/befu2007/befu07.pdf [accessed 17 November 2007].Google Scholar
The New Zealand Treasury (2007) Kiwisaver Documents Budget 2007 Information Release, available: http://www.treasury.govt.nz/publications/informationreleases/budget/2007/kiwisaver/index.htm [accessed 17 November 2007].Google Scholar
TOLIS (Working Group on Taxation of Life Insurance and Superannuation Fund Savings) (1997) Report to Ministers from the Working Group on the Taxation of Life Insurance and Superannuation Fund Savings, Wellington.Google Scholar
Wynd, D. (2007) KiwiScammer: Helping (some) New Zealanders retire richer, Workers Charter (June), Child Poverty Action Group Resources, available http://www.cpag.org.nz/resources/articles/res1182164835.pdf [accessed 17 November 2007].Google Scholar
Yoo, K., de Serres, A. (2004) Tax treatment of private pension savings in OECD Countries and the net tax cost per unit of contribution to tax-favoured schemes, OECD Economics Department Working Papers, No. 406, OECD Publishing, Paris.Google Scholar