Skip to main content

Economic comparison of unenriched and alternative cage systems used in laying hen husbandry - recent experience under Turkish commercial conditions

  • Y. ARAL (a1), M.S. ARIKAN (a1), E.E. ONBASILAR (a2), N. UNAL (a2), A. GOKDAI (a1) and E. ERDEM (a3)...

This review provides a comparative analysis on the unenriched and alternative cage systems used in commercial egg production as required by the directive (99/74/EC) of the EU Council on animal welfare in terms of technical performance indicators, distribution of cost items, egg sales revenue, and profitability. Unenriched (conventional) cages are commonly used in Turkey. However these cages don't provide for the laying hens natural needs. The comparison was taken from data regarding Lohmann Brown Classic and Lohmann LSL Classic laying hybrids kept in two caging systems. The rearing period was composed of 399 days starting when 16-week-old commercial pullets were put into unenriched and alternative cage systems and ending at the end of their 73rd weeks of age when laying hens were removed from production. The average shares of the some important cost items in the total cost in the production period were calculated to be as follows for unenriched and alternative cage systems, respectively: pullet 22.17% and 21.17%; feed 61.31% and 58.29%; labour 2.67% and 2.55%; veterinary and health 0.74% and 0.98%; egg packaging 3.23% and 3.48%; maintenance and repair expenses 1.50% and 2.29%; and depreciation costs 5.48% and 8.35%. The average cost of producing one egg was found to be 0.094 US$ and 0.097 US$, respectively. It was determined that investment costs in alternative cage systems was 14.93% higher and the production cost per hen was 2.03% higher than that in unenriched cage systems. In Turkey, on January 1, 2023, all systems will be converted to alternative cages. Investment amounts and production costs for the alternative cage systems are very important in this transformation process. Therefore the present review is to examine the available information on the production data of laying hens reared in the unenriched and alternative cages and to make economic feasibility conclusions under Turkey conditions.

Corresponding author
Corresponding author:
Hide All
ABRAHAMSSON P. and TAUSON R. (1995a) Aviary systems and conventional cages for laying hens: Effects on production, egg quality, health and bird location in three hybrids. Acta Agriculturae Scandinavica A-Animal Sciences 45: 191-203.
ABRAHAMSSON P., TAUSON R. and APPLEBY M.C. (1995b) Performance of four hybrids of laying hens in modified and conventional cages. Acta Agriculturae Scandinavica A-Animal Sciences 45: 286-296.
ACIL F. (1980) Calculation of the agricultural product costs and development in agricultural product costs in Turkey. Ankara University Agricultural Faculty Publications No: 665.
AGRA and CEAS (2004) Study on the socio-economic implications of the various systems to keep laying hens. Final Report for the European Commission.
BELL D. (2006) A Review of Recent Publications On Animal Welfare Issues For Table Egg Laying Hens. University of California, Riverside, USA.
BLOKHUIS H.J., FIKS-VAN NIEKERK T., BESSEI W., ELSON A., GUÉMENÉ D., KJAER J.B. and VAN DE WEERD H.A. (2007) The LayWel project: welfare implications of changes in production systems for laying hens. World's Poultry Science Journal 63: 101-114.
DIRECTIVE EU (1999) Council Directive 99/74/EC of 19 July 1999 laying down minimum standards for the protection of laying hens. Official Journal of the European Communities, pp. 53-57.
GOCSIK E., LANSINK A.O., VOERMANS G. and SAATKAMP H.W. (2015) Economic feasibility of animal welfare improvements in Dutch intensive livestock production: A comparison between broiler, laying hen, and fattening pig sectors. Livestock Science 182: 38-53.
GUESDON V. and FAURE J.M. (2004) Laying performance and egg quality in hens kept in standard or furnished cages. Animal Research 53: 45-57.
LAY D.C., FULTON R.M., HESTER P.Y., KARCHER D.M., KJAER J.B., MENCH J.A., MULLEN B.A., NEWBERRY R.C., NICOL C.J., SULLIVAN N.P.O. and PORTER R.E. (2011) Hen welfare in different housing systems. Poultry Science 90: 278-294.
MATTHEWS W.A. and SUMNER D.A. (2015) Effects of housing system on the costs of commercial egg production. Poultry Science 94: 552-557.
MUFTUOGLU M.T. (1989) Business Economics (Book in Turkish). Turhan Kitabevi, 3. Baskı, Ankara.
ONBASILAR E.E., UNAL N., ERDEM E., KOCAKAYA A. and YARANOGLU B. (2015) Production performance, use of nest box, and external appearance of two strains of laying hens kept in conventional and enriched cages. Poultry Science 94: 559-564.
SARIOZKAN S. and SAKARYA E. (2006) The profitability and productivity analysis of layer hen enterprises in Afyon province, Turkey. Journal of Lalahan Livestock Research Institute 46: 29-44.
SINGH R., CHENG K.M. and SILVERSIDES F.G. (2009) Production performance and egg quality of four strains of laying hens kept in conventional cages and floor pens . Poultry Science 88: 256-264.
SUMNER D.A., ROSEN-MOLINA J.T., MATTHEWS W.A., MENCH J.A. and RICHTER K.R. (2008) Economic effects of proposed restrictions on egg-laying hen housing in California. University of California Agricultural Issues Center, USA.
TAUSON R. (2005) Management and housing systems for layers-effects on welfare and production. World's Poultry Science Journal 61: 477-490.
VAN HORNE P.L.M., TACKEN G., ELLEN H., FIKS-VAN NIEKERK T., IMMINK V. and BONDT N. (2007) Prohibition of enriched cages for laying hens in the Netherlands; an examination of the consequences. Agricultural Economics Research Institute (LEI). Report, 2 (10).
VAN HORNE P.L.M. and BONDT N. (2003) Impact of EU Council Directive 99/74/EC 'welfare of laying hens' on the competitiveness of the EU egg industry. Agricultural Economics Research Institute (LEI) Report, No. 2 (03.04).
VAN HORNE P.L.M. (2003) The impact of laying hen welfare on the competitiveness of the EU egg industry. World's Poultry Science Journal 19: 18-21.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

World's Poultry Science Journal
  • ISSN: 0043-9339
  • EISSN: 1743-4777
  • URL: /core/journals/world-s-poultry-science-journal
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *



Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 9
Total number of PDF views: 71 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 397 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between 12th January 2017 - 24th November 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.