Traditional accounts of Henrietta Maria's original French Catholic household have argued that domestic and religious tensions at the Caroline court were the principal factors behind Charles I's expulsion of the majority of his wife's officers in July 1626. In defending his actions to his brother-in-law, Louis XIII, Charles accused Henrietta Maria's French ecclesiastical household of working against his government by creating a Catholic faction in his kingdom. On a more personal level, the king resented the French household's introduction of what he perceived as intrusive Catholic devotional practices that restricted physical access to his wife. As Charles stated,

This official story was echoed more widely in Protestant contemporary discourse. According to John Pory, a London newswriter, Henrietta Maria's ecclesiastical officers ‘by way of confession’, would discover ‘how often in a night the king had kissed her’. Tensions at court were heightened further by the colourful depiction of the queen allegedly walking barefoot from St James's to the gallows at Tyburn's Triple Tree to honour Catholic martyrs. Although Protestants initially hoped that Henrietta Maria would convert to the Anglican faith, her overt Catholic devotions soon dampened these speculations.

At first glance, these displays of Counter-Reformation practices and Protestant responses to them indicate the struggle for confessional hegemony that existed within the Caroline court in 1625–26. Unease at the French household's pilgrimage to St James's, coupled with the disruption to Protestant services by the queen and her French officers at Titchfield in September 1625, resonates with Dagmar Freist's study of mixed marriages in eighteenth-century Germany.