Hostname: page-component-76fb5796d-2lccl Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-27T07:20:22.329Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Mastering the market: Japanese government targeting of the computer industry

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 May 2009

Marie Anchordoguy
Marie Anchordoguy
Affiliation:
Research Fellow at Harvard Business School in Boston.
Get access

Abstract

A key topic of inquiry in the ongoing debate over Japan's remarkable postwar growth is the role of the government. Some argue that the state has played a leading role in stimulating and guiding the development of specific industries; others argue that market factors, such as high rates of investment and savings and low labor costs, have been the key impetus. This article focuses on the link between the state and the market, in particular the impact of state policies on market competition. It is primarily concerned with how targeting policies can be structured in ways that spur industrial development; that is, how policies can help firms enter an industry and encourage them to invest heavily to make better products, without sapping their initiative and making them dependent on the government. A case study of Japan's national strategy to develop an economically viable computer industry provides an opportunity to explore the relationship among targeting policies, market competition, and industrial development.

Type
Articles
Information
International Organization , Volume 42 , Issue 3 , Summer 1988 , pp. 509 - 543
Copyright
Copyright © The IO Foundation 1988

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1. See Johnson, Chalmers, MITI and the Japanese Miracle (Stanford, Calif.: Stanford University Press, 1982)Google Scholar; Abegglen, James, “The Economic Growth of Japan,” Scientific American 222 (03 1970), pp. 31–37Google Scholar.

2. Patrick, Hugh and Rosovsky, Henry, eds., Asia's New Giant (Washington, D.C.: Brookings Institution, 1976)Google Scholar; Yutaka, Kosai, “‘Nihon Kabushiki Gaisha Ron’ no Tasogare” (“Dusk of the ‘Japan Inc. Theory’”), Tōyōkeizai (10 07 1981), pp. 56–63Google Scholar.

3. Patrick, and Rosovsky, , Asia's New Giant, p. 47Google Scholar.

4. Ibid., p. 15.

5. Ibid., pp. 44–45.

6. Shepherd, William, The Treatment of Market Power (New York: Columbia University Press, 1975), p. 291Google Scholar; Weidenbaum, Murray, Business, Government, and the Public (Englewood Hills, N.J.: Prentice-Hall, 1981)Google Scholar.

7. Johnson, , MITl and the Japanese Miracle, p. 19Google Scholar.

8. Scott, Bruce R. and Lodge, George C., eds., U.S. Competitiveness in the World Economy (Boston, Mass.: Harvard Business School Press, 1985)Google Scholar; Tyson, Laura and Zysman, John, eds., American Industry in International Competition (Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell University Press, 1983), pp. 23–32Google Scholar.

9. Schumpeter, Joseph, Capitalism, Socialism, and Democracy, 3d ed. (New York: Harper, 1950), p. 84Google Scholar.

10. Scherer, F. M., Industrial Market Structure and Economic Performance, 2d ed. (Chicago: Rand McNally College Publishing, 1980), p. 407Google Scholar; Shepherd, William, Market Power and Economic Welfare (New York: Random House, 1970), p. 17Google Scholar.

11. Vogel, Ezra, Comeback (New York: Simon & Schuster, 1985)Google Scholar; Ouchi, William, The M-Form Society (Reading, Mass.: Addison-Wesley, 1984)Google Scholar.

12. Denshi Kōgyō Nenkan (Electronics Industry Yearbook), (Tōkyō: Dempa Shimbunsha, 1962), p. 161Google Scholar. Rate was reduced to 15% for GATT members in 1964, when Japan changed its status in GATT and joined the OECD. Genkō Yunyū Seido Ichiran (A Summary of the Current Import System), (Tōkyōsa Kai, annual).

13. “JECC Monogatari” (The JECC Story), segment 19, in Kokusan Denshi Keisanki Nyūzu (Domestic Computers News), (Tōkyō: JECC), no. 135, 1 04 1981, p. 8Google Scholar.

14. Asahi Shimbun (Asahi News), 6 June 1961.

15. Yomiuri Shimbun (Yomiuri News), 14 September 1961.

16. Percent in monetary value. Kompyūtopia (Computopia), (Tōkyō: Kompyūtā Eiji Sha), 01 1983, pp. 92, 95Google Scholar.

17. Estimated using data on computers in use at government institutions. In the 1960s, about 25% of domestic computers were used in government offices, thus the assumption that the government bought or rented about 25% of Japanese computers annually. Kompyūtā Jitsudōkyō Chōsa (Survey of Computers Currently in Use), (Tōkyō: JECC, annual); Kompyūtopia, January issues.

18. Denshi Kōgyō Nenkan, 1976, p. 683. The Foreign Capital Law is sometimes translated as the Foreign Investment Law.

19. “JECC Monogatari,” segment 3, no. 119, 1 December 1979; Hiroshi, Matsuo, IBM Ōkoku o Obiyakasu Fujitsu (Fujitsu Threatening the IBM Monarchy), (Tōkyō: Asahi Sonorama, 1980), p. 152Google Scholar.

20. “JECC Monogatari,” segment 3, no. 119, 1 December 1979.

21. Ibid., segment 4, no. 120, 1 January 1980, p. 6.

22. Kompyūtopia, December 1973, p. 24.

23. “JECC Monogatari,” segment 5, 1 February 1980, p. 3.

24. Board, Ekonomisuto, ed., Sengo Sangyō Shi e no Slōgen (Interviews for a History of Postwar Industry), vol. 1 (Tōkyō: Mainichi Shimbunsha, 1977), pp. 142–43Google Scholar.

25. “JECC Monogatari,” segment 5, 1 February 1980, p. 3.

26. Ibid., segment 4, no. 120, 1 January 1980.

27. Denshi Kōgyō Nenkan, 1971–72, p. 172.

28. JECC Kompyūtā Nōto (JECC Computer Notes), (Tōkyō: JECC, 1979), p. 10Google ScholarPubMed.

29. JECC 10 Nenshi (Ten-Year History of JECC), (Tōkyō: JECC, 1973) pp. 50–51, 59Google Scholar; JECC Kompyūtā Nōto, annual.

30. Interview with Ishiguro Ryūji, Director of the JDB's Center for Research on Investment in Plant and Equipment, 12 November 1984.

31. “JECC Monogatari,” segment 9, 1 June 1980, p. 2.

32. Interview with Ishii Yoshiaki, general manager, JECC's Research Division, 19 July 1984; various discussions with Hirose Kōichi of JECC in 1984.

33. Denshi Kōgyō Nenkan, 1970–71, p. 180.

34. Interview with Hirose Kōichi of JECC.

35. JECC's monthly fee is l/44th the sales price; 44 months equals 3.7 years.

36. Marie Anchordoguy, “The Role of Public Corporations in Japan's Industrial Development: The Japan Electronic Computer Company,” Political Science Quarterly, forthcoming.

37. Ibid.

38. Anchordoguy, , “The State and the Market: Industrial Policy towards Japan's Computer Industry,” Ph.D. diss., pp. 382–83Google Scholar. Subsidy is the difference between the interest JECC paid on JDB loans and the estimate of what the firms would have had to pay if they had borrowed the money at the prime rate from private banks.

39. Anchordoguy, “The Role of Public Corporations.”

40. See Appendix 2.

41. Interview with Ishiguro Ryūji, 12 November 1984.

42. JECC 10 Nenshi, pp. 50–51, 59.

43. See Appendix 2.

44. Calculated using data from: JECC Kompyūtā Nōlo, 1979, pp. 10–11, 377; Denshi Kōgyō Nenkan, 1979, p. 447; Kenkyūkai, Dokusen Bunseki, ed., Nihon no Dokusen Kigyō (Japan's Monopolistic Enterprises), vol. 1 (Tōkyō: Shin Nihon Shuppankai, 1969), p. 292Google Scholar; Kompyūtā Warudo (Computer World), 31 May 1982, p. 21.

45. See Wheeler, Jimmy, Janow, Merit E., and Pepper, Thomas, Japanese Industrial Development Policies in the 1980s (New York: Hudson Institute, 1982)Google Scholar.

46. See Appendix 1.

47. They invested $708.8 million.

48. Interview with Maeda Norihiko, 28 February 1986.

49. Interview in Bungeishunjū, September 1982, p. 101.

50. Calculated using data from Appendix 1 and 2 and Fujitsu's 1975 financial statement. For details of calculations, see Anchordoguy, Marie, “The State and the Market: Industrial Policy towards Japan's Computer Industry,” paper presented at the Business History Seminar, Harvard Business School, 27 01 1987, p. 75Google Scholar.

51. Cited, in Kompyūtopia, 10 1973, p. 43Google Scholar.

52. See Anchordoguy, , “The State and the Market,” Ph.D. diss., p. 120–21Google Scholar.

53. Calculated at 360 yen to the dollar. Nihon Kaihatsu Ginkō Tōkei Yōran (JDB Summary of Statistics), (Tōkyō: JDB, annual); Hojokin Benran (Handbook of Subsidies), (Tōkyō: Nihon Densan Kikaku Kabushiki Gaisha, annual).

54. Kompyūtopia, April 1969, p. 30.

55. Nihon Denshin Denwa Kōsha 25 Nenshi Iinkai, ed., Nihon Denshin Denwa Kōsha 25 Nenshi (25-Year History of NTT), vol. 3 (Tōkyō: Denki Tsūshin Kyōkai, 1978), p. 249Google Scholar.

56. Kenkyūkai, Nihon Chōki Shinyō Ginkō Sangyō, Shin Jidai ni Chōsen suru Nihon no Sangyō (Japan's Industries: Challenging the New Era), (Tōkyō: Mainichi Shimbun Sha, 1968) pp. 230–33Google Scholar.

57. Ibid., p. 10.

58. Denshi Kōgyō 30 Nenshi (Thirty-year History of the Electronics Industry), (Tōkyō: Nihon Denshi Kikai Kōgyō Kai. 1979), pp. 82, 108Google Scholar.

59. Gijutsu, Kōgyō In, Ōgata Purojekuto ni yoru Chōkō Seiriō Denshi Keisanki (The Super High-Performance Computer Project of the Large-Scale Program), (Tōkyō: Nihon Sangyō Gijutsu Shinkō Kyōkai), 07 1972, pp. 9–10, 17Google Scholar; Kompyūtopia, June 1973, pp. 15–17; Electronics, 24 May 1971, pp. 42–49; Ibid., 24 April 1971, pp. 42–43; Denshi Kōgyō Nenkan, 1973, pp. 312–15.

60. Kompyūtopia, June 1973, p. 15.

61. Ōgata Purojekuto ni yoru…, p. 202.

62. Tōyō Keizai Shūkan (Oriental Economist Weekly), 24 January 1970, p. 42.

63. Letter from 1971 reprinted in Fujitsu Shashi, vol. 2 (A History of Fujitsu), (Tōkyō: Jyoban Shoin, 1977), pp. 134–36.

64. Interview with Kobayashi in Bungeishunjū, September 1982, p. 101.

65. Interview with Shimizu Sakae, 3 February 1986.

66. Denshi (Electronics), (Tōkyō: Nihon Denshi Kikai Kogyokai, 07 1976), pp. 9, 14.Google ScholarPubMed

67. Yasuo, Tarui, IC no Hanashi, Toranjisuta kara Chō LSI made (The Story of ICs, from Transistors to LSI), (Tōkyō: Nihon Hōsō Shuppan Kyōkai, 1984) pp. 147, 156Google Scholar.

68. Interview with Nishimura Taizo, general manager of Tōshiba's International Operations, Electronic Components Division, 3 February 1986.

69. Quotation from a participant in the VLSI project, cited in Tōru, Uozumi, Kompyūtā Sensō (The Computer War), (Tōkyō: Aoya Shoten, 1979), p. 156Google Scholar.

70. Tarui, , IC no Hanashi…, pp. 168–70Google Scholar; Japan Computer News, September 1977, p. 7; EDP in Japan (Tōkyō: JECC, 1977), pp. 53–54Google Scholar; JECC Kompyūtā Nōto, 1981, p. 183.

71. Interview with Shimizu, 3 February 1986.

72. Tarui, , IC no Hanashi…, p. 149Google Scholar.

73. Electronics, 25 November 1985, pp. 20–21.

74. Discussion with Todoriki Itaru, director general of MITI's Agency for Industrial Science and Technology, 23 January 1986.

75. Interview with Yamamoto Kinko, managing director of the Japan Information Processing Development Center, 28 February 1986.

76. Kompyūtopia, February 1973, pp. 27–30.

77. Noburō, Minamisawa, Nihon Kompyūtā Hatten Shi (The History of the Development of Japanese Computers), (Tōkyō: Nihon Keizai Shimbunsha, 1978), pp. 173–74Google Scholar .