Skip to main content Accesibility Help
×
×
Home
  • Print publication year: 2012
  • Online publication date: April 2013

3 - Limits of Presidential Power

Summary

William H. Herndon was Lincoln’s law partner (and posthumous biographer). During his single term as a Whig member of the US House of Representatives (1847–9) Lincoln opposed the Mexican-American War as unconstitutional. In a strongly worded speech he held President James K. Polk responsible for starting that war by abusing and overextending his presidential power as outlined in the Constitution. Herndon wrote to Lincoln to object to (as Herndon saw it) his undue restriction of presidential prerogative. Here is Lincoln’s reply.

Washington, February 15, 1848

Dear William:

Your letter of the 29th Jany. was received last night. Being exclusively a constitutional argument, I wish to submit some reflections upon it in the same spirit of kindness that I know actuates you. Let me first state what I understand to be your position. It is, that if it shall become necessary, to repel invasion, the President may, without violation of the Constitution, cross the line, and invade the territory of another country; and that whether such necessity exists in any given case, the President is to be the sole judge.

Before going further, consider well whether this is, or is not your position. If it is, it is a position that neither the President himself, nor any friend of his, so far as I know, has ever taken. Their only positions are first, that the soil was ours where hostilities commenced, and second, that whether it was rightfully ours or not, Congress had annexed it, and the President, for that reason was bound to defend it, both of which are as clearly proved to be false in fact, as you can prove that your house is not mine. That soil was not ours; and Congress did not annex or attempt to annex it. But to return to your position: Allow the President to invade a neighboring nation, whenever he shall deem it necessary to repel an invasion, and you allow him to do so, whenever he may choose to say he deems it necessary for such purpose – and you allow him to make war at pleasure. Study to see if you can fix any limit to his power in this respect, after you have given him so much as you propose. If, today, he should choose to say he thinks it necessary to invade Canada, to prevent the British from invading us, how could you stop him? You may say to him, “I see no probability of the British invading us,” but he will say to you “be silent; I see it, if you don’t.”

Recommend this book

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this book to your organisation's collection.

Lincoln
  • Online ISBN: 9781139034784
  • Book DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9781139034784
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to *
×