Skip to main content Accessibility help
  • Print publication year: 2012
  • Online publication date: July 2012

2 - Telling Stories of Love, Sex, and Race


In 1662, more than 300 years before Loving v. Virginia, the Virginia colonial legislature enacted the first statute penalizing sex across the color line. In the years that followed, legislators, legal thinkers, and racial ideologues throughout the South condemned the practice, promising banishment, fines, and imprisonment for those who refused to obey. Interracial sex, the guardians of the social order reasoned, blurred the carefully drawn distinctions between black and white, slave and free. Yet few doubted then and no one doubts now that interracial sex, if not a frequent part of Southern life, was not uncommon either. The sheer number of people with light-brown skin and soft, wavy hair – 500,000 in the 1860 census, a number most agree was a gross underestimate – provided glaring evidence of interracial contacts for even those who were not personally involved in the practice.

Yet, notwithstanding their regular occurrence, efforts to provide some content and character to these early relationships are fraught with difficulty. Sources are difficult to locate and sometimes even harder to interpret, leaving many simply to rely on stock characters and familiar storylines. Following the groundbreaking work of scholars like Deborah Gray White, most point out today how interracial sex in the years before Loving was used as a tool of oppression, reinforcing the bedrock principles of white supremacy and patriarchal privilege. Many white men of all social ranks regularly took advantage of black women, and white society in general was all too willing to greet accusations of black-on-white rape with violence and destruction.

White, Deborah Gray 1999
Davis, Angela Y. 1981
Bardaglio, Peter W.Rape and the Law in the Old South: “Calculated to Excite Indignation in Every Heart,” 60 J.S. Hist.749 1994
Getman, Karen A.Sexual Control in the Slaveholding South: The Implementation and Maintenance of a Racial Caste System 7 Harv. Women’s L.J.115 1984
Higginbotham, A. LeonRacial Purity and Interracial Sex in the Law of Colonial and Antebellum Virginia 77 Geo. L.J.1967 1989
Wriggins, JenniferRape, Racism, and the Law 6 Harv. Women’s L.J.103 1983
Bynum, Victoria E. 1992
Door, Lisa Lindquist 2004
Hodes, Martha 1997
Johnson, WalterThe Slave Trader, the White Slave, and the Politics of Racial Determination in the 1850s 87 J. Am. Hist.13 2000
McLaurin, Melton A. 1991
Rothman, Joshua D. 2003
Sommerville, Dianne Miller 2004
Olmsted, Fredrick Law 1861
Bugbee, Lester G.The Old Three Hundred: A List of Settlers in Austin’s First Colony I Tex. Hist. Assoc. Q.108 1898
Yoakum, I H. 1855
Wortham, I Louis J. 1924
Campbell, Randolph B. 1989
Jacobs, Harriet A. 1987
Hammond, James HenryLetter to an English AbolitionistThe Ideology of Slavery: Proslavery Thought in the Antebellum South1830 1981
Cobb, Thomas R. R. 1858
Harper, William 1981
Chesnut, Mary Boykin 1981
Genovese, Eugene D. 1972
Gillmer, Jason A.Base Wretches and Black Wenches: A Story of Sex and Race, Violence and Compassion, during Slavery Times 59 Ala. L. Rev1501 2008
Wells, Ida B. 1997
Haygood, Atticus G.The Black Shadow in the South 16 Forum167 1893
Door, Lisa Lindquist 2004
Hodes, Martha 1997
Sommerville, Dianne Miller 2004
Gillmer, Jason A.Poor Whites, Benevolent Masters, and the Ideologies of Slavery: The Local Trial of a Slave Accused of Rape 85 N.C. L. Rev.489 2007
Morgan, Edmund S. 1975