Skip to main content

No Strength in Numbers: The Failure of Big-City Bills in American State Legislatures, 1880–2000

  • GERALD GAMM (a1) and THAD KOUSSER (a2)

Do big cities exert more power than less populous ones in American state legislatures? In many political systems, greater representation leads to more policy gains, yet for most of the nation's history, urban advocates have argued that big cities face systematic discrimination in statehouses. Drawing on a new historical dataset spanning 120 years and 13 states, we find clear evidence that there is no strength in numbers for big-city delegations in state legislatures. District bills affecting large metropolises fail at much higher rates than bills affecting small cities, counties, and villages. Big cities lose so often because size leads to damaging divisions. We demonstrate that the cities with the largest delegations—which are more likely to be internally divided—are the most frustrated in the legislative process. Demographic differences also matter, with district bills for cities that have many foreign-born residents, compared with the state as a whole, failing at especially high rates.

Corresponding author
Gerald Gamm is Associate Professor of Political Science and History, University of Rochester (
Thad Kousser is Associate Professor of Political Science, University of California, San Diego (
Hide All
Allard Scott, Burns Nancy, and Gamm Gerald. 1998. “Representing Urban Interests: The Local Politics of State Legislatures.” Studies in American Political Development 12: 267302.
Ansolabehere Stephen, and Snyder James M. Jr. 2008. The End of Inequality: One Person, One Vote and the Transformation of American Politics. New York: Norton.
Axelrod Robert, and Hamilton William D.. 1981. “The Evolution of Cooperation.” Science 211: 1390–96.
Baker Benjamin. 1960. “Municipal Autonomy: Its Relationship to Metropolitan Government.” Western Political Quarterly 13: 8398.
Banfield Edward C., and Wilson James Q.. 1963. City Politics. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Beard Charles A. 1912. American City Government: A Survey of Newer Tendencies. New York: Century.
Bernhard Helen, Fischbacher Urs, and Fehr Ernst. 2006. “Parochial Altruism in Humans.” Nature 442: 912–15.
Bridges Amy. 1984. A City in the Republic: Antebellum New York and the Origins of Machine Politics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Bryce James. 1891. The American Commonwealth. 2d ed. rev.London: Macmillan.
Burns Nancy, Evans Laura, Gamm Gerald, and McConnaughy Corrine. 2008. “Pockets of Expertise: Institutional Capacity in Twentieth-Century State Legislatures.” Studies in American Political Development 22: 229–48.
Burns Nancy, Evans Laura, Gamm Gerald, and McConnaughy Corrine. 2009. “Urban Politics in the State Arena.” Studies in American Political Development 23: 122.
Canon David T. 1999. Race, Redistricting, and Representation: The Unintended Consequences of Black Majority Districts. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Carroll Royce, and Cox Gary W.. 2007. “The Logic of Gamson's Law: Pre-election Coalitions and Portfolio Allocations.” American Journal of Political Science 51: 300–13.
Childs Sarah, and Krook Mona Lena. 2008. “Critical Mass Theory and Women's Political Representation.” Political Studies 56: 725–36.
Choi Jung-Kyoo, and Bowles Samuel. 2007. “The Coevolution of Parochial Altruism and War.” Science 26: 636–40.
David Paul T., and Eisenberg Ralph. 1961. Devaluation of the Urban and Suburban Vote: A Statistical Investigation of Long-Term Trends in State Legislative Representation. Charlottesville: University of Virginia Press.
Derge David R. 1958. “Metropolitan and Outstate Alignments in Illinois and Missouri Legislative Delegations.” American Political Science Review 52: 1051–65.
Desmond T. C. 1955. “States Eclipse the Cities.” National Municipal Review 44: 296300.
Duggan Catherine S. M. 2006. “Money from Strangers: Group Boundaries and Indirect Regulation in Developing Financial Markets.” Unpublished paper.
Erie Steven. 1988. Rainbow's End: Irish-Americans and the Dilemmas of Urban Machine Politics, 1840–1985. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Fenno Richard F. 1966. The Power of the Purse: Appropriations Politics in Congress. Boston: Little, Brown.
Ferejohn John F. 1974. Pork Barrel Politics: Rivers and Harbors Legislation, 1947–1968. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
Frug Gerald E. 1999. City Making: Building Communities without Building Walls. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Gamm Gerald, and Kousser Thad. 2007. “Broad Bills or Particularistic Policy? Historical Patterns in American State Legislatures.” Presented at the annual meeting of the Midwest Political Science Association, Chicago.
Gamm Gerald, and Kousser Thad. 2008. “Birds of a Feather: Homogeneity and the Politics of Deference in State Legislatures.” Presented at the annual meeting of the Midwest Political Science Association, Chicago.
Gamm Gerald, and Kousser Thad. 2010. “Broad Bills or Particularistic Policy? Historical Patterns in American State Legislatures.” American Political Science Review 104: 151–70.
Gamson William A. 1961. “A Theory of Coalition Formation.” American Sociological Review 26: 373–82.
Gibson Campbell, and Jung Kay. 2005. Historical Census Statistics on Population Totals by Race, 1790 to 1990, and by Hispanic Origin, 1970 to 1990, for Large Cities and Other Urban Places in the United States. U.S. Census Bureau Working Paper No. 76. (Accessed June 2012).
Griffith Ernest S. 1974. A History of American City Government: The Conspicuous Failure, 1870–1900. New York: Praeger.
Grogan Colleen M. 1994. “Political-economic Factors Influencing State Medicaid Policy.” Political Research Quarterly 47: 589622.
Grose Christian R. 2011. Congress in Black and White: Race and Representation in Washington and at Home. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Habyarimana James, Humphreys Macartan, Posner Daniel N., and Weinstein Jeremy M.. 2007. “Why Does Ethnic Diversity Undermine Public Goods Provision?” Unpublished paper.
Haines Michael R. 2006. “State Populations.” In Historical Statistics of the United States, Earliest Times to the Present, Millennial Edition, vol. 1, eds. Carter Susan B., Gartner Scott Sigmund, Haines Michael R., Olmstead Alan L., Sutch Richard, and Wright Gavin. New York: Cambridge University Press, 180379.
Key V. O. 1956. American State Politics: An Introduction. New York: Alfred A. Knopf.
Kingdon John W. 1973. Congressmen's Voting Decisions. New York: Harper and Row.
Krane Dale, Rigos Platon N., and Hill Melvin B. Jr. 2001. Home Rule in America: A Fifty-State Handbook. Washington, DC: CQ Press.
Kristof Nicholas D. 2008. “Our Racist, Sexist Selves.” New York Times, April 6.
Kronebusch Karl. 1993. Medicaid Politics: Policymaking Contexts and the Politics of Group Differences in the American States. Ph.D. diss., Harvard University.
Lax Jeffrey R., and Phillips Justin H.. 2009. “How Should We Estimate Public Opinion in the States?American Journal of Political Science 53: 107–21.
McGoldrick Joseph D. 1933. Law and Practice of Municipal Home Rule, 1916–1930. New York: Columbia University Press.
“Mr. Gantt Says No.” 2008. Editorial. New York Times, July 24, p. A:24.
Plotnick Robert D., and Winters Richard F.. 1985. “A Politico-Economic Theory of Income Redistribution.” American Political Science Review 79: 458–73.
Putnam Robert D. 2007. “E Pluribus Unum: Diversity and Community in the Twenty-first Century.” Scandinavian Political Studies 30: 137–74.
Rabe–Hesketh Sophia, Skrondal Anders, and Pickles Andrew. 2004. GLAMM Manual. Paper 160, U.C. Berkeley Division of Biostatistics Working Paper Series.
Riordon William L. 1994. Plunkitt of Tammany Hall: A Series of Very Plain Talks on Very Practical Politics. Edited with an introduction by McDonald Terrence J.. Boston: Bedford Books.
Rodden Jonathan. 2012. “The Long Shadow of the Industrial Revolution.” Stanford University. Unpublished manuscript.
Schattschneider E. E. 1935. Politics, Pressures and the Tariff. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
Shefter Martin Allen. 1970. City Hall and State House: State Legislative Involvement in the Politics of New York City and Boston. Ph.D. diss., Harvard University.
Squire Peverill, and Moncrief Gary. 2010. State Legislatures Today: Politics under the Domes. Boston: Longman.
Stedman Murray S. Jr. 1957. “American Political Parties as a Conservative Force.” Western Political Quarterly 10: 392–97.
Steiner Gilbert Y., and Gove Samuel K.. 1960. Legislative Politics in Illinois. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.
Swain Carol M. 1995. Black Faces, Black Interests: The Representation of African Americans in Congress. Enlarged ed. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Swers Michele L. 2002. The Difference Women Make: The Policy Impact of Women in Congress. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Tate Katherine. 2003. Black Faces in the Mirror: African Americans and Their Representatives in the U.S. Congress. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Teaford Jon C. 1984. The Unheralded Triumph: City Government in America, 1870–1900. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Weir Margaret. 1996. “Central Cities’ Loss of Power in State Politics.” Cityscape: A Journal of Policy Development and Research 2: 2340.
Weir Margaret, Wolman Harold, and Swanstrom Todd. 2005. “The Calculus of Coalitions: Cities, Suburbs, and the Metropolitan Agenda.” Urban Affairs Review 40: 730–60.
Wells Roger Hewes. 1939. American Local Government. New York: McGraw-Hill.
Wiebe Robert H. 1967. The Search for Order, 1877–1920. New York: Hill and Wang.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

American Political Science Review
  • ISSN: 0003-0554
  • EISSN: 1537-5943
  • URL: /core/journals/american-political-science-review
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
Type Description Title
Supplementary Materials

Gamm and Kousser Supplementary Material
Appendix Figures and Tables

 PDF (76 KB)
76 KB


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 17
Total number of PDF views: 113 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 2766 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 23rd November 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.