Skip to main content
×
×
Home

Religious Social Identity, Religious Belief, and Anti-Immigration Sentiment

  • PAZIT BEN-NUN BLOOM (a1), GIZEM ARIKAN (a2) and MARIE COURTEMANCHE (a3)
Abstract

Somewhat paradoxically, numerous scholars in various disciplines have found that religion induces negative attitudes towards immigrants, while others find that it fuels feelings of compassion. We offer a framework that accounts for this discrepancy. Using two priming experiments conducted among American Catholics, Turkish Muslims, and Israeli Jews, we disentangle the role of religious social identity and religious belief, and differentiate among types of immigrants based on their ethnic and religious similarity to, or difference from, members of the host society. We find that religious social identity increases opposition to immigrants who are dissimilar to in-group members in religion or ethnicity, while religious belief engenders welcoming attitudes toward immigrants of the same religion and ethnicity, particularly among the less conservative devout. These results suggest that different elements of the religious experience exert distinct and even contrasting effects on immigration attitudes, manifested in both the citizenry's considerations of beliefs and identity and its sensitivity to cues regarding the religion of the target group.

Copyright
Corresponding author
Pazit Ben-Nun Bloom, Senior Lecturer, Department of Political Science, Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Jerusalem, Israel (pazit.bennun@mail.huji.ac.il).
Gizem Arikan, Associate Professor, Department of International Relations, Yasar University, Izmir, Turkey (gizem.arikan@yasar.edu.tr).
Marie Courtemanche, Assistant Professor, Department of Political Science, Thiel College, Greenville, PA, USA (mcourtemanche@thiel.edu).
References
Hide All
Abramson Harold J. 1980. “Assimilation and Pluralism.” In Harvard Encyclopedia of American Ethnic Groups, ed. Thernstrom Stephan. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 150–60.
Adorno Theodor W., Frenkel-Brunswik Else, Levinson Daniel J., and Sanford Nevitt R.. 1950. The Authoritarian Personality. New York: Harper and Row.
Ahmed Ali M., and Salas Osvaldo. 2008. “In the Back of Your Mind: Subliminal Influences of Religious Concepts on Prosocial Behavior.” University of Gothenburg Working Papers in Economics, No. 331.
Allport Gordon W. 1954. The Nature of Prejudice. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
Allport Gordon W. 1966. “The Religious Context of Prejudice.” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 5 (3): 447–57.
Appleby Scott R. 2000. The Ambivalence of the Sacred: Religion, Violence, and Reconciliation. New York: Rowman and Littlefield.
Beit-Hallahmi Benjamin, and Sobel Zvi. 1991. “Introduction.” In Tradition, Innovation, Conflict: Jewishness and Judaism in Contemporary Israel, eds. Sobel Zvi and Beit-Hallahmi Benjamin. New York: SUNY Press, 124.
Ben-Nun Bloom Pazit, and Arikan Gizem. 2013a. “Religion and Support for Democracy: A Cross-National Test of the Mediating Mechanisms.” British Journal of Political Science 43 (2): 375–97.
Ben-Nun Bloom Pazit, and Arikan Gizem. 2013b. “Priming Religious Belief and Religious Social Behavior Affects Support for Democracy.” International Journal of Public Opinion Research 25 (3): 368–82.
Ben-Nun Bloom Pazit, Arikan Gizem, and Lahav Gallya. 2015. “The Effect of Perceived Cultural and Material Threats on Ethnic Preferences in Immigration Attitudes.” Ethnic and Racial Studies. In press.
Ben-Nun Bloom Pazit, and Courtemanche Marie. 2015. “Religion, Morality, and Tolerance: The Role of Disgust.” In Religion and Political Tolerance in America: Advances in the State of the Art, ed. Djupe Paul. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
Boomgaarden Hajo G., and Freire André. 2009. “Religion and Euroscepticism: Direct, Indirect, or No Effects?West European Politics 32 (6): 1240–65.
Brader Ted, Valentino Nicholas A., and Suhay Elizabeth. 2008. “What Triggers Public Opposition to Immigration? Anxiety, Group Cues, and Immigration Threat.” American Journal of Political Science 52 (4): 959–78.
Brewer Marilynn B. 1999. “The Psychology of Prejudice: In-Group Love or Out-Group Hate?Journal of Social Issues 55 (3): 429–44.
Brown Rupert. 2000. “Social Identity Theory: Past Achievements, Current Problems, and Future Challenges.” European Journal of Social Psychology 30 (6): 745–78.
Caprara Gian Vittorio, Schwartz Shalom, Capanna Cristina, Vecchione Michele, Barbaranelli Claudio. 2006. “Personality and Politics: Values, Traits, and Political Choice.” Political Psychology 27 (1): 128.
Carkoglu Ali, and Kalaycioglu Ersin. 2009. The Rising Tide of Conservatism in Turkey. New York: Palgrave MacMillan.
Cassidy John. 2014. “Obama Goes Big on Immigration.” The New Yorker (November 21, 2014).
Chong Dennis, Citrin Jack, and Conley Patricia. 2001. “When Self-Interest Matters.” Political Psychology 22 (3): 541–70.
Citrin Jack, Reingold Beth, and Green Donald. 1990. “American Identity and the Politics of Ethnic Change.” The Journal of Politics 52 (4): 1124–54.
Citrin Jack, and Sides John. 2008. “Immigration and the Imagined Community in Europe and the United States.” Political Studies 56 (1): 3356.
Cornelius Wayne A., and Rosenblum Marc R.. 2005. “Immigration and Politics.” Annual Review of Political Science 8: 99119.
Crisp Richard J., Walsh Judi, and Hewstone Miles. 2006. “Crossed Categorization in Common In-group Contexts.” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 32 (9): 1204–18.
De Zavala Agnieszka G., Cislak Aleksandra, and Wesolowska Elzbieta. 2010. “Political Conservatism, Need for Cognitive Closure, and Intergroup Hostility.” Political Psychology 31 (4): 521–41.
Dekker Paul, and Halman Loek. 2003. The Values of Volunteering: Cross-Cultural Perspectives. New York: Kluwer Academic Plenum Publishers.
Djupe Paul A., and Calfano Brian R.. 2013a. “Religious Value Priming, Threat, and Political Tolerance.” Political Research Quarterly 66 (4): 768–80.
Djupe Paul A., and Calfano Brian R.. 2013b. God Talk: Experimenting with the Religious Causes of Public Opinion. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
Djupe Paul A. and Gilbert Christopher P.. 2006. “The Resourceful Believer: Generating Civic Skills in Church.” The Journal of Politics 68 (1): 116–27.
Dougherty Kevin D., and Huyser Kimberly R.. 2008. “Racially Diverse Congregations: Organizational Identity and the Accommodation of Differences.” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 47 (1): 2344.
Eisenberg-Berg Nancy, and Mussen Paul. 1980. “Personality Correlates of Socio- Political Liberalism and Conservatism in Adolescents.” Journal of Genetic Psychology 137: 165–77.
Fetzer Joel S. 2000. Public Attitudes toward Immigration in the United States, France, and Germany. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Fish Steven M. 2011. Are Muslims Distinctive? A Look at the Evidence. New York: Oxford University Press.
Foner Nancy, and Alba Richard. 2008. “Immigrant Religion in the U.S. and Western Europe: Bridge or Barrier to Inclusion?International Migration Review 42 (2): 360–92.
Fowler James W. 1981. Stages of Faith: The Psychology of Human Development and the Quest for Meaning. New York: Harper and Row.
Gibson James L. 2010. “The Political Consequences of Religiosity: Does Religion Always Cause Political Intolerance?” In Religion and Democracy in America: Danger or Opportunity?, eds. Wolfe Alan and Katznelson Ira. New York and Princeton: Russell Sage Foundation and Princeton University Press, 147–75.
Graham Jesse, Haidt Jonathan, and Nosek Brian A.. 2009. “Liberals and Conservatives Rely on Different Sets of Moral Foundations.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 96 (5): 1029–46.
Guth James L., Green John C., Kellstedt Lyman A., Smidt Corwin E.. 1995. “Faith and the Environment: Religious Beliefs and Attitudes on Environmental Policy.” American Journal of Political Science 39 (2): 364–82.
Hagendoorn Louk. 1993. “Ethnic Categorization and Out-group Exclusion: Cultural Values and Social Stereotypes in the Construction of Ethnic Hierarchies.” Ethnic and Racial Studies 16 (1): 2651.
Hagendoorn Louk, and Henke Roger. 1991. “The Effect of Multiple Category Membership on Intergroup Evaluations in a North Indian Context: Class, Caste, and Religion.” British Journal of Social Psychology 30 (3): 247–60.
Hoffman Lesa, and Rovine Michael J.. 2007. “Multilevel Models for the Experimental Psychologist: Foundations and Illustrative Examples.” Behavior Research Methods 39 (1): 101–17.
Hunsberger Bruce. 1995. “Religion and Prejudice: The Role of Religious Fundamentalism, Quest, and Right-Wing Authoritarianism.” Journal of Social Issues 51 (2): 113–29.
Huntington Samuel P. 2004. Who Are We? America's Great Debate. London: Simon and Schuster.
Jelen Ted G. 1992. “Political Christianity: A Contextual Analysis.” American Journal of Political Science 36 (3): 692714.
Johnson Megan, Rowatt Wade C., and Labouff Jordan. 2010. “Priming Christian Religious Concepts Increases Racial Prejudice.” Social Psychology and Personality Science 1 (2): 119–26.
Jost John T., Glaser Jack, Kruglanski Arie W., and Sulloway Frank J.. 2003. “Political Conservatism as Motivated Social Cognition.” Psychological Bulletin 129 (3): 339–75.
Kedem Peri. 1995. “Dimensions of Jewish Religiosity.” In Israeli Judaism, ed. Deshen Shlomo, Liebman Charles, and Shokeid Mishe. London, UK: Transaction Publishers, 3362.
Kinder Donald R., and Kam Cindy D.. 2009. Us against Them: Ethnocentric Foundations of American Opinion. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Kinder Donald R., and Sears David O.. 1981. “Prejudice and Politics: Symbolic Racism versus Racial Threats to the Good Life.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 40 (3): 414–31.
Kinnvall Catarina. 2004. “Globalization and Religious Nationalism: Self, Identity, and the Search for Ontological Security.” Political Psychology 25 (5): 741–67.
Kirisci Kemal. 2007. “Turkey: A Country of Transition from Emigration to Immigration.” Mediterranean Politics 12 (1): 91–7.
Knoll Benjamin R. 2009. “And Who Is My Neighbor? Religion and Immigration Policy Attitudes.” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 48 (2): 313–31.
Kotler-Berkowitz Laurence A. 2001. “Religion and Voting Behaviour in Great Britain: A Reassessment.” British Journal of Political Science 31 (3): 523–54.
Laurin Kristin, Shariff Azim F., Henrich Joseph, and Kay Aaron C.. 2012. “Outsourcing Punishment to God: Beliefs in Divine Control Reduce Earthly Punishment.” Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 279 (1741): 3272–81.
Layman Geoffrey. 2000. The Great Divide: Religious and Cultural Conflict in American Party Politics. New York: Columbia University Press.
Leege David C., and Kellstedt Lyman A.. 1993. “Religious Worldviews and Political Philosophies: Capturing Theory in the Grand Manner through Empirical Data.” In Rediscovering the Religious Factor in American Politics. eds. Leege David. C. and Kellstedt Lyman A.. New York: M. E. Sharpe, 216–31.
Lipka Michael, and Martínez Jessica. 2013. “Catholic Leaders Urge Immigration Reform.” Fact Tank: Pew Research Center. http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2013/09/06/demographics-play-role-in-catholic-leaders-push-for-immigration-bill/
Lubbers Marcel, Coenders Marcel, and Scheepers Peer. 2006. “Objections to Asylum Seeker Centres: Individual and Contextual Determinants of Resistance to Small and Large Centres in the Netherlands.” European Sociological Review 22 (3): 243–57.
Lugo Luis (ed.). 2008. US Religious Landscape Survey. Washington, DC: Pew Research Center.
Lustick Ian S. 1999. “Israel as a Non-Arab State: The Political Implications of Mass Immigration of Non-Jews.” Middle East Journal 53 (3): 417–33.
McDaniel Eric Leon, Nooruddin Irfan, and Shortle Allyson Faith. 2011. “Divine Boundaries: How Religion Shapes Citizens’ Attitudes toward Immigrants.” American Politics Research 39 (1): 205–33.
McFarland Sam G. 1981. “Effects of Question Order on Survey Responses.” Public Opinion Quarterly 45: 208–15.
Norenzayan Ara. 2014. Big Gods: How Religion Transformed Cooperation and Conflict. New Jersey: Princeton University Press.
O’Reilly Charles T., and O’Reilly Edward J.. 1954. “Religious Beliefs of Catholic College Students and Their Attitudes toward Minorities.” Abnormal Social Psychology 49 (3): 378–80.
Parker Ashley, and Shear Michael D.. 2013. “Catholic Push to Overhaul Immigration Goes to Pews.” New York Times (August 21, 2013).
Perdue Charles W., Dovidio John F., Gurtman Michael B., and Tyler Richard B.. 1990. “Us and Them: Social Categorization and the Process of Intergroup Bias.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 59 (3): 475–86.
Philpott Daniel. 2007. “Explaining the Political Ambivalence of Religion.” American Political Science Review 101 (3): 505–25.
Putnam Robert D., and Campbell David E.. 2012. American Grace: How Religion Divides and Unites Us. New York: Simon and Schuster.
Roccas Sonia, and Amit Adi. 2011. “Group Heterogeneity and Tolerance: The Moderating Role of Conservation Values.” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 47 (5): 898907.
Roccas Sonia, and Brewer Marilynn B.. 2002. “Social Identity Complexity.” Personality and Social Psychology Review 6 (2): 88106.
Saroglou Vassilis, Delpierre Vanessa, and Dernelle Rebecca. 2004. “Values and Religiosity: A Meta-Analysis of Studies using Schwartz's Model.” Personality and Individual Differences 37 (4): 721–34.
Scheepers Peer, Gijsbert Merove, and Hello Eveline. 2002. “Religiosity and Prejudice against Ethnic Movements in Europe: Cross-National Tests on a Controversial Relationship.” Review of Religious Research 43 (3): 242–65.
Schwartz Shalom, and Huismans Sipke. 1995. “Value Priorities and Religiosity in Four Western Religions.” Social Psychology Quarterly 58 (2): 88107.
Shariff Azim F., and Norenzayan Ara. 2011. “Mean Gods Make Good People.” International Journal for the Psychology of Religion 21 (2): 8596.
Singer Peter. 2011. The Expanding Circle: Ethics, Evolution, and Moral Progress. New Jersey: Princeton University Press.
Smidt Corwin E., Kellstedt Lyman A., and Guth James L.. 2009. “The Role of Religion in American Politics: Explanatory Theories and Associated Analytical and Measurement Issues.” In Oxford Handbook on Religion and American Politics, eds. Smidt Corwin, Kellstedt Lyman A., and Guth James L.. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 342.
Sniderman Paul M., Hagendoorn Louk, and Prior Markus. 2004. “Predispositional Factors and Situational Triggers: Exclusionary Reactions to Immigrant Minorities.” American Political Science Review 98 (1): 3550.
Snijders Tom, and Bosker Roel. 1999. Multilevel Analysis: An Introduction to Basic and Advanced Multilevel Modeling. London: Sage.
Srull Thomas, K., and Wyer Robert S.. 1979. “The Role of Category Accessibility in the Interpretation of Information about Persons: Some Determinants and Implications.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 37 (10): 1660–7.
Steensland Brian, Robinson Lynn D., and Wilcox W. Bradford. 2000. “The Measure of American Religion: Toward Improving the State of the Art.” Social Forces 79 (1): 291318.
Strabac Zan, and Listhaug Ola. 2008. “Anti-Muslim Prejudice in Europe: A Multilevel Analysis of Survey Data from 30 Countries.” Social Science Research 37 (1): 268–86.
Tajfel Henri. 1981. Human Groups and Social Categories: Studies in Social Psychology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Tajfel Henri, and Dawson John. 1965. Disappointed Guests. London: Oxford University Press.
Tolbert Caroline, and Hero Rodney. 1996. “Race/Ethnicity and Direct Democracy: An Analysis of Californian's Illegal Immigration Initiative.” The Journal of Politics 58 (3): 806–18.
Transue John E. 2007. “Identity Salience, Identity Acceptance, and Racial Policy Attitudes: American National Identity as a Uniting Force.” American Journal of Political Science 51 (1): 7891.
Triandis Harry C., and Triandis Leigh Minturn. 1960. “Race, Social Class, Religion, and Nationality as Determinants of Social Distance.” Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology 61 (1): 110–18.
Turner John C., and Reynolds Katherine J.. 2001. “The Social Identity Perspective in Intergroup Relations: Theories, Themes, and Controversies.” In Blackwell Handbook of Social Processes: Intergroup Processes, ed. Brown Rupert and Gaertner Sam. Malden, MA: Blackwell Publishing, 133–52.
Urban Lynn M., and Miller Norman. 1998. “A Meta-analysis of Crossed Categorization Effects.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 74: 894908.
Valentino Nicholas A., Brader Ted, and Jardina Ashley E.. 2013. “Immigration Opposition among U.S. Whites: General Ethnocentrism or Media Priming of Attitudes about Latinos?Political Behavior 34 (2): 149–66.
Wald Kenneth D., and Smidt Corwin E.. 1993. “Measurement Strategies in the Study of Religion and Politics.” In Rediscovering the Religious Factor in American Politics, eds. Leege David. C. and Kellstedt Lyman A.. New York: M.E. Sharpe, 2652.
Wald Kenneth D., and Wilcox Clyde. 2006. “Getting Religion: Has Political Science Rediscovered the Faith Factor?American Political Science Review 100 (4): 523–9.
Wald Kenneth D., Owen Dennis E., and Hill Samuel S.. 1988. “Churches as Political Communities.” American Political Science Review 82 (3): 531–48.
Wallace Dennis, and Green Samuel B.. 2002. “Analysis of Repeated Measures Designs with Linear Mixed Models.” In Modeling Intra-individual Variability with Repeated Measures Data: Methods and Applications, ed. Moskowitz D. S., and Hershberger Scott L.. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 103–34.
Wright Matthew, Citrin Jack, and Wand Jonathan. 2012. “Alternative Measures of American National Identity: Implications for the Civic-Ethnic Distinction.” Political Psychology 33 (4): 469–82.
Yilmaz Ihsan. 2005. “State, Law, Civil Society, and Islam in Contemporary Turkey.” The Muslim World 95 (3): 385411.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

American Political Science Review
  • ISSN: 0003-0554
  • EISSN: 1537-5943
  • URL: /core/journals/american-political-science-review
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×
Type Description Title
PDF
Supplementary materials

Ben-Nun Bloom supplementary materials
Appendix

 PDF (702 KB)
702 KB

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 70
Total number of PDF views: 649 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 1960 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 18th December 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.