Skip to main content
    • Aa
    • Aa

Unraveling the Central State, but How? Types of Multi-level Governance


The reallocation of authority upward, downward, and sideways from central states has drawn attention from a growing number of scholars in political science. Yet beyond agreement that governance has become (and should be) multi-level, there is no consensus about how it should be organized. This article draws on several literatures to distinguish two types of multi-level governance. One type conceives of dispersion of authority to general-purpose, nonintersecting, and durable jurisdictions. A second type of governance conceives of task-specific, intersecting, and flexible jurisdictions. We conclude by specifying the virtues of each type of governance.For comments and advice we are grateful to Christopher Ansell, Ian Bache, Richard Balme, Arthur Benz, Tanja Börzel, Renaud Dehousse, Burkard Eberlein, Peter Hall, Edgar Grande, Richard Haesly, Bob Jessop, Beate Kohler-Koch, David Lake, Patrick Le Galés, Christiane Lemke, David Lowery, Michael McGinnis, Andrew Moravcsik, Elinor Ostrom, Franz U. Pappi, Thomas Risse, James Rosenau, Alberta Sbragia, Philippe Schmitter, Ulf Sverdrup, Christian Tusschoff, Bernhard Wessels, the political science discussion group at the University of North Carolina, and the editor and three anonymous reviewers of APSR. We received institutional support from the Center for European Studies at the University of North Carolina, the Alexander von Humboldt Foundation, and the Wissenschaftszentrum für Sozialforschung in Berlin. Earlier versions were presented at the European Union Studies Association meeting, the ECPR pan-European Conference in Bordeaux, and Hannover Universität, Harvard University, Humboldt Universität, Indiana University at Bloomington, Mannheim Universität, Sheffield University, Sciences Po (Paris), Technische Universität München, and the Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam. The authors' names appear in alphabetical order.

Linked references
Hide All

This list contains references from the content that can be linked to their source. For a full set of references and notes please see the PDF or HTML where available.

AlesinaAlbertoSpolaoreEnrico1997On the Number and Size of NationsQuarterly Journal of Economics1121027-56

BenzArthur2000Two Types of Multi-Level Governance: Intergovernmental Relations in German and European Union Regional PolicyRegional and Federal Studies102144

BlatterJoachim K.2001Debordering the World of States: Towards a Multi-Level System in Europe and a Multi-Polity System in North America? Insights from Border RegionsEuropean Journal of International Relations7175209

BuchananJames1965An Economic Theory of ClubsEconomica32114

CaporasoJames A.2000Changes in the Westphalian Order: Territory, Public Authority, and SovereigntyInternational Studies Review2128

CasellaAlessandraFreyBruno1992Federalism and Clubs. Towards An Economic Theory of Overlapping Political JurisdictionsEuropean Economic Review36639-46

DowdingKeithJohnPeterStephenBiggs1994Tiebout: A Survey of the Empirical LiteratureUrban Studies31767-97

GarmanChristopherHaggardStephanWillisEliza2001Fiscal Decentralization: A Political Theory with Latin American CasesWorld Politics53205-36

GrayVirginia1973Innovation in the States: A diffusion StudyAmerican Political Science Review671174-85

HoogheLiesbetMarksGaryWilsonCarole2002Does Left/Right Structure Party Positions on European Integration?Comparative Political Studies35965-89

InmanRobert P.RubinfeldDaniel1992Fiscal Federalism in Europe: Lessons from the United States ExperienceEuropean Economic Review36654-60

KeohaneRobert O.1982The Demand for International RegimesInternational Organization36325-55

KrasnerStephen D.1999Sovereignty: Organized HypocrisyPrinceton, NJPrinceton University Press

LoweryDavid2000A Transactions Costs Model of Metropolitan Governance: Allocation versus Redistribution in Urban AmericaJournal of Public Administration Research and Theory104978

LoweryDavidLyonsW. E.RuthHoogland DeHoogTeskePaulSchneiderMarkMintromMichaelBestSamuel1995The Empirical Evidence for Citizen Information and a Local Market for Public GoodsAmerican Political Science Review89705-9

LyonsWilliam E.LoweryDavid1989Governmental Fragmentation vs. Consolidation: Five Public Choice Myths about Creating Informed, Involved, and Happy CitizensPublic Administration Review49533-43

MajoneGiandomenico1998Europe's ‘Democratic Deficit’: The Question of StandardsEuropean Law Journal4528

MarksGaryHoogheLiesbet2000Optimality and Authority: A Critique of Neo-Classical TheoryJournal of Common Market Studies38795816

McGuireMartin1974Group Segregation and Optimal JurisdictionsJournal of Political Economy82112-32

NicolaidisKalypso2001Conclusion: The Federal Vision Beyond the StateThe Federal Vision: Legitimacy and Levels of Governance in the United States and the European UnionKalypsoNicolaidisRobertHowseOxfordOxford University Press442-70

NortonAlan1991Western European Local Government in Comparative PerspectiveLocal Government in Europe: Trends and DevelopmentsRichardBatleyGerryStokerLondonMacmillan2140

OatesWallace E.1999An Essay on Fiscal FederalismJournal of Economic Literature371120-49

OatesWallace E.SchwabRobert M.1988Economic Competition among Jurisdictions: Efficiency Enhancing or Distortion InducingJournal of Public Economics35333-54

O'BrienRobertet-al2000Contesting Global Governance: Multilateral Economic Institutions and Global Social MovementsCambridgeCambridge University Press

OstromElinor1990Governing the Commons: The Evolution of Institutions for Collective ActionCambridgeCambridge University Press

OstromVincentTieboutCharlesWarrenRobert1961The Organization of Government in Metropolitan Areas: A Theoretical InquiryAmerican Political Science Review55831-42

PappiFranz U.HenningChristian H. C. A.1999The Organization of Influence on the EC's Common Agricultural Policy: A Network ApproachEuropean Journal of Political Research36257-81

PerkmannMarkus1999Building Governance Institutions across European BordersRegional Studies33657-67

PetersB. GuyPierreJon2000Developments in Intergovernmental Relations: Towards Multi-Level GovernancePolicy and Politics29131-35

PetersonJohn2001The Choice for European Union Theorists: Establishing a Common Framework for AnalysisEuropean Journal of Political Research39289318

RoddenJonathan2002The Dilemma of Fiscal Federalism: Grants and Fiscal Performance Around the WorldAmerican Journal of Political Science46670-87

RonitKarstenSchneiderVolker1999Global Governance through Private OrganizationsGovernance12243-66

RosenauJames N.1997Along the Domestic Foreign Frontier. Exploring Governance in a Turbulent WorldCambridgeCambridge University Press

ScharpfFritz W.1988The Joint Decision Trap: Lessons from German Federalism and European IntegrationPublic Administration66239-78

ShanksCherylJacobsonHarold K.KaplanJeffrey H.1996Inertia and Change in IGOs, 1981–1992International Organization50593627

TieboutCharles1956A Pure Theory of Local ExpendituresJournal of Political Economy64416-24

TreismanDaniel1999Political Decentralization and Economic Reform: A Game-Theoretic AnalysisAmerican Journal of Political Science43488517

TullockGordon1969Federalism: Problems of ScalePublic Choice61929

WeyandSabine1999Inter-Regional Associations and the European Integration ProcessRegional and Federal Studies6166-82

Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

American Political Science Review
  • ISSN: 0003-0554
  • EISSN: 1537-5943
  • URL: /core/journals/american-political-science-review
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 47
Total number of PDF views: 917 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 1701 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 20th July 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.