Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home

Meta-analysis of the effect of immunocastration on production performance, reproductive organs and boar taint compounds in pigs

  • N. Batorek (a1), M. Čandek-Potokar (a1) (a2), M. Bonneau (a3) (a4) and J. Van Milgen (a3) (a4)

Abstract

Meta-analytical approach was used to quantitatively synthesize the effect of immunocastration on growth, carcass, meat quality, reproductive organs and boar taint compounds. Altogether, 41 papers were collected for effect size (θ) calculation and the comparisons were made with entire males (EM) and surgical castrates (SC). The data for reproductive organs and growth performance are numerous enough to draw firm conclusions. In contrast, data for carcass and meat quality are more limited. Results of meta-analysis show efficient immunocastration with the magnitude of the response being by far the largest for reproductive organs (θ = −2.8 to −5.0) and boar taint substances (θ = −2.8 and −0.8 for androstenone and skatole, respectively). However, compared with SC, the immunocastrates exhibit larger bulbourethral glands (θ = 1.3) and slightly higher concentrations of androstenone and skatole (θ = 0.1 and θ = 0.2, respectively). The impact of immunocastration is also remarkable on performance, where the main advantage of the immunocastrates is their boar-like performance until revaccination. In the period following the second vaccination, they eat much more than EM (θ = 2.1), resulting in large effect size for growth rate compared with both EM and SC (θ = 1.1 and θ = 1.4, respectively). Considering the whole fattening period, their feed conversion ratio is higher compared with EM (θ = 0.6) and much lower than that of SC (θ = −1.3), although exhibiting moderately faster growth compared with both (θ = 0.6 and θ = 0.2, respectively). With regard to carcass quality, the immunocastrates take intermediate position between EM and SC. Besides, our analysis suggests no difference in meat quality with SC and some meat quality advantages of immunocastrates over EM because of higher intramuscular fat content (θ = 0.4) and lower shear force (θ = −0.6).

Copyright

Corresponding author

References

Hide All
Andrews, S, Lohner, E, Schrade, H, Horst, I 2009. The effect of vaccinating male pigs with Improvac on growth performance and carcase quality. 55th International Congress of Meat Science and Technology, Copenhagen, Denmark, August 16–21, PE1.03.
Awoniyi, CA, Chandrashekar, V, Arthur, RD, Schanbacher, BD, Amador, AG, Falvo, RE 1988. Pituitary and Leydig cell function in boars actively immunized against gonadotropin-releasing hormone. Journals of Reproduction & Fertility 84, 295302.
Babol, J, Squires, J 1995. Quality of meat from entire male pigs. Food Research International 28, 201212.
Bauer, A, Lacorn, M, Danowski, K, Claus, R 2008. Effects of immunization against GnRH on gonadotropins, the GH-IGF-1-axis and metabolic parameters in barrows. Animal 2, 12151222.
Bonneau, M 2010. Accessory sex glands as a tool to measure the efficacy of immunocastration in male pigs. Animal 4, 930932.
Bonneau, M, Meusy-Dessolle, N, Léglise, PC, Claus, R 1982. Relationships between fat and plasma androstenone and plasma testosterone in fatty and lean young boars following castration. Acta Endocrinologica (Copenhagen) 101, 129133.
Bonneau, M, Dufour, R, Chouvet, C, Roulet, C, Meadus, W, Squires, EJ 1994. The effects of immunization against luteinizing hormone-releasing hormone on performance, sexual development, and levels of boar taint-related compounds in intact male pigs. Journal of Animal Science 72, 1420.
Borenstein, M, Hedges, L, Rothstein, H 2007. Meta-analysis. Fixed effects vs. random effects. www.Meta-Analysis.com © Borenstein, Hedges, Rothstein, 162 pp.
Brunius, C, Zamaratskaia, G, Andersson, K, Chen, G, Norrby, M, Madej, A, Lundström, K 2011. Early immunocastration of male pigs with Improvac® – effect on boar taint,hormones and reproductive organs. Vaccine 29, 95149520.
Caraty, A, Bonneau, M 1986. Immunisation active du porc mâle contre la gonadolibérine: effets sur la secrétion d'hormones gonadotropes et sur la teneur en 5a-androst-16-ène-3-one du tissu adipeux. Comptes Rendus des Séances de l'Académie des Sciences de Paris, Série D 303, 673676.
Claus, R 1976. Messung des Ebergeruchstoffes im Fett von Schweinen mittels eines Radioimmunotest. 2. Mitteilung: Zeitlicher Verlauf des Ebergeruchdepotabbaues nach der Kastration. Zeitschrift für Tierzucht und Züchtungsbiologie 93, 3847.
Claus, R, Weiler, U 1987. Umwelteinflüsse auf das geschlechtsspezifische Wachstumsvermögen. Übersicht zur Tierernahrung 15, 301316.
Claus, R, Lacorn, M, Danowski, K, Pearce, MC, Bauer, A 2007. Short-term endocrine and metabolic reactions before and after second immunization against GnRH in boars. Vaccine 25, 46894696.
Cronin, GM, Dunshea, FR, Butler, KL, McCauley, I, Barnett, JL, Hemsworth, P 2003. The effects of immuno- and surgical-castration on the behaviour and consequently growth of group-housed, male finisher pigs. Applied Animal Behaviour Science 81, 111126.
D'Souza, DN, Mullan, BP 2003. The effect of genotype and castration method on the eating quality characteristics of pork from male pigs. Animal Science 77, 6772.
Dunshea, FR, Colantoni, C, Howard, K, McCauley, I, Jackson, P, Long, KA, Lopaticki, S, Nugent, EA, Simons, JA, Walker, J, Hennessy, DP 2001. Vaccination of boars with a GnRH vaccine (Improvac) eliminates boar taint and increases growth performance. Journal of Animal Science 79, 25242535.
Einarsson, S, Andersson, K, Wallgren, M, Lundström, K, Rodriguez-Martinez, H 2009. Short- and long-term effects of immunization against gonadotropin-releasing hormone, using Improvac™, on sexual maturity, reproductive organs and sperm morphology in male pigs. Theriogenology 71, 302310.
Einarsson, S, Brunius, C, Wallgren, M, Lundström, K, Andersson, K, Zamaratskaia, G, Rodriguez-Martinez, H 2011. Effects of early vaccination with Improvac® on the development and function of reproductive organs of male pigs. Animal Reproduction Science 127, 5053.
Fàbrega, E, Velarde, A, Cros, J, Gispert, M, Suárez, P, Tibau, J, Soler, J 2010. Effect of vaccination against gonadotrophin-releasing hormone, using Improvac®, on growth performance, body composition, behavior and acute phase proteins. Livestock Science 132, 5359.
Falvo, RE, Chandrashekar, V, Arthur, RD, Kuenstler, AR, Hasson, T, Awoniyi, C, Schanbacher, BD 1986. Effect of active immunization against LHRH or LH in boars – reproductive consequences and performance traits. Journal of Animal Science 63, 986994.
Fang, F, Li, H, Liu, Y, Zhang, Y, Tao, Y, Li, Y, Cao, H, Wang, L, Zhang, X 2010. Active immunization with recombinant GnRH fusion protein in boars reduces both testicular development and mRNA expression levels of GnRH receptor in pituitary. Animal Reproduction Science 119, 275281.
Font i Furnols, M, Gispert, M, Soler, J, Diaz, M, Garcia-Regueiro, JA, Diaz, I, Pearce, MC 2012. Effect of vaccination against gonadotrophin-releasing factor on growth performance, carcass, meat and fat quality of male Duroc pigs for dry cured ham production. Meat Science, doi: 10.1016/j.meatsci.2012.01.008, Published online by Elsevier 21 January 2012.
Friis, C 1993. Distribution, metabolic fate and elimination of skatole in the pig. In Measurement and prevention of boar taint in entire male pigs (ed. M Bonneau) INRA Edition, Paris 113115.
Fuchs, T, Nathues, H, Koehrmann, A, Andrews, S, Brock, F, Sudhaus, N, Klein, G, Beilage, EG 2009. A comparison of the carcase characteristics of pigs immunized with a ‘gonadotropin-releasing factor (GnRF)’ vaccine against boar taint with physically castrated pigs. Meat Science 83, 702705.
Fuchs, T, Nathues, H, Koehrmann, A, Andrews, S, Brock, F, Klein, G, Beilage, E 2011. Comparative growth performance of pigs immunised with gonadotropin factor vaccine with surgically castrated pigs and entire boars raised under conventional managed conditions. Berliner und Münchener tierärztliche Wochenschrift 124, 2227.
Gispert, M, Àngels Oliver, M, Velarde, A, Suarez, P, Pérez, J, Font i Furnols, M 2010. Carcass and meat quality characteristics of immunocastrated male, surgically castrated male, entire male and female pigs. Meat Science 85, 664670.
Grizzle, TB, Esbenshade, KL, Johnson, BH 1987. Active immunization of boars against gonadotropin releasing hormone. I. Effects on reproductive parameters. Theriogenology 27, 571580.
Houseknecht, KL, Baile, CA, Matteri, RL, Spurlock, ME 1998. The biology of leptin: a review. Journal of Animal Science 76, 14051420.
Hemonic, A, Courboulay, V, Kuhn, G, McLaughlin, CL, Martin, VA, Brock, FC, Pearce, MC 2009. Evaluation of safety, efficiency and production benefits of vaccination against boar taint in male pigs raised under commercial field conditions in France. Revue de médecine vétérinaire 160, 383393.
Higgins, JPT, Thompson, SG 2002. Quantifying heterogeneity in meta-analysis. Statistics in Medicine 21, 15391558.
Hilbe, M, Jaros, P, Ehrensperger, F, Zlinszky, K, Janett, F, Hässing, M, Thun, R 2006. Histomorphological and immunohistochemical findings in testes, bulbourethral glands and brain of immunologically castrated piglets. Schweizer Archiv für Tierheilkunde 148, 599608.
Januskauskas, A, Zilinskas, H, Sutkeviciene, N, Bilskis, R, Szabo, I, Garlaite, K 2009. Impact of raising Improvac®-vaccinated boars on growth, carcass quality and meat quality compared to physical castrates under field conditions. Proceedings of the 21st IPVS Congress, Vancouver, Canada, p. 825.
Jaros, P, Bürgi, E, Stärk, KDC, Claus, R, Hennessy, D, Thun, R 2005. Effect of immunization against GnRH on androstenone concentration, growth performance and carcass quality in intact male pigs. Livestock Production Science 92, 3138.
Kubale, V, Fazarinc, G, Batorek, N, Škrlep, M, Šegula, B, Bonneau, M, Čandek-Potokar, M 2011. Dynamic effect of a gonadotropin-releasing hormone vaccine (Improvac®) on morphology of testes and male reproductive accessory glands: bulbourethral gland, prostate and vesicular gland in pig fatteners. Slovenian Veterinary Research 48 (suppl. 13), 203206.
Kim, YH, Jung, HJ, Lee, SD, Ji, SY, Park, JC, Moon, HK 2007. Effects of immunocastration on physiological changes, the characteristic of carcass and meat quality in boars. Journal of Animal Science & Technology (Korean) 49, 753760.
Kristensen, L, Therkildsen, M, Riis, BM, Sorensen, MT, Oksbjerg, N, Purslow, P, Ertbjerg, P 2002. Dietary induced changes of muscle growth rate in pigs: effects on in vivo and post-mortem muscle proteolysis and meat quality. Journal of Animal Science 80, 28622871.
Lametsch, R, Kristensen, L, Larsen, MR, Therkildsen, M, Oksbjerg, N, Ertbjerg, P 2006. Changes in the muscle proteome after compensatory growth in pigs. Journal of Animal Science 84, 918924.
Lealiifano, AK, Pluske, JR, Nicholls, RR, Dunshea, FR, Campbell, RG, Hennessy, DP, Miller, DW, Hansen, CF, Mullan, BP 2011. Reducing the length of time between harvest and the secondary gonadotropin-releasing factor immunization improves growth performance and clears boar taint compounds in male finishing pigs. Journal of Animal Science 89, 27822792.
McCauley, I, Watt, M, Suster, D, Kerton, DJ, Oliver, WT, Harrell, RJ, Dunshea, FR 2003. A GnRH vaccine (Improvac®) and porcine somatotropin (Reporcin®) have sinergistic effect upon growth performance in both boars and gilts. Australian Journal of Agricultural Research 54, 1120.
Medina, S, Castaneda, E, Brana, D, Cuaron, J 2008. Effects of vaccine against gonadotropin releasing factor (GNRF) on intact male pig production. Retrieved July 26, 2011, from http://www.pigprogress.net/public//Effects_of_a_vaccine_against_gonadotropin_releasing_factor_%28GnRF%29_on_intact_male_pig_production.pdf.
Meloen, RH, Turkstra, JA, Lankhof, H, Puijk, WC, Schaaper, WMM, Dijkstra, G, Wensing, CJG, Oonk, RB 1994. Efficient immunocastration of male piglets by immunoneutralization of GnRH using a new GnRH-like peptide. Vaccine 12, 741746.
Metz, C, Claus, R 2003. Active immunization of boars against GnRH does not affect growth hormone but lowers IGF-1 in plasma. Livestock Production Science 81, 129137.
Metz, C, Hohl, K, Waidelich, S, Drochner, W, Claus, R 2002. Active immunization of boars against GnRH at an early age: consequences for testicular function, boar taint accumulation and N-retention. Livestock Production Science 74, 147157.
Millet, S, Gielkens, K, De Brabander, D, Janssens, GPJ 2011. Considerations on the performance of immunocastrated male pigs. Animal 5, 11191123.
Moore, KL, Dunshea, FR, Mullan, BP, Hennessy, DP, D'Souza, DN 2009. Rectopamine supplementation increases lean deposition in entire and immunocastrated male pigs. Animal Production Science 49, 11131119.
Morales, J, Gispert, M, Hortos, M, Pérez, J, Suárez, P, Piñeiro, C 2010. Evaluation of production performance and carcass quality characteristics of boars immunised against gonadotropin-releasing hormone (GnRH) compared with phisically castrated male, entire male and female. Spanish Journal of Agricultural Research 8, 599606.
Morales, JI, Cámara, L, Berrocoso, JD, López, JP, Mateos, GG, Serrano, MP 2011. Influence of sex and castration on growth performance and carcass quality of crossbred pigs from two Large White sire lines. Journal of Animal Science 89, 34813489.
Oliver, WT, McCauley, I, Harrell, RJ, Suster, D, Kerton, DJ, Dunshea, FR 2003. A gonadotropin-releasing factor vaccine (Improvac) and porcine somatotropin have synergistic and additive effects on growth performance in group-housed boars and gilts. Journal of Animal Science 81, 19591966.
Patterson, RLS 1968. 5α-androst-16-ene-3-one: compound responsible for taint in boar fat. Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture 19, 3138.
Pauly, C, Spring, P, O'Doherty, JV, Kragten, SA, Bee, G 2009. Growth performance, carcass characteristics and meat quality of group-penned surgically castrated, immunocastrated (Improvac®) and entire male pigs and individually penned entire male pigs. Animal 3, 10571066.
Pearce, M, Andrews, S, Brock, F, Allison, J 2009. Effects of vaccination with Improvac® on boar taint and carcase quality of male pigs reared under commercial conditions in Europe. 55th International Congress of Meat Science and Technology, Copenhagen, Denmark, August 16–21, PE1.08.
PIGCAS 2009. Report on recommendations for research and policy support. Deliverable D4.1 of the EU project PIGCAS: attitude, practices and state of the art regarding piglet castration in Europe. Retrieved September 10, 2011 from http://w3.rennes.inra.fr/pigcas.
Ramsay, TG 1999. Leptin: a regulator of feed intake and physiology in swine. In Manipulating pig production VIII (ed. PD Cranwell), pp. 157170. Australian Pig Science Association, Werribe, Vic., Australia.
Ramsay, TG, Yan, X, Morrison, C 1998. The obesity gene in swine: sequence and expression of porcine leptin. Journal of Animal Science 76, 484490.
Rikard-Bell, C, Curtis, MA, van Barneveld, RJ, Mullan, BP, Edwards, AC, Gannon, NJ, Henman, DJ, Hughes, PE, Dunshea, FR 2009. Rectopamine hydrochloride improves growth performance and carcass composition in immunocastrated boars, intact boars, and gilts. Journal of Animal Science 87, 35363543.
Sather, AP, Jones, SDM, Squires, EJ, Schaefer, AL, Robertson, WM, Tong, AKW, Zawadski, S 1995. Antemortem handling effects on the behaviour, carcass yield and meat quality of market weight entire male pigs. Canadian Journal of Animal Science 75, 4556.
Saville, DJ, Rowarth, JS 2008. Statistical measures, hypotheses, and tests in applied research. Journal of Natural Resources and Life Sciences Education 37, 7482.
Schmoll, F, Kauffold, J, Pfützner, A, Baumgartner, J, Brock, F, Grodzycki, M, Andrews, S 2009. Growth performance and carcass traits of boars raised in Germany and either surgically castrated of vaccinated against gonadotropin-releasing hormone. Journal of Swine Health and Production 17, 250255.
Škrlep, M, Šegula, B, Zajec, M, Kastelic, M, Košorok, S, Fazarinc, G, Čandek-Potokar, M 2010a. Effect of immunocastration (Improvac®) in fattening pigs I: growth performance, reproductive organs and malodourous compounds. Slovenian Veterinary Research 47, 5764.
Škrlep, M, Šegula, B, Prevolnik, M, Kirbiš, A, Fazarinc, G, Čandek-Potokar, M 2010b. Effect of immunocastration (Improvac®) in fattening pigs II: carcass traits and meat quality. Slovenian Veterinary Research 47, 6572.
Therkildsen, M, Vestergaard, M, Busk, H, Jensen, MT, Riis, B, Karlsson, AH, Kristensen, L, Ertbjerg, P, Oksbjerg, N 2004. Compensatory growth in slaughter pigs – in vitro muscle protein turnover at slaughter, circulating IGF-1, performance and carcass quality. Livestock Production Science 88, 6375.
Turkstra, JA, van Diepen, JTM, Jongbloed, AW, Oonk, HB, van de Wiel, DFM, Meloen, RH 2002. Performance of male pigs immunized against GnRH is related to the time of onset of biological response. Journal of Animal Science 80, 29532959.
van Laack, RJM, Stevens, SG, Stalder, KJ 2001. The influence of ultimate pH and intramuscular fat content on pork tenderness and tenderization. Journal of Animal Science 79, 392397.
Vold, E 1970. Fleishproduktionseigenschaften bei Ebern Kastraten IV: Organoleptische und gaschromatographische Untersuchungen wasserdampfflüchtiger Stoffe des Rückenspeckes von Ebern. Maldinger fra Norges Landbrukshøgskole 49, 125.
Walstra, P, Maarse, G 1970. Onderzoek gestachlengen von mannelijke mestvarkens, Researchrroep voor Vlees en Vleeswaren TNO. IVO-Rapport C 147, 30 pp., Zeist, The Netherlands.
Zamaratskaia, G, Andersson, HK, Chen, G, Andersson, K, Madej, A, Lundström, K 2008a. Effect of a gonadotropin-releasing hormone vaccine (Improvac™) on steroid hormones, boar taint compounds and performance in entire male pigs. Reproduction in Domestic Animals 43, 351359.
Zamaratskaia, G, Rydhmer, L, Andersson, HK, Chen, G, Lowagie, S, Andersson, K, Lundström, K 2008b. Long-term effect of vaccination against gonadotropin-releasing hormon, using ImprovacTM, on hormonal profile and behaviour of male pigs. Animal Reproduction Science 108, 3748.
Zankl, A, Götz, R, Pausenberger, A, Dodenhoff, J, Wittmann, W 2011. Impfung gegen Ebergeruch-Erfahrungen und Ergebnisse einer Feldstudie in Bayern. Der Praktische Tierarzt 92, 148154.
Zeng, XY, Turkstra, JA, van de Wiel, DFM, Guo, DZ, Liu, XY, Meloen, RH, Schaaper, WMM, Chen, FQ, Oonk, HB, Zhang, X 2001. Active immunization against gonadotrophin-releasing hormone in Chinese male pigs. Reproduction in Domestic Animals 36, 101105.
Zeng, XY, Turkstra, JA, Meloen, RH, Liu, XY, Chen, FQ, Schaaper, WMM, Oonk, HB, Guo, DZ, van de Wiel, DFM 2002a. Active immunization against gonadotrophin-releasing hormone in Chinese male pigs: effects of dose on antibody titre, hormone levels and sexual development. Animal Reproduction Science 70, 223233.
Zeng, XY, Turkstra, JA, Jongbloed, AW, van Diepen, JTM, Meloen, RH, Oonk, HB, Guo, DZ, van de Wiel, DFM 2002b. Performance and hormone levels of immunocastrated, surgically castrated and intact male pigs fed ad libitum high- and low-energy diets. Livestock Production Science 77, 111.

Keywords

Type Description Title
WORD
Supplementary materials

Batorek supplementary material
Table S1.doc

 Word (104 KB)
104 KB

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed