Skip to main content
    • Aa
    • Aa

Cultural and reproductive success in industrial societies: Testing the relationship at the proximate and ultimate levels

  • Daniel Pérusse (a1)

In most social species, position in the male social hierarchy and reproductive success are positively correlated; in humans, however, this relationship is less clear, with studies of traditional societies yielding mixed results. In the most economically advanced human populations, the adaptiveness of status vanishes altogether; social status and fertility are uncorrelated. These findings have been interpreted to suggest that evolutionary principles may not be appropriate for the explanation of human behavior, especially in modern environments. The present study tests the adaptiveness of social status with actual mating and reproductive data in a representative sample of males from an industrial society. Reproductive success, even when assessed by a more reliable measure of actual male fertility than the one commonly used, fails to correlate with social status. In striking contrast, however, status is found to be highly correlated with potential fertility, as estimated from copulation frequency. Status thus accounts for as much as 62% of the variance in this proximate component of fitness. This pattern is remarkably similar to what is found in many traditional societies and would result in a substantial positive relationship between cultural and reproductive success in industrial populations were it not for the novel conditions imposed by contraception and monogamy. Various underlying mechanisms are suggested for these findings, illustrating the value of current behavioral and reproductive data in the study of adaptation. It is concluded that evolutionary explanations of human behavior remain entirely relevant in modern societies.

Linked references
Hide All

This list contains references from the content that can be linked to their source. For a full set of references and notes please see the PDF or HTML where available.

R. D. Alexander (1990) Epigenetic rules and Darwinian algorithms. Ethology and Sociobiology 11:241301. [aDP]

A. Antonovsky & J. Bernstein (1977) Social class and infant mortality. Social Science and Medicine 11:453–70. [aDP]

J. H. Barkow (1977) Conformity to ethos and reproductive success in two Hausa communities: An empirical evaluation. Ethos 5:409–25. [WI]

J. H. Barkow (1978) Culture and sociobiology. American Anthropologist 80:520. [aDP]

J. H. Barkow (1990) Beyond the DP/DSS controversy. Ethology and Sociobiology 11:341–51. [aDP]

J. H. Barkow & N. Burley (1980) Evolutionary biology, human fertility, and the demographic transition. Ethology and Sociobiology 1:163–80. [aDP, HK]

M. Bellis & R. Baker (1990) Do females promote sperm competition? Data for humans. Animal Behavior 40:997–99. [LB]

J. Belsky , L. Steinberg & P. Draper (1991) Childhood experience, interpersonal development, and reproductive strategy: An evolutionary theory of socialization. Child Development 62:647–70. [EMH]

I. H. Bernstein (1988) Applied multivariate analysis. Springer-Verlag. [rDP]

L. L. Betzig (1989) Rethinking human ethology. Ethology and Sociobiology 10:315–24. [aDP]

B. R. Blishen , W. K. Carroll & C. Moore (1987) The 1981 socio-economic index for occupations. Canadian Review of Sociology and Anthropology 24:465–88. [DW]

J. Bongaarts & R. G. Potter (1983) Fertility, biology and behavior: An analysis of the proximate determinants. Academic Press [aDP, DCS]

L. M. Burton (1990) Teenage childbearing as an alternative life-course strategy in multi-generational black families. Human Nature 1:123–44. [HK]

K. L. Campbell & J. W. Wood (1988) Fertility in traditional societies. In: Natural human fertility: Social and biological determinants, ed. P. Diggory , M. Potts & S. Teper . Macmillan. [BSL]

T. M. Caro & Mulder M. Borgerhoff (1987) The problem of adaptation in the study of human behavior. Ethology and Sociobiology 8:6172. [MBM]

R. Centers (1949) Marital selection and occupational strata. American Journal of Sociology 54:530–35. [aDP]

N. A. Chagnon (1988) Life histories, blood revenge, and warfare in a tribal population. Science 239:985–92. [LB, WI]

B. Chapais & D. Pérusse (1988) Anthropologie et sociobiologie: Les fondements d'une possible intégration. Anthropologies et Sociétés 12:175–91. [aDP]

L. C. Cole (1954) The population consequences of life history phenomena. Quarterly Review of Biology 29:103–37. [MDi]

L. M. Collins , J. W. Graham , W. B. Hansen & C. A. Johnson (1985) Agreement between retrospective accounts of substance use and earlier reported substance use. Applied Psychological Measurement 9:301–9. [UM]

H. J. Crockett Jr., (1962) The achievement motive and differential occupational mobility in the United States. American Sociological Review 27:191204.32. [aDP]

L. Cronk (1991) Wealth, status, and reproductive success among the Mukogodo of Kenya. American Anthropologist 93:345–60. [LB, WI]

D. P. Crowne & D. Marlowe (1960) A new scale of social desirability independent of psychopathology. Journal of Consulting Psychology 24:349–54. [aDP]

M. -J. DelVecchio Good , G. M. Fair & B. J. Good (1980) Social status and fertility: A study of a town and three villages in Northwestern Iran. Population Studies 34:311–19. [aDP]

D. A. Dewsbury (1982) Dominance rank, copulatory behavior, and differential reproduction. Quarterly Review of Biology 57:135–59. [arDP]

M. Dickemann (1979b) The ecology of mating systems in hypergynous dowry societies. Social Science Information 18:163–95. [MDi]

M. Dickemann (1991) Women, class and dowry. American Anthropologist 93(4):944–46. [JS]

P. Draper & J. Belsky (1990) The relevance of evolutionary thinking for issues in personality development. Journal of Personality 58:141–62. [EMH]

E. S. Edgington (1972a) An additive method for combining probability values from independent experiments. Journal of Psychology 80:8589. [WI]

E. S. Edgington (1972b) A normal curve method for combining probability value from independent experiments. Journal of Psychology 82:8589. [WI]

S. T. Emlen & L. W. Oring (1977) Ecology, sexual selection, and evolution of mating systems. Science 197:215–23. [rDP, EMH]

S. M. Essock-Vitale (1984) The reproductive success of wealthy Americans. Ethology and Sociobiology 5:4549. [aDP]

L. M. Fedigan (1983) Dominance and reproductive success in primates. Yearbook of Physical Anthropology 26:91129. [arDP]

A. Feingold (1992) Gender differences in mate selection preferences: A test of the parental investment model. Psychological Bulletin 112:125–39. [GC]

M. V. Flinn (1986) Correlates of reproductive success in a Caribbean village. Human Ecology 14:225–43. [aDP]

M. V. Flinn & R. D. Alexander (1982) Culture theory: The developing synthesis from biology. Human Ecology 10:383400. [aDP]

D. Freedman (1987) As others see us: A case study in path analysis. Journal of Educational Statistics 12:101–28. [FLB]

D. Freedman & A. Thornton (1982) Income and fertility: The elusive relationship. Demography 19:6579. [EMH]

S. W. Gangestad & J. A. Simpson (1990) Toward an evolutionary history of female sociosexual variation. Journal of personality 58(1):6996. [LM]

S. J. C. Gaulin & J. S. Boster (1990) Dowry as female competition. American Anthropologist 92(4):9941005. [JS]

N. D. Glenn & P. A. Taylor (1984) Education and family income: A comparison of white married men and women in the U.S. Social Forces 63:169–83. [aDP]

B. Greenberg , J. Abernathy & D. Horowitz (1970) A new survey technique and its application in the field of public health. Milbank Memorial Fund Quarterly 48:3955. [DW]

W. D. Hamilton (1964) The genetical evolution of social behavior. Journal of Theoretical Biology 7:152. [arDP]

W. P. Handwerker (1986a) The modern demographic transition: An analysis of subsistence choices and reproductive consequences. American Anthropologist 88:400417. [MDi]

W. V. Harris (1980) Towards a study of the Roman slave trade. Memoirs of the American Academy in Rome 36:117–40. [LB]

R. M. Hauser (1972) Disaggregating a social-psychological model of educational attainment. Social Science Research 1:159–88. [aDP]

R. M. Hauser & D. L. Featherman (1977) The process of stratification: Trends and analyses. Academic Press. [aDP]

K. Hawkes (1991) Showing off: Tests of an hypotheses about men's foraging goals. Ethology and Sociobiology 12:2954. [rDP]

K. Hawkes , J. F. O'Connell & N. G. Blurton Jones (1991) Hunting income patterns among the Hadza: Big game, common goods, foraging goals and the evolution of the human diet. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society London B 334:243–51. [rDP]

A. H. Hawley (1955) Rural fertility in central Luzon. American Sociological Review 20:2127. [aDP]

V. A. Hiday (1978) Agricultural organization and fertility: A comparison of two Philippine frontier communities. Social biology 25:6979. [aDP]

E. M. Hill & B. S. Low (1992) Contemporary abortion patterns: A life history approach. Ethology and Sociobiology 13:3548. [EMH]

J. Hill (1984) Prestige and reproductive success in man. Ethology and Sociobiology 5:7795. [aDP]

H. J. Hippler , N. Schwarz & S. Sudman , eds. (1987) Social information processing and survey methodology. Springer. [UM]

J. R. Hochstim (1967) A critical comparison of three strategies of collecting data from households. Journal of American Statistical Association 62:967–89. [aDP]

R. Hodson (1985) Some considerations concerning the functional form of earnings. Social Science Research 14:374–94. [aDP]

A. B. Hollingshead (1950) Cultural factors in the selection of marriage mates. American Sociological Review 15:619–27. [aDP]

L. L. Hoyt & J. W. Hudson (1981) Personal characteristics important in mate preference among college students. Social Behavior and Personality 9:9396. [aDP]

F. Hsu , T. Anantharaman , M. Campbell & A. Nowatzyk (1990) A grandmaster chess machine. Scientific American 263:4450. [aDP]

J. W. Hudson & L. F. Henze (1966) Campus values in mate selection: A replication. Journal of Marriage and the Family 31:772–75. [aDP]

T. H. Hull & V. J. Hull (1977) The relation of economic class and fertility: An analysis of some Indonesian data. Population Studies 31:4357. [aDP]

T. C. Hunt (1940) Occupational status and marriage selection. American Sociological Review 5:495504. [aDP]

M. Hurtado , K. Hill , H. Kaplan & I. Hurtado (1992) Tradeoffs between food acquisition and child care among Hiwi and Ache women. Human Nature 3(3):185216. [BSL]

W. Irons (1990) Let's make our perspective broader rather than narrower. Ethology and Sociobiology 11:361–74. [aDP]

W. H. James (1974) Marital coital rates, spouses' ages, family size and social class. Journal of Sex Research 10:205–18. [aDP]

N. E. Johnson & S. Lean (1985) Relative income, race, and fertility. Population Studies 39:99112. [EMH]

A. M. Khalifa (1973) A proposed explanation of the fertility gap differentials by socio-economic status and modernity: The case of Egypt. Population Studies 27:431–42. [aDP]

E. M. Kitagawa & P. M. Hauser (1973) Differential mortality in the United States: A study in socioeconomic epidemiology. Harvard University Press, [aDP]

B. M. Knauft (1991) Violence and sexuality in human evolution. Current Anthropology 32(4):391428. [JS]

R. F. Larson & G. R. Leslie (1968) Prestige influences in serious dating relationships of university students. Social Forces 47:195202. [aDP]

G. C. Leavitt (1990) Sociobiological explorations of incest avoidance. A critical review of evidential claims. American Anthropologist 92(4):971–93. [JS]

G. C. Leavitt (1992) Inbreeding fitness: A reply to Uhlmann. American Anthropologist 94(2):448–50. [JS]

B. S. Low (1990) Occupational status, landownership, and reproductive behavior in nineteenth-century Sweden: Tuna Parish. American Anthropologist 92:457–68. [MDi, BSL]

B. S. Low (1991) Reproductive life in nineteenth-century Sweden: An evolutionary perspective on demographic phenomena. Ethology and Sociobiology 12:411–48. [BSL]

B. S. Low & A. L. Clarke (1992) Resources and the life course: Patterns through the demographic transition. Ethology and Sociobiology 13(4–5). [BSL]

B. S. Low & A. L. Clarke (1992) Toward an ecological demography. Population and Development Review 18(1):131. [BSL]

S. H. Lowrie (1961) Early and late dating: Some conditions associated with them. Marriage and Family Living 23:284–90. [aDP]

R. MacArthur (1962) Some generalized theorems of natural selection. Proceedings, National Academy of Sciences (USA) 48:1893–97. [MDi]

D. C. McClelland (1985) Human motivation. Scott, Foresman, [NST]

D. C. McClelland & D. A. Pilon (1983) Sources of adult motives in patterns of parent behavior in early childhood. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 44:564–74. [aDP]

L. Mealey (1985) The relationship between social and biological success: A case study of the Mormon religious hierarchy. Ethology and Sociobiology 6:249–57. [aDP, LM]

J. L. Menken (1985) Age and fertility: How late can you wait? Population Association of America presidential address. Demography 22:469–83. [DW]

D. W. Mock & M. Fujioka (1990) Monogamy and long-term pair bonding in vertebrates. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 5:3943. [LB]

A. P. Møller (1987) Extent and duration of mate guarding in swallow Hirundo rustica. Ornis Scandinacica 18:95100. [LB]

A. P. Møller (1988) Female choice selects for male sexual tail ornaments in the monogamous swallow. Nature 332:640–42. [LB]

H. Moss & J. Kagan (1961) Stability of achievement and recognition-seeking behaviors from early childhood through adulthood. Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology 62:504–13. [aDP]

G. P. Murdock & D. White (1969) Standard cross-cultural sample. Ethnology 8:329–60. [LB]

R. Noe & A. A. Sluijter (1990) Reproductive tacties of male savanna baboons. Behaviour 113:117–70. [RIMD]

C. M. Perrins (1965) Population fluctuation and clutch-size in the great tit (Parus major L.) Journal of Animal Ecology 34:601–47. [HK]

D. Pérusse (1988) Succès social et succès reproductif dans les sociétés modernes: Une analyse sociobiologique. Anthropologies et Sociétés 12:151–74. [arDP]

P. C. Pineo & J. Porter (1967) Occupational prestige in Canada. Canadian Review of Sociology and Anthropology 4:2440. [aDP]

S. Polgar & J. M. Marshall (1976) The search for culturally acceptable fertility regulation methods. In: Culture, natality and family planning, ed. J. F. Marshall & S. Polgar . University of North Carolina Press. [HK]

I. L. Reiss (1965) Social class and campus dating. Social Problems 13:193205. [aDP]

A. R. Rogers (1988) Does biology constrain culture? American Anthropologist 90:819–31. [aDP]

A. R. Rogers (1990) The evolutionary economics of human reproduction. Ethology and Sociobiology 11:479–95. [HK, BSL]

A. R. Rogers (1991a) Conserving resources for children. Human Nature 2(1):7382. [BSL]

E. M. Rogers & A. E. Havens (1960) Prestige rating and mate selection on a college campus. Marriage and Family Living 22:5559. [aDP]

B. C. Rosen & R. D'Andrade (1959) The psychological origins of achievement motivation. Sociometry 22:185218. [aDP]

P. C. Rosenblatt & W. J. Hillabrant (1972) Divorce for childlessness and the regulation of adultery. Journal of Sex Research 8:117–27. [HK]

Z. Rubin (1968) Do American women marry up? American Sociological Review 33:750–60. [aDP]

J. P. Rushton (1988) Race differences in behavior: A review and evolutionary analysis. Personality and Individual Differences 9:1009–24. [JH]

E. K. Sadalla , D. T. Kenrick & B. Vershure (1987) Dominance and heterosexual attraction. Journal of Personality & Social Psychology 52:730–38. [DTK]

A. Schlegel (1991) Status, property and the value of virginity. American Ethnologist 18(4):719–34. [JS]

J. A. Simpson & S. W. Gangestad (1991) Individual differences in sociosexuality: Evidence for convergent and discriminant validity. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 60:870–83. [JAS]

M. F. Small (1989) Female choice in nonhuman primates. Yearbook of Physical Anthropology 32:103–27. [rDP]

C. C. Smith & S. D. Fretwell (1974) The optimal balance between size and number of offspring. American Naturalist 108:499506. [HK]

R. L. Smith (1984) Human sperm competition. In: Sperm competition and the evolution of animal mating systems, ed. R. Smith . Academic Press. [LB]

W. M. Smith Jr. (1952) Rating and dating: A re-study. Marriage and Family Living 14:312–17. [aDP]

S. C. Stearns (1982) Components of fitness. Science 218:463–64. [LM]

G. Stevens & E. Hoisington (1987) Occupational prestige and the 1980 U.S. labor force. Social Science Research 16:74105. [arDP]

W. Stys (1957) The influence of economic conditions on the fertility of peasant women. Population Studies 11:136–48. [aDP]

D. Symons (1989) A critique of Darwinian anthropology. Ethology and Sociobiology 10:131–44. [arDP, MDa]

D. Symons (1990) Adaptiveness and adaptation. Ethology and Sociobiology 11:427–44. [aDP, MDa]

P. A. Taylor & N. D. Glenn (1976) The utility of education and attractiveness for females' status attainment through marriage. American Sociological Review 41:484–98. [aDP]

D. D. Thiessen (1972) A move towards species-specific analyses in behavioral genetics. Behavior Genetics 2(2/3): 115–26. [LM]

J. Tooby & L. Cosmides (1989) Evolutionary psychology and the generation of culture. Part I: Theoretical considerations. Ethology and Sociobiology 10:2949. [aDP, HCP]

J. Tooby & L. Cosmides (1990) The past explains the present. Ethology and Sociobiology 11:375424. [arDP, MDa, LM, EAS]

D. J. Treiman (1977) Occupational prestige in comparative perspective. Academic Press, [aDP]

P. W. Turke (1989) Evolution and the demand for children. Population & Development Review 15:6190. [EMH, WI, BSL]

P. W. Turke (1990a) Which humans behave adaptively, and why does it matter? Ethology and Sociobiology 11:305–39. [aDP, LB, WI]

P. W. Turke (1990b) Just do it. Ethology and Sociobiology 11:445–63. [aDP]

P. W. Turke & L. L. Betzig (1985) Those who can do: Wealth, status, and reproductive success on Ifaluk. Ethology and Sociobiology 6:7987. [aDP, WI]

J. E. Veevers (1979) Voluntary childlessness: A review of issues and evidence. Marriage and Family Review 2:326. [DW]

E. Voland (1990) Differential reproductive success within the Krummhorn population (Germany, 18th & 19th centuries). Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology 26:6572. [aDP]

D. R. White (1989) Questioning the correlational evidence for Kipsigis wealth as a cause of reproductive success rather than polygyny as a cause of both extra children and extra wealth. American Anthropologist 91:175–78. [aDP]

E. A. Wrigley (1966) Family limitation in preindustrial England. Economic History Review 19:82109. [HK]

H. Zurayk (1979) A two-stage analysis of the determinants of fertility in rural South Lebanon. Population Studies 33:489504. [aDP]

Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Behavioral and Brain Sciences
  • ISSN: 0140-525X
  • EISSN: 1469-1825
  • URL: /core/journals/behavioral-and-brain-sciences
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *