Skip to main content
    • Aa
    • Aa

Unconscious influences on decision making: A critical review

  • Ben R. Newell (a1) and David R. Shanks (a2)

To what extent do we know our own minds when making decisions? Variants of this question have preoccupied researchers in a wide range of domains, from mainstream experimental psychology (cognition, perception, social behavior) to cognitive neuroscience and behavioral economics. A pervasive view places a heavy explanatory burden on an intelligent cognitive unconscious, with many theories assigning causally effective roles to unconscious influences. This article presents a novel framework for evaluating these claims and reviews evidence from three major bodies of research in which unconscious factors have been studied: multiple-cue judgment, deliberation without attention, and decisions under uncertainty. Studies of priming (subliminal and primes-to-behavior) and the role of awareness in movement and perception (e.g., timing of willed actions, blindsight) are also given brief consideration. The review highlights that inadequate procedures for assessing awareness, failures to consider artifactual explanations of “landmark” results, and a tendency to uncritically accept conclusions that fit with our intuitions have all contributed to unconscious influences being ascribed inflated and erroneous explanatory power in theories of decision making. The review concludes by recommending that future research should focus on tasks in which participants' attention is diverted away from the experimenter's hypothesis, rather than the highly reflective tasks that are currently often employed.

  • View HTML
    • Send article to Kindle

      To send this article to your Kindle, first ensure is added to your Approved Personal Document E-mail List under your Personal Document Settings on the Manage Your Content and Devices page of your Amazon account. Then enter the ‘name’ part of your Kindle email address below. Find out more about sending to your Kindle.

      Note you can select to send to either the or variations. ‘’ emails are free but can only be sent to your device when it is connected to wi-fi. ‘’ emails can be delivered even when you are not connected to wi-fi, but note that service fees apply.

      Find out more about the Kindle Personal Document Service.

      Unconscious influences on decision making: A critical review
      Available formats
      Send article to Dropbox

      To send this article to your Dropbox account, please select one or more formats and confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your Dropbox account. Find out more about sending content to Dropbox.

      Unconscious influences on decision making: A critical review
      Available formats
      Send article to Google Drive

      To send this article to your Google Drive account, please select one or more formats and confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your Google Drive account. Find out more about sending content to Google Drive.

      Unconscious influences on decision making: A critical review
      Available formats
Hide All
J. M. Ackerman , C. C. Nocera & J. A. Bargh (2010) Incidental haptic sensations influence social judgments and decisions. Science 328:1712–15.

J. G. Adair & B. Spinner (1981) Subjects' access to cognitive processes: Demand characteristics and verbal report. Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour 11:3152.

H. R. Arkes (1981) Impediments to accurate clinical judgment and possible ways to minimize their impact. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 49:323–30.

P. Azzopardi & A. Cowey (1997) Is blindsight like normal, near-threshold vision? Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 94:14190–94.

B. J. Baars (2002) The conscious access hypothesis: Origins and recent evidence. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 6(1):4752.

W. K. Balzer , J. Rohrbaugh & K. R. Murphy (1983) Reliability of actual and predicted judgments across time. Organizational Behavior and Human Performance 32:109–23.

J. A. Bargh , M. Chen & L. Burrows (1996) Automaticity of social behavior: Direct effects of trait construct and stereotype activation on action. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 71:230–44.

R. F. Baumeister , E. J. Masicampo & K. D. Vohs (2011) Do conscious thoughts cause behavior? Annual Review of Psychology 62:331–61. doi: 10.1146/annurev.psych.093008.131126.

A. Bechara , A. R. Damasio , H. Damasio & S. W. Anderson (1994) Insensitivity to future consequences following damage to human prefrontal cortex. Cognition 50(1–3):715. Retrieved from

A. Bechara , H. Damasio & A. R. Damasio (2000) Emotion, decision making and the orbitofrontal cortex. Cerebral Cortex 10:295307.

A. Bechara , H. Damasio , D. Tranel & A. R. Damasio (1997) Deciding advantageously before knowing the advantageous strategy. Science 275:1293–95.

A. Bechara , D. Tranel , H. Damasio & A. R. Damasio (1996) Failure to respond autonomically to anticipated future outcomes following damage to prefrontal cortex. Cerebral Cortex 6:215–25.

B. L. Benson , J. A. Anguera & R. D. Seidler (2011) A spatial explicit strategy reduces error but interferes with sensorimotor adaptation. Journal of Neurophysiology 105:2843–51.

I. V. Blair , C. M. Judd & K. M. Chapleau (2004a) The influence of Afrocentric facial features in criminal sentencing. Psychological Science 15:674–79.

M. W. Bos , A. Dijksterhuis & R. B. van Baaren (2011) The benefits of “sleeping on things”: Unconscious thought leads to automatic weighting. Journal of Consumer Psychology 21:48.

C. H. Bowman , C. E. Y. Evans & O. H. Turnbull (2005) Artificial time constraints on the Iowa Gambling Task: The effects on behavioural performance and subjective experience. Brain and Cognition 57:2125.

L. R. Brooks , G. R. Norman & S. W. Allen (1991) The role of specific similarity in a medical diagnostic task. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 120:278–87.

L. R. Brooks & J. R. Vokey (1991) Abstract analogies and abstracted grammars: Comments on Reber (1989) and Mathews et al. (1989) Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 120:316–23.

M. Cella , S. Dymond , A. Cooper & O. Turnbull (2007) Effects of decision-phase time constraints on emotion-based learning in the Iowa Gambling Task. Brain and Cognition 64:164–69.

A. Cowey (2010) The blindsight saga. Experimental Brain Research 200:324.

B. Crandall & K. Getchell-Reiter (1993) Critical decision method: A technique for eliciting concrete assessment indicators from the “intuition” of NICU nurses. Advances in Nursing Sciences 16:4251.

T. Davis , B. C. Love & W. T. Maddox (2009) Anticipatory emotions in decision tasks: Covert markers of value or attentional processes? Cognition 112:195200.

R. M. Dawes , D. Faust & P. E. Meehl (1989) Clinical versus actuarial judgment. Science 243(4899):1668–74.

M. E. Dawson & P. Reardon (1973) Construct validity of recall and recognition postconditioning measures of awareness. Journal of Experimental Psychology 98:308–15.

M. K. Dhami , R. Hertwig & U. Hoffrage (2004) The role of representative design in an ecological approach to cognition. Psychological Bulletin 130:959–88.

Z. Dienes & A. Seth (2010) Gambling on the unconscious: A comparison of wagering and confidence ratings as measures of awareness in an artificial grammar task. Consciousness and Cognition 19:674–81.

A. Dijksterhuis (2004) Think different: The merits of unconscious thought in preference development and decision making. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 87:586–98.

A. Dijksterhuis , M. W. Bos , L. F. Nordgren & R. B. van Baaren (2006b) On making the right choice: The deliberation-without-attention effect. Science 311(5763):10051007. doi: 10.1126/science.1121629.

A. Dijksterhuis , M. W. Bos , A. van der Leij & R. van Baaren (2009) Predicting soccer matches after unconscious and conscious thought as a function of expertise. Psychological Science 20:1381–87.

A. Dijksterhuis & L. F. Nordgren (2006) A theory of unconscious thought. Perspectives in Psychological Science 1:95109.

A. Dijksterhuis , R. Spears , T. Postmes , D. A. Stapel , W. Koomen , A. van Knippenberg & D. Scheepers (1998) Seeing one thing and doing another: Contrast effects in automatic behavior. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 75:862–71.

S. Doyen , O. Klein , C.-L. Pichon & A. Cleeremans (2012) Behavioral priming: It's all in the mind, but whose mind? PLoS One 7:e29081.

B. D. Dunn , T. Dalgleish & A. D. Lawrence (2006) The somatic marker hypothesis: A critical evaluation. Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews 30:239–71.

F. H. Durgin , J. A. Baird , M. Greenburg , R. Russell , K. Shaughnessy & S. Waymouth (2009) Who is being deceived? The experimental demands of wearing a backpack. Psychonomic Bulletin & Review 16:964968.

W. Edwards & B. Fasolo (2001) Decision technology. Annual Review of Psychology 52:581606.

K. A. Ericsson & H. A. Simon (1980) Verbal reports as data. Psychological Review 87:215–51.

C. E. Y. Evans , C. H. Bowman & O. H. Turnbull (2005) Subjective awareness on the Iowa Gambling Task: The key role of emotional experience in schizophrenia. Journal of Clinical and Experimental Neuropsychology 27:656–64.

J. St. B. T. Evans (2008) Dual-processing accounts of reasoning, judgment and social cognition. Annual Review of Psychology 59:255–78.

J. St. B. T. Evans , J. Clibbens , A. Cattani , A. Harris & I. Dennis (2003) Explicit and implicit processes in multicue judgment. Memory & Cognition 31:608–18.

I. Fried , R. Mukamel & G. Kreiman (2011) Internally generated preactivation of single neurons in human medial frontal cortex predicts volition. Neuron 69:548–62.

E. Gámez , J. M. Díaz & H. Marrero (2011) The uncertain universality of the Macbeth effect with a Spanish sample. Spanish Journal of Psychology 14:156–62.

I. Gavanski & C. Hoffman (1987) Awareness of influences on one's own judgments: The roles of covariation detection and attention to the judgment process. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 52:453–63.

A. Glöckner & C. Witteman (2010) Beyond dual-process models: A categorisation of processes underlying intuitive judgement and decision making. Thinking & Reasoning 16:125.

J. I. Gold & M. N. Shadlen (2007) The neural basis of decision making. Annual Review of Neuroscience 30:535–74.

D. G. Goldstein & G. Gigerenzer (2002) Models of ecological rationality: The recognition heuristic. Psychological Review 109:7590.

C. González-Vallejo , G. D. Lassiter , F. S. Bellezza & M. J. Lindberg (2008) “Save angels perhaps”: A critical examination of unconscious thought theory and the deliberation-without-attention effect. Review of General Psychology 12(3):282–96.

B. Guerin & J. M. Innes (1981) Awareness of cognitive processes: Replications and revisions. Journal of General Psychology 104:173–89.

J. Ham , K. van den Bos & E. van Doorn (2009) Lady Justice thinks unconsciously: Unconscious thought can lead to more accurate justice judgments. Social Cognition 27:509–21.

C. Harries , J. St. B. T. Evans & I. Dennis (2000) Measuring doctors' self-insight into their treatment decisions. Applied Cognitive Psychology 14:455–77.

R. R. Hassin , M. J. Ferguson , D. Shidlovski & T. Gross (2007) Subliminal exposure to national flags affects political thought and behavior. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 104(50): 19757–61.

R. Hastie & B. Park (1986) The relationship between memory and judgment depends on whether the judgment task is memory-based or on-line. Psychological Review 93:258–68.

R. M. Hogarth (2010) Intuition: A challenge for psychological research on decision making. Psychological Inquiry 21:338–53.

H. M. Huizenga , R. Wetzels , D. Van Ravenzwaaij & E. J. Wagenmakers (2012) Four empirical tests of unconscious thought theory. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 117(2):332–40. doi: 10.1016/j.obhdp.2011.11.010.

P. A. Ikomi & R. M. Guion (2000) The prediction of judgment in realistic tasks: An investigation of self-insight. International Journal of Aviation Psychology 10:135–53.

T. Johnstone & D. R. Shanks (2001) Abstractionist and processing accounts of implicit learning. Cognitive Psychology 42:61112.

D. Kahneman & G. Klein (2009) Conditions for intuitive expertise: A failure to disagree. American Psychologist 64:515–26.

N. Karelaia & R. M. Hogarth (2008) Determinants of linear judgment: A meta-analysis of lens model studies. Psychological Bulletin 134(3):404–26.

H. Kelley & D. Friedman (2002) Learning to forecast price. Economic Inquiry 40:556–73.

D. A. Lagnado , B. R. Newell , S. Kahan & D. R. Shanks (2006) Insight and strategy in multiple cue learning. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 135:162–83.

D. G. Lassiter , M. J. Lindberg , C. González-Vallejo , F. S. Bellezza & N. D. Phillips (2009) The deliberation-without-attention effect: Evidence for artifactual interpretation. Psychological Science 20:671–75.

D. Lerouge (2009) Evaluating the benefits of distraction on product evaluations: The mind-set effect. Journal of Consumer Research 36:367–79.

Y. Li & N. Epley (2009) When the best appears to be saved for last: Serial position effects on choice. Journal of Behavioral Decision Making 22:378–89.

B. Libet (1985) Unconscious cerebral initiative and the role of conscious will in voluntary action. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 8:529–39.

B. Libet , C. A. Gleason , E. W. Wright & D. K. Pearl (1983) Time of conscious intention to act in relation to onset of cerebral-activity (readiness potential): The unconscious initiation of a freely voluntary act. Brain 106:623–42.

C. Loersch & B. K. Payne (2011) The situated inference model: An integrative account of the effects of primes on perception, behavior, and motivation. Perspectives on Psychological Science 6:234–52.

G. D. Logan & N. J. Zbrodoff (1979) When it helps to be misled: Facilitative effects of increasing the frequency of conflicting stimuli in a Stroop-like task. Memory & Cognition 7:166–74.

S. Mamede , H. G. Schmidt , R. M. J. P Rikers ., E. J. F. M. Custers , T. A. W. Splinter & J. L. C. M. van Saase (2010) Conscious thought beats deliberation without attention in diagnostic decision-making: At least when you are an expert. Psychological Research 74:586–92.

A. Mantonakis , P. Rodero , I. Lesschaeve & R. Hastie (2009) Order in choice: Effects of serial position on preferences. Psychological Science 20:1309–12.

G. F. Marcus , S. Vijayan , S. Bandi Rao & P. M. Vishton (1999) Rule learning by seven-month-old infants. Science 283:7780.

J. McClure (2012) Attributions, causes, and actions: Is the consciousness of will a perceptual illusion? Theory & Psychology 22:402–19. doi: 10.1177/0959354310386845.

J. Miller , P. Shepherdson & J. Trevena (2011) Effects of clock monitoring on electroencephalographic activity: Is unconscious movement initiation an artifact of the clock? Psychological Science 22:103109.

E. Nahmias (2005) Agency, authorship, and illusion. Consciousness and Cognition 14:771–85.

B. R. Newell & T. Rakow (2011) Revising beliefs about the merits of unconscious thought: Evidence in favor of the null hypothesis. Social Cognition 29:711–26.

B. R. Newell , K. Y. Wong , J. C. Cheung & T. Rakow (2009) Think, blink or sleep on it? The impact of modes of thought on complex decision making. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 62:707–32.

R. E. Nisbett & T. D. Wilson (1977) Telling more than we can know: Verbal reports on mental processes. Psychological Review 84(3):231–59.

L. F. Nordgren , M. W. Bos & A. Dijksterhuis (2011) The best of both worlds: Integrating conscious and unconscious thought best solves complex decisions. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 47:509–11.

M. Overgaard (2011) Visual experience and blindsight: A methodological review. Experimental Brain Research 209:473–79.

M. Overgaard , K. Fehl , K. Mouridsen , B. Bergholt & A. Cleeremans (2008) Seeing without seeing? Degraded conscious vision in a blindsight patient. PLoS One 3:e3028.

J. W. Payne , A. Samper , J. R. Bettman & M. F. Luce (2008) Boundary conditions on unconscious thought in complex decision making. Psychological Science 19(11):1118–23. doi: 10.1111/j.1467–9280.2008.02212.x.

N. Persaud , P. McLeod & A. Cowey (2007) Post-decision wagering objectively measures awareness. Nature Neuroscience 10:257261.

R. H. Phelps & J. Shanteau (1978) Livestock judges: How much information can an expert use? Organizational Behavior and Human Performance 21:209219.

E. M. Pothos (2007) Theories of artificial grammar learning. Psychological Bulletin 133:227–44.

M. S. Pratte & J. N. Rouder (2009) A task-difficulty artifact in subliminal priming. Attention, Perception & Psychophysics 71(6):1276–83.

T. Z. Ramsøy & M. Overgaard (2004) Introspection and subliminal perception. Phenomenology and the Cognitive Sciences 3:123.

G. Rees , C. D. Frith & N. Lavie (1997) Modulating irrelevant motion perception by varying attentional load in an unrelated task. Science 278:1616–19.

B. A. Reilly & M. E. Doherty (1992) The assessment of self-insight in judgment policies. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 53:285309.

E. M. Reingold & P. M. Merikle (1988) Using direct and indirect measures to study perception without awareness. Perception & Psychophysics 44:563–75.

J. J. Rolison , J. St. B. T. Evans , C. R. Walsh & I. Dennis (2011) The role of working memory capacity in multiple-cue probability learning. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 64:1494–514.

D. R. Shanks (2006) Complex choices better made unconsciously? Science 313:760.

D. R. Shanks & M. F. St. John (1994) Characteristics of dissociable human learning systems. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 17:367447.

J. Shanteau (1992) Competence in experts: The role of task characteristics. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 53:252–66.

J. P. Simmons , L. D. Nelson & U. Simonsohn (2011) False-positive psychology: Undisclosed flexibility in data collection and analysis allows presenting anything as significant Psychological Science 22:1359–66.

H. A. Simon (1992) What is an explanation of behavior? Psychological Science 3:150–61.

P. Slovic , D. Fleissner & W. S. Bauman (1972) Analyzing the use of information in investment decision making: A methodological proposal. Journal of Business 45:283301.

P. Slovic & S. Lichtenstein (1971) Comparison of Bayesian and regression approaches to the study of information processing in judgment. Organizational Behaviour and Human Performance 6:649744.

E. R. Smith & F. D. Miller (1978) Limits on perception of cognitive processes: A reply to Nisbett and Wilson. Psychological Review 85:355–62.

M. Speekenbrink & D. R. Shanks (2010) Learning in a changing environment. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 139:266–98.

M. Strick , A. Dijksterhuis , M. W. Bos , A. Sjoerdma , R. B. van Baaren & L. F. Nordgren (2011) A meta-analysis on unconscious thought effects. Social Cognition 29:738–62.

M. Strick , A. Dijksterhuis & R. van Baaren (2010) Unconscious-thought effects take place off-line, not on-line. Psychological Science 21:484–88.

C. F. Surber (1985) Measuring the importance of information in judgment: Individual differences in weighting ability and effort. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 35:156–78.

J. A. Trevena & J. Miller (2002) Cortical movement preparation before and after a conscious decision to move. Consciousness and Cognition 11:162–90.

E. L. Uhlmann , D. A. Pizarro & P. Bloom (2008) Varieties of social cognition. Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour 38:293322.

M. Usher , Z. Russo , M. Weyers , R. Brauner & D. Zakay (2011) The impact of the mode of thought in complex decisions: Intuitive decisions are better. Frontiers in Psychology 2(March):37. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2011.00037.

S. I. Vrieze & W. M. Grove (2009) Survey on the use of clinical and mechanical prediction methods in clinical psychology. Professional Psychology: Research and Practice 40:525–31.

B. M. Wagar & M. Dixon (2006) Affective guidance in the Iowa Gambling Task. Cognitive Affective & Behavioral Neuroscience 6:277–90.

E.-J. Wagenmakers , R. Wetzels , D. Borsboom & H. L. J. van der Maas (2011) Why psychologists must change the way they analyze their data: The case of psi. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 100:432–36.

D. M. Wegner (2004) Précis of The illusion of conscious will. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 27:649–92.

D. M. Wegner , B. Sparrow & L. Winerman (2004) Vicarious agency: Experiencing control over the movements of others. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 86:838–48.

L. Weiskrantz (2009) Is blindsight just degraded normal vision? Experimental Brain Research 192:413–16.

P. White (1980) Limitations on verbal reports of internal events: A refutation of Nisbett and Wilson and of Bem. Psychological Review 87:105–12.

P. A. White (1988) Knowing more about what we can tell: “Introspective access” and causal report accuracy 10 years later. British Journal of Psychology 79:1345.

P. A. White (1989) Evidence for the use of information about internal events to improve the accuracy of causal reports. British Journal of Psychology 80:375–82.

T. D. Wilson & R. E. Nisbett (1978) The accuracy of verbal reports about the effects of stimuli on evaluations and behavior. Social Psychology 41:118–31.

T. D. Wilson & J. W. Schooler (1991) Thinking too much: Introspection can reduce the quality of preferences and decisions. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 60:181–92.

P. Winkielman , K. C. Berridge & J. L. Wilbarger (2005) Unconscious affective reactions to masked happy versus angry faces influence consumption behavior and judgments of value. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 31:121–35.

P. Wright & P. D. Rip (1981) Retrospective reports on the causes of decisions. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 40:601–14.

C.-B. Zhong & K. Liljenquist (2006) Washing away your sins: Threatened morality and physical cleansing. Science 313:1451–52.

Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Behavioral and Brain Sciences
  • ISSN: 0140-525X
  • EISSN: 1469-1825
  • URL: /core/journals/behavioral-and-brain-sciences
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *



Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 235
Total number of PDF views: 2468 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 4721 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 17th October 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.