Skip to main content
    • Aa
    • Aa
  • Get access
    Check if you have access via personal or institutional login
  • Cited by 11
  • Cited by
    This article has been cited by the following publications. This list is generated based on data provided by CrossRef.

    Bentley, R. Alexander Brock, William A. Caiado, Camila C. S. and O'Brien, Michael J. 2016. Evaluating reproductive decisions as discrete choices under social influence. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, Vol. 371, Issue. 1692, p. 20150154.

    Caiado, Camila C.S. Brock, William A. Bentley, R. Alexander and O’Brien, Michael J. 2016. Fitness landscapes among many options under social influence. Journal of Theoretical Biology, Vol. 405, p. 5.

    Moat, Helen Susannah Olivola, Christopher Y. Chater, Nick and Preis, Tobias 2016. Searching Choices: Quantifying Decision-Making Processes Using Search Engine Data. Topics in Cognitive Science, Vol. 8, Issue. 3, p. 685.

    Nardo, Michela Petracco-Giudici, Marco and Naltsidis, Minás 2016. WALKING DOWN WALL STREET WITH A TABLET: A SURVEY OF STOCK MARKET PREDICTIONS USING THE WEB. Journal of Economic Surveys, Vol. 30, Issue. 2, p. 356.

    O’Brien, Michael J. Buchanan, Briggs and Eren, Metin I. 2016. Clovis Colonization of Eastern North America: A Phylogenetic Approach. STAR: Science & Technology of Archaeological Research, Vol. 2, Issue. 1, p. 67.

    O’Brien, Michael J. Boulanger, Matthew T. Buchanan, Briggs Bentley, R. Alexander Lyman, R. Lee Lipo, Carl P. Madsen, Mark E. and Eren, Metin I. 2016. Design Space and Cultural Transmission: Case Studies from Paleoindian Eastern North America. Journal of Archaeological Method and Theory, Vol. 23, Issue. 2, p. 692.

    Phillips, James G. Landhuis, C. Erik Shepherd, Daniel and Ogeil, Rowan P. 2016. Online Activity Levels Are Related to Caffeine Dependency. Cyberpsychology, Behavior, and Social Networking, Vol. 19, Issue. 5, p. 352.

    White, Leroy Burger, Katharina and Yearworth, Mike 2016. Behavioral Operational Research.

    Bentley, R. Alexander and O’Brien, Michael J. 2015. Collective behaviour, uncertainty and environmental change. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences, Vol. 373, Issue. 2055, p. 20140461.

    Phillips, James G. Sargeant, James Ogeil, Rowan P. Chow, Yang-Wai and Blaszczynski, Alex 2014. Self-Reported Gambling Problems and Digital Traces. Cyberpsychology, Behavior, and Social Networking, Vol. 17, Issue. 12, p. 742.

    Seshia, Shashi S. Makhinson, Michael Phillips, Dawn F. and Young, G. Bryan 2014. Evidence-informed person-centered healthcare part I: Do ‘cognitive biases plus’ at organizational levels influence quality of evidence?. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice, Vol. 20, Issue. 6, p. 734.


Mapping collective behavior in the big-data era

  • R. Alexander Bentley (a1), Michael J. O'Brien (a2) and William A. Brock (a3)
  • DOI:
  • Published online: 26 February 2014

The behavioral sciences have flourished by studying how traditional and/or rational behavior has been governed throughout most of human history by relatively well-informed individual and social learning. In the online age, however, social phenomena can occur with unprecedented scale and unpredictability, and individuals have access to social connections never before possible. Similarly, behavioral scientists now have access to “big data” sets – those from Twitter and Facebook, for example – that did not exist a few years ago. Studies of human dynamics based on these data sets are novel and exciting but, if not placed in context, can foster the misconception that mass-scale online behavior is all we need to understand, for example, how humans make decisions. To overcome that misconception, we draw on the field of discrete-choice theory to create a multiscale comparative “map” that, like a principal-components representation, captures the essence of decision making along two axes: (1) an east–west dimension that represents the degree to which an agent makes a decision independently versus one that is socially influenced, and (2) a north–south dimension that represents the degree to which there is transparency in the payoffs and risks associated with the decisions agents make. We divide the map into quadrants, each of which features a signature behavioral pattern. When taken together, the map and its signatures provide an easily understood empirical framework for evaluating how modern collective behavior may be changing in the digital age, including whether behavior is becoming more individualistic, as people seek out exactly what they want, or more social, as people become more inextricably linked, even “herdlike,” in their decision making. We believe the map will lead to many new testable hypotheses concerning human behavior as well as to similar applications throughout the social sciences.

Linked references
Hide All

This list contains references from the content that can be linked to their source. For a full set of references and notes please see the PDF or HTML where available.

P. M. Allen & J. M. McGlade (1986) Dynamics of discovery and exploitation: The case of the Scotian Shelf groundfish fisheries. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Science 43:1187–200.

A. Alvergne , E. Gurmu , M. A. Gibson & R. Mace (2011) Social transmission and the spread of modern contraception in rural Ethiopia. PLoS ONE 6(7):e22515.

R. R. N. Alves & I. M. L. Rosa (2007) Biodiversity, traditional medicine and public health: Where do they meet? Journal of Ethnobiology and Ethnomedicine 3:14.

C. L. Apicella , F. W. Marlowe , J. H. Fowler & N. A. Christakis (2012) Social networks and cooperation in hunter–gatherers. Nature 481:497501.

S. Aral & D. Walker (2012) Identifying influential and susceptible members of social networks. Science 337:337–41.

R. Arawatari (2009) Informatization, voter turnout and income inequality. Journal of Economic Inequality 7:2954.

C. Atkisson , M. J. O'Brien & A. Mesoudi (2012) Adult learners in a novel environment use prestige-biased social learning. Evolutionary Psychology 10:519–37.

B. R. Bates , S. Romina , R. Ahmed & D. Hopson (2006) The effect of source credibility on consumers' perceptions of the quality of health information on the Internet. Medical Informatics and the Internet in Medicine 31:4552.

M. Batty (2006) Rank clocks. Nature 444:592–96.

H. Belefant-Miller & D. W. King (2001) How, what, and why science faculty read. Science and Technology Libraries 19:91112.

E. G. Benotsch , S. Kalichman & L. S. Weinhardt (2004) HIV–AIDS patients' evaluations of health information on the Internet: The digital divide and vulnerability to fraudulent claims. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 72:1004–11.

R. A. Bentley , P. Garnett , M. J. O'Brien & W. A. Brock (2012) Word diffusion and climate science. PLoS ONE 7(11):e47966.

R. A. Bentley , C. P. Lipo , M. W. Hahn & H. A. Herzog (2007) Regular rates of popular culture change reflect random copying. Evolution and Human Behavior 28:151–58.

R. A. Bentley & H. D. G. Maschner (2000) A growing network of ideas. Fractals 8:227–37.

R. A. Bentley & M. J. O'Brien (2011) The selectivity of social learning and the tempo of cultural evolution. Journal of Evolutionary Psychology 9:125–41.

R. A. Bentley & P. Ormerod (2010) A rapid method for assessing social versus independent interest in health issues: A case study of “bird flu” and “swine flu”. Social Science and Medicine 71(3):482–85.

J. Berger & G. Le Mens (2009) How adoption speed affects the abandonment of cultural tastes. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 106:8146–50.

L. M. A. Bettencourt , J. Lobo , D. Helbing , C. Kühnert & G. B. West (2007a) Growth, innovation, scaling, and the pace of life in cities. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 104:7301–6.

J. S. Biermann , G. J. Golladay , M. L. V. H. Greenfield & L. H. Baker (1999) Evaluation of cancer information on the Internet. Cancer 86:381–90.

S. P. Borgatti , A. Mehra , D. J. Brass & G. Labianca (2009) Network analysis in the social sciences. Science 323:892–95.

W. A. Brock & S. N. Durlauf (1999) A formal model of theory choice in science. Economic Theory 14:113–30.

D. Centola (2010) The spread of behavior in an online social network experiment. Science 329:1194–97.

N. A. Christakis & J. H. Fowler (2007) The spread of obesity in a large social network over 32 years. New England Journal of Medicine 357:370–79.

A. Clauset , C. R. Shalizi & M. E. J. Newman (2009) Power-law distributions in empirical data. SIAM Review 51:661703.

I. D. Couzin , C. C. Ioannou , G. Demirel , T. Gross , C. J. Torney , A. Hartnett , L. Conradt , S. A. Levin & N. E. Leonard (2011) Uninformed individuals promote democratic consensus in animal groups. Science 334:1578–80.

I. D. Couzin , J. Krause , N. R. Franks & S. A. Levin (2005) Effective leadership and decision making in animal groups on the move. Nature 433:513–16.

D. J. de Sola Price (1965) Networks of scientific papers. Science 149:510–15.

P. S. Dodds & D. J. Watts (2005) A generalized model of social and biological contagion. Journal of Theoretical Biology 232:587604.

A. Dreber , D. G. Rand , D. Fudenberg & M. A. Nowak (2008) Winners don't punish. Nature 452:348–51.

R. I. M. Dunbar (1992) Neocortex size as a constraint on group size in primates. Journal of Human Evolution 22:469–93.

R. I. M. Dunbar (1993) Coevolution of neocortical size, group size and language in humans. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 16:681735.

S. Durlauf (1999) How can statistical mechanics contribute to social science? Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 96:10582–84.

S. Durlauf (2002) On the empirics of social capital. Economic Journal 112:F459–79.

K. Eriksson , M. Enquist & S. Ghirlanda (2007) Critical points in current theory of conformist social learning. Journal of Evolutionary Psychology 5:6787.

K. Eriksson , F. Jansson & J. Sjöstrand (2010) Bentley's conjecture on popularity toplist turnover under random copying. Ramanujan Journal 23:371–96.

J. A. Evans & J. G. Foster (2011) Metaknowledge. Science 331:721–25.

J. D. Farmer , P. Patelli & I. I. Zovko (2005) The predictive power of zero intelligence in financial markets. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 102:2254–59.

E. M. Fratkin (1989) Household variation and gender inequality in Ariaal Rendille pastoral production. American Anthropologist 91:4555.

H. R. George , V. Swami , P. L. Cornelissen & M. J. Tovee (2008) Preferences for body mass index and waist-to-hip ratio do not vary with observer age. Journal of Evolutionary Psychology 6:207–18.

H. Gintis (2007) A framework for the unification of the behavioral sciences. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 30(1):161.

S. A. Golder & M. W. Macy (2011) Diurnal and seasonal mood vary with work, sleep, and daylength across diverse cultures. Science 333:1878–81.

G. J. Goodhardt , A. S. C. Ehrenberg & C. Chatfield (1984) The Dirichlet: A comprehensive model of buying behaviour. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society A 147:621–55.

M. J. Hamilton , B. T. Milne , R. S. Walker , O. Burger & J. H. Brown (2007) The complex structure of hunter–gatherer social networks. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B 274:2195–202.

D. Helbing & W. Yu (2009) The outbreak of cooperation among success-driven individuals under noisy conditions. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 106:3680–85.

D. Helbing , I. Farkas & T. Vicsek (2000) Simulating dynamical features of escape panic. Nature 407:487–90.

J. Henrich (2004) Demography and cultural evolution: Why adaptive cultural processes produced maladaptive losses in Tasmania. American Antiquity 69:197214.

J. Henrich , and F. J. Gil-White (2001) The evolution of prestige: Freely conferred deference as a mechanism for enhancing the benefits of cultural transmission. Evolution and Human Behavior 22:165–96.

J. Henrich , R. Boyd , S. Bowles , C. Camerer , H. Gintis , R. McElreath & E. Fehr (2001) In search of Homo economicus: Experiments in 15 small-scale societies. American Economic Review 91:7379.

J. Henrich , S. J. Heine & A. Norenzayan (2010) The weirdest people in the world? Behavioral and Brain Sciences 33:61135.

J. Henrich , R. McElreath , A. Bar , J. Ensminger , C. Barrett , A. Bolyanatz , J. C. Cardenas , M. Gurven , E. Gwako , N. Henrich , C. Lesorogol , F. Marlowe , D. Tracer & J. Ziker (2006) Costly punishment across human societies. Science 312:1767–70.

C. M. Heyes (1994) Social learning in animals: Categories and mechanisms. Biological Reviews 69:207–31.

K. R. Hill , R. S. Walker , M. Božicčević , J. Eder , T. Headland , B. Hewlett , A. M. Hurtad , F. Marlowe , P. Wiessner & B. Wood (2011) Co-residence patterns in hunter–gatherer show unique human social structure. Science 331:1286–89.

R. A. Hill , R. A. Bentley & R. I. M. Dunbar (2008) Network scaling reveals consistent fractal pattern in hierarchical mammalian societies. Biology Letters 4:748–51.

J. J. Horton , D. G. Rand & R. J. Zeckhauser (2011) The online laboratory: Conducting experiments in a real labor market. Experimental Economics 14:399425.

D. Jones (2010) Human kinship, from conceptual structure to grammar. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 33:367416.

A. Kandler , K.N. Laland (2009) An investigation of the relationship between innovation and cultural diversity. Theoretical Population Biology 76:5967.

D. A. Kessler , Y. E. Maruvka , J. Ouren & N. M. Shnerb (2012) You name it – How memory and delay govern first name dynamics. PLoS ONE 7(6):e38790.

N. Kikumbih , K. Hanson , A. Mills , H. Mponda & J. A. Schellenberg (2005) The economics of social marketing: The case of mosquito nets in Tanzania. Social Science and Medicine 60:369–81.

D. Krakauer (2011) Darwinian demons, evolutionary complexity, and information maximization. Chaos 21:037110.

J. Laherrère & D. Sornette (1998) Stretched exponential distributions in nature and economy: “Fat tails” with characteristic scales. European Physical Journal B 2:525–39.

K. N. Laland (2004) Social learning strategies. Learning and Behavior 32:414.

K. N. Laland , F. J. Odling-Smee & S. Myles (2010) How culture shaped the human genome: Bringing genetics and the human sciences together. Nature Reviews Genetics 11:137–48.

A. P. Lenton , B. Fasolo & P. M. Todd (2008) “Shopping” for a mate: Expected vs. experienced preferences in online mate choice. IEEE Transactions on Professional Communication (Special Section: Darwinian Perspectives on Electronic Communication) 51:169–82.

A. P. Lenton , B. Fasolo & P. M. Todd (2009) The relationship between number of potential mates and mating skew in humans. Animal Behaviour 77:5560.

K. Lewis , M. Gonzalez & J. Kaufman (2011) Social selection and peer influence in an online social network. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 109:6872.

J. Li & L. Lee (2009) Binary choice under social interactions: An empirical study with and without subjective data on expectations. Journal of Applied Econometrics 24:257–81.

E. Lieberman , C. Hauert & M. A. Nowak (2005) Evolutionary dynamics on graphs. Nature 433:312–16.

E. Lieberman , J.-B. Michel , J. Jackson , T. Tang & M. A. Nowak (2007) Quantifying the evolutionary dynamics of language. Nature 449:713–16.

J. Lorenz , H. Rauhut , F. Schweitzer & D. Helbing (2011) How social influence can undermine the wisdom of crowd effect. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 108:9020–25.

R. Mace & H. Colleran (2009) Kin influence on the decision to start using modern contraception: A longitudinal study from rural Gambia. American Journal of Human Biology 21:472–77.

R. D. Malmgren , J. M. Ottino & L. A. Nunes Amaro (2010) The role of mentorship in protégé performance. Nature 465:622–26.

C. F. Manski (1993) Identification of endogenous social effects: The reflection problem. Review of Economic Studies 60:531–42.

E. Marshall (2000) Reinventing an ancient cure for malaria. Science 290:437–39.

A. P. Masucci , A. Kalampokis , V. Martínez Equíluz & E. Hernández-García (2011) Wikipedia information flow analysis reveals the scale-free architecture of the semantic space. PLoS ONE 6(2):e17333.

P. Mateos , P. A. Longley & D. O'Sullivan (2011) Ethnicity and population structure in personal naming networks. PLoS ONE 6(9):e22943.

D. L. McFadden (2001) Economic choices. American Economic Review 91:351–78.

A. Mesoudi (2008) An experimental simulation of the “copy-successful-individuals” cultural learning strategy: Adaptive landscapes, producer–scrounger dynamics, and informational access costs. Evolution and Human Behavior 29:350–63.

A. Mesoudi (2011) Cultural evolution: How Darwinian theory can explain human culture and synthesize the social sciences. University of Chicago Press.

D. Nettle (2010) Understanding of evolution may be improved by thinking about people. Evolutionary Psychology 8:205–28.

M. E. J. Newman (2005) Power laws, Pareto distributions and Zipf's law. Contemporary Physics 46:323–51.

M. J. O'Brien & R. A. Bentley (2011) Stimulated variation and cascades: Two processes in the evolution of complex technological systems. Journal of Archaeological Method and Theory 18:309–35.

J.-P. Onnela & F. Reed-Tsochas (2010) Spontaneous emergence of social influence in online systems. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 107:18375–80.

K. Ouattara , A. Lemasson & K Zuberbühler (2009) Campbell's monkeys use affixation to alter call meaning. PLoS ONE 4(11):e7808.

T. Postmes , R. Spears & S. Cihangir (2001) Quality of decision making and group norms. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 80:918–30.

A. Powell , S. Shennan & M. G. Thomas (2009) Late Pleistocene demography and the appearance of modern human behavior. Science 324:1298–301.

D. G. Rand , A. Dreber , T. Ellingsen , D. Fudenberg & M. A. Nowak (2009) Positive interactions promote public cooperation. Science 325:1272–75.

F. Reali & T. L. Griffiths (2010) Words as alleles: Connecting language evolution with Bayesian learners to models of genetic drift. Proceedings of the Royal Society B 277:429–36.

L. Rendell , L. Fogarty , W. J. E. Hoppitt , T. J. H. Morgan , M. M. Webster & K. N. Laland (2011) Cognitive culture: Theoretical and empirical insights into social learning strategies. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 15:6876.

M. J. Salganik , P. S. Dodds & D. J. Watts (2006) Experimental study of inequality and unpredictability in an artificial cultural market. Science 311(5762):854–56. doi:10.1126/science.1121066.

P. C. Salzman (1999) Is inequality universal? Current Anthropology 40:3161.

A. Sela & J. Berger (2012) Decision quicksand: How trivial choices suck us in. Journal of Consumer Research 39:360–70.

C. R. Shalizi & A. C. Thomas (2010) Homophily and contagion are genetically confounded in observational social network studies. Sociological Methods and Research 40:211–39.

S. J. Shennan (2000) Population, culture history and the dynamics of culture change. Current Anthropology 41:811–35.

H. A. Simon (1955) A behavioral model of rational choice. Quarterly Journal of Economics 69:99118.

B. Sparrow , J. Liu & D. M. Wegner (2011) Google effects on memory: Cognitive consequences of having information at our fingertips. Science 333:776–78.

M. J. Stringer , M. Sales-Pardo & L. A. N. Amaral (2010) Statistical validation of a global model for the distribution of the ultimate number of citations accrued by papers published in a scientific journal. Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology 61:1377–85.

D. Sumecki , M. Chipulu & U. Ojiako (2011) Email overload: Exploring the moderating role of the perception of email as a “business critical” tool. International Journal of Information Management 31:407–14.

M. Tomasello , M. Carpenter , J. Call , T. Behne & H. Moll (2005) Understanding and sharing intentions: The origins of cultural cognition. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 28:675735.

J. Twenge , K. W. Campbell & B. Gentile (2012) Increases in individualistic words and phrases in American books, 19602008. PLoS ONE 7(7):e40181.

C. Venditti , A. Meade & M. Pagel (2010) Phylogenies reveal new interpretation of speciation and the Red Queen. Nature 463:349–52.

B. Viswanath , A. Mislove , M. Cha & K. P. Gummadi (2009) On the evolution of user interaction in Facebook. In: Proceedings of the 2nd ACM Workshop on Online Social Networks, ed. J. Crowcroft & B. Krishnamurthy, pp. 3742. Association for Computing Machinery.

R. A. Voeks (1996) Tropical forest healers and habitat preference. Economic Botany 50:381400.

D. M. Wegner (1995) A computer network model of human transactive memory. Social Cognition 13:319–39.

B. Winterhalder , D. J. Kennett , M. N. Grote & J. Bartruff (2010) Ideal free settlement of California's Northern Channel Islands. Journal of Anthropological Archaeology 29:469–90.

F. Wu & B. A. Huberman (2007) Novelty and collective attention. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 104:17599–601.

G. U. Yule (1924) A mathematical theory of evolution based on the conclusions of Dr. J. C. Willis. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B 213:2187.

L. S. Zun , D. N. Blume , J. Lester , G. Simpson & L. Downey (2004) Accuracy of emergency medical information on the web. American Journal of Emergency Medicine 22:9497.

Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Behavioral and Brain Sciences
  • ISSN: 0140-525X
  • EISSN: 1469-1825
  • URL: /core/journals/behavioral-and-brain-sciences
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


This erratum applies to the following article(s)