Skip to main content

Political Journalism Represented by Headline News: Canadian Public and Commercial Media Compared

  • Blake Andrew (a1)

Abstract. Headlines play a key role in influencing how and about what citizens are informed. In news media, their task is threefold: to represent stories, signal informational hierarchy and draw publicity for (or sell) what follows. This article examines the representative dimension of headline news content for the 2006 Canadian federal election campaign, testing whether public media headlines more faithfully reflected story-level coverage than commercial media. Comparing both public and commercial media coverage of this watershed election presents a unique opportunity to assess whether the overarching macro-incentive of commercial media—profit-making—may have influenced micro-level relationships between headlines and stories. Results of 55-day multiplatform analysis (N = 11,002) involving CBC election media and 12 commercial newsrooms reveal few differences with respect the representativeness of headlines from public and commercial media, save for the presence of journalists' opinion in headline content.

Résumé. Les titres influencent comment les citoyens sont informés, et à propos de quoi ils en pensent. Les titres ont trois objectifs dans les nouvelles : ils résument les nouvelles, signalent quelles nouvelles sont les plus importantes, et vendre l'histoire complète qui suit. L'article examine le niveau de représentativité des titres dans les nouvelles sur la campagne de l'élection fédérale canadienne de 2006. Plus précisément, il teste si les titres venant des médias publics sont plus représentatifs que les nouvelles dans le média commercial. En comparant la couverture médiatique dans cette élection structurante, nous explorons si la motivation des médias commerciaux, notamment le profit, peut influencer le lien entre les titres et les articles. Les résultats de l'analyse multiplateforme de la campagne qui durait 55 jours (N = 11 002) incluent la couverture sur la CBC et 12 médias commerciaux. Ils indiquent qu'il n'y a pas beaucoup de différence dans la représentativité des titres entre les sources publiques et commerciales, sauf la présence de l'opinion dans le contenu des titres.

Corresponding author
Blake Andrew, Département de science politique, Université de Montréal, CP 6128, Succ. Centre-ville, Montreal QC H3C 3J7,
Hide All
Aalberg Toril, van Aelst Peter and Curran James. 2010. “Media Systems and the Political Information Environment: A Cross-National Comparison.” International Journal of Press/Politics 15 (3): 255–71.
Aarts Kees and Semetko Holli A.. 2003. “The Divided Electorate: Media Use and Political Involvement.” Journal of Politics 65 (3): 759–84.
Althaus Scott L., Edy Jill A. and Phalen Patricia F.. 2001. “Using Substitutes for Full-Text News Stories in Content Analysis: Which Text Is Best?American Journal of Political Science 45 (3): 707–23.
Althaus Scott L., Edy Jill A. and Phalen Patricia F.. 2002. “Using the Vanderbilt Television Abstracts to Track Broadcast News Content: Possibilities and Pitfalls.” Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media 46 (3): 473–92.
Andrew Blake C. 2007. “Media-Generated Shortcuts: Do Newspaper Headlines Present Another Roadblock for Low Information Rationality?International Journal of Press/Politics 12 (2): 2444.
Bardoel Johannes and d'Haenens Leen. 2008. “Reinventing Public Service Broadcasting in Europe: Prospects, Promises and Problems.” Media, Culture & Society 30 (3): 337–55.
Barnhurst Kevin G. 1994. Seeing the Newspaper. New York: St. Martin's Press.
Bell Allan. 1991. The Language of News Media. Oxford: Blackwell.
Bennett Lance and Iyengar Shanto. 2008. “A New Era of Minimal Effects: The Changing Foundations of Political Communication.” Journal of Communication 58 (4): 707–31.
Brants Kees. 2003. “Auditing Public Broadcasting Performance: Its Theory and Practice.” Javnost 10 (3): 511.
Canada. Parliament. 1991. Broadcasting Act (S.C. 1991, c. 11). (June 12, 2013).
Cappella Joseph N. and Jamieson Kathleen Hall. 1997. Spiral of Cynicism: The Press and the Public Good. New York: Oxford University Press.
Caulfield Timothy and Bubela Tania. 2004. “Media Representations of Genetic Discoveries: Hype in the Headlines?Health Law Review 12 (2): 5361.
CBC/Radio Canada. 2007. Annual Report of CBC/Radio-Canada 2007–2008. (June 12, 2013).
Condit Celeste M., Alex Ferguson Rachel Kassel, Chitra Thadhani Holly Catherine Gooding Roxanne Parrott. 2001. “An Exploratory Study of the Impact of News Headlines on Genetic Determinism.” Science Communication 22 (4): 379–95.
Connolly Sara and Hargreaves-Heap Shaun P.. 2007. “Cross Country Differences in Trust in Television and the Governance of Public Broadcasters.” Kyklos 60 (1): 314.
Dalton Russell J. and Wattenberg Martin P.. 2001. Parties without Partisans: Political Change in Advanced Industrial Democracies. New York: Oxford University Press.
Debrett Mary. 2009. “Riding the Wave: Public Service Television in the Multi-Platform Era.” Media, Culture and Society 31 (5): 807–27.
Eveland William P. Jr. and Dunwoody Sharon. 2002. “An Investigation of Elaboration and Selective Scanning as Mediators of Learning from the Web versus Print.” Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media 46 (1): 3453.
Fenichel Michael and Dan Peter. 1980. “Heads from Post and Times on Three-Mile Island.” Journalism Quarterly 57 (2): 338–39.
Fletcher Frederick J. 1991. Reporting the Campaign: Election Coverage in Canada. Toronto: Dundurn.
Flynn James, Peters Ellen, Mertz C. K. and Slovic Paul. 1998. “Risk, Media, and Stigma at Rocky Flats.” Risk Analysis 18 (6): 715–27.
Fowler Linda L. and Lawless Jennifer L.. 2009. “Looking for Sex in All the Wrong Places: Press Coverage and the Electoral Fortunes of Gubernatorial Candidates.” Perspectives on Politics 7 (3): 519–36.
Gandy Oscar H. Jr., Kopp Katharina, Hands Tanya, Frazer Karen and Phillips David. 1997. “Race and Risk: Factors Affecting the Framing of Stories about Inequality, Discrimination, and Just Plain Bad Luck.” Public Opinion Quarterly 61 (1): 158–82.
Garcia Mario R. and Stark Pegie. 1991. Eyes on the News. St. Petersburg: Poynter.
Garst Robert and Bernstein Theodore. 1961. Headlines and Deadlines: A Manual for Copy Editors. 3rd ed. New York: Columbia University Press.
Geer John G. and Kahn Kim F.. 1993. “Grabbing Attention: An Experimental Investigation of Headlines during Campaigns.” Political Communication 10 (2): 175–91.
Graber Doris A. 1988. Processing the News: How People Tame the Information Tide. 2nd ed. New York: Longman.
Gunter Barrie. 1987. Poor Reception: Misunderstanding and Forgetting Broadcast News. Hillsdale: Erlbaum.
Hallin Daniel C. and Mancini Paolo. 2004. Comparing Media Systems: Three Models of Media and Politics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Hamilton James T. 2004. All the News That's Fit to Sell. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Hamilton James T. 2010. “The (Many) Markets for International News: How News from Abroad Sells at Home.” Journalism Studies 11 (5): 650–66.
Hanretty Chris. 2010. “Explaining the De Facto Independence of Public Broadcasters.” British Journal of Political Science 40 (1): 7589.
Hayes Danny and Guardino Matt. 2010. “Whose Views Made the News? Media Coverage and the March to War in Iraq.” Political Communication 27 (1): 5987.
Holtz-Bacha Christina, and Norris Pippa. 2001. ““To Entertain, Inform, and Educate”: Still the Role of Public Television.” Political Communication 18 (2): 123–40.
Iyengar Shanto, Curran James, Lund Anker Brink, Salovaara-Moring Inka, Hahn Kyu S. and Coen Sharon. 2010. “Cross-National versus Individual-Level Differences in Political Information: A Media Systems Perspective.” Journal of Elections, Public Opinion and Parties 20 (3): 291309.
Iyengar Shanto, Hahn Kyu S., Bonfadelli Heinz and Marr Mirko. 2009. “‘Dark Areas of Ignorance’ Revisited: Comparing International Affairs Knowledge in Switzerland and the United States.” Communication Research 36 (3): 341–58.
Kolmer Christian and Semetko Holli A.. 2010. “International Television News: Germany Compared.” Journalism Studies 11 (5): 700717.
Larsen Håkon. 2010. “Legitimation Strategies of Public Service Broadcasters: The Divergent Rhetoric in Norway and Sweden.” Media, Culture and Society 32 (2): 267–83.
León José. 1997. “The Effects of Headlines and Summaries on News Comprehension and Recall.” Reading and Writing: An Interdisciplinary Journal 9 (2): 85106.
Marcotte Philippe and Bastien Frédérick. 2012. “L'influence du mode de financement des médias audiovisuels sur le cadrage des campagnes: le cas des élections canadiennes de 2005–2006 et 2008.” Canadian Journal of Political Science 45 (2): 313–36.
Marquez F.T. 1980. “How Accurate Are the Headlines.” Journal of Communication 30 (3): 3036.
McCombs Maxwell E. and Shaw Donald L.. 1972. “The Agenda-Setting Function of Mass Media.” The Public Opinion Quarterly 36 (2): 176–87.
McManus John. 1994. Market-Driven Journalism: Let the Citizen Beware. Thousand Oaks: Sage.
Mindich David T. Z. 1998. Just the Facts: How “Objectivity” Came to Define American Journalism. New York: New York University Press.
Niven David. 2002. Tilt? The Search for Media Bias. Westport: Praeger.
Norris Pippa. 2000. A Virtuous Circle: Political Communications in Postindustrial Societies. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Patterson Thomas E. 1994. Out of Order. New York: Random House.
Peter Jochen and de Vreese Claes H.. 2004. “In Search of Europe: A Cross-National Comparative Study of the European Union in National Television News.” International Journal of Press/Politics 9 (4): 324.
Pfau Michael R. 1995. “Covering Urban Unrest: The Headline Says It All.” Journal of Urban Affairs 17 (2): 131–41.
Popescu Marina, and Toka Gabor. 2009. “Public Television, Private Television and Citizens' Political Knowledge.” EUI Working Papers RSCAS 66.
Raboy Marc. 1996. “Canada: The Hybridization of Public Broadcasting.” In Public Broadcasting for the 21st Century, ed. Raboy Marc. Luton: University of Luton Press.
Riffe Daniel, Lacy Stephen and Fico Frederick. 2005. Analyzing Media Messages: Using Quantitative Content Analysis in Research. 2nd ed. Mahwah: Lawrence Erlbaum.
Rosenstiel Tom, Just Marion, Belt Todd, Dean Walter and Chinni Dante. 2007. We Interrupt This Newscast: How to Improve Local News and Win Ratings, Too. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Schudson Michael. 1978. Discovering the News: A Social History of American Newspapers. New York: Basic Books.
Smith Ted J. III, and Verrall Derek O.. 1985. “A Critical Analysis of Australian Television Coverage of Election Opinion Polls.” Public Opinion Quarterly 49 (1): 5879.
Soroka Stuart. 2002. Agenda-Setting Dynamics in Canada. Vancouver: UBC Press.
Soroka Stuart, Andrew Blake, Aalberg Toril, Iyengar Shanto, Curran James, Coen Sharon, Hayashi Kaori, Jones Paul, Mazzoleni Gianpetro, Rhee June Woong, Rowe David and Tiffen Rod. 2012. “Auntie Knows Best: Public Broadcasters and Current Affairs Knowledge.” British Journal of Political Science FirstView (June 12, 2013).
Stamm Keith R. and Jacoubovitch M. Daniel. 1980. “How Much Do They Read in the Daily Newspaper: A Measurement.” Journalism Quarterly 57 (2): 234–42.
Tannenbaum Percy H. 1953. “The Effect of Headlines on the Interpretation of News Stories.” Journalism Quarterly 30: 189–97.
Trimble Linda and Sampert Shannon. 2004. “Who's in the Game? Framing of the Canadian Election 2000 by The Globe and Mail and The National Post.” Canadian Journal of Political Science 37 (1): 5171.
Valentino Nicolas A., Banks Antoine J., Hutchings Vincent L. and Davis Anne K.. 2009. “Selective Exposure in the Internet Age: The Interaction between Anxiety and Information Utility.” Political Psychology 30 (4): 591613.
van Dijk Teun A. 1988. News as Discourse. Hillsdale: Lawrence Erlbaum.
Waddell Christopher and Dornan Chris. 2006. “The Media and the Campaign.” In The Canadian Federal Election of 2006, ed. Dornan Chris and Pammett Jon H.. Toronto: Dundurn.
Wattenberg Martin P. 1998. The Decline of American Political Parties, 1952–1996. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
West Darrell M. 1994. “Political Advertising and News Coverage in the 1992 California U.S. Senate Campaigns.” The Journal of Politics 56 (4): 1053–75.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Canadian Journal of Political Science/Revue canadienne de science politique
  • ISSN: 0008-4239
  • EISSN: 1744-9324
  • URL: /core/journals/canadian-journal-of-political-science-revue-canadienne-de-science-politique
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 11
Total number of PDF views: 62 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 230 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 23rd November 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.