Skip to main content Accessibility help

Britain's Productivity Gap in the 1930s: Some Neglected Factors

  • S. N. Broadberry (a1) and N. F. R. Crafts (a1)

This article proposes a reinterpretation of the failure of interwar British productivity levels to match those of the United States. We argue that key elements in poor British productivity performance included inadequate human capital, a bargaining environment that allowed workers to maintain restrictive practices, and collusive agreements that limited the exit of inefficient firms. We suggest that weaknesses in the structure of British firms pointed out by Chandler and his followers have been overemphasized and that more attention should be given to the role of the market environment in determining the conduct of business.

Hide All
Abramovitz, Moses, “Catching Up, Forging Ahead, and Falling Behind,” this Journal, 46 (06 1986), pp. 385406.
Anglo-American Council on Productivity, Rayon Weaving (London, 1949).
Anglo-American Council on Productivity, Building (London, 1950).
Anglo-American Council on Productivity, Final Report (London, 1952).
Bain, George S., and Price, Robert, Profiles of Union Growth: A Comparative Statistical Portrait of Eight Industrial Countries (Oxford, 1980).
Barnett, Correlli, The Audit of War: The Illusion and Reality of Britain as a Great Nation (London, 1986).
Batstone, Eric, The Reform of Workplace Industrial Relations (Oxford, 1988).
Bean, Charles, and Symons, James, “Ten years of Mrs T” (Centre for Economic Policy Research Discussion Paper No. 316, London, 1989).
Beck, Geraldine M., A Survey of British Employment and Unemployment (Oxford, 1951).
Board of Trade, Survey of International Cartels and Internal Cartels, Vol. 2: Internal Cartels (London, 1946).
Broadberry, S. N., and Crafts, N. F. R., “The Implications of British Macroeconomic Policy in the 1930s for Long Run Growth Performance,” Rivista di Storia Economica, 7 (02 1990), pp. 119.
Broadberry, S. N., and Crafts, N. F. R., “Explaining Anglo-American Productivity Differences in the Mid-Twentieth Century,” Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics, 52 (11 1990), pp. 375402.
Broadberry, S. N., and Fremdling, R., “Comparative Productivity in British and German Industry, 1907–37,” Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics, 52 (11 1990), pp. 403–21.
Carruth, Alan A., and Oswald, Andrew J., Pay Determination and Industrial Prosperity (Oxford, 1989).
Chandler, Alfred D., Scale and Scope (Cambridge, MA, 1990).
Channon, Derek F., The Strategy and Structure of British Enterprise (London, 1973).
Clegg, Hugh, “Restrictive Practices,” Socialist Commentary (12 1964), pp. 911.
Cohen, Ruth, “The Soap Industry,” in Cook, P. Lesley, ed., Effects of Mergers: Six Case Studies (London, 1958), pp. 215–73.
Coleman, Donald C., and MacLeod, Christine, “Attitudes to New Techniques: British Businessmen, 1800–1950,” Economic History Review, 39 (11 1986), pp. 588611.
Cook, P. Lesley, Effects of Mergers: Six Case Studies (London, 1958).
Cowling, Keith, Monopoly Capitalism (London, 1982).
Cowling, Keith et al. , Mergers and Economic Performance (Cambridge, 1980).
Crafts, N. F. R., “Economic Growth,” in Crafts, N. F. R. and Woodward, N. W. C., eds., The British Economy Since 1945 (Oxford, 1991), pp. 261–90.
Crafts, N. F. R., Leybourne, S. J., and Mills, T. C., “The Climacteric in Late Victorian Britain and France: A Reappraisal of the Evidence,” Journal of Applied Econometrics, 4 (04 1989), pp. 103–17.
Crafts, N. F. R., and Thomas, Mark, “Comparative Advantage in UK Manufacturing Trade, 1910–1935,” Economic Journal, 96 (09 1986), pp. 629–45.
Daly, Anne, Hitchens, David M., and Wagner, Karin, “Productivity, Machinery and Skills in a Sample of British and German Manufacturing p1ants,” National Institute Economic Review, 111 (02 1985), pp. 4861.
David, Paul A., “Computer and Dynamo: The Modern Productivity Paradox in a Not-Too-Distant Mirror” (Economic Research Paper No. 339, University of Warwick, 1989).
Delamotte, Y., The Social Partners Face the Problems of Productivity and Employment (Paris, 1971).
Department of Employment, Employment Gazette (London, 1990).
Dunning, John H., American Investment in British Manufacturing Industry (London, 1958).
Dyas, Gareth P., and Thanheiser, Heinz T., The Emerging European Enterprise (London, 1976).
Elbaum, Bernard, and Lazonick, William, eds., The Decline of the British Economy (Oxford, 1986).
Elliott, D. C., and Gribbin, J. Dennis, “The Abolition of Cartels and Structural Change in the United Kingdom,” in Jacquemin, A. P. and Jong, H. W. de, eds., Welfare Aspects of Industrial Markets (Leiden, Netherlands, 1977), pp. 345–65.
Flanagan, Robert, Soskice, David W., and Ulman, Lloyd, Unionism, Economic Stabilization and Incomes Policies: The European Experience (Washington, DC, 1983).
Flanders, Alan, The Fawley Productivity Agreements (London, 1964).
Frankel, M., British and American Manufacturing Productivity (Urbana, IL, 1957).
Franks, Julian, and Harris, Robert, “Shareholder Wealth Effects of Corporate Takeovers: The UK Experience, 1955–85” (London Business School Working Paper, 1986).
Gourvish, Terence R., “British Business and the Transition to a Corporate Economy: Entrepreneurship and Management Structures,” Business History, 29 (12 1987), pp. 1845.
Gribbin, J. Dennis, “The Postwar Revival of Competition as Industrial Policy” (Government Economic Service Working Paper No. 19, London, 1978).
Hannah, Leslie, The Rise of the Corporate Economy (2nd edn., London, 1983).
Hawley, E. W., The New Deal and the Problem of Monopoly (Princeton, 1966).
Hexner, E., The International Steel Cartel (Chapel Hill, NC, 1943).
Howard, J. A., “Collusive Behavior,” Journal of Business, 27 (07 1954), pp. 196204.
Hutchinson, H., Tariff-Making and Industrial Reconstruction (London, 1965).
Hutton, Graham, We Too Can Prosper (London, 1953).
Jones, R., and Marriott, O., Anatomy of a Merger: A History of GEC, AEI and English Electric (London, 1970).
Kaysen, C., and Turner, D. F., Antitrust Policy: An Economic and Legal Analysis (Cambridge, MA, 1959).
Kirby, Maurice W., “Supply-Side Management,” in Crafts, N. F. R. and Woodward, N. W. C., eds., The British Economy Since 1945 (Oxford, 1991), pp. 236–60.
Kravis, Irving B., Heston, Alan, and Summers, Robert, World Product and Income: International Comparisons of Real Gross Product (Baltimore, 1982).
Landes, David S., The Unbound Prometheus (Cambridge, 1969).
Leak, H., and Maizels, A., “The Structure of British Industry,” Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, 108 (Part 1–2, 1945), pp. 142–99.
Lewchuk, Wayne, “Fordist Technology and Britain: The Diffusion of Labor Speed-Up” (Economic Research Paper No. 340, University of Warwick, 1989).
Lucas, Robert E., “On the Mechanics of Economic Development,” Journal of Monetary Economics, 22 (08 1988), pp. 342.
Lupton, Tom, On the Shop Floor (Oxford, 1963).
McCloskey, Donald N., “Did Victorian Britain Fail?Economic History Review, 23 (12 1970), pp. 446–59.
McCloskey, Donald N., Economic Maturity and Entrepreneurial Decline: British Iron and Steel, 1870–1913 (Cambridge, MA, 1973).
Machin, Steven, and Wadhwani, Sushil, “The Effects of Unions on Organisational Change, Investment and Employment: Evidence from WIRS” (Centre for Labor Economics Discussion Paper No. 355, London School of Economics, 1989).
McKinlay, Alan, “Employers and Skilled Labour in the Interwar Depression: Engineering and Shipbuilding on Clydeside, 1919–1939” (D.Phil, thesis, Oxford University, 1986).
Mathias, Peter, Retailing Revolution: A History of Multiple Retailing in the Food Trades Based Upon the Allied Suppliers Group of Companies (London, 1967).
Matthews, Kent G. P., The Interwar Economy: An Equilibrium Analysis (Aldershot, England, 1986).
Matthews, Robin C. O., Feinstein, Charles H., and Odling-Smee, John C., British Economic Growth, 1856–1973 (Oxford, 1982).
Meeks, Geoffrey, Disappointing Marriage: A Study of the Gains from Merger (Cambridge, 1977).
Mercer, Helen, “The Evolution of British Government Policy Towards Competition in Private Industry, 1940–1956” (Ph.D. thesis, London School of Economics, 1989).
Metcalf, David, “Water Notes Dry Up,” British Journal of Industrial Relations, 27 (03 1989), pp. 131.
Middlemas, Keith, Power, Competition and the State (London, 1986).
Ministry of Works, Cement Costs (London, 1947).
Monopolies and Restrictive Practices Commission, The Supply of Electric Lamps (London, 1951).
Morris, Derek J., and Stout, David K., “Industrial Policy,” in Morris, Derek J., ed., The Economic System in the UK (3rd edn., Oxford, 1985), pp. 851–94.
Neale, Alan D., The Antitrust Laws of the United States of America (2nd edn., Cambridge, 1970).
Nickell, Stephen, Wadhwani, Sushil, and Wall, M., “Unions and Productivity Growth in Britain, 1974–1986: Evidence from UK Company Accounts” (Centre for Labor Economics Discussion Paper No. 353, London School of Economics, 1989).
Paige, D., and Bombach, G., A Comparison of National Output and Productivity of the United Kingdom and the United States (Paris, 1959).
Pollard, Sidney, The Development of the British Economy, 1914–1980 (3rd edn., London, 1983).
Prais, S. J., Productivity and Industrial Structure (Cambridge, 1981).
Reader, William J., Unilever: A Short History (London, 1960).
Reader, William J., Metal Box: A History (London, 1976).
Richardson, Harry W., Economic Recovery in Britain, 1932–1939 (London, 1967).
Romer, Paul M., “Human Capital and Growth: Theory and Evidence” (Carnegie-Rochester Conference Series on Public Policy No. 32, 1990), pp. 337–67.
Rostas, L., Comparative Productivity in British and American Industry (Cambridge, 1948).
Rostas, L., Productivity, Prices and Distribution in Selected British Industries (Cambridge, 1948).
Salter, W. E. G., Productivity and Technical Change (Cambridge, 1960).
Sandberg, Lars G., “The Entrepreneur and Technical Change,” in Floud, Roderick C. and McCloskey, Donald N., eds., The Economic History of Britain Since 1700, Vol. 2 (Cambridge, 1981), pp. 99120.
Sanderson, Michael, “Education and Economic Decline, 1890 to the 1980s,” Oxford Review of Economic Policy, 4 (Spring 1988), pp. 3850.
Scherer, F. M., Industrial Market Structure and Economic Performance (2nd edn., Boston, 1980).
Schumpeter, Joseph A., Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy (London, 1943).
Scott, W. H. et al. , Technical Change and Industrial Relations (Liverpool, 1956).
Shaw, Richard W., and Sutton, Clive J., Industry and Competition: Industry Case Studies (London, 1976).
Shepherd, William G., “Causes of Increased Competition in the US Economy, 1939–1980,” Review of Economics and Statistics, 64 (11 1982), pp. 613–26.
Silberston, Aubrey, “Industrial Policies in Britain, 1960–1980,” in Carter, Charles, ed., Industrial Policy and Innovation (London, 1981), pp. 3951.
Steer, Peter, and Cable, John R., “Internal Organisation and Profit: An Empirical Analysis of Large UK Companies,” Journal of Industrial Economics, 27 (09 1978), pp. 1330.
Supple, Barry E., The History of the British Coal Industry: Vol. 4, 1913–1946 (Oxford, 1987).
Tolliday, Steven, Business, Banking and Politics: The Case of British Steel, 1918–1939 (Cambridge, MA, 1987).
Ark, Van Bart, “Comparative Levels of Labor Productivity in Postwar Europe: Some Evidence for Manufacturing,” Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics, 52 (11 1990), pp. 343–74.
Wadhwani, Sushil, “The Effect of Unions on Productivity Growth, Investment and Employment: A Report on Some Recent Work” (Centre for Labor Economics Discussion Paper No. 356, London School of Economics, 1989).
Walshe, J. Grahame, “Industrial Organisation and Competition Policy,” in Crafts, N. F. R. and Woodward, N. W. C., eds., The British Economy Since 1945 (Oxford, 1991), pp. 335–80.
Webb, Steven, “Tariffs, Cartels, Technology, and Growth in the German Steel Industry, 1879 to 1914,” this Journal, 40 (06 1980), pp. 309–29.
Wilkinson, Frank, “Industrial Relations and Industrial Decline: The Case of the British Iron and Steel Industry, 1870–1930” (Department of Applied Economics Working Paper No. 8915, University of Cambridge, 1989).
Williams, B. R., “The Building Materials Industry,” in Burn, Duncan, ed., The Structure of British Industry: A Symposium (Cambridge, 1958), vol. 1, pp. 309–58.
Wilson, Charles, The History of Unilever: A Study of Economic Growth and Social Change (London, 1954).
Zweig, F., Productivity and Trade Unions (Oxford, 1951).
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

The Journal of Economic History
  • ISSN: 0022-0507
  • EISSN: 1471-6372
  • URL: /core/journals/journal-of-economic-history
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed