Hostname: page-component-7c8c6479df-995ml Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-03-18T20:24:00.645Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

‘A Moment of Truth’? The Church and Political Change in Malawi, 1992

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 November 2008

Extract

The immediate origins of the democratic elections held in Malawi in 1994, which brought to an end over 30 years of political dominance by President Kamuzu Banda and the Malawi Congress Party (MCP), lie in the unprecedented events which shook the entire nation in 1992. Although that turbulent year was characterised by industrial action, serious urban riots, student demonstrations, the emergence of new domestic political groupings, and the Government's agreement to hold a national referendum on the future of the one-party system in the country, in retrospect perhaps what was most remarkable about these developments was that they were sparked off by the Catholic Church, and that their momentum was sustained at crucial stages by other Christian denominations in Malawi.1

Type
Articles
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1995

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 The influence of Christian churches in the contemporary democratic transformation of much of Africa has yet to be properly addressed by scholars, although the evidence is mounting that they are continuing to play a significant rôle. For the reported pressure placed upon the régime in Maputo by the Vatican prior to the national elections in Mozambique, , see The Herald (Harare), 17 11 1994.Google Scholar

2 Decalo, Samuel, Psychoses of Power: African personal dictatorships (Boulder and London, 1989), p. 180.Google Scholar

3 Rotberg, Robert I., ‘South Africa's Regional Hegemony’, in Bloomfield, Richard J. (ed.), Regional Conflict and U.S. Policy: Angola and Mozambique (Algonac, MI, 1988), pp. 81–2.Google Scholar

4 Africa South of the Sahara, 1994 (London, 1993), p. 96.Google Scholar

5 Africa Confidential (London), 32, 25, 1991.Google Scholar

6 ‘Joint Report of the Board of World Mission and Unity and the Church and Nation Committee to the General Assembly [of the Church of Scotland] on the Situation in Malawi’, 19 May 1992. See also, The Independent (Blantyre), 21–27 07 1993.Google Scholar

7 Woods, Tony, ‘The High Costs of Obstinacy: Banda hangs on’, in Southern Africa Report (Toronto), 11 1992, p. 21.Google Scholar

8 The Malawi Financial Post (Blantyre), 19–30 05 and 30 06–6 07 1993.Google Scholar

9 The Watchers (Blantyre), 07 1993.Google Scholar

10 The Monitor (Blantyre), 14 07 1993.Google Scholar

11 Africa Confidential, 32, 5, 1991.Google Scholar

12 Lwanda, John, Kamuzu Banda of Malawi: a study in promise, power and paralysis (Glasgow, Dudu Nsomba Publications, 1993), p. 290.Google Scholar

13 Africa Confidential, 30, 13, 3 07 1992.Google Scholar

14 According to a report in ibid. 33, 10, 22 March 1992, a deputation of army officers saw the President in April 1992 and explained that they would not be prepared to undertake policing duties against Malawians calling for democratic reforms.

15 Msisha, Modecai, ‘The Current Political Situation in Malawi’, in Southern Africa Political and Economic Monthly (Harare), 6, 3–4, 19921993, p. 51.Google Scholar

16 Quoted in Woods, loc. cit. p. 17.

17 Anonymous Letter addressed to Heads of Department at Chancellor College, Zomba, 19 February 1992. According to Lwanda, op. cit. 294, an underground political movement had been functioning inside Malawi since August 1991.

18 ‘Joint Report of the Board of World Mission and Unity’, 19 May 1992.

19 The precise extent of abuses of human rights in Malawi has always been difficult to ascertain, but the fact that they were widely believed to be numerous by Malawians themselves was important. However, documented cases are widely available. See, for example, Africa Confidential, 24, 11, 1983, and 30, 25, 1989.Google Scholar

20 Malawi: a Moment of Truth (London, Catholic Institute for International Relations, 1993), p. 22.Google Scholar

21 See Kyambalesa, Henry, ‘The Religious Dimension in Politics after the Cold War’, in Southern Africa Political and Economic Monthly, 7, 12, 09 1994, pp. 36 and 38, note 8, for examples of the Catholic Church's involvement in politics in Africa.Google Scholar

22 See ‘Choosing Our Future. Pastoral Letter to the Catholic Faithful on the Occasion of the National Referendum, 1993’, Episcopal Conference of Malawi, Blantyre, p. 4.

23 Rt. Rev. DrKalilombe, P. A., ‘Pastors for the Third Millennium in Southern Africa’, in Association of Theological Institutions in Southern and Central Africa, ATISCA Bulletin (Balaka), I, 1992, p. 13.Google Scholar

24 ‘The Concluding Statement of the Conference’, in ibid. p. 26.

25 Malawi: a Moment of Truth, p. 23.

26 Ross, K. R., Presbyterian Theology and Participatory Democracy (Saint Andrews Press, Church of Scotland, Board of World Mission and Unity, 1993), p. 1.Google Scholar

27 The signatories of the Pastoral Letter were: Archbishop J. Chiona (Blantyre), Bishops F. Mkhori (Chikwawa), M. A. Chimole (Lilongwe), A. Assolari (Mangoche), A. Chamgwera (Zomba), and G. M. Chisendera (Dedza), and Monsignor John Roche (Mzuzu).

28 Lwanda, op. cit. p. 290. I myself received prior warning of the existence of the letter from a Malawian friend who taught in Luchenza.

29 Daily Times (Blantyre), 5 and 13 03 1992.Google Scholar

30 Lwanda, op. cit. p. 291 and ibid.

31 The Monitor, 9 July 1993.

32 ‘Living Our Faith. Pastoral Letter of the Catholic Bishops of Malawi, Lent 1992’.

33 The Statesman's Year Book, 1992–3 (London and Basingstoke, 1992), pp. 911 and 914,Google Scholar and ‘The Referendum in Malawi: free expression denied’, in Article 19. The International Centre Against Censorship (London), 22, 04 1993, p. 6.Google Scholar

34 Short, Philip, Banda (London and Boston, 1974), p. 39.Google Scholar

35 Lwanda, op. cit. p. 118.

36 See Forster, Peter G., ‘Culture, Nationalism, and the Invention of Tradition in Malawi’, in The Journal of Modern African Studies (Cambridge), 32, 3, 09 1994, pp. 477–97.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

37 See, for example, Detailed Working Programme. Independence Anniversary Celebrations, 1980 (Blantyre, 1980), pp. 912.Google Scholar

38 Lwanda, op. cit. p. 118.

39 The Monitor Referendum Special (Blantyre), 18 06 1993.Google Scholar

40 ‘Joint Report of the Board of World Mission and Unity’, 19 May 1992.

41 Africa Confidential, 33, 6, 1992.Google Scholar

42 See Financial Observer (Blantyre), 05 1993,Google Scholar and Michiru Sun (Blantyre), 19 11 1993, for specific examples of Malawians who appear to have been victims of physical abuse while held in prison for possessing copies of the Pastoral Letter.Google Scholar

43 ‘The Referendum in Malawi’, p. 6.

44 The Monitor, 9 July 1993.

45 See, for example, Daily Times, 13 March 1992; The Daily Telegraph (London), 2 04 1992; and The Washington Post, 5 May 1992.Google Scholar

46 ‘Joint Report … on the Situation in Malawi’.

47 Ham, Melinda, ‘Malawi: the waiting game’, in Africa Report (New York), 37, 4, 1992, p. 26.Google Scholar

48 ‘The Referendum in Malawi’, p. 6.

49 Quoted in Ross, Kenneth, ‘The Transformation of Power in Malawi, 1992–95: the role of the Christian Churches’, Theology for Life Project, 1995, p. 8, note 43.Google Scholar

50 Much of the information here is drawn from my own experiences since I witnessed the entire affair at first hand.

51 Conversations with students and members of staff who witnessed what happened. Also Woods, loc. cit. p. 19.

52 I attended the SCOM conference, and the hounding of students as reported in the press was somewhat exaggerated. See Ankomah, Baffour, ‘The Shame of Malawi’, in New African (London), 305, 1993, p. 8.Google Scholar

53 Lwanda, op. cit. p. 294.

54 For details of the exiled opposition parties, see Cook, Chris and Killingray, David, African Political Facts Since 1945, 2nd edn. (London, 1991), p. 172.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

55 Woods, loc. cit. p. 19.

56 The Nation (Blantyre, 9 08 1993.Google Scholar

57 Africa Confidential, 32, 6, 1992, and 33, 7, 1992, and The Daily Telegraph, 2 April 1992.

58 The Nation, 9 August 1993, and The Independent, 7–13 August 1993.

59 Africa Today (London), 1981, p. 813.Google Scholar

60 Ham, loc. cit. p. 24.

61 The Nation, 9 August 1993.

62 The Monitor Referendum Special, 18 June 1993, and The Independent, 7–13 August 1993.

63 Africa Confidential, 33, 9, 1992.

64 Woods, loc. cit. p. 19.

65 University of Malawi Newsletter (Zomba), 4, 3, 1992, p. 12, and my own recollections of what took place at Chancellor College in April 1992.Google Scholar

66 Ham, loc. cit. p. 25.

67 Daily Times, 7 May 1992.

68 Malawi News (Blantyre), 2–8 01 1993.Google Scholar

69 Ham, loc. cit. p. 26. See also, ‘Deliverance’ of General Assembly of Church of Scotland on ‘Joint Report of the Board of World Mission and Unity’, 19 May 1992.

70 Lwanda, op. cit. pp. 294–5.

71 ‘The Nation in Malawi in Crisis: the Church's Concern’, 2 June 1992, letter addressed to His Excellency the Life President.

72 ‘Church of Central Africa Presbyterian. Synod of Livingstonia. Statement to CCAP General Synod’, 9 June 1992.

73 Africa Confidential, 33, 17, 1992.Google Scholar

74 The Convener of Church and Politics, CCAP, Livingstonia, to Board of World Mission and Unity, Church of Scotland, 25 August 1992.

75 Open Letter to the Government of Malawi from the Christian Council of Malawi, 26 August 1992.

76 ‘Memorandum to His Excellency the Life President Ngwazi Dr H. Kamuzu Banda’, 28 August 1992, from the CCAP, the ECM, the Anglicans, Muslims, the Law Society, and the business community.

77 Msisha, loc. cit. pp. 51–2.

78 New African, 303, 1992, p. 46.Google Scholar

79 The Financial Observer, 14 June 1993.

80 Msisha, loc. cit. p. 51.

81 The Monitor, 14 July 1993.

82 Ibid. 25 June 1993 – Mbumbas were always ‘uniformed’ when dancing for the President. Cf. Chamley, Santorri, ‘How Banda Ruined Malawi's Music’, in New African, 324, 1994, pp. 27–8.Google Scholar

83 Kimble, David, The Great Hall Complex (Zomba, 1982), pp. 1012.Google Scholar

84 Hansard Official Verbatim Report of the Debates of the Twenty-Ninth Session: Third Meeting of Parliament, Seventh Day, 1 April 1993 (Zomba, Government Printer, 1993), p. 1155.Google Scholar

85 The Monitor, 11 October 1993.

86 The New Nation, 1, 2, 1993.

87 Anonymous Letter addressed to Heads of Department, Chancellor College, dated 19 February 1992.

88 For concern about the population growth, see The Watchers, July 1993, and The Independent, 21–27 July 1993. Urban unrest and the plight of Ndirande, in particular, have been frequently covered in the press since the May 1992 riots. See, for example, The New City Star (Blantyre), 6–11 07 1993, and New Express (Chichiri), 9–15 July 1993.Google Scholar

89 Kashoti, Dickson, ‘Endangered Families in Malawi’, in Malawi News, 8–14 January 1994.Google Scholar

90 Michiru Sun, 7–13 January 1994.

91 The Pastoral Letter talked about indiscipline in schools, but admitted that this was partly due to a breakdown of parental authority. Also, The Monitor, 29 June 1993.

92 New Express, 23–29 July 1993, and The Nation, 22 November 1993.

93 The Independent, 21–27 July 1993, and Michiru Sun, 10–16 December 1993.

94 Guardian Today: the Voice of the Malawi Congress Party (Blantyre), 23–29 07 1993.Google Scholar