Skip to main content

Saving a species threatened by trade: a network study of Bali starling Leucopsar rothschildi conservation

  • Paul R. Jepson (a1)

Saving species from extinction is a central tenet of conservation, yet success in this endeavour remains unpredictable and elusive, especially where wildlife trade is involved. Influential conservation policy actors operating internationally advocate strong regulatory and enforcement approaches to governance of wildlife trade. However, a broad body of evidence suggests that in some situations positive incentives for sustainable use may achieve better conservation outcomes. This analysis of efforts over 3 decades to avoid the extinction of the Bali starling Leucopsar rothschildi draws on network perspectives from environmental governance and geography, and shows how an international project adopting traditional enforcement approaches generated a ‘prestige of ownership’ dynamic among local elites. This placed trade in Bali starlings above the enforcement competencies of the relevant government authority, leading to the demise of the species. Subsequently, two separate Indonesian initiatives created spaces of regulatory flexibility and embraced traits of the starling's phenotype to construct identities for the species suited to the local context. This enrolled a wider range of stakeholders in the conservation of the species, including bird-keeping elites, and led to significant successes in restoring captive and free-flying populations. This case study highlights the potential of conservation networks that involve non-establishment personnel and, while recognizing the appeal of generic enforcement approaches to politicians, funders and the urban public, it adds to an increasing body of evidence that suggests top-down prescriptive conservation frameworks may undermine the ability of situated conservationists to develop interventions appropriate to their political and cultural realities.

Hide All
Bennett E.L., Blencowe E., Brandon K., Brown D., Burn R.W., Cowlishaw G. et al. (2007) Hunting for consensus: reconciling bushmeat harvest, conservation, and development policy in West and Central Africa. Conservation Biology, 21, 884887.
Betsill M. & Bulkeley H. (2007) Looking back and thinking ahead: a decade of cities and climate change research. Local Environment, 12, 447456.
BirdLife International (2001) Threatened Bird of Asia: The BirdLife International Red Data Book. BirdLife International, Cambridge, UK.
Blok A. (2007) Actor-networking ceta-sociality, or, what is sociological about contemporary whales? Distinktion, 15, 6589.
Brook S.M., Dudley N., Mahood S.P., Polet G., Williams A.C., Duckworth J.W. et al. (2014) Lessons learned from the loss of a flagship: the extinction of the Javan rhinoceros Rhinoceros sondaicus annamiticus from Vietnam. Biological Conservation, 174, 2129.
Butchart S.H.M., Stattersfield A.J. & Collar N.J. (2006) How many bird extinctions have we prevented? Oryx, 40, 266278.
Callon M. (1986) Some elements in a sociology of translation: domestication of the scallops and fishermen of St. Brieuc Bay. In Power, Action and Belief. A New Sociology of Knowledge (ed. Law J.), pp. 196223. Routledge, London, UK.
Caughley G. (1994) Directions in conservation biology. Journal of Animal Ecology, 63, 215244.
Challender D.W. & MacMillan D.C. (2014) Poaching is more than an enforcement problem. Conservation Letters, 7, 46.
CITES (2014) Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora. Appendices I, II and III. Http:// [accessed 18 December 2014].
Collar N.J., Crosby M.J. & Stattersfield A.J. (1994) Birds to Watch 2: The World List of Threatened Birds. BirdLife International, Cambridge, UK.
Collins M.S., Smith T.B., Seibels R.E. & Putra A. (1998) Approaches to the reintroduction of the Bali mynah. Zoo Biology, 17, 267275.
Conway W.G. (1980) Where we go from here. International Zoo Yearbook, 20, 184189.
Cooney R. & Jepson P. (2006) The international wild bird trade: what's wrong with blanket bans? Oryx, 40, 1823.
Dijkman G. (2007) Bali myna takes flight to Nusa Penida. BirdingAsia, 7, 5560.
Djelic M-L. & Sahlin-Andersson K. (eds) (2008) Transnational Governance: Institutional Dynamics of Regulation. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK.
Duffy R. (2006) Non-governmental organisations and governance states: the impact of transnational environmental management networks in Madagascar. Environmental Politics, 15, 731749.
Earnhardt J.M., Thompson S.D. & Faust L.J. (2009) Extinction risk assessment for the species survival plan (SSP) population of the Bali mynah (Leucopsar rothschildi). Zoo Biology, 28, 230252.
Gibbs M.T. (2008) Network governance in fisheries. Marine Policy, 32, 113119.
Gilpin M.E. & Soulé M.E. (1986) Minimum viable populations: process of extinction. In Conservation Biology: The Science of Scarcity and Diversity (ed. Soulé M.E.), pp. 1934. Sinauer Associates, Sunderland, USA.
IUCN (2014) IUCN Red List of Threatened Species v. 2014.3. Http:// [accessed 17 December 2014].
IUCN/SSC (1995) Guidelines for Re-introductions. Http:// [accessed 7 January 2015].
Jepson P., Barua M. & Buckingham K. (2011a) What is a conservation actor? Conservation & Society, 9, 229235.
Jepson P. & Ladle R.J. (2009) Governing bird-keeping in Java and Bali: evidence from a household survey. Oryx, 43, 364374.
Jepson P., Ladle R.J. & Sujatnika (2011b) Assessing market-based conservation governance approaches: a socio-economic profile of Indonesian markets for wild birds. Oryx, 45, 482491.
Jepson P., van Balen S.V., Soehartono T.R. & Mardiastuti A. (1997) Rencana Pemulihan Spesies Jalak Bali/Bali Starling Recovery Plan. PHPA/BirdLife International—Indonesia Programme, Bogor, Indonesia.
King W.B. (1978–1979) Red Data Book. Volume 2: Aves. IUCN, Morges, Switzerland.
Lacy R.C. (1993) VORTEX: a computer simulation model for population viability analysis. Wildlife Research, 20, 4565.
Ladle R.J. & Jepson P. (2008) Toward a biocultural theory of avoided extinction. Conservation Letters, 1, 111118.
Latour B. (2005) Reassembling the Social: An Introduction to Actor-Network-Theory. Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK.
London Conference on The Illegal Wildlife Trade (2014) Declaration. Https:// [accessed 7 January 2015].
Lovejoy T.E. (1980) Tomorrow's ark: by invitation only. International Zoo Yearbook, 20, 181183.
McNeely J.A., Miller K.R., Reid W.V., Mittermeier R.A. & Werner T.B. (1990) Conserving the World's Biological Diversity. IUCN, Gland, Switzerland.
Minteer B.A. (2013) Conservation, animal rights, and human welfare. A pragmatic view of the ‘bushmeat crisis’. In Ignoring Nature No More. The Case for Compassionate Conservation (ed. Bekoff M.), pp. 7794. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, USA.
Oldfield S. (ed.) (2003) The Trade in Wildlife: Regulation for Conservation. Earthscan, London, UK.
Rhodes R.A.W. (2007) Understanding governance: ten years on. Organization Studies, 28, 12431264.
Roe D., Milledge S., Cooney R., ‘t Sas-Rolfes M., Biggs D., Murphree M. & Kasterine A. (2014) The Elephant in the Room: Sustainable Use in the Illegal Wildlife Trade Debate. IIED Briefing Papers, London, UK.
Sanderson E.W., Redford K.H., Chetkiewicz C.L.B., Medellin R.A., Rabinowitz A.R., Robinson J.G., & Taber A.B. (2002) Planning to save a species: the jaguar as a model. Conservation Biology, 16, 5872.
Shaffer M.L. (1981) Minimum population sizes for species conservation. BioScience, 31, 131134.
Shavit D. (2006) Bali and the Tourist Industry: A History, 1906–1942. McFarland & Co., Jefferson, USA.
Sørensen E. & Torfing J. (eds) (2007) Theories of Democratic Network Governance. Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke, UK.
United for Wildlife (2014) Http:// [accessed 17 December 2014].
van Balen B. & Dirgayusa I.W.A. (1993) Bali Starling Project: Activity Report, September 1992–February 1993. PHPA/ICBP Indonesia Programme, Bogor, Indonesia.
van Balen V. & Gepak V.H. (1994) The captive breeding and conservation programme of the Bali starling (Leucopsar rothschildi). In Creative Conservation: Interactive Management of Wild and Captive Animals (eds Olney P.J.S., Mace G.M. & Feistner A.T.C.), pp. 420430. Chapman & Hall, London, UK.
Vincent J. (1966–1971) Red Data Book. Volume 2: Aves. IUCN, Morges, Switzerland.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

  • ISSN: 0030-6053
  • EISSN: 1365-3008
  • URL: /core/journals/oryx
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *



Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 15
Total number of PDF views: 190 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 413 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 25th November 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.