Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Preface
- I Study skills for mathematicians
- II How to think logically
- 6 Making a statement
- 7 Implications
- 8 Finer points concerning implications
- 9 Converse and equivalence
- 10 Quantifiers – For all and There exists
- 11 Complexity and negation of quantifiers
- 12 Examples and counterexamples
- 13 Summary of logic
- III Definitions, theorems and proofs
- IV Techniques of proof
- V Mathematics that all good mathematicians need
- VI Closing remarks
- Appendices
- Index
12 - Examples and counterexamples
from II - How to think logically
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Preface
- I Study skills for mathematicians
- II How to think logically
- 6 Making a statement
- 7 Implications
- 8 Finer points concerning implications
- 9 Converse and equivalence
- 10 Quantifiers – For all and There exists
- 11 Complexity and negation of quantifiers
- 12 Examples and counterexamples
- 13 Summary of logic
- III Definitions, theorems and proofs
- IV Techniques of proof
- V Mathematics that all good mathematicians need
- VI Closing remarks
- Appendices
- Index
Summary
Some facts can be seen more clearly by example than by proof.
Leonard EulerIf I were wrong, one would be enough.
Einstein's reply to hearing of the Nazi book 100 Authors Against EinsteinNow we come to one of the biggest secrets in thinking like a mathematician. So far in this book we have covered many of the important tools for logical thinking: statements, implications, quantifiers. Many other books cover these. But they cover in little detail what I consider to be one of the most important tools. It is fundamental to thinking like a mathematician as I am sure many mathematicians will agree, including those textbook writers. But you won't find this topic given its true prominence in the textbooks.
So what is this great secret tool? Simple! Examples. The quote from Euler is crucial to thinking like a mathematician. First let's remove a possible misconception. Low-level mathematics is often taught in the following way: ‘This is how the product rule for differentiation works, here are some examples, now you do some exercises just like the examples.’ This is the monkey-see-monkey-do approach. Students are set problems where they can look at the given examples and merely copy the format. (This does actually work well for low-level mathematics.) This type of example is usually called a worked example. It is not these I am interested in.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- How to Think Like a MathematicianA Companion to Undergraduate Mathematics, pp. 90 - 95Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 2009