Skip to main content
  • Get access
    Check if you have access via personal or institutional login
  • Cited by 2
  • Cited by
    This chapter has been cited by the following publications. This list is generated based on data provided by CrossRef.

    Warwick, Claire 2015. A New Companion to Digital Humanities. p. 538.

    Atherton, Carol 2005. Defining Literary Criticism. p. 59.

  • Print publication year: 2000
  • Online publication date: March 2008

14 - Criticism and the academy

During the second half of the twentieth century, literary criticism became virtually the monopoly of university departments. At the beginning of the century, the distinction between men of letters and professors was not so sharp as to prevent movement from one occupation to the other. Later, universities served as occasional havens for writers and poets. This chapter discusses the founding of English studies, whose shape is determined by politics, economics, demography, and the character of universities as institutions. It then talks about the critiques of the philological and historical emphasis of English studies that appeared between the 1890s and 1930s. Through reference to discussions of pedagogy and commission reports prepared in the 1930s, the chapter argues that the success practical criticism identifiably achieved in the academy resulted from its compatibility with pedagogical changes initiated independently within the profession. Finally, the chapter talks about the accommodation between criticism and scholarship that it facilitated in the 1950s.
Recommend this book

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this book to your organisation's collection.

The Cambridge History of Literary Criticism
  • Online ISBN: 9781139053730
  • Book DOI:
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to *
Applebee, Arthur N., Tradition and Reform in the Teaching of English: A History (Urbana, 1974).
Arac, Jonathan, Critical Genealogies (New York, 1987).
Arnold, Matthew, Schools and Universities on the Continent, ed. Super, R. H. (Ann Arbor, 1964).
Axelrod, Joseph (ed.), Graduate Study for Future College Teachers (Washington, 1959).
Babbitt, Irving, ‘The Basic Issues in the Teaching of English’, PMLA, 74 (1959).
Babbitt, Irving, Literature and the American College: Essays in Defense of the Humanities (Boston, 1908).
Baldick, Chris, The Social Mission of English Criticism, 1848–1932 (Oxford, 1983).
Bateson, F. W., ‘The Function of Criticism at the Present Time’, Essays in Criticism, 3 (1953).
Bateson, F. W., Essays in Critical Dissent (London, 1972).
Bennett, Arnold, Books and Persons (London, 1917).
Brooks, Cleanth, ‘I. A. Richards and Practical Criticism’, Sewanee Review, 89 (1981).
Brooks, Cleanth, ‘The New Criticism’, Sewanee Review, 87 (1979).
Bush, Douglas, ‘Memories of Harvard's English Department 1920–1932’, Sewanee Review, 89 (1981).
Campbell, Oscar (ed.), The Teaching of College English (New York, 1934).
Canby, Henry Seidel, ‘The American Scholar – Ninety Years Later’, Saturday Review of Literature, 4 (1928).
Canby, Henry Seidel, Cardinal Principles of Secondary Education (Washington, 1918).
Clapp, June (ed.), College Textbooks (New York, 1960).
Conant, J. B., ‘Free Thinking or Dogma?’, Atlantic Monthly, 155 (1935).
Cook, Albert, The Higher Study of English (Boston, 1906).
Cooper, Lane, Methods and Aims in the Study of Literature (Boston, 1915).
Craig, Hardin, Literary Study and the Scholarly Profession (Seattle, 1944).
Crane, R. S., ‘History vs. Criticism in the Study of Literature’, English Journal, 24 (1935).
Culler, Jonathan, Framing the Sign (Norman, Okla., 1988).
Davidson, H. Carter, ‘Our College Curriculum in English’, English Journal, 20 (1931).
de Man, Paul, Essays on the Teaching of English in Honour of Charles Swain Thomas (Cambridge, Mass., 1940).
de Man, Paul, ‘The Return to Philology’, in The Resistance to Theory (Minneapolis, 1986).
Douglas, Wallace, ‘Accidental Institution: On the Origin of Modern Language Study’, in Graff, Gerald and Gibbons, Reginald (eds.), Criticism in the University (Evanston, Ill., 1985).
Elton, Oliver, Essays and Addresses (London, 1939).
Foerster, Norman, ‘Literary Scholarship and Criticism’, English Journal, 25 (1936).
Foerster, Norman, (ed.), Humanism and America: Essays on the Outlook of Modern Civilisation (New York, 1930).
Foerster, Norman, The American Scholar: A Study in Litterae Inhumaniores (Chapel Hill, 1929).
Foerster, Norman, Towards Standards: A Study of the Present Critical Movement in American Letters (New York, 1930).
French, J. Milton, ‘The Introductory Course in Literature’, College English, 3 (1941).
Fritz K, RingerEducation and Society in Modern EuropeBloomington 1979
Frye, Northrop, ‘Literary Criticism’, in The Aims and Methods of Scholarship in Modern Languages and Literatures (New York, 1963).
Frye, Northrop, Anatomy of Criticism (Princeton, 1957).
Gardner, Helen, The Business of Criticism (Oxford, 1959).
Gerber, John C. (ed.), The College Teaching of English (New York, 1965).
Graff, Gerald, Professing Literature: An Institutional History (Chicago, 1987).
Graff, Gerald, and Warner, Michael, The Origins of Literary Studies in America: A Documentary Anthology (New York, 1989).
Graff, Gerald, and Reginald, Gibbons (eds.), Criticism in the University (Evanston, I11, 1985).
Grattan, C. Hartley (ed.), The Critique of Humanism: A Symposium (New York, 1930).
Greenlaw, Edwin, The Province of Literary History (Baltimore, 1931).
Gross, John, The Rise and Fall of the Man of Letters: A Studyof the Idiosyncratic and the Humane in Modern Literature (New York, 1969).
Haber, Tom Burns, Review of Understanding Poetry, English Journal, 27 (1938).
Harrison, G. B., Profession of English (New York, 1962).
Hawkins, Eric W., Modern Languages in the Curriculum (Cambridge, 1981).
Hays, Edna, College Entrance Requirements in English: Their Effects on the High Schools (New York, 1936).
Hays, Edna, Historical Statistics of the U. S., 2 vols. (Washington, 1975).
Hoeveler, J. David Jr, The New Humanism: A Critique of Modern America 1900–1940 (Charlottesville, 1977).
Holloway, John, The Charted Mirror: Literary and Critical Essays (London, 1960).
Holloway, John, The Colours of Clarity: Essays on Contemporary Literature and Education (London, 1972).
Hook, J. H., A Long Way Together: A Personal View of the NCTE's First Sixty Seven Years (Urbana, 1979).
Hosiac, James F., Reorganisation of English in Secondary Schools (Washington, 1917).
Hough, Graham, The Dream and the Task: Literature and Morals in the Culture of Today (London, 1963).
Hughes, Merritt Y., ‘Our Social Contract’, College English, 1 (1940).
Hyman, Stanley Edgar, The Armed Vision: A Study in the Methods of Modern Literary Criticism (1948; rev. edn. New York, 1955).
James, William, ‘The Ph.D. Octopus’, in Essays, Comments and Reviews (Cambridge, Mass., 1987).
Knapp, Robert H., The Origins of American Humanistic Scholars (Englewood Cliffs, 1964).
Knight, G. Wilson, ‘The New Interpretation’, Essays in Criticism, 3 (1953).
Knights, L. C., ‘Scrutiny of Examinations’, Scrutiny, 2 (1933).
Ladd, Everett Carl Jr, and , Seymour Martin Lipset, The Divided Academy: Professors and Politics (New York, 1975).
Leary, Lewis (ed.), Contemporary Literary Scholarship: A Critical Review (New York, 1958).
Leavis, F. R., ‘Literary Criticism and Philosophy: A Reply’, Scrutiny, 6 (1937).
Leavis, F. R., Education and the University: A Sketch for an ‘English School’ (London, 1943).
Lewis, C. S., An Experiment in Criticism (Cambridge, 1961).
Lovett, Robert Morse, All Our Years (New York, 1948).
Lowes, John Livingston, ‘The Modern Language Association and Humane Scholarship’, PMLA, 48 (1933).
Lyman, R. L., ‘English in Relation to Three Major Curriculum Trends’, English Journal, 25 (1936).
Mathiesen, Margaret, The Preachers of Culture: A Study of English and Its Teachers (London, 1975).
McMurtry, Jo, English Language, English Literature: The Creation of an Academic Discipline (Hamden, 1985).
Menand, Louis, ‘The Demise of Disciplinary Authority’, in What's Happened to the Humanities?, ed. Kernan, Alvin (Princeton, 1997).
Nitze, Albert, ‘Horizons’, PMLA, 44 (1930).
Palmer, D. J., The Rise of English Studies: An Account of the Study of English Language and Literature from Its Origins to the Making of the Oxford English School (London, 1965).
Pattee, Fred Lewis, Tradition and Jazz (New York, 1925).
Payne, William P.English in American UniversitiesWilliam M, PayneBoston 1895
Perry, Bliss, ‘College Professors and the Public’, in The Amateur Spirit (Boston, 1904).
Potter, Stephen, The Muse in Chains: A Study in Education (London, 1937).
Quiller-Couch, Arthur, ‘Inaugural’, in On the Art of Writing (Cambridge, 1916).
Raleigh, Walter, On Writing and Writers, ed. Gordon, George (London, 1926).
Ransom, John Crowe, The World's Body (New York, 1938; rpt. Baton Rouge, 1968).
Richards, I. A., Practical Criticism (New York, 1969).
Richards, I. A., Principles of Literary Criticism (London, 1952).
Ruland, Richard, The Rediscovery of American Literature: Premises of Critical Taste, 1900–1940 (Cambridge, Mass., 1967).
Saintsbury, George, A History of Criticism and Literary Taste in Europe, 3 vols. (Edinburgh, 19001904).
Sherman, Stuart, Shaping Men and Women, ed. Zeitlin, Jacob (Garden City, N. J., 1928).
Skeat, W. W., Questions for Examination in English Literature (3rd edn. London, 1890).
Smith, Nowell, The Origin and Historyof the [English] Association (London, 1942).
Spingarn, J. E., The New Criticism (New York, 1911).
Stoll, E. E.Certain Fallacies and Irrelevancies in the Literary Scholarship of the Day’, Studies in Philology, 24 (1927).
Stoll, E. E.Training for the New Social Order’, English Journal, 23 (1934).
The Aims of Literary Study’, PMLA, 53 (1938).
Tillyard, E. M. W., The Muse Unchained: An Intimate Account of the Revolution in English Studies at Cambridge (London, 1958).
Van Deusen, Marshall, J. E. Spingarn (New York, 1971).
Vanderbilt, Kermit, American Literature and the Academy: The Roots, Growth, and Maturity of a Profession (Philadelphia, 1987).
Vaughn, W. E., Articulation in English Between the High School and College (New York, 1929).
Warner, Michael, ‘Professionalisation and the Rewards of Literature: 1875– 1900’, Criticism, 27 (1985).
Wellek, René, ‘Academic Criticism’, in A History of Modern Criticism, 1750–1950, Volume 6: American Criticism, 1900–1950 (New Haven, 1986).
Wellek, René, ‘Literary Criticism and Philosophy’, Scrutiny, 5 (1937).
Wellek, René, and Warren, Austin, Theory of Literature (New York, 1949).
Wilcox, Thomas W., The Anatomy of College English (San Francisco, 1973).
Williams, Raymond, Writing in Society (London, 1983).
Wimsatt, William K., and Brooks, Cleanth, Literary Criticism: A Short History, 2 vols. (New York, 1957).
Woodberry, G. E., ‘Two Phases of Criticism: Historical and Esthetic’, in Criticism in America, ed. Spingarn, J. E. (New York, 1924).
Wray, Edith A., ‘A Modern Odyssey’, College English, 16 (1955).