Skip to main content Accessibility help

Measurement and modelling of the turbulent boundary layer near the attachment line of a swept wing

  • E. R. Gowree (a1) and C. J. Atkin (a1)

This work is motivated by the need for low-order aerodynamic models to predict accurately the effect on profile drag of controlling attachment line transition. Head's entrainment method(1), a rapid integral boundary layer technique used for design studies on swept wings, suffers from the governing swept-tapered turbulent integral boundary layer equations being ill-posed in the vicinity of the attachment line. This singularity has been treated using crude extrapolations of the attachment-line similarity solution for over half a century, but this approach is unlikely to deliver accurate predictions of the effect of changes in the attachment line flow on profile drag. An experimental study has been carried out to explore the nature of the turbulent flow in the vicinity of a highly swept swept attachment line and has revealed a quite complex, non-monotonic development of the momentum thickness in this region. It has also revealed lower levels of twist in the boundary layer velocity profiles than anticipated from the highly curved character of the inviscid flow streamlines. These observations have prompted an alternative approach to the modelling of the flow in this region which not only successfully eliminates the lack of robustness in the swept-tapered equations but which also matches the experimental results to within ±5%.

Corresponding author
Hide All
1. Head, M.R. Entrainment in the turbulent boundary layer, ARC R&M 3152, 1958.
2. Alderman, J., Rolston, S., Gaster, M. and Atkin, C. A method of reducing the drag transport wings, 34th AIAA Applied Aviation Conference, 2016, Washington, DC, US.
3. Green, J.E., Weeks, D.J. and Brooman, J.W.F. Prediction of turbulent boundary layers and wakes in compressible flow by lag-entrainment method, ARC R&M 3791, 1973.
4. Lock, R.C. and Williams, B.R. Viscous and inviscid interactions in external aerodynamics, Progress in Aerospace Science, 1987, 24, pp 51-171.
5. Garabedian, P. and Korn, D. Analysis of transonic aerofoil, Communications of Pure and Applied Mathematics, 1971, 24, pp 841-851.
6. Lock, R.C. An equivalence law relating three-and two-dimensional pressure distributions, NPL Aero Report no. 1028, 1962.
7. Ashill, P.R., Wood, R.F. and Weeks, D.J. An improved semi-inverse method of the viscous Garabedian and Korn method (VGK), RAE TR 87002, 1987.
8. Atkin, C.J. and Gowree, E.R. Recent developments to the viscous Garabedian and Korn method, 28th International Congress of Aeronautical Sciences, 2012, Brisbane, Australia.
9. Gowree, E.R., Atkin, C.J. and Grupppetta, S. A simple digital-optical system to improve accuracy of hot-wire measurements, Measurement Science and Technology, 2015, 26, (9).
10. Kaups, K. and Cebeci, T. Compressible laminar boundary layers with suction on swept and tapered wings, J Aircr, 1977, 14, (7), pp 661-667.
11. Horton, H.P. and Stock, H.W. Computation of compressible, laminar boundary layers on swept, tapered wings, J Aircr, 1995, 32, (6), pp 1402-1405.
12. Ashill, P.R. and Smith, P.D. An integral method for calculating the effects on turbulent boundary layer development of sweep and taper, Aeronautical J. 1985, 88, pp 43-54.
13. Green, J.E. Application of Head's entrainment method to the prediction of turbulent boundary layers and wakes in compressible flow, ARC R&M 3788, 1972.
14. Smith, , P.D. An integral prediction method for three-dimensional turbulent boundary layers, ARC R&M 3739, 1972.
15. England, R. Error estimates for runge-kutta type solutions to systems of ordinary differential equations, Computational J., 1969, 12, pp 166-170.
16. Cumpsty, N.A. and Head, M.R. The calculation of three-dimensional turbulent boundary layer. Part III: Comparison of the attachment line calculations with experiment, Aeronautical Quarterly, 1969, 20, pp 99-113.
17. Smith, P.D. A calculation method for the turbulent boundary layer on an infinite yawed wing in compressible, adiabatic flow, ARC CP 1268, 1974.
18. Thompson, B.G.J. and McDonald, G.J. The prediction of boundary layer behaviour and profile drag for infinite swept wings. Part III: A method for calculation, ARC CP 1309, 1973.
19. Gowree, E.R. Influence of Attachment Line Flow on Form Drag, City, University of London, 2014, PhD Thesis, available at:
20. Preston, J.H. The determination of turbulent skin friction by means of pitot tubes, J Aeronautical Soc, 1954, 58, pp 109-121.
21. Pfenninger, W. Flow phenomena at the leading edge of swept wings, recent development in boundary layer research, AGARDograph 97, 1965.
22. Gaster, M. On the flow along swept leading edges, Aeronautical Quartely, 1967, 17, pp 165-184.
23. Spalart, P.R. Direct simulation of a turbulent boundary layer up to R=1410, J. Fluid Mechanics, 1988, 187, pp 61-98.
24. Johnston, J.P. On the three-dimensional boundary layer generated by secondary flows, ASME, J. Fluid Engineering, 1960, 82, pp 233-246.
25. Preston, J.H. The Mininmum reynolds number for a turbulent boundary layer and the selection transition device, J. Fluid Mechanics, 1957, 3, pp 373-384.
26. Spalart, P.R. Direct numerical simulation of leading edge contamination, AGARD CP 438, 1989.
27. Mager, A. Generalization of the boundary layer momentum integral equations to three-dimensional flows, including those of rotating systems, NACA Report 1067, 1952.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

The Aeronautical Journal
  • ISSN: 0001-9240
  • EISSN: 2059-6464
  • URL: /core/journals/aeronautical-journal
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *



Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed