Hostname: page-component-76fb5796d-vfjqv Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-26T13:57:19.430Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Warrior Queen: Reflections on Victoria and Her World1

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 July 2014

Walter L. Amstein
Get access

Extract

The subject of monarchy remains more fashionable in the pages of People and the National Inquirer than among NEH peer review panelists or professional historians generally. To a surprising degree, indeed, the subject has been left to non-professionals or to non-historians. Yet, when one reflects on the fact that the best-known wedding and the most traumatic funeral of the twentieth century both involved the British monarchy in a very immediate fashion, then one can hardly contend that that institution is of no account in modern cultural history. In the course of the past decade, I have drafted, and in part published, a series of topical essays involving Queen Victoria as symbol, as personality, and as actor on the political stage, and this paper constitutes a consideration of yet another facet of her world. In the process of exploring Queen Victoria's world in both printed and unpublished sources, I have made two discoveries that may not surprise you unduly once I set them forth.

First, each major biographer of Queen Victoria—and there have been a great many—tends to react to the last major previous biographers. Thus Giles St. Aubyn in 1991 and Stanley Weintraub in 1987 drafted their works in the context of Elizabeth Longford's biography of 1964 and Cecil Woodham-Smith's life of 1972. The latter two wrote their lives in reaction to Lytton Strachey's biography of 1921 and Arthur Benson's of 1930. In the process, these more recent historians have at times unwittingly neglected a number of cogent conclusions reached by Sidney Lee way back in 1902.

Type
Research Article
Information
Albion , Volume 30 , Issue 1 , Spring 1998 , pp. 1 - 28
Copyright
Copyright © North American Conference on British Studies 1998

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

1

This paper constitutes a slightly revised version of the presidential address delivered at the meeting of the North American Conference on British Studies at Asilomar, California, on November 1, 1997.

References

2 “Queen Victoria and Religion,” in Malmgreen, Gail, ed. Religion in the Lives of English Women, 1760–1930 (London, 1986), pp. 88–128Google Scholar; “Queen Victoria Opens Parliament: The Disinvention of Tradition,” Historical Research 63 (June 1990): 178–94CrossRefGoogle Scholar; “Queen Victoria's Speeches from the Throne: A New Look,” in O'Day, Alan, ed. Government and Institutions in the Post-1832 United Kingdom (Lewiston, NY, 1995), pp. 127–53Google Scholar; “Queen Victoria and the Challenge of Roman Catholicism,” The Historian 58, 2 (Winter 1996): 295–314CrossRefGoogle Scholar; “Queen Victoria's Diamond Jubilee,” The American Scholar 66, 4 (Autumn 1997): 591–97Google Scholar.

3 Cited in Longford, Elizabeth, Queen Victoria: Born to Succeed (New York, 1964), p. 230Google Scholar.

4 Cited in Walpole, Spencer, The Life of Lord John Russell, 2 vols. (London, 1889) 1: 284Google Scholar.

5 Oliphant, Margaret, Life of Queen Victoria (London, 1898), p. 135Google Scholar.

6 A Royal Service (London, 1897), p. 7Google Scholar.

7 General Grey to Mrs. Grey, 14 February 1864. Grey Mss. University of Durham Library.

8 Fulford, Roger, ed., Your Dear Letter: Private Correspondence of Queen Victoria and the Crown Princess of Prussia, 1865–1871 (London, 1971), p. 130Google Scholar

9 Bolitho, Hector, ed. Further Letters of Queen Victoria from the Archives of the House of Brandenburg-Prussia (London, 1938), p. 174Google Scholar.

10 Fraser, Antonia, The Warrior Queens (New York, 1988), p. 273Google Scholar.

11 Kuhn, William, Democratic Royalism: The Transformation of the British Monarchy, 1861–1914 (London, 1996), pp. 30–31CrossRefGoogle Scholar. A related argument is made by Homans, Margaret in “To the Queen's Private Apartments': Royal Family Portraiture and the Construction of Victoria's Sovereign Obedience,” Victorian Studies 37, 1 (Autumn 1993): 1–41Google Scholar.

12 Cf. Woodham-Smith, Cecil, Queen Victoria: From Her Birth to the Death of the Prince Consort (New York, 1972), pp. 21–24Google Scholar. Ashdown, Dulcie, Queen Victoria's Mother (London, 1974), p. 60Google Scholar.

13 Campbell, John D. S. [Marquess of Lome], V.R.I.: Her Life and Empire (London, 1901), p. 20Google Scholar.

14 Cf. Royal Archives. Queen Victoria's Journal. Entry for 23 January 1869 (hereafter cited as RA). This and subsequent citations from the Royal Archives at Windsor are quoted by the gracious permission of Queen Elizabeth II.

15 Fulford, Roger, ed., Darling Child: Private Correspondence of Queen Victoria and the German Crown Princess, 1871–1878 (London, 1976), p. 24Google Scholar.

16 Cited in Lee, Sidney, Queen Victoria, new and revised ed. (London, 1904), p. 17Google Scholar.

17 Cited in ibid., p. 38.

18 Hibbert, Christopher, ed. Queen Victoria in Her Letters and Journals (Harmondsworth, Middlesex, 1985), p. 27Google Scholar. See also Chariot, Monica, Victoria: the Young Queen (Oxford, 1991), p. 106Google Scholar.

19 Irving, Joseph, Annals of Our Time 2 vols., revised ed. (London, 1881) 1: 22Google Scholar.

20 Cf. citation in Martin, Theodore, The Life of His Royal Highness the Prince Consort, 5 vols. (New York, 1875–1881), 3: 278Google Scholar.

21 Thus on 14 July 1854 she had a long discussion with Lord Hardinge, the Commander-in-Chief about the new army uniforms which were modelled for her at Buckingham Palace. RA, Victoria's Journal for 14 July 1854. See also Strachan, H. F. A., “The Origins of the 1855 Uniform Changes—An Example of Pre-Crimean Reform,” Journal of the Society for Army Historical Research 55 (Summer 1977): 85–117, 165–76Google Scholar. I owe the latter reference, and several others in this paper, to Dr. Scott Hughes Myerly.

22 Cf. Martin, , Prince Consort, 3: 395Google Scholar. See also May, John, Victoria Remembered: A Royal History 1817–1861, Entirely Illustrated with Commemoratives (London, 1983), p. 192Google Scholar.

23 Cited in Staniland, Kay, In Royal Fashion: The Clothes of Princess Charlotte of Wales and Queen Victoria, 1796–1901 (London, 1997), p. 152Google Scholar.

24 Cited in Dress Regulations, 1846: The Uniform of the British Army at the Beginning of the Crimean War (London, 1971), p. iiiGoogle Scholar.

25 The Panmure Papers, eds. SirDouglas, George and SirRamsay, George Dalhousie. 2 vols. (London, 1908), 1: 200Google Scholar.

26 Letters of Queen Victoria, [1st ser.], 3 vols. (London, 1908), 2: 55–57Google Scholar.

27 Cox, Hamersham, The Institutions of the English Government (London, 1863) pp. 713–14Google Scholar. According to Cox, “The degree of the subordination of the Commander-in-Chief to the Executive Government, though a point of great constitutional importance, is [therefore] involved in no little obscurity.”

28 Prince Albert's summary of the duke's views as cited in Martin, , Prince Consort, 2: 211Google Scholar.

29 Ibid, p. 382.

30 Richardson, Joanna, Victoria and Albert (New York, 1977), p. 166Google Scholar.

31 Cited in RA, E42/1847.

32 See Martin, , Prince Consort, 2: 353–54Google Scholar and Letters, 1st ser., 2: 396–97Google ScholarPubMed

33 Bennett, Daphne, King Without a Crown: Albert, Prince Consort of England 1819–1861 (Philadelphia, 1977), p. 238Google Scholar.

34 Martin, , Prince Consort, 2: 402Google Scholar. See also May, , Victoria Remembered, p. 156Google Scholar.

35 Martin, , Prince Consort, 4: 321Google Scholar. A comparable library, under royal patronage, was set up at the British army center near Dublin.

36 Cited in Irving, , Annals, 1: 462Google Scholar.

37 See Bennett, , King Without Crown, p. 285Google Scholar

38 Cited in Martin, , Prince Consort, 5: 114Google Scholar.

39 Cf. Bennett, , King Without Crown, pp. 239, 252Google Scholar.

40 See Maxwell, Herbert, Life of the 4th Earl of Clarendon, 2 vols. (London, 1913), 2: 30Google Scholar

41 RA, Queen Victoria's Journal. Entries for 1 Jan., 9 Feb., 13 Feb., and 20 March 1854.

42 Cited in Irving, , Annals, 1: 403–04Google Scholar.

43 Bolitho, , Further Utters, p. 90Google Scholar.

44 Cited in Martin, , Prince Consort, 3: 39Google Scholar.

45 RA, Queen Victoria's Journal. Entries for 16 and 10 March 1854. See also Lady Clarendon's diary cited in Maxwell, , Clarendon, 2: 42Google Scholar.

46 May, , Victoria Remembered, p. 164Google Scholar.

47 Cited in Martin, , Prince Consort, 3: 41Google Scholar

48 Cited in ibid, 3: 117

49 Letters of Queen Victoria, 1st ser, 3: 52Google Scholar.

50 Bolitho, , Further Letters, p. 51Google Scholar.

51 Cf. Panmure Papers, 1: 393Google Scholar, and Irving, , Annals, 1: 438Google Scholar.

52 Cited in Irving, , Annals, 1: 428Google Scholar.

53 Cited in Martin, , Prince Consort, 3: 155Google Scholar.

54 Bennett, , King Without Crown, p. 262Google Scholar. See also Schroeder, Paul W., Austria, Great Britain, and the Crimean War (Ithaca, NY, 1972), pp. 276–78Google Scholar and passim.; Ridley, Jasper, Lord Palmerston (New York, 1971), p. 446Google Scholar.

55 Martin, , Prince Consort, 3: 218–19Google Scholar.

56 Cited in ibid., pp. 202 and 212.

57 Panmure Papers, 1: 156Google Scholar

58 Ibid., 1: 253.

59 ibid, 1: 126, 316.

60 Ibid., 1: 291

61 Cited in Martin, , Prince Consort, 3: 186Google Scholar.

62 Long excerpts are included in ibid, 3: 135–36; 251–52.

63 Panmure Papers, 1: 298Google Scholar.

64 Ibid,, 1: 497, Martin, , Prince Consort, 3: 314f.Google Scholar

65 Panmure Papers, 1: 87Google Scholar

66 Cited in Martin, , Prince Consort, 3: 229–30Google Scholar. See also Irving, , Annals, 1: 436Google Scholar.

67 Cf. Letters of Lady Augusta Stanley, 1849–1863, ed. Dean of Windsor and Bolitho, Hector (London, 1927), p. 80Google Scholar.

68 Martin, , Prince Consort, 3: 191–92, 401Google Scholar; Panmure Papers, 1: 95–96Google Scholar. Four decades later, the queen retained a close personal interest in the hospital at Netley. See Reid, Michaela, Ask Sir James: Sir James Reid, Personal Physician to Queen Victoria (New York, 1987), p. 46Google Scholar.

69 Cited in SirCook, Edward, The Life of Florence Nightingale, 2 vols. (London, 1913), 1: 307Google Scholar.

70 Bolitho, , Further Letters, p. 75Google Scholar. See also Letters of Augusta Stanley, 1849–1863, pp. 105–06.

71 May, , Victoria Remembered, p. 173Google Scholar.

72 Martin, , Prince Consort, 3: 150Google Scholar; Irving, , Annals, 1: 433Google Scholar.

73 University of Durham Library. Grey Mss. Letter of 10 Sept. 1855 by General Charles Grey to Mrs. Grey.

74 RA, Queen Victoria's Journal Entry for 13 Jan. 1856; Panmure Papers, 2: 91Google Scholar.

75 Cited in Maxwell, , Clarendon, 2: 121Google Scholar

76 Martin, , Prince Consort, 3: 396Google Scholar

77 Ibid., 3: 405–06.

78 Strachey, Lytton and Fulford, Roger, eds., The Greville Memoirs, 1814–1860, 8 vols. (London, 1938), 7: 235Google Scholar

79 Martin, , Prince Consort, 4: 61Google Scholar; Lee, , Victoria, p. 265Google Scholar.

80 Cited in Maxwell, , Clarendon, 2: 164Google Scholar.

81 Cited in Connell, Brian, ed., Regina Versus Palmerston (New York, 1960), p. 219Google Scholar.

82 “The Queen's Speech, Parliamentary Debates, 3rd Series, Vol. 152, col. 2 (Feb. 3, 1859)Google Scholar.

83 Letters of Queen Victoria, 1st Series, 3: 399Google Scholar.

84 Martin, , Prince Consort, 5: 117–18Google Scholar.

85 Ibid, 5: 119–20.

86 Cited by Disraeli, in Monypenny, W.F. & Buckle, G. E., The Life of Benjamin Disraeli, Earl of Beaconsfield, 2 vols. (London, 1929), 2: 117Google Scholar.

87 As she wrote to her eldest daughter less than a month after Albert's death, “I who always hated business, have now nothing but that. Public and private, it falls upon me! [but] now I must labour alone!” See Fulford, Roger, ed., Dearest Mama: Private Correspondence of Queen Victoria and Her Eldest Daughter, 1861–1864 (London, 1968), p. 37Google Scholar.

88 The relevant biographies are Aubyn, Giles St., The Royal George: The Life of H.R.H. Prince George Duke of Cambridge 1819–1904 (New York, 1964)Google Scholar and Frankland, Noble, Witness of a Century: The Life and Times of Prince Arthur Duke of Connaught, 1850–1942 (London, 1993)Google Scholar.

89 RA, E14/22.

90 RA, E14/81.

91 RA, E14/69, E58/1, E14/105, 57.

92 Ibid., Queen Victoria's Journal entry for Jan. 16, 1884 (reprinted in Queen Victoria: Letters and Journals, ed. Hibbert, , p. 283—84Google Scholar). Khaki impressed her as “very ugly” and as, at best, suitable for wear during “foreign service in hot climates.”

93 RA, Queen Victoria's Journal for Sept. 8, 1870

94 Aubyn, St., Royal George, pp. 149–154Google Scholar.

95 Cited in ibid., p. 155.

96 Cited in ibid., p. 156.

91 Letters of Queen Victoria, 2nd ser., 2: 162–63Google Scholar.

98 Cf. ibid., p. 154

99 Cf. RA, Queen Victoria's Journal for July 16 and July 30, 1870.

100 Cited in Aubyn, St., Royal George, p. 152Google Scholar.

101 Even Victoria agreed that at the age of seventy-six it was appropriate for the duke to retire. See Bond, Brian, “The Retirement of the Duke of Cambridge,” Journal of the Royal United Service Organisation 106 (1961): 544–51CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

102 Cf. Review by Strachan, Hew of Spiers, Edward M., The Late Victorian Army, 1868–1902 (Manchester, 1992)Google Scholar in The Times Literary Supplement, Oct. 9, 1992, p. 27Google Scholar.

103 RA, W12/14 cited in Aubyn, St., Royal George, p. 305Google Scholar.

104 The story is told in detail in Arnstein, “Queen Victoria Opens Parliament.” The speech was read by the Lord Chancellor. During most years between 1837 and 1854 Queen Victoria also closed Parliament in person.

105 Letters of Queen Victoria, 2nd ser., 1: 244Google Scholar.

106 RA, E57/39.

107 RA, E57/41

108 RA, E58/18

109 RA, Journal of Queen Victoria for June 9, 1870.

110 RA, Journal of Queen Victoria for April 16, 18, and 22, 1873.

111 SirMartin, Theodore, Queen Victoria as I Knew Her (Edinburgh, 1908), pp. 119–20Google Scholar.

112 Pope-Hennesy, James, ed., Queen Victoria at Windsor and Balmoral: Letters from Her Grand-Daughter Princess Victoria of Prussia—June 1889 (London, 1959), p. 36Google Scholar.

113 RA, Queen Victoria's Journal for Feb. 17 and Feb. 19, 1885.

114 Cf. Reid, Michaela, Ask Sir James, p. 147Google Scholar.

115 Lee, , Victoria, pp. 515–16Google ScholarPubMed.

116 RA, full MS version of Ramm, Agatha, ed. Beloved and Darling Child: Last Letters Between Queen Victoria and Her Eldest Daughter 1886–1901 (Far Strupp Throud, Glos., 1990), p. 458Google Scholar. (This letter was not included in the printed book.)

117 SirPonsonby, Frederick, Memoirs of Three Reigns (London, 1951), p. 63Google Scholar.

118 Fulford, R., ed., Your Dear Letter, p. 295Google Scholar. See also Bolitho, , Further Correspondence, pp. 162, 171Google Scholar.

119 RA, Queen Victoria's Journal for Jan. 9, 1878.

120 Ramm, A., ed., Beloved and Darling Child, p. 132.Google Scholar

121 RA, Queen Victoria's Journal for July 9, 1870.

122 Cited in Bloom, Ursula, Edward and Victoria (London, 1977), p. 133Google Scholar.

123 Fulford, R., ed, Your Dear Letter, pp. 142, 192Google Scholar.

124 Lee, , Victoria, p. 477Google Scholar.

125 Cited in Frankland, , Witness of a Century, p. 5Google Scholar. The author provides a detailed account of the successive military appointments held by Prince Arthur, the Duke of Connaught.

126 RA, A17/135 [Letter from Queen Victoria to her son-in-law, the Marquess of Lome, Jan. 4, 1883]. See also Ponsonby, Magdalen, ed., Mary Ponsonby: A Memoir, Some Letters, and a Journal (London, 1927), p. 163Google Scholar, and Frankland, , Witness of a Century, p. 102Google Scholar.

127 Cited in Frankland, , Witness of a Century, pp. 146, 202Google Scholar.

128 Ibid., p. 82.

129 RA, Queen Victoria's Journal for Sept. 4, 1870.

130 Cf. ibid for Aug. 17, 1877, Sept. 1, 1877, and Jan. 13, 1878. See also, Queen Victoria's letter to the Empress of Germany in Bolitho, , Further Correspondence, p. 224Google Scholar.

131 Cited in Monypenny, & Buckle, , Disraeli, 2: 1002Google Scholar.

132 RA, Queen Victoria's Journal for Aug. 7, 1877.

133 Lee, , Victoria, pp. 439–40Google Scholar. See also Lady Waldegrave as cited in Hewitt, Osbert, Strawberry Fair (London, 1956), p. 255Google Scholar, and Sir Henry Ponsonby's letter to his wife in RA, A36/1058.

134 RA, Queen Victoria's Journal for July 13, 1877.

135 Ibid. Entry for Feb. 7, 1878

136 Cf. ibid. Entry for June 13, 1877.

137 Ibid. Entry for Jan. 3, 1878.

138 Cited in Ponsonby, Arthur, Henry Ponsonby, Queen Victoria's Private Secretary: His Life from His Letters (New York, 1944), p. 166Google Scholar.

139 Cited in Monypenny, and Buckle, , Disraeli, 2: 1022Google Scholar.

140 Cf. Ponsonby, , Ponsonby, p. 167Google Scholar.

141 Cited in Monypenny, and Buckle, , Disraeli, 2: 1089Google Scholar.

142 Victoria: Letters & Journals, ed. Hibbert, , p. 284Google Scholar. See also Lee, , Victoria, pp. 458–59Google Scholar.

143 Cf. RA, Queen Victoria's Journal for May 15, 1885.

144 Victoria: Letters & Journals, ed. Hibbert, , p. 339Google Scholar.

145 Cited in Longford, , Victoria R.I., p. 683Google Scholar

146 Victoria: Letters & Journals, ed. Hibbert, , p. 339Google Scholar. The specific reference was to the Gordon Highlanders.

147 Weintraub, , Victoria, p. 620Google Scholar.

148 Packard, Jerrold M., Farewell in Splendor: The Passing of Queen Victoria and Her Age (New York, 1995), p. 20Google Scholar. He died of enteric fever.

149 Lee, , Victoria, p. 526Google Scholar; Ponsonby, F., Memoirs of Three Reigns, pp. 78–79Google Scholar.

150 Letters of Queen Victoria, 3rd ser., 3: 503–05Google Scholar.

151 RA, Complete typescript of Ramm, Agatha, ed., Beloved and Darling Child, p. 551Google Scholar.

152 ibid., p. 552.

153 Packard, , Farewell, pp. 19–20Google Scholar.

154 Cited in Reid, , Ask Sir James, p. 205Google Scholar.

155 A recent example is Ehrenreich, Barbara, Blood Rites: Origins and History of the Passions of War (New York, 1997)Google Scholar.

156 Cited in Letters of Queen Victoria, 2nd ser., 1: 397Google Scholar. Even as in 1867 she had vetoed Lord Grosvenor for the post of Secretary of State for War so did she veto a Col. Stanley in 1885. She reported that Lord Salisbury “was vexed” by her decision. RA, Queen Victoria's Journal for June 12, 1885.

157 Cf. Reid, , Ask Sir James, p. 40Google Scholar.

158 Cited in Aubyn, St., Royal George, p. 242Google Scholar.

159 James, David, Life of Lord Roberts (London, 1954), p. 224Google Scholar, cited in ibid., p. 118.

160 RA, E14/19. See also Raymond, John, ed., Queen Victoria's Early Letters (New York, 1963), p. 146Google Scholar.

161 Bloom, , Edward and Victoria, pp. 151–52Google Scholar.

162 Underwood, Paul & Spencer-Smith, Jenny, Lady Butler: Battle Artist, 1846–1933 (Alan Sutton: National Army Museum, 1988), p. 29Google Scholar and passim. See also Ponsonby, , Mary Ponsonby, p. 149Google Scholar.

163 Victoria: Letters & Journals, ed. Hibbert, , p. 253Google Scholar.

164 Packari, , Farewell, pp. 220, 238–57Google Scholar.