Hostname: page-component-669899f699-g7b4s Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2025-05-04T23:10:23.990Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Hall and Chambers: Oakham Castle Reconsidered

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  20 September 2013

Nick Hill
Nick Hill*
Affiliation:
Nick Hill, English Heritage, 44 Derngate, Northampton NN1 1UH, UK. Email: nick.hill@english-heritage.org.uk
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The late twelfth-century aisled hall at Oakham Castle, Rutland, is well known as the earliest and most complete building of its type in England. This study, based on detailed fabric analysis and little-known excavations of the 1950s, puts forward a new theory for the building's development. It is proposed that the original hall had attached lean-to buildings at both gable ends, probably built of timber, housing services and other lesser rooms. Like other early halls, the principal chamber at Oakham took the form of a free-standing chamber block, some of whose features have been later incorporated in the surviving hall, including its great east window. Tree-ring dating has shown that, although the roof was rebuilt around 1737, many original timbers survive from the 1180s. A comparative study of other early halls is made, to set Oakham into its wider Anglo-Norman context.

Resume

La grande salle à bas-côtés d'Oakham Castle, dans le Rutland, qui date de la fin du XIIe siècle, est bien connue car elle représente la construction de ce type la plus ancienne et la plus complète en Angleterre. Cette étude, fondée sur l'analyse détaillée de la structure et sur des fouilles peu connues des années 1950, propose une nouvelle théorie du développement du bâtiment. Elle fait l'hypothèse que le manoir d'origine comportait, adossés à chacun des murs pignons, des appentis sans doute en bois qui abritaient des pièces de service et d'autres salles moins importantes. Comme dans d'autres manoirs de cette époque, à Oakham, la pièce principale prenait la forme d'un ensemble indépendant dont certains des éléments ont été par la suite incorporés au manoir qui subsiste, y compris sa grande fenêtre est. La dendrochronologie a montré que si le toit a été construit vers 1737, un grand nombre des poutres d'origine, qui datent des années 1180, ont survécu. Une étude comparative d'autres manoirs anciens est effectuée pour replacer Oakham dans un contexte anglo-normand plus général.

Zusammenfassung

Die dreischiffige Halle von Oakland Castle, Rutland, aus dem späten 12. Jahrhundert gilt als das früheste und vollständigste Gebäude seiner Art in England. Diese Studie bietet basierend auf ausführlichen Substanzanalysen und wenig bekannter Ausgrabungen in den 1950-er Jahren neue theoretische Erwägungen zum Entwicklungsgang dieses Gebäudes. Es wird dabei dargelegt, dass die ursprüngliche Halle an beiden Giebelseiten Anbauten, wahrscheinlich aus Holz, hatte, in denen die Hausdienste und andere weniger wichtige Räume untergebracht waren. Wie in anderen frühen Hallen hatte der Hauptraum in Oakham die Form eines freistehenden Kammerblocks, von dem einige Charakteristiken, wie das große Ostfenster, später in die noch erhaltene Halle aufgenommen wurden. Anhand dendrochdronologischer Daten hat sich gezeigt, dass obwohl das Dach um 1737 neu gebaut wurde, viele der Originalbalken aus der Zeit nach 1180 überdauert haben. Eine Vergleichsstudie mit anderen frühen Hallen dient dem Zweck Oakham in seinen breiteren angelsächsischen Kontext einzuordnen.

Type
Papers
Information
The Antiquaries Journal , Volume 93 , September 2013 , pp. 163 - 216
Copyright
Copyright © The Society of Antiquaries of London 2013 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Article purchase

Temporarily unavailable

References

Secondary sources

Alcock, N WBuckley, R J 1987. ‘Leicester Castle: the Great Hall’, Medieval Archaeol, 31, 73–79CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Arnold, AHoward, R 2013. Oakham Castle, Castle Lane, Oakham, Rutland: tree-ring analysis of timbers, Engl Heritage Res Rep 23, Portsmouth: English HeritageGoogle Scholar
Biddle, M 1970. ‘Excavations at Winchester, 1969: eighth interim report’, Antiq J, 50, 277–326CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Biddle, MClayre, B 2006. The Castle, Winchester: Great Hall and Round Table, 2nd edn, Winchester: Hampshire County CouncilGoogle Scholar
Blair, J 1987. ‘The twelfth-century bishop's palace at Hereford’, Medieval Archaeol, 31, 59–72CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Blair, J 1993. ‘Hall and chamber: English domestic planning 1000–1250’, in Meirion-Jones and Jones 1993, 1–21Google Scholar
Borenius, TCharlton, J 1936. ‘Clarendon Palace: an interim report’, Antiq J, 16, 55–84CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brears, P 2008. Cooking and Dining in Medieval England, Totnes: Prospect BooksGoogle Scholar
Bullen, M, Crook, J, Hubbuck, RPevsner, N 2010. The Buildings of England: Hampshire: Winchester and the North, London: Yale University PressGoogle Scholar
Cherry, M 1989. ‘Nurstead Court, Kent: a re-appraisal’, Archaeol J, 146, 451–464CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Clayton, J 1847. Three drawings of January 1847, Society of Antiquaries of London drawings collection, Rutlandshire BP39Google Scholar
Clough, T H McK 2008. Oakham Castle: a guide and history, 4th edn, Oakham: Rutland County CouncilGoogle Scholar
Colvin, H M 1963. The History of the King's Works, iii, London: HMSOGoogle Scholar
Coppack, G 2000. Medieval Bishops' Palace, Lincoln, London: English HeritageGoogle Scholar
Costambeys, M 2004. ‘Ferrers, Henry de (d 1093x1100)’, in Oxford Dictionary of National Biography: online edition (eds H C G Matthew and B Harrison), 〈http://www.oxforddnb.com/view/article/9361〉 (10 Apr 2013)Google Scholar
Cunningham, J 1990. ‘Auckland Castle: some recent discoveries’, in Medieval Architecture and its Intellectual Context: studies in honour of Peter Kidson (eds E Fernie and P Crossley), 81–90, London: Hambledon PressGoogle Scholar
Dollman, F TJobbins, J R 1861. An Analysis of Ancient Domestic Architecture of Great Britain, i, London: BatsfordGoogle Scholar
Emery, A 2000. Greater Medieval Houses of England and Wales 1300–1500. Vol II: East Anglia, Central England and Wales, Cambridge University PressGoogle Scholar
Emmerson, R 1981. ‘Twelfth-century sculpture at Oakham Castle’, in Clough 2008, 30–7Google Scholar
Faulkner, P A 1958. ‘Domestic planning from the twelfth to the fourteenth centuries’, Archaeol J, 115, 150–183CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Faulkner, P A 1966. ‘Warnford, King John's House’, Archaeol J, 123, 190Google Scholar
Fernie, E 1976. ‘The ground plan of Norwich Cathedral and the square root of two’, J Brit Archaeol Ass, 129, 77–86CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gardiner, M 2008. ‘Buttery and pantry and their antecedents: ideas and architecture in the English medieval house’, in Medieval Domesticity (eds M Kowaleski and P J P Goldberg), 37–65, Cambridge University PressGoogle Scholar
Goodall, J 2006. Warkworth Castle and Hermitage, London: English HeritageGoogle Scholar
Goodall, J 2011. The English Castle 1066–1650, London: Yale University PressGoogle Scholar
Gotch, J A 1909. The Growth of the English House, London: BatsfordGoogle Scholar
Grenville, J 1997. Medieval Housing, London: Leicester University PressGoogle Scholar
Hartley, R F 1983. The Medieval Earthworks of Rutland: a survey, Leicestershire Museums, Art Galleries and Record Service Archaeol Rep 7, LeicesterGoogle Scholar
Hartshorne, C H 1848. ‘The hall of Oakham’, Archaeol J, 5, 124–142CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Heard, H 2005. ‘Oakham Castle, Rutland’, Geophysical Survey Rep ref J 2002, Stratascan for Univ Leicester Archaeol ServicesGoogle Scholar
Heslop, T A 1991. ‘Orford Castle, nostalgia and sophisticated living’, Architect Hist, 34, 36–58CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hodgson, J F 1896. ‘The chapel of Auckland Castle’, Archaeol Aeliana, new ser, 8, 113–240Google Scholar
Holland Walker, J 1924. ‘Oakham Castle’, Trans Thoroton Soc Nottinghamshire, 28, 29–45Google Scholar
Impey, E 1993. ‘Seigneurial domestic architecture in Normandy, 1050–1350’, in Meirion-Jones and Jones 1993, 82–120Google Scholar
Impey, E 1999. ‘The seigneurial residence in Normandy, 1125–1225: an Anglo-Norman tradition?’, Medieval Archaeol, 43, 45–73CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Impey, E 2002. ‘Le Manoir des Vallées at Barneville-la-Bertran, Normandy’, Vernacular Architect, 33, 1–18CrossRefGoogle Scholar
James, T B 1990. The Palaces of Medieval England, London: SeabyGoogle Scholar
James, T BRobinson, A M 1988. Clarendon Palace: the history and archaeology of a medieval palace, Rep Res Comm Soc Antiq London 45, LondonGoogle Scholar
Johnson, S 1989. Conisbrough Castle, London: HMSOGoogle Scholar
Jones, EOvens, R 2013. John Barber's Oakham Castle, Digital Publication 1, Oakham: Rutland Local History and Record SocietyGoogle Scholar
Kenyon, J R 1990. Medieval Fortifications, Leicester University PressGoogle Scholar
Loyd, L C 1903–4. ‘The family of Ferrers of Ferrières, St Hilaire, and its connection with Oakham’, Rutland Mag, 1, 177–185Google Scholar
Maddison, J 2000. Ely Cathedral: design and meaning, Ely: Ely Cathedral PublicationsGoogle Scholar
Mahany, C 1977. ‘Excavations at Stamford Castle, 1971–6’, Château Gaillard, 8, 223–245Google Scholar
Meekings, C A F 1956. ‘The Rutland Eyre of 1253: a correction’, Engl Hist Rev, 71 (281), 615–618CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Meirion-Jones, GJones, M (eds) 1993. Manorial Domestic Buildings in England and Northern France, Soc Antiq London Occas Pap 15, LondonGoogle Scholar
Parsons, D 1986. ‘Transitional architecture in Rutland’, Rutland Rec, 6, 195–201Google Scholar
Pevsner, NWilliamson, E 1984. The Buildings of England: Leicestershire and Rutland, Harmondsworth: PenguinGoogle Scholar
Prescott, E 1992. The English Medieval Hospital c 1050–1640, London: SeabyGoogle Scholar
Radford, C A R 1955. ‘Oakham Castle’, Archaeol J, 112, 181–184Google Scholar
RCHME 1984. An Inventory of the Historical Monuments in the County of Northampton. Vol VI: Architectural Monuments in North Northamptonshire, Roy Comm Hist Monuments Engl Inventories, London: HMSOGoogle Scholar
Salzman, L F 1952. Building in England Down to 1540: a documentary history, Oxford University PressGoogle Scholar
Sandall, K 1986. ‘Aisled halls in England and Wales’, Vernacular Architect, 17, 21–35CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sawday, D 2013. ‘The pottery from John Barber's excavation’, in Jones and Ovens 2013, 38–48Google Scholar
Smith, J T 1955. ‘Medieval aisled halls and their derivatives’, Archaeol J, 112, 76–94CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Speed, J 1611. ‘Rutlandshire’, from J Speed, The Theatre of the Empire of Great Britaine, no page, London: Sudbury and HumbleGoogle Scholar
Stenning, D F 2003. ‘Small aisled halls in Essex’, Vernacular Architect, 34, 1–19CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Thompson, M W 1995. The Medieval Hall: the basis of secular domestic life 600–1600 AD, Aldershot: Scolar PressGoogle Scholar
Thompson, M W 1998. Medieval Bishops’ Houses of England and Wales, Aldershot: AshgateGoogle Scholar
Turner, T HParker, J H 1851. Some Account of Domestic Architecture in England. Vol I: From the Conquest to the End of the Thirteenth Century, Oxford: J H ParkerGoogle Scholar
Tyers, IHibberd, H 1993. ‘List 53: tree-ring dates from Museum of London Archaeology Service’, Vernacular Architect, 24, 50–54Google Scholar
VCH Hants 1908. The Victoria History of the County of Hampshire. Vol III (ed W Page), London: ConstableGoogle Scholar
VCH Rutland 1908. The Victoria History of the County of Rutland. Vol I (ed W Page), London: ConstableGoogle Scholar
VCH Rutland 1935. The Victoria History of the County of Rutland. Vol II (ed W Page), London: St Catherine PressGoogle Scholar
VCH Surrey 1905. The Victoria History of the County of Surrey. Vol II (ed H E Malden), London: ConstableGoogle Scholar
Walker, J 1999. ‘Late twelfth- and early thirteenth-century aisled buildings: a comparison’, Vernacular Architect, 30, 21–53CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wilson, D MHurst, J G 1957. ‘Medieval Britain in 1956’, Medieval Archaeol, 1, 157CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wilson, D MHurst, J G 1958. ‘Medieval Britain in 1957’, Medieval Archaeol, 2, 195CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wilson, D MHurst, J G 1959. ‘Medieval Britain in 1958’, Medieval Archaeol, 3, 308CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wood, M E 1935. ‘Norman domestic architecture’, Archaeol J, 92, 167–242CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wood, M E 1950. ‘Thirteenth-century domestic architecture in England’, Archaeol J, 105, supplement, London: Royal Archaeological Institute of Great Britain and IrelandGoogle Scholar
Wood, M E 1965. The English Medieval House, London: DentGoogle Scholar
Wright, J 1684. History and Antiquities of the County of Rutland, London: Bennet GriffinGoogle Scholar
Wright, L 1986. ‘The role of musicians at court in twelfth-century Britain’, in Art and Patronage in the English Romanesque (eds S Macready and F H Thompson), 97–106, Soc Antiq London Occas Pap, new ser 8, LondonGoogle Scholar
Wyndham, H P 1779. ‘Observations on an ancient building at Warnford, in the County of Southampton’, Archaeologia, 5, 357–366CrossRefGoogle Scholar