Skip to main content
×
Home

Organized Labor as the New Undeserving Rich?: Mass Media, Class-Based Anti-Union Rhetoric and Public Support for Unions in the United States

Abstract

Labor unions play a prominent role in the economy and in politics, and have long been depicted by opponents as an overly powerful, corrupt and economically harmful institution. In labor-related news in recent years, anti-union rhetoric has regularly focused on union workers themselves, frequently portraying them as overpaid, greedy and undeserving of their wealth, while also drawing a contrast between the compensation of union vs. non-union workers. This type of rhetoric is referred to here as class-based anti-union rhetoric (CAR). Despite its prevalence, it remains unknown whether CAR affects public opinion toward unions. This study uses a series of national survey experiments to demonstrate that exposure to CAR reduces the perceived similarity of targeted union workers, unions’ perceived deservingness of public support and support for pro-union legislation. Moreover, CAR repeatedly nullified or reversed the otherwise positive relationship between the strength of worker identity and solidarity with union workers.

Copyright
Footnotes
Hide All
*

Department of Political Science, Stony Brook University (email: john.v.kane@stonybrook.edu); School of Public Policy and Department of Political Science, University of California, Riverside (email: bnewman@ucr.edu). We wish to express our deep gratitude to Chuck Taber for his assistance with this project, as well as participants at the 2015 Identity Politics Research Group meeting at the University of Connecticut for their thoughtful insights on an earlier version of this manuscript. Finally, we also wish to thank the anonymous reviewers and editor for their helpful comments and suggestions. Data replication sets are available in Harvard Dataverse at: doi:10.7910/DVN/XT08HW and online appendices are available at https://doi.org/doi:10.1017/S000712341700014X

Footnotes
References
Hide All
Aarøe Lene, and Petersen Michael Bang. 2014. Crowding Out Culture: Scandinavians and Americans Agree on Social Welfare in the Face of Deservingness Cues. The Journal of Politics 76 (3):684697.
Arceneaux Kevin, and Johnson Martin. 2013. Changing Minds or Changing Channels? Partisan News in an Age of Choice. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
Berinsky Adam J., Huber Gregory A., and Lenz Gabriel S.. 2012. Evaluating Online Labor Markets for Experimental Research: Amazon.com’s Mechanical Turk. Political Analysis 20 (3):351368.
Billig Michael. 2003. Political Rhetoric. In The Oxford Handbook of Political Psychology, 1st Edition, edited by David O. Sears, Leonie Huddy and Robert Jervis, 222250. New York: Oxford University Press.
Bruno Robert. 2009. Evidence of Bias in the Chicago Tribune Coverage of Organized Labor A Quantitative Study from 1991 to 2001. Labor Studies Journal 34 (3):385407.
Bureau of Labor Statistics. 2016. Union Members Summary 2015, 28 January. Available from http://www.bls.gov/news.release/union2.nr0.htm. Accessed 30 December 2016.
Carreiro Joshua L. 2005. Newspaper Coverage of the U.S. Labor Movement: The Case of Anti-Union Firings 1. Labor Studies Journal 30 (3):120.
Chandler Jesse, Mueller Pam, and Paolacci Gabriele. 2013. Nonnaïveté among Amazon Mechanical Turk Workers: Consequences and Solutions for Behavioral Researchers. Behavior Research Methods 46 (1):112130.
Cohn Jonathan. 2008. Autoworkers Making $70 An Hour? Not Really. CBS News, 24 November. Available from http://www.cbsnews.com/news/autoworkers-making-70-an-hour-not-really/. Accessed 30 December 2016.
Collins Chuck. 2012. 99 to 1: How Wealth Inequality Is Wrecking the World and What We Can Do About It. 1st Edition. San Francisco, CA: Berrett-Koehler Publishers.
Desilver Drew. 2014. American Unions Membership Declines as Public Support Fluctuates. Pew Research Center, 20 February. Available from http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2014/02/20/for-american-unions-membership-trails-far-behind-public-support/. Accessed 30 December 2016.
Editorial Board. 2014. Taken for a Ride by the LIRR Unions. The New York Post, 17 July. Available from http://nypost.com/2014/07/17/taken-for-a-ride-by-the-lirr-unions/. Accessed 30 December 2016.
Emmenegger Patrick. 2009. Barriers to Entry: Insider/Outsider Politics and the Political Determinants of Job Security Regulations. Journal of European Social Policy 19 (2):131146.
Engels Friedrich. 1892. The Condition of the Working Class in England. English Edition. New York: Progress Publishers, Available from https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1892/01/11.htm.
Erickson Christopher L., Fisk Catherine L., Milkman Ruth, Mitchell Daniel J. B., and Wong Kent. 2002. Justice for Janitors in Los Angeles: Lessons from Three Rounds of Negotiations. British Journal of Industrial Relations 40 (3):543567.
Fermino Jennifer. 2012. Wrong-Shoremen. New York Post, 23 August. Available from http://nypost.com/2012/08/23/wrong-shoremen/. Accessed 30 December 2016.
Fletcher Michael A. 2010. Amid Backlash and Budget Deficits, Government Workers’ Pensions Are Targets. The Washington Post, 6 October. Available from http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/10/05/AR2010100506187.html. Accessed 30 December 2016.
Flynn Francis J. 2000. No News Is Good News: The Relationship Between Media Attention and Strike Duration. Industrial Relations: A Journal of Economy and Society 39 (1):139160.
Fund John. 2012. Chicago Bled Dry by Striking Teachers’ Unions. National Review Online, 10 September. Available from http://www.nationalreview.com/corner/316395/chicago-bled-dry-striking-teachers-unions-john-fund. Accessed 30 December 2016.
Gelinas Nicole. 2014. Millionaires on Strike? The Unfair Demands of LIRR Unions. New York Post, 9 June. Available from http://nypost.com/2014/06/08/millionaires-on-strike-the-unfair-demainds-of-lirr-unions/. Accessed 30 December 2016.
Gilens Martin. 1999. Why Americans Hate Welfare: Race, Media, and the Politics of Antipoverty Policy. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
Greenhouse Steven. 2014. Wisconsin’s Legacy for Unions. The New York Times, 22 February. Available from http://www.nytimes.com/2014/02/23/business/wisconsins-legacy-for-unions.html. Accessed 30 December 2016.
Gregory Paul Roderick. 2011. American Labor Unions: Underpaid, Overproductive Or Overpaid? Forbes, 12 July. Available from http://www.forbes.com/2011/07/08/labor-unions-economics.html. Accessed 30 December 2016.
Hamill Ruth, Wilson Timothy D., and Nisbett Richard E.. 1980. Insensitivity to Sample Bias: Generalizing from Atypical Cases. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 39 (4):578589.
Harmon Mark D., and Lee Shu-Yueh. 2010. A Longitudinal Study of U.S. Network TV Newscasts and Strikes: Political Economy on the Picket Line. Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly 87 (3–4):501514.
Hochschild Jennifer, and Weaver Vesla. 2015. Is the Significance of Race Declining in the Political Arena? Yes, and No. Ethnic and Racial Studies 38 (8):12501257.
Huddy Leonie, Mason Lilliana, and Aarøe Lene. 2015. Expressive Partisanship: Campaign Involvement, Political Emotion, and Partisan Identity. American Political Science Review 109 (1):117.
Iyengar Shanto, Peters Mark D., and Kinder Donald R.. 1982. Experimental Demonstrations of the ‘Not-So-Minimal’ Consequences of Television News Programs. The American Political Science Review 76 (4):848858.
Jackman Mary R., and Jackman Robert W.. 1985. Class Awareness in the United States. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Kane John. 2017. “Replication Data for: “Organized Labor as the New Undeserving Rich? Mass Media, Class-Based Anti-Union Rhetoric, and Public Support for Unions in the U.S.””, doi: 10.7910/DVN/XT08HW, Harvard Dataverse, V1, UNF:6:GeH640RWWsg5q3pqppLapQ==.
Kaufmann Karen M. 2003. Cracks in the Rainbow: Group Commonality as a Basis for Latino and African-American Political Coalitions. Political Research Quarterly 56 (2):199210.
Kelloway E. Kevin, Francis Lori, Catano Victor M., and Dupré Kathryne E.. 2008. Third-Party Support for Strike Action. Journal of Applied Psychology 93 (4):806817.
Kellstedt Paul M. 2000. Media Framing and the Dynamics of Racial Policy Preferences. American Journal of Political Science 44 (2):245260.
Kilkenny Allison. 2013. BART Strike: Another Instance of Media Portraying Workers as Greedy. The Nation, 2 July. Available from http://www.thenation.com/blog/175063/bart-strike-another-instance-media-portraying-workers-greedy. Accessed 30 December 2016.
Kinder Donald R., and Kam Cindy D.. 2010. Us Against Them: Ethnocentric Foundations of American Opinion. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
Klandermans Bert. 1986. Psychology and Trade Union Participation: Joining, Acting, Quitting. Journal of Occupational Psychology 59 (3):189204.
Klapper Joseph T. 1960. The Effects of Mass Communication Vol. xii. New York: Free Press.
Krugman Paul. 2011. Oligarchy, American Style. The New York Times, sec. Opinion, 3 November. Available from http://www.nytimes.com/2011/11/04/opinion/oligarchy-american-style.html.
Kumar Deepa. 2001. Mass Media, Class, and Democracy: The Struggle over Newspaper Representation of the UPS Strike. Critical Studies in Media Communication 18 (3):285302.
Lane Charles. 2012. Charles Lane: Students Are Victims in Chicago Fight over Clout. The Washington Post, 10 September. Available from https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/charles-lane-students-are-victims-in-chicago-fight-over-clout/2012/09/10/ec4b47c2-fb66-11e1-b2af-1f7d12fe907a_story.html?amp;denied=1&socialreader_check=0. Accessed 30 December 2016.
Leone Lew. 2014. Lew’s View: LIRR Workers’ Strike Threat. My Fox NY, 11 June. Available from http://www.myfoxny.com/story/25753400/lews-view-lirr-workers-strike-threat. Accessed 30 December 2016.
Levin Josh. 2013. The Real Story of Linda Taylor, America’s Original Welfare Queen. Slate Magazine, 19 December. Available from http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/history/2013/12/linda_taylor_welfare_queen_ronald_reagan_made_her_a_notorious_american_villain.html. Accessed 30 December 2016.
Lippmann Walter. 1946. Public Opinion. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers.
Lipset Seymour Martin, and Schneider William. 1987. The Confidence Gap: Business, Labor and Government in the Public Mind, Revised Edition. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Lovett Kenneth. 2014. Over 10K MTA Employees Earned Six-Figure-Salaries in 2013: Report. NY Daily News, 4 June. Available from http://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/10k-mta-employees-earned-six-figure-salaries-2013-report-article-1.1817547. Accessed 30 December 2016.
Macaray David. 2013. What the Longshoremen’s Strike Was Really About. The Huffington Post, 6 February. Available from http://www.huffingtonpost.com/david-macaray/longshoremens-strike-was-about_b_2257917.html. Accessed 30 December 2016.
Maher Kris, and Terlep Sharon. 2008. For UAW, Aid Likely to Come With Strings. Wall Street Journal, 21 November. Available from http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB122723654355647077. Accessed 30 December 2016.
Maitner Angela T., Mackie Diane M., Claypool Heather M., and Crisp Richard J.. 2010. Identity Salience Moderates Processing of Group-Relevant Information. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 46 (2):441444.
Marlow Michael. 2012. The Huge Cost of Public Unions: Spending We Can’t Sustain. NY Daily News, 24 August. Available from http://www.nydailynews.com/opinion/huge-cost-public-unions-article-1.1143138. Accessed 30 December 2016.
Martin Christopher R. 2004. Framed!: Labor and the Corporate Media. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
McCall Leslie. 2013. The Undeserving Rich: American Beliefs about Inequality, Opportunity, and Redistribution. New York and Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
McKinstry Leo. 2015. Unions vs. Workers – This Is David Cameron’s Chance to Strike Back. The Spectator, 11 July. Available from http://www.spectator.co.uk/2015/07/unions-no-longer-serve-working-people-its-time-to-emasculate-themcounter-strike/. Accessed 30 December 2016.
Mullinix Kevin J., Leeper Thomas J., Druckman James N., and Freese Jeremy. 2015. The Generalizability of Survey Experiments. Journal of Experimental Political Science 2 (2):109138.
Nelson Thomas E., Clawson Rosalee A., and Oxley Zoe M.. 1997. Media Framing of a Civil Liberties Conflict and Its Effect on Tolerance. The American Political Science Review 91 (3):567.
Oorschot Wim van. 2000. Who Should Get What, and Why? On Deservingness Criteria and the Conditionality of Solidarity among the Public. Policy & Politics 28 (1):3348.
Parenti Michael. 1986. Inventing Reality: The Politics of the Mass Media. 1st Edition. New York: St. Martin’s Press.
Park David J., and Wright Larry M.. 2007. Giving Labor the Business? Changes in Business and Labor Reporting from 1980 to 2000. Labor Studies Journal 32 (1):6081.
Patterson Matt. 2012. Chicago Teachers Union: Overpaid Babysitters? Competitive Enterprise Institute, 13 September. https://cei.org/blog/chicago-teachers-union-overpaid-babysitters. Accessed 30 December 2016.
Pawlenty Tim. 2010. Government Unions vs. Taxpayers. The Wall Street Journal, 13 December. Available from http://online.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052748703766704576009350303578410. Accessed 30 December 2016.
Payne Ed, 2012. Q&A: What’s behind the Chicago Teachers’ Strike? – CNN.com. CNN, 17 September. Available from http://www.cnn.com/2012/09/17/us/chicago-strike-explainer/index.html. Accessed 30 December 2016.
PBS. 2011. Ohio Voters Weigh Repeal of Controversial Collective-Bargaining Law. PBS NewsHour, 14 October. Available from http://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/politics-july-dec11-ohiounion_10-14/. Accessed 30 December 2016.
Perry Charles R. 1987. Union Corporate Campaigns. Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania Center for.Wharton School of Business.
Petersen Michael Bang, Slothuus Rune, Stubager Rune, and Togeby Lise. 2011. Deservingness versus Values in Public Opinion on Welfare: The Automaticity of the Deservingness Heuristic. European Journal of Political Research 50 (1):2452.
Potts Monica. 2012. Outrageous Teacher Pay? The American Prospect, 18 September. Available from http://prospect.org/article/outrageous-teacher-pay. Accessed 30 December 2016.
Puette William. 1992. Through Jaundiced Eyes: How the Media View Organized Labor. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
Rashbaum William K. 2009. Carpenters’ Union Chief and 9 Others Face Corruption Charges. The New York Times, 5 August. Available from http://cityroom.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/08/05/carpenters-union-head-and-9-others-charged-in-corruption-scheme/. Accessed 30 December 2016.
Reich Robert B. 2010. Aftershock: The Next Economy and America’s Future. New York: Knopf Doubleday Publishing Group.
Reich Robert B. 2011. The Shameful Attack on Public Employees. Huffington Post, 5 January. Available from http://www.huffingtonpost.com/robert-reich/the-shameful-attack-on-pu_b_805050.html. Accessed 30 December 2016.
Reich Robert B. 2012. Beyond Outrage: Expanded Edition: What Has Gone Wrong with Our Economy and Our Democracy, and How to Fix It. Expanded Edition. New York: Vintage.
Reicher Stephen, and Hopkins Nicolas. 1996. Self-Category Constructions in Political Rhetoric; an Analysis of Thatcher’s and Kinnock’s Speeches Concerning the British Miners’ Strike (1984–5). European Journal of Social Psychology 26 (3):353371.
Richwine Jason. 2012. Chicago Teachers’ Retirement Benefits Are Extravagant. The Daily Signal, 13 September. Available from http://dailysignal.com/2012/09/13/chicago-teachers-retirement-benefits-are-extravagant/. Accessed 30 December 2016.
Riggins Stephen Harold. 1997. The Rhetoric of Othering. In The Language and Politics of Exclusion: Others in Discourse, edited by Stephen Harold Riggins, 130. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Rueda David. 2005. Insider-Outsider Politics in Industrialized Democracies: The Challenge to Social Democratic Parties. The American Political Science Review 99 (1):6174.
Ryan Charlotte. 2004. It Takes a Movement to Raise an Issue: Media Lessons from the 1997 U.P.S. Strike. Critical Sociology 30 (2):483511.
Schattschneider E. E.. 1960. The Semi-Sovereign People. New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston.
Schmidt Diane E. 1993. Public Opinion and Media Coverage of Labor Unions. Journal of Labor Research 14 (2):151164.
Schwander Hanna, and Häusermann Silja. 2013. Who Is in and Who Is out? A Risk-Based Conceptualization of Insiders and Outsiders. Journal of European Social Policy 23 (3):248269.
Sherk James. 2008. UAW Workers Actually Cost the Big Three Automakers $70 an Hour. The Heritage Foundation, 8 December. Available from http://www.heritage.org/research/reports/2008/12/uaw-workers-actually-cost-the-big-three-automakers-70-an-hour. Accessed 30 December 2016.
Sirin Cigdem V., Villalobos José D., and Valentino Nicholas A.. 2016. Group Empathy Theory: The Effect of Group Empathy on US Intergroup Attitudes and Behavior in the Context of Immigration Threats. The Journal of Politics 78 (3):893908.
Smiley Tavis, and West Cornell. 2012. The Rich and the Rest of Us. New York: SmileyBooks.
Surowiecki James. 2011. State Of The Unions. The New Yorker, 10 January. Available from http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2011/01/17/state-of-the-unions. Accessed 30 December 2016.
Taber Charles S., and Lodge Milton. 2006. Motivated Skepticism in the Evaluation of Political Beliefs. American Journal of Political Science 50 (3):755769.
Tajfel Henri. 1974. Social Identity and Intergroup Behaviour. Social Science Information/Sur Les Sciences Sociales 13 (2):6593.
Tajfel Henri, Billig M. G., Bundy R. P., and Flament Claude. 1971. Social Categorization and Intergroup Behaviour. European Journal of Social Psychology 1 (2):149178.
The Daily Mail . 2015. PM Must Stop Greedy Unions in Their Tracks, 17 May. Available from http://www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/article-3084826/MAIL-SUNDAY-COMMENT-PM-stop-greedy-unions-tracks.html. Accessed 30 December 2016.
The New York Times . 1982. Big Labor Settles for Less, 4 March. Available from http://www.nytimes.com/1982/03/04/opinion/big-labor-settles-for-less.html. Accessed 30 December 2016.
The New York Times . 1977. Labor Loses Two in a Row, 26 March. Available from http://www.nytimes.com/1977/03/26/archives/labor-loses-two-in-a-row.html. Accessed 30 December 2016.
Tingley Dustin, Yamamoto Teppei, Hirose Kentaro, Keele Luke, and Imai Kosuke. 2014. Mediation: R Package for Causal Mediation Analysis. UCLA Statistics/American Statistical Association, August. Available from http://dspace.mit.edu/handle/1721.1/91154. Accessed 30 December 2016.
Winslow Samantha. 2012. Union-Backed Ballot Measures Mostly Voted Up | Labor Notes, 7 November. Available from http://labornotes.org/2012/11/union-backed-ballot-measures-mostly-voted. Accessed 30 December 2016.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

British Journal of Political Science
  • ISSN: 0007-1234
  • EISSN: 1469-2112
  • URL: /core/journals/british-journal-of-political-science
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Keywords:

Type Description Title
PDF
Supplementary Materials

Kane and Newman supplementary material
Appendix

 PDF (1.2 MB)
1.2 MB
UNKNOWN
Supplementary Materials

Kane and Newman Dataset
Dataset

 Unknown

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 6
Total number of PDF views: 44 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 440 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between 14th August 2017 - 13th December 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.