Skip to main content
×
Home

Unhinged Frames: Assessing Thought Experiments in Normative Political Theory

Abstract

This article develops a framework for assessing thought experiments in normative political theory. It argues that we should distinguish between relevant and irrelevant hypotheticals according to a criterion of modality. Relevant hypotheticals, while far-fetched, construct imaginary cases that are possible for us, here and now. Irrelevant hypotheticals conjure up imaginary cases that are barely conceivable at all. To establish this claim, the article interrogates, via a discussion of Susan Sontag and Judith Butler’s accounts of representations of violence, the frames through which hypotheticals construct possible worlds, and concludes that some frames are better than others at sustaining a link with the world as we know it. Frames that disrupt this link can be charged with failing to offer action-guidance.

Copyright
Footnotes
Hide All
*

Politics and International Relations, University of Edinburgh (email: mathias.thaler@ed.ac.uk). Earlier versions of this article were presented at the Political Theory Research Group meeting in Edinburgh (2015), the PSA General Conference in Sheffield (2015) and the APSA General Conference in San Francisco (2015). The author is grateful to the audiences of all these events for their excellent questions. Special thanks are due to Philip Cook, Liz Frazer, Dustin Howes, Kim Hutchings, Moya Lloyd, Mihaela Mihai, Kieran Oberman and Alan Wilson, who have read various/different versions of this article and proposed highly perceptive and helpful feedback. A debt of gratitude is also due to this Journal’s three referees for suggesting many improvements to the original manuscript. Finally, the author thanks the Editor, Rob Johns, for expertly navigating the article through the review process and for generously offering guidance throughout. The usual disclaimers apply. The research for this article has benefited from a Marie Curie Career Integration Grant (JUDGEPOL).

Footnotes
References
Hide All
Alfano Mark, and Loeb Don. 2014. Experimental Moral Philosophy. In Edward N. Zalta, ed., The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Available from http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/sum2014/entries/experimental-moral/, accessed 20 November 2014.
Allhoff Fritz. 2005. A Defense of Torture: Separation of Cases, Ticking Time-Bombs, and Moral Justification. International Journal of Applied Philosophy 19:243264.
Anscombe G. E. M. 1958. Modern Moral Philosophy. Philosophy 33:119.
Boltanski Luc. 1999. Distant Suffering: Morality, Media, and Politics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Bourdieu Pierre. 2000. Pascalian Meditations. Stanford, Calif.: Stanford University Press.
Brand-Ballard Jeffrey. 2007. F. M. Kamm: Intricate Ethics: Rights, Responsibilities, and Permissible Harm. Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews. Available from https://ndpr.nd.edu/news/25299-intricate-ethics-rights-responsibilities-and-permissible-harm/, accessed 14 November 2014.
Brecher Robert. 2007. Torture and the Ticking Bomb. Malden/Oxford: Blackwell Publishing.
Brendel Elke. 2004. Intuition Pumps and the Proper Use of Thought Experiments. Dialectica 58:89108.
Brown James Robert, and Yiftach Fehige. 2016. “Thought Experiments”, The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Spring 2016 Edition), Edward N. Zalta (ed.), URL=<http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/spr2016/entries/thought-experiment/>.
Bufacchi Vittorio, and Arrigo Jean Maria. 2006. Torture, Terrorism and the State: A Refutation of the Ticking-Bomb Argument. Journal of Applied Philosophy 23:355373.
Butler Judith. 2004. Precarious Life: The Powers of Mourning and Violence. London/New York: Verso.
Butler Judith. 2007. Torture and the Ethics of Photography. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 25:951966.
Butler Judith. 2009. Frames of War: When Is Life Grievable? London/New York: Verso.
Carroll Noël. 2002. The Wheel of Virtue: Art, Literature, and Moral Knowledge. Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism 60:326.
Chambers Samuel A., and Carver Terrell, eds. 2008. Judith Butler and Political Theory: Troubling Politics. London/New York: Routledge.
Chappell Timothy. 2014. Knowing What to Do: Imagination, Virtue, and Platonism in Ethics. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Cohen G. A. 2008. Rescuing Justice and Equality. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.
Cohen Stanley. 2001. States of Denial: Knowing about Atrocities and Suffering. Cambridge/Malden, Mass.: Polity.
Cova Florian, and Naar Hichem. 2011. Side-Effect Effect without Side Effects: The Pervasive Impact of Moral Considerations on Judgments of Intentionality. Philosophical Psychology 25:837854.
Dennett Daniel C. 1991. Consciousness Explained. Boston, Mass.: Little, Brown and Co.
Dershowitz Alan M. 2002. Why Terrorism Works: Understanding the Threat, Responding to the Challenge. New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press.
Edmonds David. 2013. Would You Kill the Fat Man? The Trolley Problem and What Your Answer Tells Us about Right and Wrong. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.
Elster Jakob. 2011. How Outlandish Can Imaginary Cases Be? Journal of Applied Philosophy 28:241258.
Farrell Michelle. 2013. The Ticking Bomb Scenario: Origins, Usages and the Contemporary Discourse. Pp. 82146 in The Prohibition of Torture in Exceptional Circumstances. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Farrelly Colin. 2007. Justice in Ideal Theory: A Refutation. Political Studies 55:844864.
Foot Philippa. 1967. The Problem of Abortion and the Doctrine of Double Effect. Oxford Review 5:515.
Fried Gregory. 2014. Review of Uwe Steinhoff, On the Ethics of Torture, SUNY Press 2013. Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews. Available from http://ndpr.nd.edu/news/48412-on-the-ethics-of-torture/, accessed 19 May 2014.
Geuss Raymond. 2008. Philosophy and Real Politics. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.
Gilabert Pablo. 2011. Comparative Assessments of Justice, Political Feasibility, and Ideal Theory. Ethical Theory and Moral Practice 15:3956.
Gourevitch Philip. 2008. Exposure: The woman behind the camera at Abu Ghraib. 24 March. Available from http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2008/03/24/exposure-5, accessed 26 November 2014.
Gross Oren. 2004. The Prohibition on Torture and the Limits of the Law. Pp. 229251 in Sanford Levinson, ed., Torture: A Collection. Oxford/New York: Oxford University Press.
Kamm Frances M. 2006. Terrorism and Several Moral Distinctions. Legal Theory 12:1969.
Kamm Frances M. 2008. Intricate Ethics: Rights, Responsibilities, and Permissible Harm. Oxford/New York: Oxford University Press.
Knobe Joshua Michael, and Nichols Shaun, eds. 2008. Experimental Philosophy. Oxford/New York: Oxford University Press.
Laden Anthony Simon. 2011. The Key to/of Public Philosophy. Political Theory 39:112117.
Lebow Richard Ned. 2010. Forbidden Fruit: Counterfactuals and International Relations. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.
Luban David. 2009. Human Dignity, Humiliation, and Torture. Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 19:211230.
Luban David. 2014. Torture, Power, and Law. Cambridge/New York: Cambridge University Press.
McMahan Jeff. 2002. The Ethics of Killing: Problems at the Margins of Life. New York: Oxford University Press.
McMahan Jeff. 2008. Torture in Principle and in Practice. Public Affairs Quarterly 22:91108.
McMahan Jeff. 2009. Killing in War. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
McMahan Jeff. Forthcoming. Torture and Method in Moral Philosophy. In Torture and the Rule of Law, edited by Scott Anderson and Martha Nussbaum. Chicago: Chicago University Press.
Mills Charles W. 2005. ‘Ideal Theory’ as Ideology. Hypatia 20:165183.
Miščević Nenad. 2013. Political Thought Experiments from Plato to Rawls. Pp. 191206 in Melanie Frappier, Letitia Meynell and Robert Brown, eds, Thought Experiments in Science, Philosophy, and the Arts. New York: Routledge.
Morris Errol. 2008. The Most Curious Thing. New York Times blog. Available from http://morris.blogs.nytimes.com/2008/05/19/the-most-curious-thing/?, accessed 26 November 2014.
Nozick Robert. 1974. Anarchy, State, and Utopia. New York: Basic Books.
Rawls John. 1999. A Theory of Justice, Revised Edition. Cambridge, Mass.: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.
Rejali Darius M. 2007. Torture and Democracy. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.
Scheppele Kim Lane. 2005. Hypothetical Torture in the War on Terrorism. Journal of National Security Law & Policy 1:285340.
Shapiro Ian. 2005. The Flight from Reality in the Human Sciences. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.
Shue Henry. 1978. Torture. Philosophy and Public Affairs 7:124143.
Shue Henry. 2006. Torture in Dreamland: Disposing of the Ticking Bomb. Case Western Reserve Journal of International Law 37:231239.
Sontag Susan. 1977. On Photography. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
Sontag Susan. 2003. Regarding the Pain of Others. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
Sontag Susan. 2004. Regarding the Torture of Others. New York Times, 23 May. Available from http://www.nytimes.com/2004/05/23/magazine/regarding-the-torture-of-others.html, accessed 9 October 2014.
Sorensen Roy A. 1992. Thought Experiments. New York/Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Standard Operating Procedure, directed by Errol Morris (2008), available at http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0896866/
Steinhoff Uwe. 2010. Defusing the Ticking Social Bomb Argument: The Right to Self-Defensive Torture. Global Dialogue 12:1 Winter/Spring. Available from http://www.worlddialogue.org/content.php?id=457, accessed 19 November 2014.
Steinhoff Uwe. 2013. On the Ethics of Torture. Albany: State University of New York Press.
Stone Alison. 2005. Towards a Genealogical Feminism: A Reading of Judith Butler’s Political Thought. Contemporary Political Theory 4:424.
Tetlock Philip E., and Belkin Aaron, eds. 1996. Counterfactual Thought Experiments in World Politics: Logical, Methodological, and Psychological Perspectives. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.
Thomson Judith Jarvis. 1971. A Defense of Abortion. Philosophy and Public Affairs 1:4766.
Tully James. 2008. Public Philosophy in a New Key. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Vaidya Anand. 2015. The Epistemology of Modality. In Edward N. Zalta ed., The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Available from http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/sum2015/entries/modality-epistemology/, accessed 6 October 2015.
Valentini Laura. 2012. Ideal vs. Non-Ideal Theory: A Conceptual Map. Philosophy Compass 7:654664.
Waldron Jeremy. 2011. What Are Moral Absolutes Like? Rochester, N.Y.: Social Science Research Network. Available from http://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=1906850, accessed 26 September 2013.
Walsh Adrian. 2011. A Moderate Defence of the Use of Thought Experiments in Applied Ethics. Ethical Theory and Moral Practice 14:467481.
Walzer Michael. 2006. Just and Unjust Wars: A Moral Argument with Historical Illustrations, 4th edn. New York: Basic Books.
Williams Bernard. 2005. In the Beginning Was the Deed: Realism and Moralism in Political Argument. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.
Wisnewski J. Jeremy. 2008. It’s About Time: Defusing the Ticking Bomb Argument. International Journal of Applied Philosophy 22:103116.
Wisnewski J. Jeremy. 2014. Review of F. M. Kamm, Ethics for Enemies: Terror, Torture, and War, Oxford University Press, 2011, in Journal of Moral Philosophy 11:657660.
Zehfuss Maja. 2009. Hierarchies of Grief and the Possibility of War: Remembering UK Fatalities in Iraq. Millennium: Journal of International Studies 38:419440.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

British Journal of Political Science
  • ISSN: 0007-1234
  • EISSN: 1469-2112
  • URL: /core/journals/british-journal-of-political-science
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Keywords:

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 26
Total number of PDF views: 73 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 512 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between 17th October 2016 - 20th November 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.