Skip to main content
×
Home

HIV Positive People’s Perspectives on Canadian Criminal Law and Non-Disclosure

  • Barry D. Adam (a1), Jason Globerman (a2), Richard Elliott (a3), Patrice Corriveau (a4), Ken English (a5) and Sean Rourke (a6)...
Abstract
Abstract

The largest survey to date of people living with HIV regarding attitudes toward criminalization of HIV non-disclosure, this study investigates: sources of legal information available to HIV-positive people; perceptions of how criminal prosecutions and media coverage affect understanding of rights and responsibilities of self and others; and where HIV-positive people themselves stand on the role the criminal justice system should play. While mainstream media constructions of criminal iconography do affect PHA views, those who have higher levels of formal education, are active in the dating scene, and have been living longer with HIV hold less punitive views than those who do not. While the overall pattern of agreement on where to draw the line in criminal prosecution holds regardless of demographic characteristics, there is some statistically significant variation in degree of punitiveness according to sexual orientation and gender as well.

Résumé

Cette étude représente le plus important sondage à ce jour auprès de personnes séropositives sur leur attitude par rapport à la criminalisation de la non-divulgation. L’auteur y étudie: les sources d’information juridique offertes aux personnes atteintes du VIH; les perceptions sur la façon par laquelle les poursuites criminelles et le battage médiatique connexe influent sur la compréhension des droits et responsabilités de soi-même et des autres; et l’opinion des personnes séropositives sur le rôle que devrait jouer l’appareil de justice pénale. Les points de vue semblent être infléchis sur quatre rapports: (1) les constructions d’iconographie criminelle des grands médias, (2) le niveau d’instruction des répondants, (3) la fréquentation, par les répondants, des milieux de rencontres, et (4) la transition du statut de plaignant potentiel (peu après la contraction du virus) au statut d’accusé potentiel (au terme d’un certain délai après l’infection au VIH). Bien que tous les répondants semblent convenir de l’opportunité de poursuites criminelles, et ce, toutes caractéristiques démographiques confondues, il existe des variations statistiques importantes, selon l’orientation sexuelle et le sexe, quant à la sévérité des sanctions à imposer.

Copyright
References
Hide All
Adam Barry D., Corriveau Patrice, Elliott Richard, Globerman Jason, English Ken, and Rourke Sean. 2014. HIV disclosure as practice and public policy. Critical Public Health 25 (4): 386–97.
Adam Barry D., Elliott Richard, Corriveau Patrice, and English Ken. 2014. Impacts of criminalization on the everyday lives of people living in with HIV in Canada. Sexuality Research and Social Policy 11: 3949.
Adam Barry D., Elliott Richard, Husbands Winston, Murray James and Maxwell John. 2008. Effects of the criminalization of HIV transmission in Cuerrier on men reporting unprotected sex with men. Canadian Journal of Law and Society 23 (1–2): 143–59.
Adam Barry D., and Sears Alan. 1996. Experiencing HIV. New York: Columbia University Press.
Buchanan 2015. When is HIV a crime? Sexuality, gender and consent. Minnesota Law Review 99: 1231–42.
Caldwell B. 2013. Culprit still shrugs off blame for HIV sexual assault crimes. Waterloo Record, April 8. http://www.therecord.com/news-story/2626669-culprit-still-shrugs-off-blame-for-hiv-sexual-assault-crimes/.
Calzavara Liviana, Allman Dan, Worthington Catherine, Tyndall Mark, and Adrien Alix. 2012. HIV and AIDS in Canada: A National Survey. http://www.srchiv.ca/NationalSurvey/the-knowledge-bank/publications/.
Canadian HIV/AIDS Legal Network. 2012a. Positive Women: Exposing Injustice. http://www.positivewomenthemovie.org.
Canadian HIV/AIDS Legal Network, HIV/AIDS Legal Clinic Ontario, Coalition des organismes communautaires québécois de lutte contre le sida, Positive Living Society of British Columbia, Canadian AIDS Society, Toronto People with AIDS Foundation, Black Coalition for AIDS Prevention, et al. 2012b. Unjust Supreme Court Ruling on Criminalization of HIV Major Step Backwards for Public Health and Human Rights. News release: Toronto, October 5.
Canadian HIV/AIDS Legal Network. 2012c. HIV non-disclosure and the criminal law: An analysis of two recent decisions of the Supreme Court of Canada. http://www.aidslaw.ca/site/hiv-non-disclosure-and-the-criminal-law-an-analysis-of-two-recent-decisions-of-the-supreme-court-of-canada/. Toronto, October 29.
Canadian HIV/AIDS Legal Network, AIDS ACTION NOW! and International Community of Women Living with HIV (Global). 2013. Courthouse protestors condemn ‘witch-hunt’ by Crown prosecutors against people living with HIV, call for action by Attorney General. News release: Toronto, July 8.
Canadian HIV/AIDS Legal Network. 2015. Consent: HIV non-disclosure and sexual assault law. http://www.consentfilm.org.
Clarke Juanne. 2006. Homophobia out of the closet in the media portrayal of HIV/AIDS 1991, 1996 and 2001. Critical Public Health 16 (4): 317–30.
Dodds C., and Keogh P.. 2006. Criminal prosecutions for HIV transmission: people living with HIV respond. International Journal of STD & AIDS 17: 315–18.
Dodds C., Bourne A., and Weait M.. 2009. Responses to criminal prosecutions for HIV transmission among gay men with HIV in England and Wales. Reproductive Health Matters 17 (34): 135–45.
Galletly Carol, Glasman Laura, Pinkerton Steven, and DiFrancisco Wayne. 2012. New Jersey’s HIV Exposure Law and the HIV-Related Attitudes, Beliefs, and Sexual and Seropositive Status Disclosure Behaviors of Persons Living with HIV. American Journal of Public Health 102 (11): 2135–40.
Grant Isabel. 2011. The prosecution of non-disclosure of HIV in Canada: time to rethink Cuerrier. McGill Journal of Law and Health 5 (1): 759.
Grant Isabel. 2013. The over-criminalization of persons with HIV. University of Toronto Law Journal 63: 475–84.
Hoppe Trevor. 2014. From sickness to badness: The criminalization of HIV in Michigan. Social Science and Medicine 101: 139–47.
Horvath Keith, Weinmeyer Richard, and Rosser Simon. 2010. Should it be illegal for HIV-positive persons to have unprotected sex without disclosure? AIDS Care 22 (10): 1221–28.
Jiwani Yasmin. 2014. Rape and race in the Canadian press. Arts and Social Sciences Journal S1009. doi: 10.4172/2151-6200.S1-009.
Kirkup Kyle. 2015. Releasing stigma: Police, journalists and crimes of HIV non-disclosure. Ottawa Law Review 46 (1): 129–60.
Klitzman Robert, Kirshenbaum Sheri, Kittel Lauren, Morin Stephen, Daya Shaira, Mastrogiacomo Maddalena, and Rotheram-Borus Mary Jane. 2004. Naming names. Sexuality Research & Social Policy 1 (3): 3857.
Loutfy Mona, Tyndall Mark, Baril Jean-Guy, Montaner Julio SG, Kaul Rupert, Hankins Catherine. 2014. Canadian Consensus Statement on HIV and its transmission in the context of the criminal law. Canadian Journal of Infectious Diseases & Medical Microbiology 25 (3): 135–40.
Mathen Carissima, and Plaxton Michael. 2011. HIV, consent and criminal wrongs. Criminal Law Quarterly 57: 464–85.
Miller James. 2005. African immigrant damnation syndrome. Sexuality Research & Social Policy 2 (2): 3150.
Myers Ted, Allman Dan, Adam Barry D., Alexander Stephen, Blais Martin, Calzavara Liviana, Remis Robert, Marchand Rick, and Maxwell John. 2013. Male Call Canada Technical Report. http://www.malecall.ca/technical-report/.
Mykhalovskiy Eric, and Betteridge Glenn. 2012. Who? What? Where? When? And with what consequences? An analysis of criminal cases of HIV non-disclosure in Canada. Canadian Journal of Law and Society 27 (1): 3153.
Persson Asha, and Newman Christy. 2008. Making monsters: Heterosexuality, crime and race in recent western media coverage of HIV. Sociology of Health and Illness 30 (4): 632–46.
Rangel J. Cristian, and Adam Barry D.. 2014. Everyday moral reasoning in the governmentality of HIV risk. Sociology of Health and Illness 36 (1): 6074.
Shaffer Martha. 2013. Sex, lies and HIV: Mabior and the concept of sexual fraud. University of Toronto Law Journal 63: 466–74.
Symington Alison. 2013. Injustice amplified by HIV non-disclosure ruling. University of Toronto Law Journal 63: 485–95.
Weait Matthew. 2007. Intimacy and Responsibility. New York: Routledge-Cavendish.
R. v Cuerrier, [1998] 2 SCR 371
R. v Mabior, 2012 SCC 47
R. v D.C., 2012 SCC 48
R. v J.T.C., 2013 NSPC 88
R. v J.T.C., 2013 NSPC 105
Criminal Code RSC 1985, c. C-46.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Canadian Journal of Law and Society / La Revue Canadienne Droit et Société
  • ISSN: 0829-3201
  • EISSN: 1911-0227
  • URL: /core/journals/canadian-journal-of-law-and-society-la-revue-canadienne-droit-et-societe
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Keywords:

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 12
Total number of PDF views: 70 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 553 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 19th November 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.