Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-c4f8m Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-18T10:00:16.909Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

China's New “Black Box”: Problems and Prospects for the Central National Security Commission

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  10 November 2017

Joel Wuthnow
Joel Wuthnow*
Affiliation:
National Defense University, Washington, DC. Email: joel.wuthnow.civ@ndu.edu.
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

China's establishment of a Central National Security Commission (CNSC) in late 2013 was a potentially transformative event in the evolution of China's national security decision-making structure. Yet, as of mid-2017, few details about this organization and its activities have been released, leading to continuing questions about its likely role and functions in the Chinese system. Based on an analysis of numerous authoritative but under-utilized Chinese sources, this article addresses the rationale, prospects and implications of the CNSC. It argues that the organization is both a fulfilment of a long-held desire by many in China for a centralized, permanent national security deliberation forum and also a reflection of the unique challenges facing China in the 21st century. Contrary to existing analyses, which argue that the CNSC is likely to be focused primarily on domestic security tasks, the article contends that it is more likely to play a major role in both internal and external security affairs. Moreover, the article argues that if certain obstacles can be addressed, the CNSC may have broad implications in areas ranging from China's crisis response capability to the role played by the Chinese Communist Party general secretary in the national security decision-making process. The conclusion recaps the findings and suggests avenues for further research.

摘要

中国在 2013 年底设立的中央国家安全委员会 (简称为国安委) 成为了中国国家安全决策结构演变的潜在的改革性的时刻. 但是, 截至 2015 年后期, 中国公布了较少关于国安委的结构和行动的信息, 而引起了对于它在中国体系的作用和职能的持续问题. 这片文章采用了各种不常利用的权威性的研究资料而进行了对于国安委的意图, 前途, 和影响力的探索. 本篇文章认为国安委的成立不仅实现了建立一个固定的国家安全决策机构长期持有的期望, 也是中国在 21 世纪面临的独特挑战的反映。 现有研究分析认为国安委的主要任务集中在国内安全事务, 但本文章却认为组织更有可能发挥内部以及外部安全事务的重大作用. 此外, 文章认为, 如果某些障碍能取得解决, 国安委即可影响到各种各样的安全领域, 包括了中国的危机应对能力以及中共总书记在国家安全决策过程中的角色等领域. 结论重述结果和提出了进一步研究的领域。

Keywords

Central National Security CommissionPeople's Liberation ArmyChinese civil–military relationsChinese foreign policyChinese domestic politicsnational security国家安全委员会决策结构习近平中共中央
Type
Special section: The People's Liberation Army in the Xi Jinping Era
Information
The China Quarterly , Volume 232 , December 2017 , pp. 886 - 903
Check for updates
Copyright
Copyright © SOAS University of London 2017 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Buckley, Chris. 2016. “Anonymous call for Xi to quit rattles Party leaders in China,” New York Times, 29 March.Google Scholar
Chen, Xiangyang. 2013. “Zhuajin yunchou xin shiqi Zhongguo guojia anquan zhanlüe” (Seize the opportunity to plan China's national security strategy), Liaowang, 2 December.Google Scholar
Christensen, Thomas. 2012. “More actors, less coordination? New challenges for the leaders of a rising China.” In Rozman, Gilbert (ed.), China's Foreign Policy: Who Makes It, and How Is It Made? New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 21–37.Google Scholar
Erickson, Andrew, and Liff, Adam. 2016. “Installing a safety on the ‘loaded gun’? China's institutional reforms, National Security Commission, and Sino-Japanese crisis (in)stability.” Journal of Contemporary China 25(98), 197–215.Google Scholar
Gong, Fangbin. 2014a. “Guo'an wei fahui zuoyong xu jiao chang guocheng” (The National Security Commission needs a relatively long time to play its role), International Herald Leader, 3 January.Google Scholar
Gong, Fangbin. 2014b. “Guojia anquan weiyuanhui sheli hou de anquan guanli” (Security management after the establishment of the National Security Commission), Xuexi shibao, 13 January.Google Scholar
Hu, Qingyun, and Guo, Yuandan. 2015. “Unprecedented security risks threaten nation: CPC,” Global Times, 24 January.Google Scholar
Hu, Weixing. 2016. “Xi Jinping's ‘big power diplomacy’ and China's Central National Security Commission.” Journal of Contemporary China 25(98), 163–177.Google Scholar
Hua, Yiwen. 2013. “Guojia anquan niejin wuzhi zuan cheng quan” (Squeeze five fingers to form a fist on national security), Renmin ribao (overseas edition), 13 November.Google Scholar
Hua, Yiwen. 2015. “‘Sanwei yiti’ kaiqi guojia anquan quanxin jieduan” (A “three-in-one” structure has ushered in a new period of national security), Renmin ribao (overseas edition), 2 July.Google Scholar
Jakobson, Linda, and Knox, Dean. 2010. “New foreign policy actors in China.” SIPRI Policy Paper No. 26, September.Google Scholar
Johnson, Christopher K. 2014. Decoding China's Emerging “Great Power” Strategy in Asia. Washington, DC: CSIS.Google Scholar
Johnston, Alastair Iain. 2016. “The evolution of interstate security crisis-management theory and practice in China.” Naval War College Review 69(1), 29–71.Google Scholar
Lamb, Christopher J., and Bond, Joseph C.. 2016. “Naitonal security reform and the 2016 election.” INSS Strategic Forum 293, 29 March, http://inss.ndu.edu/Portals/68/Documents/stratforum/SF-293.pdf.Google Scholar
Lampton, David M. 2015. “Xi Jinping and the National Security Commission: policy coordination and political power.” Journal of Contemporary China 24(95), 759–777.Google Scholar
Li, Cheng. 2014a. “Xi Jinping's inner circle (part 1: the Shaanxi gang),” China Leadership Monitor, 14 March.Google Scholar
Li, Cheng. 2014b. “Xi Jinping's inner circle: political protégés from the provinces,” China Leadership Monitor, 22 October.Google Scholar
Li, Shengquan. 2013. “Sheli guojia anquan weiyuanhui, tongchou guojia anquan de zhanlüe zhi ju” (Establishing a National Security Commission is a strategic decision for planning national security), Xuexi shibao, 18 November.Google Scholar
Meng, Xiangqing. 2013. “Zhongguo sheli guojia anquan weiyuanhui zheng dangqi shi” (China sets up the National Security Commission at the right time), Jiefangjun bao, 22 November.Google Scholar
Miller, Alice. 2008. “The CCP Central Committee's Leading Small Groups,” China Leadership Monitor, 2 September.Google Scholar
Miller, Alice. 2015. “The PLA in the Party decision-making system.” In Saunders, Phillip C. and Scobell, Andrew (eds.), PLA Influence on China's National Security Policymaking. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 58–83.Google Scholar
Miller, Frank, and Scobell, Andrew. 2005. “‘Decision-making under stress’ or ‘crisis management’?: In lieu of a conclusion.” In Scobell, Andrew and Wortzel, Larry M. (eds.), Chinese National Security Decision-Making Under Stress. Carlisle, PA: US Army War College, 229–248.Google Scholar
Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the PRC. 2014. “The central conference on work relating to foreign affairs was held in Beijing,” 29 November, http://www.fmprc.gov.cn/mfa_eng/zxxx_662805/t1215680.shtml.Google Scholar
Mulvenon, James. 2015. “The yuan stops here: Xi Jinping and the ‘CMC Chairman Responsibility System’,” China Leadership Monitor, 14 July.Google Scholar
National People's Congress Online. 2015. “Guojia anquan fa (cao'an erci shenyi gao) quanwen” (Draft National Security Law (for second deliberation) full text), 6 May, http://www.npc.gov.cn/npc/xinwen/lfgz/flca/2015-05/06/content_1935766.htm.Google Scholar
Pang, Qingjie. 2014. “Zongti guojia anquan guan yin hang Zhongguo” (The overall national security concept steers China), Jiefangjun bao, 27 April.Google Scholar
Saunders, Phillip C., and Wuthnow, Joel. 2016. “China's Goldwater-Nichols? Assessing PLA organizational reforms.” INSS Strategic Forum 294, April, http://inss.ndu.edu/Portals/68/Documents/stratforum/SF-294.pdf.Google Scholar
State Council Information Office of the PRC. 2015. “China's military strategy,” May, http://news.xinhuanet.com/english/china/2015-05/26/c_134271001.htm.Google Scholar
Sun, Yun. 2013a. “China's new ‘State Security Committee’: questions ahead,” PacNet, 14 November, https://www.csis.org/analysis/pacnet-81-chinas-new-state-security-committee-questions-ahead.Google Scholar
Sun, Yun. 2013b. Chinese National Security Decision-Making: Processes and Challenges. Washington, DC: The Brookings Institution.Google Scholar
Swaine, Michael D. 1998. The Role of the Chinese Military in National Security Policymaking. Santa Monica, CA: RAND Corporation.Google Scholar
Swaine, Michael D. 2012a. “China's assertive behavior part four: the role of the military in foreign crises,” China Leadership Monitor, 30 April.Google Scholar
Swaine, Michael D. 2012b. “China's assertive behavior part three: the role of the military in foreign policy,” China Leadership Monitor, 6 January.Google Scholar
Swaine, Michael D. 2015. “The PLA role in China's foreign policy and crisis behavior.” In Saunders, Phillip C. and Scobell, Andrew (eds.), PLA Influence on China's National Security Policymaking. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 141–165.Google Scholar
Welch, Catherine. 2015. “Civilian authorities and contingency planning in China.” In Scobell, Andrew, Ding, Arthur S., Saunders, Phillip C. and Harold, Scott W. (eds.), The People's Liberation Army and Contingency Planning in China. Washington, DC: NDU Press, 85–105.Google Scholar
Wong, Gillian. 2013. “China's State Security Committee shows Xi's clout,” AP, 13 November.Google Scholar
Wuthnow, Joel. 2013. “Decoding China's new ‘National Security Commission’.” CNA Occasional Paper, https://www.cna.org/CNA_files/PDF/CPP-2013-U-006465-Final.pdf.Google Scholar
Xinhua. 2013a. “Xi Jinping: guanyu ‘Zhonggong zhongyang guanyu quanmian shenhua gaige nuo gan zhongda wenti de jueding’ de shuoming” (Xi Jinping: explanation of the “Chinese Communist Party Central Committee decision on several important questions concerning the comprehensive deepening of reform”), 15 November.Google Scholar
Xinhua. 2013b. “Zhonggong zhongyang guanyu quanmian shenhua gaige nuogan zhongda wenti de jueding” (Chinese Communist Party Central Committee's decision on several important questions related to the comprehensive deepening of reform), 15 November.Google Scholar
Xinhua. 2014a. “Zhonggong zhongyang zhengzhiju zhaokai huiyi yanjiu jueding zhongyang guojia anquan weiyuanhui shezhi shenyi guanqie zhixing zhongyang baxiang guiding qingkuang baogao” (The Chinese Communist Party Politburo opens a meeting to study and decide the organizational structure of the Central National Security Commission and review implementation of the central authorities’ eight regulations), 24 January.Google Scholar
Xinhua. 2014b. “Xi Jinping: jianchi zongti guojia anquan guan zou Zhongguo tese guojia anquan daolu” (Xi Jinping: maintain an overall national security concept, travel the national security road with Chinese characteristics), 15 April.Google Scholar
Xinhua. 2014c. “President Xi vows intense pressure on terrorism,” 27 April.Google Scholar
Xinhua. 2015a. “China's leadership warns of unprecedented national security risks, 23 January.Google Scholar
Xinhua. 2015b. “China withdrawing citizens from Yemen,” 30 March.Google Scholar
You, Ji. 2016. “China's National Security Commission: theory, evolution, and operations.” Journal of Contemporary China 25(98), 178–196.Google Scholar
Yuen, Samson. 2014. “Disciplining the Party: Xi Jinping's anti-corruption campaign and its limits.” China Perspectives 3(2014), 41–47.Google Scholar
Zhang, Tuosheng. 2011. “Zhongguo guoji junshi anquan weiji xingwei yanjiu” (Research on China's international military security crisis behaviour). Shijie jingji yu zhengzhi 4, 103–121.Google Scholar