Skip to main content

Isomorphic Pressures, Epistemic Communities and State–NGO Collaboration in China*

  • Reza Hasmath (a1) and Jennifer Y.J. Hsu (a2)

This article suggests that the lack of meaningful collaboration between the state and NGOs in China is not solely a result of the state seeking to restrict the development of the sector, or the fear of a potential opposing actor to the state; instead, interviews with NGOs in Beijing and Shanghai suggest that a lack of meaningful engagement between the state and NGOs can be partially attributed to isomorphic pressures within state–NGO relations, and insufficient epistemic awareness of NGO activities on the part of the state. In fact, the evidence suggests that once epistemic awareness is achieved by the state, it will have a stronger desire to interact with NGOs – with the caveat that the state will seek to utilize the material power of NGOs, rather than their symbolic, interpretive or geographical capital.

该论文指出, 中国政府与非政府组织 (NGO) 之间合作的缺乏并不能完全归咎于政府对该领域发展的限制, 或是出于对一个潜在的政府反对者的害怕。与北京和上海的 NGO 访谈显示, 政府与 NGO 之间缺乏有意义的合作的部分原因是同构压力, 以及政府对于 NGO 活动认知的缺乏。 事实上, 证据显示, 一旦政府获得了对 NGO 工作的认知, 它将会更加愿意与 NGO 建立联系。当然必须说明的是, 政府想要利用的是 NGO 的物质资源, 而非他们的象征性, 阐释性, 或是地理上的资本。

Corresponding author
Email: (corresponding author).
Hide All

The authors are grateful for the valuable feedback received at seminar presentations at the Institute of East Asian Studies, University of California at Berkeley; Lau China Institute, King's College London; NGO Research Center, Tsinghua University; East Asia Workshop, University of Chicago; Chinese Politics Research Workshop, Harvard University; the Centre for Chinese Studies, University of California at Los Angeles; and the 2013 Forum on NGO Governance and Management in China (Edmonton, Canada). This research is supported by the Social Science Research Council of Canada.

Hide All
Binney, Derek. 2001. “The knowledge management spectrum – understanding the KM landscape.” Journal of Knowledge Management 5(1), 3342.
Covaleski, Mark A., and Dirsmith, Mark W.. 1988. “An institutional perspective on the rise, social transformation, and fall of a university budget category.” Administrative Science Quarterly 33(4), 562587.
Dacin, M. Tina, Goodstein, Jerry and Scott, W. Richard. 2002. “Institutional theory and institutional change.” The Academy of Management Journal 45(1), 4554.
Deephouse, David L. 1996. “Does isomorphism legitimate?The Academy of Management Journal 39, 1024–39.
Deng, Guosheng. 2010. “The hidden rules governing China's unregistered NGOs: management and consequences.” The China Review 10(1), 183206.
Deng, Guosheng, and Shieh, Shawn. 2011. “An emerging civil society: the impact of the 2008 Sichuan earthquake on grassroots associations in China.” The China Journal 65, 181194.
Dickson, Bruce. 2000. “Cooptation and corporatism in China: the logic of Party adaptation.” Political Science Quarterly 115, 517540.
DiMaggio, Paul. 1988. “Interest and agency in institutional theory.” In Zucker, Lynne G. (ed.), Institutional Patterns and Organizations: Culture and Environment. Cambridge, MA: Ballinger, 321.
DiMaggio, Paul, and Powell, Walter W.. 1983. “The Iron Cage revisited: institutional isomorphism and collective rationality in organizational fields.” American Sociological Review 48(2), 147160.
Froissart, Chloé. 2006. “Escaping from under the Party's thumb: a few examples of migrant workers' strivings for autonomy.” Social Research 73(1), 197218.
Froissart, Chloé. 2010. “Is there a NGO model? Comparing NGOs supporting migrant workers in Beijing and the Pearl River Delta.” Asia Centre at Sciences Po, Conference Series.
Fu, Hualing. 2012. “Embedded socio-legal activism in China: the case of Yirenping.” University of Hong Kong Faculty of Law Research Paper No. 2012/029.
Fulda, Andreas, Li, Yanyan and Song, Qinghua. 2012. “New strategies of civil society in China: a case study of the network governance approach.” Journal of Contemporary China 21(76), 675693.
Gazley, Beth, and Brudney, Jeffrey L.. 2007. “The purpose (and perils) of government–nonprofit partnership.” Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly 36(3), 389415.
Gross, Mattais. 2010. Ignorance and Surprise: Science, Society and Ecological Design. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Guo, Chao, and Acar, Muhittin. 2005. “Understanding collaboration among nonprofit organizations: combining resource dependency, institutional, and network perspectives.” Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly 34(3), 340361.
Haas, Peter. 1992. “Introduction: epistemic communities and international policy coordination.” International Organization 46(1), 135.
Hasmath, Reza, and Hsu, Jennifer. 2008. “NGOs in China and issues of accountability.” Asia Pacific Journal of Public Administration 30(1), 111.
Hess, David J. 2009. “The potentials and limitations of civil society research: getting undone science done.” Sociological Inquiry 79(3), 306327.
Heurlin, Christopher. 2010. “Governing civil society: the political logic of NGO–state relations under dictatorship.” Voluntas 21, 220239.
Hildebrandt, Timothy. 2011. “The political economy of social organization registration in China.” The China Quarterly 208, 980–89.
Hsu, Carolyn. 2009. “Chinese NGOs and the state: institutional interdependence rather than civil society.” Paper presented at the American Sociological Association, San Francisco, 8–11 August 2009.
Hsu, Carolyn. 2010. “Beyond civil society: an organizational perspective on state–NGO relations in the People's Republic of China.” Journal of Civil Society 6(3), 259277.
Hsu, Carolyn. 2011. “Even further beyond civil society: the rise of internet-oriented Chinese NGOs.” Journal of Civil Society 7(1), 123–27.
Hsu, Jennifer. 2009. “Quietly, quietly: Beijing's migrant civil society organizations.” In Butcher, Melissa and Velayuthum, Selvaraj (eds.), Dissent and Cultural Resistance in Asia's Cities. London: Routledge, 5171.
Hsu, Jennifer. 2012a. “Spaces of civil society: the role of migrant non-governmental organisations in Beijing and Shanghai?Progress in Development Studies 12(1), 6376.
Hsu, Jennifer. 2012b. “Layers of the state: migrant organizations and the Chinese state.” Urban Studies 49(16), 3513–30.
Hsu, Jennifer, and Hasmath, Reza (eds.). 2013. The Chinese Corporatist State: Adaptation, Survival and Resistance. New York: Routledge.
Hsu, Jennifer, and Hasmath, Reza. 2014. “The local corporatist state and NGO relations in China.” Journal of Contemporary China 23(87), 516534.
Kang, Xiaoguang, and Heng, Han. 2008. “Graduated controls: the state–society relationship in contemporary China.” Modern China 34(1), 3655.
Kaufman, Joan. 2012. “China's evolving AIDS policy: the influence of global norms and transnational non-governmental organizations.” Contemporary Politics 18(2), 225238.
Kostova, Tatiana, and Roth, Kendall. 2002. “Adoption of an organizational practice by subsidiaries of multinational corporations: institutional and relational effects.” The Academy of Management Journal 45(1), 215233.
Lewis, David, and Opoku-Mensah, Paul. 2006. “Moving forward research agendas on international NGOs: theory, agency and context.” Journal of International Development 18(5), 665675.
Liu, Zuyun. 2008. “Feizhengfu zuzhi xingqi beijing yu gongneng jiedu” (The rise and functions of non-governmental organizations). Hunan shehui kexue 1, 7378.
Ma, Qiusha. 2002. “The governance of NGOs in China since 1978: how much autonomy?Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly 31(3), 305328.
Mawdsley, Emma, Townsend, Janet G., Porter, Gina and Oakley, Peter. 2002. Knowledge, Power and Development Agendas: NGOs North and South. Oxford: INTRAC.
McGoey, Linsey. 2007. “On the will to ignorance in bureaucracy.” Economy and Society 36(2), 212235.
McGoey, Linsey. 2008. “Ignorance and regulation: the strategic avoidance of risky knowledge.” Risk and Regulation 16, 1112.
Meyer, John W., and Rowan, Brian. 1991. “Institutional organizations: formal structure as myth and ceremony.” In Powell, Walter W. and DiMaggio, Paul J. (eds.), The New Institutionalism in Organizational Analysis. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 4162.
Murphy, Brian K. 2000. “International NGOs and the challenge of modernity.” Development in Practice 10(3 & 4), 330347.
Oliver, Christine. 1991. “Strategic responses to institutional processes.” The Academy of Management Review 16(1), 145179.
Pache, Anne-Claire, and Santos, Filipe M.. 2010. “When worlds collide: the internal dynamics of organizational responses to conflicting institutional demands.” The Academy of Management Review 35, 455476.
Qi, Mei. 2011. “Developing a working model for legal NGOs in China.” Washington University Global Studies Law Review 10(3), 617639.
Ru, Jiang, and Ortolano, Leonard. 2008. “Corporatist control of environmental non-governmental organizations: a state perspective.” In Ho, Peter and Edmonds, Richard L. (eds.), Embedded Environmentalism: Opportunities and Constraints of a Social Movement in China. London: Routledge, 4668.
Saich, Tony. 2008. “The changing role of urban government.” In Yusuf, Shahid and Saich, Tony (eds.), China Urbanizes: Consequences, Strategies and Policies. Washington, DC: World Bank, 181206.
Savage, Charles. 2000. “The development of knowledge management and why it is important.” Knowledge Management for Development Organizations. Report of the Knowledge Management Brighton Workshop, University of Sussex, 26–28 June 2000.
Simon, Karla. 2009. “Regulation of civil society in China: necessary changes after the Olympic Games and the Sichuan earthquake.” Fordham International Law Journal 32(3), 943987.
Stern, Rachel, and O'Brien, Kevin J.. 2011. “Politics at the boundary: mixed signals and the Chinese state.” Modern China 38(2), 175199.
Teets, Jessica. 2012. “Reforming service delivery in China: the emergence of social innovation model.” Journal of Chinese Political Science 17(1), 1532.
Teets, Jessica. 2013. “Let many civil societies bloom: the rise of consultative authoritarianism in China.” The China Quarterly 213, 1938.
Thornton, Patricia M. 2013. “The advance of the Party: transformation or takeover at the urban grassroots.” The China Quarterly 213, 118.
Thornton, Patricia M., and Ocasio, William. 2008. “Institutional logics.” In Greenwod, Royston, Oliver, Christine, Sahlin, Kerstin and Suddaby, Roy (eds.), The Sage Handbook of Organizational Institutionalism. London: Sage, 99129.
Tolbert, Pamela S., and Zucker, Lynn G.. 1996. “The institutionalization of institutional theory.” In Clegg, Stewart R., Hardy, Cynthia, Lawrence, Thomas and Nord, Walter R. (eds.), Handbook of Organization Studies. London: Sage, 175190.
Watkins, Susan Cotts, Swidler, Ann and Hannan, Thoma. 2012. “Outsourcing social transformation: development NGOs as organizations.” Annual Review of Sociology 38, 285315.
Wen, Ying-na, and Chen, Chung-tai. 2012. “Resource platform, capacity building and social networking: a case study of NPI initiative.” China Journal of Social Work 5(2), 139147.
Wu, Fengshi, and Chan, Kin-Man. 2012. “Graduated control and beyond: the evolving government–NGO relations.” China Perspectives 3, 917.
Xu, Guihong. 2008. “Feizhengfu zuzhi xingqi de jingjixue jieshi” (Economic explanations for the rise of non-governmental organizations). Heilongjiang shehui kexue 6, 8891.
Yu, Jianxing, and Zhou, Jun. 2012. “Growing out of participation: finding the developmental path of China's civil society.” In Jianxin, Yu and Sujian, Guo (eds.), Civil Society and Governance in China. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 133156.
Zack, Michael H. 1999. “Managing organizational ignorance.” Knowledge Directions 1, 3649.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

The China Quarterly
  • ISSN: 0305-7410
  • EISSN: 1468-2648
  • URL: /core/journals/china-quarterly
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *



Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed