Skip to main content
×
×
Home

THE HYDRA OF HOROWITZIAN HISTORY: The Mobilization of Scholarship against Black Reparations

  • Paul Anthony Dottin (a1)
Abstract

Whether to provide reparations to African Americans for the atrocities of slavery and segregation is arguably the most controversial public matter concerning race in the United States today. This debate, a clash over the economics and ethics of equality, is nothing less than a struggle over the future of racial identity, race relations, and racial progress in the current post–civil rights movement era.

With the stakes for African Americans so high, and the prospects for affirmative action dim, public intellectuals have weighed in heavily on each side of the issue. Randall Robinson—author of the best-known work advocating for reparations, The Debt: What America Owes to Blacks (2000)—and David Horowitz—the reparationist movement's most reviled nemesis and author of Uncivil Wars: The Controversy over Reparations for Slavery (2002)—have become the alpha and omega of almost any deliberation on Black reparations.

Not surprisingly, rancorous rhetoric has often overshadowed rigorous research on the veracity of antireparations and proreparations claims. This essay aims to correct this problem with an extensive analysis of David Horowitz's (2002) arguments, providing a synthesis of data, concepts, theories, and methodologies from the disciplines of sociology, history, economics, and anthropology. This essay finds that Horowitz's use of academic scholarship to discredit African American reparations fails to meet the “scientific” standards he demands of his opponents.

Copyright
Corresponding author
Paul Anthony Dottin, Director of the Culture/Language/Theory Program, Hunan Institute of Science and Technology, Hunan, Yueyang 414006, China. E-mail: pdottin@gmail.com
References
Hide All
Adamu, Mahdi (1984). The Hausa and Their Neighbors in the Sudan. In Niane, Djibril Tamsir (Ed.), Africa from the Twelfth to the Sixteenth Century. Vol. 4 of General History of Africa, by UNESCO, pp. 266300. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Allen, Robert L. (1974). Reluctant Reformers: Racism and Social Reform Movements in the United States. In collaboration with Pamela P. Allen. Washington, DC: Howard University Press.
Baker-Fletcher, Garth Kasimu (1996). Xodus: An African American Male Journey. Minneapolis, MI: Fortress.
Bathily, Abdoulaye and Meillassoux, Claude (1988). Relations between the Different Regions of Africa. In El Fasi, Mohammad (Ed.) and Hrbek, Ivan (Asst. Ed.), Africa from the Seventh to the Eleventh Century. Vol. 3 of General History of Africa, by UNESCO, pp. 734749. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Behrendt, Stephen (1999). Transatlantic Slave Trade. In Appiah, Kwame Anthony and Gates, Henry Louis Jr. (Eds.), Africana: The Encyclopedia of the African and African American Experience, pp. 18651877. New York: Basic Civitas.
Berlin, Ira (1974). Slaves without Masters: The Free Negro in the Antebellum South. New York: Pantheon Books.
Berlin, Ira (1998). Many Thousands Gone: The First Two Centuries of Slavery in North America. Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.
Boas, Franz ([1895] 1970). The Social Organization and the Secret Societies of the Kwakiutl Indians. New York: Johnson Reprint.
Bogger, Tommy L. (1997). Free Blacks in Norfolk, Virginia, 1790–1860: The Darker Side of Freedom. Charlottesville, VA: University Press of Virginia.
Bush, Michael L. (2000). Servitude in Modern Times. Cambridge, MA: Polity.
Cha-Jua, Sundiata Keita (2001). Slavery, Racist Violence, American Apartheid: The Case for Reparations. New Politics, 8(3): 6076. ⟨http://www.wpunj.edu/~newpol/issue31/chajua31.htm⟩ (accessed May 15, 2008).
Chrisman, Robert and Allen, Ernest Jr. (2001). Ten Reasons: A Response to David Horowitz.http://www.umass.edu/afroam/hor.html⟩ (accessed April 16, 2008).
D'Anjou, Leo (1996). Social Movements and Cultural Change: The First Abolition Campaign Revisited. New York: Aldine de Gruyter.
Delgado, Richard and Stefancic, Jean (Eds.) (1997). Critical White Studies: Looking Behind the Mirror. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.
Dillon, Merton L. (1990). Slavery Attacked: Southern Slaves and the Allies, 1619–1865. Baton Rouge, LA: Louisiana State University Press.
Durkheim, Émile (1938). The Rules of Sociological Method, 8th ed. Trans. Solovay, Sarah A. and Mueller, John H.. Ed. Catlin, George E. G.. Glencoe, IL: Free Press.
Durkheim, Émile (1972). Selected Writings. Trans. Giddens, and ed. Anthony. Cambridge, UK: University Press.
Fine, Ben (1998). Exchange. In Bottomore, Tom, Harris, Laurence, Kiernan, V. G., and Miliband, Ralph (Eds.), A Dictionary of Marxist Thought, pp. 181182. Malden, MA: Blackwell.
Fogel, Robert William and Engerman, Stanley L. (1974). Time on the Cross: The Economics of American Negro Slavery. Boston, MA: Little, Brown.
Foley, Duncan (1998a). Commodity. In Bottomore, Tom, Harris, Laurence, Kiernan, V. G., and Miliband, Ralph (Eds.), A Dictionary of Marxist Thought, pp. 100102. Malden, MA: Blackwell.
Foley, Duncan (1998b). Use Value. In Bottomore, Tom, Harris, Laurence, Kiernan, V. G., and Miliband, Ralph (Eds.), A Dictionary of Marxist Thought, p. 561. Malden, MA: Blackwell.
Franklin, John Hope (1969). The Free Negro in North Carolina, 1790–1860. New York: Russell and Russell.
Franklin, John Hope and Schweninger, Loren (1999). Runaway Slaves: Rebels on the Plantation. New York: Oxford University Press.
Garnet, Henry Highland (1848). Walker's Appeal, with a Brief Sketch of His Life and also Garnet's Address to the Slaves of the United States of America. Buffalo, NY: J. H. Tobbit.
Gerth, H. H. and Mills, C. Wright (1946). Introduction: The Man and His Work. In Max Weber, From Max Weber: Essays in Sociology, pp. 374. New York: Oxford University Press.
Gratus, Jack (1973). The Great White Lie: Slavery, Emancipation, and Changing Racial Attitudes. New York: Monthly Review.
Hadden, Sally E. (2001). Slave Patrols: Law and Violence in Virginia and the Carolinas. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Hakem, Ahmed M. Ali (1981). The Civilization of Napata and Meroe. In Mokhtar, Gamal (Ed.), Ancient Civilizations of Africa. Vol. 2 of General History of Africa, by UNESCO, pp. 298325. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Handlin, Oscar (1957). Race and Nationality in American Life. New York: Doubleday Anchor.
Hill, Polly (1985). Comparative West African Farm-Slavery Systems (South of the Sahel) with Special Reference to Muslim Kano Emirate (N. Nigeria). In Willis, John Ralph (Ed.), The Servile Estate. Vol. 2 of Slaves and Slavery in Muslim Africa, pp. 3350. London, UK: Frank Cass.
Hopkins, Terence K. and Wallerstein, Immanuel (1987). Capitalism and the Incorporation of New Zones into the World-Economy. Review, 10(5/6): 763779.
Horowitz, David (2002). Uncivil Wars: The Controversy over Reparations for Slavery. San Francisco, CA: Encounter Books.
Horton, James Oliver (1993). Free People of Color: Inside the African American Community. Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution.
Hummell, Jeffrey Rogers (1996). Emancipating Slaves, Enslaving Free Men: A History of the American Civil War. Chicago, IL: Open Court.
Inikori, Joseph (2001). Slaves or Serfs? A Comparative Study of Slavery and Serfdom in Europe and Africa. In Okpewho, Isidore, Davies, Carole Boyce, and Mazrui, Ali A. (Eds.), The African Diaspora: African Origins and New World Identities, pp. 4975. Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press.
James, C. L. R. (1980). Notes on Dialectics: Hegel, Marx, Lenin. London: Allison and Busby.
Johnson, LaWanda (2002). Benin Apologizes for Slavery: “We're Sorry … Come Home.” Afro-American Red Star (Washington, DC), September 21, A1.
Jones, Jacqueline (1998). American Work: Four Centuries of Black and White Labor. New York: W. W. Norton.
Jordan, Winthrop D. (1968). Modern Tensions and the Origins of American Slavery. In Weinstein, Allen and Gatell, Frank Otto (Eds.), American Negro Slavery: A Modern Reader, pp. 1324. New York: Oxford University Press.
Kelley, Robin D. G. (1994). Race Rebels: Culture, Politics and the Black Working Class. New York: Free Press.
Koger, Larry (1985). Black Slaveowners: Free Black Slave Masters in South Carolina, 1790–1860. Jefferson, NC: McFarland.
Lange, D. (1984). The Kingdoms and Peoples of Chad. In Niane, Djibril Tamsir (Ed.), Africa from the Twelfth to the Sixteenth Century. Vol. 4 of General History of Africa, by UNESCO, pp. 238265. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Littlefield, Daniel C. (2000). Revolutionary Citizens: 1776–1804. In Kelley, Robin D. G. and Lewis, Earl (Eds.), To Make Our World Anew: A History of African Americans, pp. 103168. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
Lofland, John (1996). Social Movement Organizations: Guide to Research on Insurgent Realities. New York: Aldine De Gruyter.
Lovejoy, Paul E. (2000). Introduction to Slaves and Slave Holders on the Gold Coast: Towards an Understanding of Social Bondage in West Africa, by Peter Haenger. Basel, Switzerland: J. H. Tobbit.
Lyman, Stanford M. (1986). Chinatown and Little Tokyo: Power, Conflict, and Community among Chinese and Japanese Immigrants to America. Millwood, NY: Associated Faculty.
Lyman, Stanford M. (1989). The Seven Deadly Sins: Society and Evil, rev. ed.Dix Hills, NY: General Hall.
Macpherson, Crawford B. (1962). The Political Theory of Possessive Individualism: Hobbes to Locke. Oxford, UK: Clarendon.
Malinowski, Bronislaw (1922). Argonauts of the Western Pacific: An Account of Native Enterprise and Adventure in the Archipelagoes of Melanesian New Guinea. New York: E. P. Dutton.
Manning, Patrick (1999). Slavery in Africa. In Appiah, Kwame Anthony and Gates, Henry Louis Jr. (Eds.), Africana: The Encyclopedia of the African and African American Experience, pp. 17201723. New York: Basic Civitas Books.
Matison, Sumner Eliot (1948). Manumission by Purchase. Journal of Negro History, 33(1): 146167.
Matveiev, Victor V. (1984). The Development of Swahili Civilization. In Niane, Djibril Tamsir (Ed.), Africa from the Twelfth to the Sixteenth Century. Vol. 4 of General History of Africa, by UNESCO, pp. 455480. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
McAfee, Ward M. (Ed.) (2001). The Slaveholding Republic: An Account of the United States Government's Relations to Slavery, by Don E. Fehrenbacher. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
Miers, Suzanne and Klein, Martin A. (Eds.) (1999). Slavery and Colonial Rule in Africa. London, UK: Frank Cass.
Mohun, Simon (1998). Capital. In Bottomore, Tom, Harris, Laurence, Kiernan, V. G., and Miliband, Ralph (Eds.), A Dictionary of Marxist Thought, pp. 6871. Malden, MA: Blackwell.
Morgan, David L., Krueger, Richard A., King, Jean A., and Scannell, Alice U. (1998). Focus Group Kit. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Morris, Aldon D. (1984). The Origins of the Civil Rights Movement: Black Communities Organizing for Change. New York: Free Press.
Nave, Ari (1999). Trans-Saharan and Red Sea Trade, Traffic in African Slaves across the Sahara and the Red Sea for Export, Mainly to Arabia and South Asia. In Appiah, Kwame Anthony and Gates, Henry Louis Jr. (Eds.), Africana: The Encyclopedia of the African and African American Experience, pp. 18791880. New York: Basic Civitas.
N'COBRA (2002). What Is N'COBRA?http://www.ncobra.org/aboutus.htm⟩ (accessed May 15, 2008).
Niane, Djibril Tamsir (1984). Conclusion. In Niane, Djibril Tamsir (Ed.), Africa from the Twelfth to the Sixteenth Century. Vol. 4 of General History of Africa, by UNESCO, pp. 673686. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Palmer, Colin A. (2000). The First Passage: 1502–1619. In Kelley, Robin D. G. and Lewis, Earl (Eds.), To Make Our World Anew: A History of African Americans, pp. 352. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
Patterson, Orlando (1982). Slavery and Social Death: A Comparative Study. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Peoples, James and Bailey, Garrick Alan (1997). Humanity: An Introduction to Cultural Anthropology, 4th ed.Belmont, CA: Wadsworth.
Person, Yves (1984). The Coastal Peoples: From Casamance to the Ivory Coast Lagoons. In Niane, Djibril Tamsir (Ed.), Africa from the Twelfth to the Sixteenth Century. Vol. 4 of General History of Africa, by UNESCO, pp. 301323. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Phillips, Christopher (1997). Freedom's Port: The African American Community of Baltimore: 1790–1860. Urbana, IL: University of Illinois Press.
Posnansky, M. (1981). Introduction to the Later Prehistory of Sub-Saharan Africa. In Mokhtar, Gamal (Ed.), Ancient Civilizations of Africa. Vol. 2 of General History of Africa, by UNESCO, pp. 533550. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Pugh, Darrell L. (1999). Collective Rehabilitation. In Brooks, Roy L. (Ed.), When Sorry Isn't Enough: The Controversy over Apologies and Reparations for Human Injustice, pp. 372373. New York: New York University Press.
Robinson, Randall (2000). The Debt: What America Owes to Blacks. New York: Penguin, Plume.
Robinson, Randall and TransAfrica Forum (2007). Restatement of the Black Manifesto. In Martin, Michael T. and Yaquinto, Marilyn (Eds.), Redress for Historical Injustices in the United States: On Reparations for Slavery, Jim Crow, and Their Legacies, pp. 621624. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
Rubio, Philip F. (2001). A History of Affirmative Action, 1619–2000. Jackson, MS: University Press of Mississippi.
Schwab, Gustav (1946). Gods and Heroes: Myths and Epics of Ancient Greece. New York: Pantheon.
Schweninger, Loren (1990a). Black Property Owners in the South, 1790–1915. Urbana, IL: University of Illinois Press.
Schweninger, Loren (1990b). Prosperous Blacks in the South, 1790–1880. American Historical Review, 95(1): 3156.
Scott, James C. (1985). Weapons of the Weak: Everyday Forms of Peasant Resistance. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Scott, James C. (1990). Domination and the Arts of Resistance: Hidden Transcripts. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Segal, Ronald (2001). Islam's Black Slaves: The Other Black Diaspora. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
Sheriff, Abdul (1981). The East African Coast and Its Role in Maritime Trade. In Mokhtar, Gamal (Ed.), Ancient Civilizations of Africa. Vol. 2 of General History of Africa, by UNESCO, pp. 551567. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Snow, David A. and Benford, Robert D. (1992). Master Frames and Cycles of Protest. In Morris, Aldon D. and Mueller, Carol McClurg (Eds.), Frontiers in Social Movement Theory, pp. 133155. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Stampp, Kenneth M. (1956). The Peculiar Institution: Slavery in the Ante-Bellum South. New York: Vintage.
Sterkx, H. E. (1972). The Free Negro in Ante-Bellum Louisiana. Rutherford, NJ: Fairleigh Dickinson University Press.
Sylvester, Theodore L. (2000). Slavery throughout History: Almanac. Ed. Benson, Sonia. Detroit, MI: UXL.
Takaki, Ronald (1993). A Different Mirror: A History of Multicultural America. Boston, MA: Little, Brown.
Tamrat, T. (1984). The Horn of Africa: The Solomonids in Ethiopia and the States of the Horn of Africa. In Niane, Djibril Tamsir (Ed.), Africa from the Twelfth to the Sixteenth Century. Vol. 4 of General History of Africa, by UNESCO, pp. 423454. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
United Nations (2004). Africa, Map No. 4045, Rev. 4, January. New York: Cartographic Section. ⟨http://www.un.org/Depts/Cartographic/map/profile/africa.pdf⟩ (accessed April 11, 2008).
United Nations (2005). Western Africa, Map No. 4042, February. New York: Cartographic Section. ⟨http://www.un.org/Depts/Cartographic/map/profile/westafrica.pdf⟩ (accessed April 11, 2008).
Vidich, Arthur J. and Lyman, Stanford M. (1994). Qualitative Methods: Their History in Sociology and Anthropology. In Denzin, Norman K. and Lincoln, Yvonna S. (Eds.), Handbook of Qualitative Research, pp. 2359. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Walker, David ([1829] 1998). David Walker's Appeal: To the Coloured Citizens of the World. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
Walker, Juliet E. K. (1998). The History of Black Business in America: Capitalism, Race, Entrepreneurship. New York: Macmillan.
Walton, Hanes Jr. and Smith, Robert C. (2000). American Politics and the African American Quest for Universal Freedom. New York: Longman.
Weber, Max (1958). The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism. Trans. Parsons, Talcott. New York: Scribner.
Weber, Max (1978). Max Weber: Selections in Translation. Trans. Runciman, Eric Matthews. Ed. W. G.. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Weeks, John (1998). Non-capitalist Modes of Production. In Bottomore, Tom, Harris, Laurence, Kiernan, V. G., and Miliband, Ralph (Eds.), A Dictionary of Marxist Thought, pp. 401402. Malden, MA: Blackwell.
Weissberg, Robert (2001). Play that Funky Logical Positivism, White Boy; Or, If You Are Going to Be White, Do It White. In Stokes, Curtis, Meléndez, Theresa, and Rhodes-Reed, Genice (Eds.), Race in Twenty-First Century America, pp. 397423. East Lansing, MI: Michigan State University Press.
White, Deborah Gray (1996). Let My People Go: African Americans, 1804–1860. New York: Oxford University Press.
Wilson, Carol (1994). Freedom at Risk: The Kidnapping of Free Blacks in America, 1780–1865. Lexington, KY: University Press of Kentucky.
Wilson, Carol (1999). Active Vigilance Is the Price of Liberty: Black Self-Defense against Fugitive Slave Recapture and Kidnapping of Free Blacks. In McKivigan, John R. and Harrold, Stanley (Eds.), Antislavery Violence: Sectional, Racial, and Cultural Conflict in Antebellum America, pp. 108127. Knoxville, TN: University of Tennessee Press.
Wilson, Sherrill D. (1994). New York City's African Slaveowners: A Social and Material Culture History. New York: Garland.
Wolf, Eric R. (1982). Europe and the People without History. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Wood, Peter H. (2000). Strange New Land: 1619–1776. In Kelley, Robin D. G. and Lewis, Earl (Eds.), To Make Our World Anew: A History of African Americans, pp. 53102. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
Yoyotte, Jean (1981). Pharaonic Egypt: Society, Economy and Culture. In Mokhtar, Gamal (Ed.), Ancient Civilizations of Africa. Vol. 2 of General History of Africa, by UNESCO, pp. 112135. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Du Bois Review: Social Science Research on Race
  • ISSN: 1742-058X
  • EISSN: 1742-0598
  • URL: /core/journals/du-bois-review-social-science-research-on-race
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Keywords

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed