Skip to main content


  • Karim Chalak (a1)

We study the consequences of substituting an error-laden proxy W for an instrument Z on the interpretation of Wald, local instrumental variable (LIV), and instrumental variable (IV) estimands in an ordered discrete choice structural system with heterogeneity. A proxy W need only satisfy an exclusion restriction and that the treatment and outcome are mean independent from W given Z. Unlike Z, W need not satisfy monotonicity and may, under particular specifications, fail exogeneity. For example, W could code Z with error, with missing observations, or coarsely. We show that Wald, LIV, and IV estimands using W identify weighted averages of local or marginal treatment effects (LATEs or MTEs). We study a necessary and sufficient condition for nonnegative weights. Further, we study a condition under which the Wald or LIV estimand using W identifies the same LATE or MTE that would have been recovered had Z been observed. For example, this holds for binary Z and therefore the Wald estimand using W identifies the same “average causal response,” or LATE for binary treatment, that would have been recovered using Z. Also, under this condition, LIV using W can be used to identify MTE and average treatment effects for e.g., the population, treated, and untreated.

Corresponding author
*Address correspondence to Karim Calak, Department of Economics, University of Virginia, P.O. Box 400182, Charlottesville, VA 22904-4182, email:
Hide All
Abrevaya J. & Hausman J. (1999) Semiparametric estimation with mismeasured dependent variables: An application to duration models for unemployment spells. Annals of Economics and Statistics / Annales d’Économie et de Statistique 55/56, 243275.
Acemoglu D., Johnson S., & Robinson J. (2001) The colonial origins of comparative development: An empirical investigation. American Economic Review 91, 13691401.
An Y. & Hu Y. (2012) Well-posedness of measurement error models for self-reported data. Journal of Econometrics 168, 259269.
Angrist J., Graddy K., & Imbens G. (2000) The interpretation of instrumental variables estimators in simultaneous equations models with an application to the demand for fish. The Review of Economic Studies 67, 499527.
Angrist J. & Imbens G. (1995) Two–stage least squares estimation of average causal effects in models with variable treatment intensity. Journal of the American Statistical Association 90, 431442.
Angrist J., Imbens G., & Rubin D. (1996) Identification of causal effects using instrumental variables. Journal of the American Statistical Association 91, 444472 (with discussion).
Ashenfelter O. & Krueger A. (1994) Estimates of the economic returns to schooling from a new sample of twins. American Economic Review 84, 11571173.
Bagnoli M. & Bergstrom T. (2005) Log-concave probability and its applications. Economic Theory 26, 445469.
Bartle R. (1966) Elements of Integration. Wiley.
Bracewell R. (1986) The Fourier Transform and Its Applications. McGraw-Hill.
Card D. (1999) The causal effect of education on earnings. In Ashenfelter O. & Card D. (eds.), Handbook of Labor Economics, vol. 3, Part A. Elsevier.
Chalak K. & White H. (2011) An extended class of instrumental variables for the estimation of causal effects. Canadian Journal of Economics 44, 151.
Corbae D., Stinchcombe M., & Zeman J. (2009) An Introduction to Mathematical Analysis for Economic Theory and Econometrics. Princeton University Press.
Dawid A.P. (1979) Conditional independence in statistical theory. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series B. 41, 131 (with discussion).
Fan J. & Gijbels I. (1996) Local Polynomial Modelling and Its Applications. Chapman and Hall.
Hausman J., Abrevaya J., & Scott-Morton F.M. (1998) Misclassification of the dependent variable in a discrete-response setting. Journal of Econometrics 87, 239269.
Heckman J. (1996) Identification of causal effects using instrumental variables: Comment. Journal of the American Statistical Association 91, 459462.
Heckman J. (2010) Building bridges between structural and program evaluation approaches to evaluating policy. Journal of Economic Literature 48, 356–98.
Heckman J. & Vytlacil E. (2005) Structural equations, treatment effects, and econometric policy evaluation. Econometrica 73, 669738.
Heckman J., Urzua S., & Vytlacil E. (2006) Understanding instrumental variables in models with essential heterogeneity. Review of Economics and Statistics 88, 389432.
Hernán M. & Robins J. (2006) Instruments for causal inference: An epidemiologist’s dream? Epidemiology 17, 360372.
Holland P.W. (1986) Statistics and causal inference. Journal of the American Statistical Association 81, 945970 (with discussion).
Horowitz J. & Manski C. (1995) Identification and robustness with contaminated and corrupted data. Econometrica 63, 281302.
Hotz V., McElroy S., & Sanders S. (2005) Teenage childbearing and its life cycle consequences: Exploiting a natural experiment. Journal of Human Resources 40, 683715.
Hotz V., Mullin C., & Sanders S. (1997) Bounding causal effects using data from a contaminated natural experiment: Analyzing the effects of teenage childbearing. The Review of Economic Studies 64, 575603.
Hu Y. (2008) Identification and estimation of nonlinear models with misclassification error using instrumental variables: A general solution. Journal of Econometrics 144, 2761.
Imbens G. & Angrist J. (1994) Identification and estimation of local average treatment effects. Econometrica 61, 467476.
Klein T. (2010) Heterogeneous treatment effects: Instrumental variables without monotonicity? Journal of Econometrics 155, 99116.
Lehmann E. (1966) Some concepts of dependence. The Annals of Mathematical Statistics 37, 11371153.
Leoni G. (2009) A First Course in Sobolev Spaces. American Mathematical Society.
Lewbel A. (2007) Estimation of average treatment effects with misclassification. Econometrica 75, 537551.
Li Q. & Racine J. (2007) Nonparametric Econometrics: Theory and Practice. Princeton University Press.
Mahajan A. (2006) Identification and estimation of regression models with misclassification. Econometrica 74, 631665.
Manski C. (2013) Identification of treatment response with social interactions. The Econometrics Journal 16, S1S23.
Manski C. & Pepper J. (2000) Monotone instrumental variables: With an application to the returns to schooling. Econometrica 68, 9971010.
Rubin D. (1986) Statistics and causal inference: Comment: which ifs have causal answers. Journal of the American Statistical Association 81, 961962.
Schennach S.M., White H., & Chalak K. (2012) Local indirect least squares and average marginal effects in nonseparable structural systems. Journal of Econometrics 166, 282302.
Shaked M. & Shanthikumar J.G. (1994) Stochastic Orders and Their Applications. Associated Press.
Small D. & Tan Z. (2007) A Stochastic Monotonicity Assumption for the Instrumental Variables Method. Working paper, The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania Department of Statistics.
Vytlacil E. (2002) Independence, monotonicity, and latent index models: An equivalence result. Econometrica 70, 331341.
Vytlacil E. (2006) Ordered discrete-choice selection models: Equivalence, nonequivalence, and representation results. Review of Economics and Statistics 88, 578581.
Wald A. (1940) The fitting of straight lines if both variables are subject to error. Annals of Mathematical Statistics 11, 284300.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Econometric Theory
  • ISSN: 0266-4666
  • EISSN: 1469-4360
  • URL: /core/journals/econometric-theory
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 1
Total number of PDF views: 160 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 1260 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 20th February 2018. This data will be updated every 24 hours.