Skip to main content

Compensation, conservation and communities: an analysis of direct payments initiatives within an Indonesian marine protected area


Conservation practitioners are increasingly faced with the need to compensate resource users because of restrictions imposed on access and use of natural resources. The idea that direct payments may facilitate compensation more effectively than a programme based upon income substitution is questioned through examining two direct payments initiatives in an Indonesian marine national park. Elite capture of the direct payments process was facilitated in a context characterized by malleable state institutions and powerful private business interests, thereby disadvantaging key resource-dependent groups. The ecological benefits of direct payments initiatives and of protected areas were compromised through the emphasis on business priorities rather than environmental criteria. These difficulties were mitigated through taking account of existing practices regarding resource access, ensuring equal distribution of benefits and introducing new systems gradually over a period of time through trusted individuals, thereby facilitating the acceptance of direct payments initiatives amongst key user groups.

Corresponding author
*Correspondence: Dr Julian Clifton e-mail:
Hide All
Agrawal A. & Ostrom E. (2008) Decentralization and community-based forestry: learning from experience. In: Decentralization, Forests and Rural Communities. Policy Outcomes in South and Southeast Asia, ed. Webb E.L. & Shivakoti G.P., pp. 4467. New Delhi, India: Sage.
Agrawal A. & Redford K. (2006). Poverty, Development and Biodiversity Conservation: Shooting in the Dark? New York, NY, USA: Wildlife Conservation Society.
Andersson K.P. & Ostrom E. (2008) Analysing decentralised resource regimes from a polycentric perspective. Policy Science 41: 7193.
Antlov H. & Eko S. (2012) Village and sub-district functions in decentralised Indonesia [www document]. URL
Balmford A. & Whitten T. (2003) Who should pay for tropical conservation, and how could the costs be met? Oryx 37: 238250.
Brooks T.M., Mittermeier R.A., Mittermeier C.G., da Fonseca G.A.B., Rylands A.B., Konstart W.R., Rick P., Pilgrim J., Oldfield S., Magin G. & Hilton-Taylor C. (2002) Habitat loss and extinction in the hotspots of biodiversity. Conservation Biology 16: 909923.
Burkard G. (2002) Natural resource management in central Sulawesi: past experience and future prospects. STORMA Discussion Paper Series 8. STORMA, Gottingen University, Gottingen, Germany [www document]. URL
Burke L., Reytar K., Spalding M. & Perry A. (2011) Reefs At Risk Revisited. Washington, DC, USA: World Resources Institute.
Büscher B. (2012) Payments for ecosystem services as neoliberal conservation: (reinterpreting) evidence from the Maloti-Drakensberg, South Africa. Conservation and Society 10: 2941.
Büscher B. & Wolmer W. (2007) Introduction: the politics of engagement between biodiversity conservation and the social sciences. Conservation and Society 5: 121.
Butchart S.H.M and 44 others (2010) Global biodiversity: indicators of recent declines. Science 328: 11641168.
Cinner J.E., Daw T. & McClanahan T.R. (2008) Socioeconomic factors that affect artisanal fishers’ readiness to exit a declining fishery. Conservation Biology 23: 124130.
Clements T., John A., Nielsen K., An D., Tan S. & Milner-Gulland E.J. (2010) Payments for biodiversity conservation in the context of weak institutions: comparison of three programmes from Cambodia. Ecological Economics 69: 12831291.
Clifton J. (2003) Prospects for co-management in Indonesia's marine protected areas. Marine Policy 27: 389395.
Clifton J. (2009) Science, funding and participation: key issues for marine protected area networks and the Coral Triangle Initiative. Environmental Conservation 36: 9196.
Clifton J. & Majors C. (2012) Culture, conservation and conflict: perspectives on marine protection amongst the Bajau of southeast Asia. Society and Natural Resources 25: 716725.
Dirhamsyah D. (2006) Indonesian legislative framework for coastal resources management: a critical review and recommendation. Ocean and Coastal Management 49: 6892.
Djohani R.H. (1996) The Bajau: future marine park managers in Indonesia? In: Environmental Change in Southeast Asia: People, Politics and Sustainable Development, ed. Parnwell M.J.G. & Bryant R.L., pp. 260267. London, UK: Routledge.
Exton D.A. (2010) Nearshore fisheries of the Wakatobi. In: Marine Research and Conservation in the Coral Triangle: the Wakatobi National Park, ed. Clifton J., Unsworth R.K.F. and Smith D.J., pp. 193207. New York, NY, USA: Nova Science.
Ferraro P.J. (2000) Global habitat protection: limitations of development interventions and a role for conservation performance payments. Conservation Biology 15: 9901000.
Ferraro P.J. & Kiss A. (2002) Direct payments to conserve biodiversity. Science 298: 17181719.
Ferraro P.J. & Simpson R.D. (2002) The cost-effectiveness of conservation payments. Land Economics 78: 339353.
Ferraro P.J. & Simpson R.D. (2005) Cost-effective conservation when eco-entrepreneurs have market power. Environment and Development Economics 10: 113.
Gómez-Baggethun E., de Groot R., Lomas P.L. & Montes C. (2010) The history of ecosystem services in economic theory and practice: from early notions to markets and payment schemes. Ecological Economics 69: 12091218.
Gong Y., Bull G. & Baylis K. (2010) Participation in the world's first clean development mechanism forest project: the role of property rights, social capital and contractual rules. Ecological Economics 69: 12921302.
Gross-Camp N.D., Martin A., McGuire S., Kebede B. & Munyarukaza J. (2012) Payments for ecosystem services in an African protected area: exploring issues of legitimacy, fairness, equity and effectiveness. Oryx 46: 2433.
Gunawan B.I. & Visser L.E. (2012) Permeable boundaries: outsiders and access to fishing grounds in the Berau Marine Protected Area. Anthropological Forum 22: 187207.
Haapkylä J., Unsworth R.K.F., Seymour A.S., Melbourne-Thomas J., Flavell M., Willis L.B. & Smith D.J. (2009). Spatio-temporal coral disease dynamics in the Wakatobi Marine National Park, South-East Sulawesi, Indonesia. Diseases of Aquatic Organisms 87: 105115.
Hernandez A. & Kempton W. (2003) Changes in fisheries management in Mexico: effects of increasing scientific input and public participation. Ocean and Coastal Management 46: 507526.
Ito T. (2011) Historicising the power of civil society: a perspective from decentralisation in Indonesia. Journal of Peasant Studies 38: 413433.
Kosoy N. & Corbera E. (2010) Payments for ecosystem services as commodity fetishism. Ecological Economics 69: 12281236.
Larson A.M. & Soto F. (2008) Decentralization of natural resource management regimes. Annual Review of Environmental Resources 33: 213239.
Mackelworth C. & Carić H. (2010) Gatekeepers of island communities: exploring the pillars of sustainable development. Environment, Development and Sustainability 12: 463480.
Miller T.R., Minteer B.A. & Malan L.-C. (2011) The new conservation debate: the view from practical ethics. Biological Conservation 144: 948957
Muradian R., Corbera E., Pascual U., Kosoy N. & May P.H. (2010) Reconciling theory and practice: an alternative conceptual framework for understanding payments for environmental services. Ecological Economics 69: 12021208.
Myers N., Mittermeier R.A., Mittermeier C.G., da Fonseca G.A.B. & Kent J. (2000) Biodiversity hotspots for conservation priorities. Nature 403: 853858.
Ostrom E. (1990) Governing the Commons: the Evolution of Institutions for Collective Action. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Ostrom E. (2005) Understanding Institutional Diversity. Princeton, NJ, USA: Princeton University Press.
Pattanayak S.K., Wunder S. & Ferraro P.J. (2010) Show me the money: do payments supply environmental services in developing countries? Review of Environmental Economics and Policy 4: 254274.
Platteau J.-P. (2004) Monitoring elite capture in community-driven development. Development and Change 35: 223246.
Rosen F. & Olsson P. (2013) Institutional entrepreneurs, global networks and the emergence of international institutions for ecosystem-based management; the Coral Triangle Initiative. Marine Policy 38: 195204.
Roth R.J. & Dressler W. (2012) Market-oriented conservation governance: the particularities of place. Geoforum 43: 363366.
Satria A. & Matsuda Y. (2004) Decentralisation of fisheries management in Indonesia. Marine Policy 28: 437450.
Setiawan B. & Hadi S.P. (2007) Regional autonomy and local resource management in Indonesia. Asia Pacific Viewpoint 48: 7284.
Siry H.Y. (2011) In search of appropriate approaches to coastal zone management in Indonesia. Ocean and Coastal Management 54: 469477
Sodhi N.S., Koh L.P., Brook B.W. & Ng P.K.L. (2004) Southeast Asian biodiversity: an impending disaster. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 19: 654660.
Sommerville M., Jones J.P.G., Rahajaharison M. & Milner-Gulland E.J. (2010) The role of fairness and benefit distribution in community-based payment for environmental services interventions: a case study from Menabe, Madagascar. Ecological Economics 69: 12621271.
TNC (2010) MCA feasibility analysis. Coral Triangle, Indonesia [www document]. URL
Thorburn C. (2002) Regime change: prospects for community-based resource management in post-New Order Indonesia. Society and Natural Resources 15: 617628.
Unsworth R.K.F., Smith D.J., Powell A. & Hukon F. (2007) The ecology of Indo-Pacific grouper (Serranidae) species and the effects of a small scale no take area on grouper assemblage, abundance and size frequency distribution. Marine Biology 1152: 243254.
Unsworth R.K.F., Salinas de Leon P., Garrard S., Jompa J., Smith D.J. & Bell J.J. (2008) High connectivity of Indo-Pacific seagrass fish assemblages with mangrove and coral reef habitats. Marine Ecology Progress Series 353: 213224.
van Hecken G. & Bastiaensen J. (2010) Payments for ecosystem services: justified or not? A political view. Environmental Science and Policy 13: 785792.
Venter O., Meijaard E., Possingham H., Dennis R., Sheil D., Wich S., Hovani L. & Wilson K. (2009) Carbon payments as a safeguard for threatened tropical mammals. Conservation Letters 2: 123129.
Woodhouse A. (2004) Village Justice in Indonesia: Case Studies on Access to Justice, Village Democracy and Governance. Washington, DC, USA: World Bank Social Development Unit.
Wunder S. (2007) The efficiency of payments for environmental services in tropical conservation. Conservation Biology 21: 4858.
Wunder S., Engel S. & Pagiola S. (2008) Taking stock: a comparative analysis of payments for environmental services programs in developed and developing countries. Ecological Economics 65: 834852.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Environmental Conservation
  • ISSN: 0376-8929
  • EISSN: 1469-4387
  • URL: /core/journals/environmental-conservation
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *



Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 2
Total number of PDF views: 37 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 212 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 24th November 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.