Skip to main content

Management preferences, perceived benefits and conflicts among resource users and managers in the Mafia Island Marine Park, Tanzania

  • T.R. McCLANAHAN (a1), J. CINNER (a2), A.T. KAMUKURU (a3), C. ABUNGE (a4) and J. NDAGALA (a5)...

Conflicts between resource users and managers are common and well documented on Mafia Island (Tanzania), where there has been a history of unresolved conflict over marine conservation initiatives. The perceptions of fisheries and park restrictions among resource users and managers were evaluated to try to understand the underlying causes of these conflicts. Responses concerning management preferences of government officials employed by the Mafia Island Marine Park (MIMP), personnel of the fisheries department, and heads of households in three villages in and out of the Park were compared. The largest differences in perceptions were found between villagers and managers, but all respondents agreed that minimum fish lengths and gear restrictions were beneficial and that benefits increased along the scale of the individual – community – national government. Villagers and government officials differed most in their perceptions towards area-based management, spatial and temporal closures, and species restrictions. Perceptions of management restrictions and benefits were only weakly correlated with the socioeconomic status of the villagers, but more strongly correlated with their living in or out of the Park and their family's economic options. The most negative perceptions towards restrictions were found in villages near fisheries closures, where there was a heavy reliance on marine resources and a higher numbers of jobs per household, but less reliance on cash crops, animal husbandry and tourism. The lack of these three options appears to have produced lower levels of support for MIMP and associated restrictions, and might be overcome by (1) using gear and minimum size restrictions more than fisheries closures and (2) increasing access to tourism, cash crops, animal husbandry and salaried employment, rather than simply increasing livelihood diversity.

Corresponding author
*Correspondence: Dr Tim R. McClanahan e-mail:
Hide All
Allison, E.H. & Ellis, F. (2001) The livelihoods approach and management of small-scale fisheries. Marine Policy 25: 377388.
Aswani, S. (2005) Customary sea tenure in Oceania as a case of rights-based fishery management: does it work? Reviews in Fish Biology and Fisheries 15: 285307.
Beddington, J.R., Agnew, D.J. & Clark, C.W. (2007) Current problems in the management of marine fisheries. Science 316: 17131716.
Berkes, F. (2007) Community-based conservation in a globalized world. Proceedings from the National Academy of Sciences 39: 1518815193.
Campbell, D.J. (1990) Strategies for coping with severe food deficits in rural Africa: a review of the literature. Food and Foodways 4: 143162.
Caplan, P. (2002) Local understanding of modernity: food and security on Mafia Island, Tanzania. Report, Tanzania Commission for Science and Technology (COSTECH), Dar es Salaam, Tanzania.
Carter, M.R. (1997) Environment, technology, and the social articulation of risk in West African agriculture. Economic Development and Cultural Change 45: 557591.
Christie, P. (2004) Marine protected areas as biological successes and social failures in southeast Asia. American Fisheries Society Symposium 42: 155164.
Cinner, J.E. (2005) Socioeconomic factors influencing customary marine tenure in the Indo-Pacific. Ecology and Society 10 (1): 36 [www document]. URL
Cinner, J.E. (2007) The role of taboos in conserving coastal resources in Madagascar. Traditional Marine Resource Management and Knowledge Information Bulletin 22: 1523.
Cinner, J.E. & McClanahan, T.R. (2006) Socioeconomic factors that lead to overfishing in small-scale coral reef fisheries of Papua New Guinea. Environmental Conservation 33: 7380.
Cinner, J.E. & Pollnac, R. (2004) Poverty, perceptions and planning: why socioeconomics matter in the management of Mexican reefs. Ocean and Coastal Management 47: 479493.
Clausen, R. & York, R. (2008 a) Economic growth and marine biodiversity: influence of human social structure on decline of marine trophic levels. Conservation Biology 22: 458466.
Clausen, R. & York, R. (2008 b) Global biodiversity decline of marine and freshwater fish: a cross-national analysis of economic, demographic, and ecological influences. Social Science Research (in press). DOI 10.1016/j.ssresearch.2007.10.002.
Cocklin, C., Craw, M. & McAuley, I. (1998) Marine reserves in New Zealand: use rights, public attitudes, and social impacts. Coastal Management 26: 213231.
Defeo, O. & Castilla, C. (2005) More than one bag for the world fishery crisis and keys for co-management successes in selected artisanal Latin American shellfisheries. Fish Biology and Fisheries 15: 265283.
Dunlap, R.E. & York, R. (2008) The globalization of environmental concern and the limits of the postmaterialist values explanation: evidence from four multinational surveys. The Sociological Quarterly 49: 529563.
Gelcich, S., Edwards-Jones, G. & Kaiser, M. (2005) Importance of attitudinal differences among artisanal fishers toward co-management and conservation of marine resources. Conservation Biology 19: 865875.
Gelcich, S., Edwards-Jones, G. & Kaiser, M.J. (2007) Heterogeneity in fishers' harvesting decisions under a marine territorial user rights policy. Ecological Economics 61: 246254.
Gelcich, S., Edwards-Jones, G., Kaiser, M.J. & Castilla, J.C. (2006) Co-management policy can reduce resilience in traditionally managed marine ecosystems. Ecosystems 9: 951966.
Gelcich, S., Kaiser, M.J., Castilla, J.C. & Edwards-Jones, G. (2008) Engagement in co-management of marine benthic resources influences environmental perceptions of artisanal fishers. Environmental Conservation 35: 3645.
Grossman, G.M. & Krueger, A.B. (1995) Economic growth and the environment. The Quarterly Journal of Economics 110: 353377.
Hilborn, R. (2007) Moving to sustainability by learning from successful fisheries. Ambio 36: 296303.
Horrill, J.C., Darwall, W.R.T. & Ngoile, M.A.K. (1996) Development of a marine protected area: Mafia Island, Tanzania. Ambio 25: 5057.
Jacobson, S.K. & Marynowski, S.B. (1997) Public attitudes and knowledge about ecosystem management on department of defense land in Florida. Conservation Biology 11: 770781.
Jentoft, S. (2003) Co-management: the way forward. Fish and Fisheries 26: 116.
Jentoft, S., McCay, B.J. & Wilson, D.C. (1998) Social theory and fisheries co-management. Marine Policy 22: 423436.
Kamukuru, A.T., Mgaya, Y.D. & Ohman, M.C. (2004) Evaluating a marine protected area in a developing country: Mafia Island Marine Park, Tanzania. Ocean and Coastal Management 47: 321337.
Mahongo, S.B. (1994) The coastal profile of Mafia Island, Tanzania. Report, Tanzanian National Environmental Management Council. Dar es Salaam, Tanzania.
McClanahan, T.R. (1999) Is there a future for coral reef parks in poor tropical countries? Coral Reefs 18: 321325.
McClanahan, T.R. (2007) Management of area and gear in Kenyan coral reefs. In: Fisheries Management: Progress towards Sustainability, ed. McClanahan, T.R. & Castilla, J.C., pp. 166185. London, UK: Blackwell Press.
McClanahan, T.R. & Castilla, J.C. (2007) Fisheries Management: Progress towards Sustainability. London, UK: Blackwell Publishers.
McClanahan, T.R., Castilla, J.C., White, A. & Defeo, O. (2009) Healing small-scale fisheries and enhancing ecological benefits by facilitating complex social-ecological systems. Reviews in Fish Biology and Fisheries (in press). DOI 10.1007/s11160-008-9088-8.
McClanahan, T.R., Davies, J. & Maina, J. (2005 a) Factors influencing resource users and managers' perceptions towards marine protected area management in Kenya. Environmental Conservation 32: 4249.
McClanahan, T.R., Glaesel, H., Rubens, J. & Kiambo, R. (1997) The effects of traditional fisheries management on fisheries yields and the coral-reef ecosystems of southern Kenya. Environmental Conservation 24: 105120.
McClanahan, T.R., Graham, N.A.J., Calnan, M. & MacNeil, M.A. (2007) Towards pristine biomass: reef fish recovery in coral reef marine protected areas in Kenya. Ecological Applications 17: 10551067.
McClanahan, T.R., Maina, J. & Davies, J. (2005 b) Perceptions of resource users and managers towards fisheries management options in Kenyan coral reefs. Fisheries Management and Ecology 12: 105112.
McClanahan, T.R. & Mangi, S. (2000) Spillover of exploitable fishes from a marine park and its effect on the adjacent fishery. Ecological Applications 10: 17921805.
McClanahan, T.R., Verheij, E. & Maina, J. (2006) Comparing management effectiveness of a marine park and a multiple-use collaborative fisheries management area in East Africa. Aquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems 16: 147165.
Nelson, R.H. (1995) Sustainability, efficiency, and God: economic values and the sustainability debate. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 26: 135154.
Pollnac, R.B. & Crawford, B. (2000) Assessing behavioral aspects of coastal resource use. Coastal Resources Center, University of Rhode Island, Narragansett, Rhode Island, USA.
Richardson, E.A., Kaiser, M.J. & Jones, G.E. (2005) Variation in fishers' attitudes within an inshore fishery: implications for management. Environmental Conservation 32: 213225.
Sall, J., Lehmaan, A. & Creighton, L. (2001) JMP Start Statistics. Duxbury, USA: Thomson Learning.
Stern, D.I. (1998) Progress on the environmental Kuznets curve? Environment and Development Economics 3: 173196.
URT (2003) Tanzanian Census – 2002. Population and housing census, Volume 2. Age and sex distribution. National Bureau of Statistics, Dar es Salaam, Tanzania.
URT (2006) Tanzania Census - 2002. Analytical report. Volume 10. National Bureau of Statistics, Dar es Salaam, Tanzania.
United Republic of Tanzania (2000) Mafia Island Marine Park: General Management Plan. Report, Board of Trustees for Marine Parks and Reserves, Dar es Salaam, Tanzania.
Walley, C.J. (2004) Rough Water: Nature and Development in an East African Marine Park. Princeton, USA: Princeton University Press.
Wells, S., Samoilys, M., Anderson, J., Kalombo, H. & Makoloweka, S. (2007 a) Collaborative fisheries management in Tanga, Northern Tanzania. In: Fisheries Management: Progress towards Sustainability, ed. McClanahan, T.R. & Castilla, J.C., pp. 139165. London, UK: Blackwell Scientific.
Wells, S., Burgess, N. & Ngusaru, A. (2007 b) Towards the 2012 marine protected area targets in Eastern Africa. Ocean and Coastal Management 50: 6783.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Environmental Conservation
  • ISSN: 0376-8929
  • EISSN: 1469-4387
  • URL: /core/journals/environmental-conservation
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *



Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed