Hostname: page-component-797576ffbb-xmkxb Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2023-12-05T23:03:06.869Z Has data issue: false Feature Flags: { "corePageComponentGetUserInfoFromSharedSession": true, "coreDisableEcommerce": false, "useRatesEcommerce": true } hasContentIssue false

ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEWS AND CASE STUDIES: Limitations and Challenges of Provincial Environmental Protection Bureaus in China's Environmental Data Monitoring, Reporting and Verification

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  25 October 2013

Angel Hsu*
Yale School of Forestry and Environmental Studies, New Haven CT
Angel Hsu, Yale School of Forestry and Environmental Studies, 195 Prospect Street, New Haven CT 06511; (phone) 203-903-2199; (fax) 203-432-0237; (e-mail)
Get access


Although administered from the top-down, China's environmental governance is characterized by decentralization, a feature that has been cited as the cause of poor implementation of policies at the local levels. To address this implementation gap, the central government in China has instituted environmental targets in its evaluation system of local leaders. However, the system of performance evaluation based on statistics and indicators has revealed problems of data and information abnormalities, falsification, and collusion between local officials to hide or misrepresent data. Little academic attention has been paid to sub-national institutions in place for data collection, reporting, and verification in China. This paper seeks to understand how institutions collect and transfer environmental data in China's vertical governance structure, as well as the challenges faced primarily by provincial Environmental Protection Bureaus (EPBs) to shed light on why discrepancies and gaps in environmental data might exist. Using data gathered from semi-structured interviews of environmental protection officials in nine provinces and two municipalities across China, this paper provides an analysis of environmental monitoring, reporting, and verification at primarily the provincial level. The consequences of a complex, decentralized environmental monitoring system in China has meant provincial environmental protection bureaus face a multitude of challenges, including a lack of institutional coordination, weak incentives for environmental performance evaluation, limited autonomy for enforcement, and varied capacity and public demand for improved information.

Environmental Practice 15:280–292 (2013)

Copyright © National Association of Environmental Professionals 2013 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)


Beyer, S. 2006. Environmental Law and Policy in the People's Republic of China. Chinese Journal of International Law 5(1):185211.Google Scholar
Bloomberg News Agency. 2012. China Detains 2 for Wuhan Pollution Rumor, Bloomberg News Agency Daily Reports. Available at Scholar
Chan, K.W. 2007. Misconceptions and Complexities in the Study of China's Cities: Definitions, Statistics, and Implications. Eurasian Geography and Economics 48(4):383412.Google Scholar
Chan, K.W. 2010. Fundamentals of China's Urbanization and Policy. The China Review 10(1):6394.Google Scholar
China Daily. 2003. Need for accurate statistics stressed. 12 December. Available at Scholar
China Daily. 2012. Reducing soil pollution. November 2, 2012. Available at Scholar
Eaton, S., and Kostka, G.. 2012. Does cadre turnover help or hinder China's green rise? Evidence from Shanxi Province. Frankfurt School—Working Paper Series, No. 184, Frankfurt School, University of Frankfurt, Germany.Google Scholar
Falkenheim, V.C. 1980. Administrative reform and modernization in post-Mao China. Pacific Affairs 53(1):528.Google Scholar
Fei, L. 2012. China: US Embassy Should Stop Reporting Beijing's Air Quality. The Epoch Times. June 6, 2012. Available at Scholar
Ge, G., Lu, Y., Mol, A.P.J., and Beckers, T.. 2012. Changes and challenges: China's environmental management in transition. Environmental Development 3:2538.Google Scholar
Guan, D., Liu, Z., Geng, Y., Lindner, S., and Hubacek, K.. 2012. The gigatonne gap in China's carbon dioxide inventories. Nature Climate Change 2:672675.Google Scholar
Holz, C.A. 2002. Institutional constraints on the quality of statistics in China. China Information 16(1):2567.Google Scholar
Holz, C.A. 2004. China's statistical system in transition: Challenges, data problems, and institutional innovations. Review of Income and Wealth 50:3.Google Scholar
Hsu, A., de Sherbinin, A., Shi, H.. 2012. Seeking truth from facts: the challenge of environmental indicator development in China. Environmental Development 3:3951.Google Scholar
Institute of Public and Environmental Affairs (IPE) and the Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC). 2012. Pollution Information Transparency Index (PITI), Third Edition. Available at Scholar
Interview 1. Official at the Chinese Academy for Environmental Planning, Beijing. July 18, 2012. (All interviews were conducted in confidentiality, and the names of interviewees are withheld by mutual agreement.)Google Scholar
Interview 2. Official at the Shaanxi Environmental Monitoring Center, Xi'an. July 20, 2012.Google Scholar
Interview 3. Official at the Shaanxi Environmental Protection Bureau, Xi'an. July 21, 2012.Google Scholar
Interview 5. Official at the Shandong Academy for Environmental Planning, Jinan. July 25, 2012.Google Scholar
Interview 6. Official at the Shanghai Environmental Monitoring Center, Shanghai. July 27, 2012.Google Scholar
Interview 7. Official at the Suzhou Environmental Protection Bureau, Suzhou. July 30, 2012.Google Scholar
Interview 8. Official at the Suzhou Environmental Supervision Center, Suzhou. July 30, 2012.Google Scholar
Interview 9. Official at the Suzhou Environmental Monitoring Center, Suzhou. July 30, 2012.Google Scholar
Interview 10. Official at the Ningbo Environmental Protection Bureau. July 31, 2012.Google Scholar
Interview 12. Official at the Zhejiang Environmental Monitoring Center. August 1, 2012.Google Scholar
Interview 14. Official at the Hunan Provincial Government Environment and Resource Commission, Changsha. August 3, 2012.Google Scholar
Interview 17. Official at the Hubei Environmental Project Assessment Bureau, Wuhan. August 6, 2012.Google Scholar
Interview 18. Official at the Hubei Total Emissions Control Department, Wuhan. August 6, 2012.Google Scholar
Interview 24. Official at the Guangxi Environmental Performance Assessment Department, Nanning. August 9, 2012.Google Scholar
Interview 25. Official at Hunan's Environmental Monitoring Center, Changsha. August 14, 2012.Google Scholar
Interview 26. Official at the Sichuan Environmental Protection Bureau, Chengdu. October 15, 2012.Google Scholar
Kostka, G., and Hobbs, W.. 2010. Energy efficiency in China: the local bundling of interests and policies. Frankfurt School—Working Paper Series, No. 151. Frankfurt School of Finance and Management, Frankfurt, Germany.Google Scholar
Levs, J. 2011. U.S. Readings challenge China's smog claims. CNN. 2 November. Available at: Scholar
Li, L.C. 1997. Towards a Non-zero-sum Interactive Framework of Spatial Politics: the Case of Centre-Province in Contemporary China. Political Studies 16:4965.Google Scholar
Lieberthal, K. 1997. China's Governing System and Its Impact on Environmental Policy Implementation. China Environment Series 1, Autumn. Woodrow Wilson International Centre for Scholars, Washington, DC.Google Scholar
Liu, J., and Yang, H.. 2009. China fights against statistical corruption. Science 7:675:676.Google Scholar
Lo, C.W.-H., and Tang, S.Y.. 2006. Institutional reform, economic changes, and local environmental management in China: the case of Guangdong province. Environmental Politics 15(2):190210.Google Scholar
Ma, X., and Ortolano, L.. 2000. Environmental Regulation in China. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc.Google Scholar
Ministry of Environmental Protection (MEP). 2011. 2010 Environmental Statistics Annual Report. Available at: (accessed January 7, 2012).Google Scholar
Mol, A.P.J. 2009. Environmental governance through information: China and Vietnam. Singapore Journal of Tropical Geography 30:114129.Google Scholar
Mol, A.P.J. 2010. Environmental reform in modernizing China. In The International Handbook of Environmental Sociology, 2nd edition, Redclift, M. and Woodgate, G., eds. Edward Elgar Publishing, Cheltenham Glos and Camberley Surrey, UK.Google Scholar
Mol, A.P.J., and Carter, N.T.. 2006. China's environmental governance in transition. Environmental Politics 15(2):149170.Google Scholar
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. 2007. Environmental Compliance and Enforcement in China: An Assessment of Current Practices and Ways Forward. OECD, Paris.Google Scholar
Qiu, X., and Li, H.. 2009. China's Environmental Super Ministry Reform: Background, Challenges, and the Future. Environmental Law Reporter 39:1015210163.Google Scholar
Radaelli, C.M. 1995. The role of knowledge in the policy process. Journal of European Public Policy 2(2):159183.Google Scholar
Ran, R. 2013. Perverse Incentive Structure and Policy Implementation Gap in China's Local Environmental Politics. Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning 15(1):1739.Google Scholar
Rauch, J.N., and Chi, Y.F.. 2010. The Plight of the Green GDP in China. Consilience: The Journal of Sustainable Development 3(1):102116.Google Scholar
Rawski, T.G. 2001. What is happening to China's GDP statistics? China Economic Review. 12:347354.Google Scholar
Richerzhagen, C. and Scholz, I.. 2008. China's Capacities for Mitigating Climate Change. World Development 36(2):308324.Google Scholar
Schreifels, J.J., Fu, Y., and Wilson, E.J.. 2012. Sulfur dioxide control in China: policy evolution during the 10th and 11th Five-year Plans and lessons for the future. Energy Policy 48:779789.Google Scholar
Seligsohn, D., and Hsu, A.. 2011. How does China's 12th Five-Year Plan address energy and the environment? World Resources Institute. 7 March 2011. Available at (accessed October 20, 2012).Google Scholar
State Council. 2008. Regulations of the People's Republic of China on Open Government Information. English translation available at (accessed January 7, 2012).Google Scholar
State Council. 2009. Statistics Law of the People's Republic of China. Available (in Chinese) at (accessed January 20, 2013).Google Scholar
Tang, S.Y., Lo, C. W-H., and Fryxell, G.E.. 2010. Governance reform, external support, and environmental regulation enforcement in rural China: The case of Guangdong provinces. Journal of Environmental Management 91:20082018.Google Scholar
Van Rooj, B. 2003. Organization and procedure in environmental law enforcement: Sichuan in comparative perspective. China Information 17–36.Google Scholar
Wong, E. 2011. Outrage Grows Over Air Pollution and China's Response. The New York Times. 6 December. Available at Scholar
Wong, G. 2012. China steps carefully with protesting middle class. BusinessWeek. October 29, 2012. Available at Scholar
Xinhua News Agency. 2006. SEPA slams local governments for fabricating pollution figures. Xinhua News Agency. December 28, 2006. Available at Scholar
Xinhua News Agency. 2012a. Environmental protection chief dismissed after cadmium pollution. Xinhua News Agency. Available at Scholar
Xinhua News Agency. 2012b. Full text of Hu Jintao's report at 18th Party Congress. Xinhua News Agency. November 17, 2012. Available at: Scholar
Xu, Y. 2011. The use of a goal for SO2 mitigation planning and management in China's 11th Five-Year Plan. Journal of Environmental Planning and Management 54(6):769783.Google Scholar
Yale Center for Environmental Law and Policy (YCELP), the Center for International Earth Science Information Network (CIESIN), Chinese Academy for Environmental Planning, and City University of Hong Kong. 2011. Towards a China Environmental Performance Index. Available at: Scholar
Zhang, D., Aunan, K., Seip, H.M, and Vennemo, H.. 2011. The energy intensity target in China's 11th Five-Year Plan period—Local implementation and achievements in Shanxi Province. Energy Policy 39:41154124.Google Scholar
Zhang, L., Mol, P.J., He, G., Lu, Y.. 2010. An implementation assessment of China's Environmental Information Disclosure Decree. Journal of Environmental Sciences. 22(10):16491656.Google Scholar
Zhang, X., and Schreifels, J.. 2011. Continuous emission monitoring systems at power plants in China: Improving SO2 emission measurement. Energy Policy 39: 74327438.Google Scholar
Zhu, F., Li, H., and Qiu, S.. 2010. Development and application prospects of gas continuous emission monitoring systems. Environmental Monitoring Management and Technology 22(4):1014. (in Chinese). Available: .Google Scholar